It's surprising to see some negative reviews here. We stopped when we pulled off the highway for gas on a roadtrip. We met Rosie at the counter. 3 of us had great sandwiches. Bagels were fresh, flavorful, not too heavy. Eggs cooked perfectly, good ratios with ingredients in sandwiches. Side of potatoes were awesome. Everything was great. And the wait was not long at all. Other than the location, it is in a crummy strip mall, don't let that turn you away. It's a hidden gem. read more

Goldberg's Pompton Lakes - Home fries - Bagels Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

This is the most unorganized place I have ever been in. The employees handle the register and then make your food, the door is kept open no screens. The restroom is disgusting nasty. read more

So sad this bagel shop is now closed and it keeps popping up in the search as OPEN!!! read more

Goldberg's Pompton Lakes - The bagel shop that is closed permanently - Bagels Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

do not order from this one!!!! they steal and use uber and doordash to steal. they do jot check driver abd let them steal orders and you pay for the food that was stolen. owner of restaurant refuses to report theft to uber or help with refund process of theft horrible careless service read more

Amazing bagel place they fill up the cream cheese 5 stars for me definitely coming again read more

Goldberg's Pompton Lakes - Bagels Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

$13 for a lox bagel that had no capers or cream cheese ?! I was ordering for my son and told the guy I wanted a lox bagel. When I called them up after i. got home I was told I had to specify that I wanted cream cheese and capers. I've never done at any other bagel store. read more

Do not sell a "flagel" if you don't know how to make it. A flagel isn't a bagel taken out of the oven and smashed by hand once cooked. This "flagel" looked like an elephant sat on an old bagel and then was thrown into a bag. I could only eat a quarter of this "flagel" because my jaw hurt that bad from chewing. NEVER AGAIN. read more

To me they are the best Taylor ham egg and cheese sandwhiches in town and within a couple miles, and I eat alot of these sandwhiches. Well done read more

The place not only smells from the grease trap that they don't clean. They continue to get my order wrong on multiple occasions and refuse to find a solution to help accommodate. They are extremely unprofessional and all they care about is making money not providing customer service. I either received wrong items, or something is burnt, or just not what I ordered at all. And I get told I have to pay for a new order instead of just simply correcting what was wrong. It's sad because it's in a good location and they could really make it a great place if they just were better at servicing their customers and we're more organized with the orders they receive. read more

...... I always rave about this place. Its always so good. It's been years since I've came & I always have to get a bagel / flagel when I fly back home to Jersey. I have to say this was the first time I was disappointed.... . Really dont be lazy and just melt the cheese please... read more

Goldberg's Pompton Lakes - a hand holding a piece of bread - Bagels Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

I love this Goldberg's a lot is near my place they make the best Taylor ham sandwich ever I always enjoy their sandwiches there anyone looking for a good breakfast sandwich definitely come here read more

I go here pretty much every weekend for my bac egg cheese on a salt bagel, with pepper and ketchup. The staff is very friendly, seems to be a family owned business. The hispanic boy with the neck tattoo is friendly to me, maybe because I'm not a Karen like Katerina G. read more

ordered from goldbergs this afternoon for lunch. ordered egg salad on a bagel with French fries and my mom got a bacon and cheese on an everything bagel. my egg salad was good. the cheese on my moms bagel was not melted. she asked for butter on her bagel and there was none. we always order from goldbergs and have never had a problem. it's always very good. but today seemed like a miss for the bacon and cheese. read more

Goldberg's Pompton Lakes - Homemade Egg Salad - Bagels Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

See all

Ordered my bagel with the rude woman at the counter, then when I asked if I ordered coffee with her as well she snapped at me with "yea just give me a second" Then she kept taking orders after mine without even starting my bagel. She started talking to her coworker pointing to me like I needed help so I thought I was supposed to re order with him because she was too busy. I get a "why are you ordering with him if you order with me?!" read more

Bagels are fine at Goldberg's but a bagel place should never enter into the world of croissants. Awful awful awful. Tasted oily (not buttery) and bitter. Took one bite and threw both croissants away. Stick to what you do best - Bagels@@@@ read more

Goldberg's Pompton Lakes - two pieces of bread on a plate - Bagels Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

Way overpriced, and the prices on the website do not reflect the actual prices. They are more expensive than other places. It's definitely not worth the mediocre bagels, and as many other reviewers have said, the manager is always RUDE. Drive a little further to another bagel place like bagel loops!! read more

My friends and I were in town and decided to try this place. That was unfortunate for us. As the older guy was taking our order he was extremely rude.. as if us ordering was inconvenient for him. Once he took our order he went to get my bagel with one glove and scratched his head with the other hand.. so as I'm watching him he proceeds to use the same hand that he scratched his head with to put my bagel in the toaster.. I'm like wtf that's so gross. THEN the other lady took my bagel out of the toaster and starts putting cream cheese on it.. as I looked up at that exact moment my bagel fell on the floor and she picked it up.. I LITERALLY COULD NOT HOLD BACK.. I went to the counter and said excuse did that just fall on the floor?!? She looked me dead in my eyes and said no, I was like WTF I just saw it and you picked it up. I ended up walking out with my friends. We should have honestly read these reviews before going. SMH. read more

Outstanding gourmet sandwiches!! Great breakfast sandwiches on bagels! Friendly service. Highly recommend

Hey new owners!!!! I saw and gave it another shot, I got a Taylor ham egg and cheese and it was sooooo delicious so fresh then I saw the back of the menu and omggggg Spanish foood yeessssss so we got empanadas and rice and beans and wow was it so amazing so absolutely fresh and authentic. You can tell they know their stuff. I also got a pastrami. Rueben and the Russian had a kick to it , absolutely delicious. Keep it up you Guys rock read more

Perfect food every time. Fast delivery. Great service. Friendly people when I'm there in person. All around great place. Every time.

I will never buy from this place again! If everyone is complaining about the same rude woman, you'd think management would have corrected her by now, right? So I ordered breakfast from them one morning before my wife's appointment. They were a bit late - that's okay. We waited and waited and waited and still nothing. Now my wife had to leave without getting anything to eat. I called them on the phone to see what was going on. The woman on the phone was extremely rude and sounded like I was annoying her. Shouldn't I have been the one annoyed and shouldn't the business be the one trying to reassure the customer? She told me they were on the way so I waited. After an extremely long time I had to call again. Once again, the annoyed woman told me that they were on their way. Not a "sorry for the wait," not a "we apologize, we got held up this morning" (which happens) not even an estimate of the time. Just the same rude, generic answer "it's coming"... she might as well have told me to f-off! After about 2 hours later, the food finally came. Now you would think during a time like this when businesses such as this one are going down, a business would do their best to stay afloat, especially if it meant something as simple as customer service. Call a customer and tell them you're going to be late, give a sincere apology, heck, even offer a complimentary coffee or something, but to become rude and annoyed that a customer doesn't want to wait 2 hours after the anticpated time for a meal is completely unacceptable! Please, do not buy from them. read more

First time trying here via delivery, their bagels are pretty decent size and tasty. Breakfast sandwiches are good as well. Give them a try!

Love their breakfast sandwiches!!!!! The blond girls who work there regularly make the sandwiches the best!!! Sorry I do not know there names or I would use them. Definitely a weekly regular!!! Must Try! If you want your bagel toasted make sure to ask and you can choose the cheese you want on your sandwich. They slice it fresh. read more

I am usually picky with my bagel shops but I decided to stop by Goldberg's on my way home for some BEC sandwiches. I like this place, mostly because they put two eggs on the sandwich without question! They also had green bagels for Saint Patricks Day! read more

Goldberg's Pompton Lakes - BEC on a green everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

Wish I could give half a star not even. Last time I ever walk in this place. Has gone down hill with their food and NOW THEIR CUSTOMER SERVICE! My order was taken by an extremely rude lady with tattoos. Never felt so insulted ordering coffee before. By the way coffee sucks too. Don't ho here spend the extra 5 minute drive to bagel loops or pompton hot bagels. read more

I'm giving this a three star instead of 1 because I do like their food on the days that it is made well. The issue I have with Goldberg's is the really unwelcoming feeling I get from the girl that is at the counter. Not only does she not smile, but she seems annoyed by every request and actually rolls her eyes. I try to come here as little as possible because she makes me feel so uncomfortable. Even when I make phone calls to pick up an order, she gets REALLY annoyed if she can't hear you. This is the closest bagel store to my house so I am not going to stop going, but I hope her behavior is corrected. I don't know if she is the manager or something cause she is always there on weekends, but there should be an owner or another manager there to ensure that the staff is at the least, friendly. As for the food. The bacon is always rubbery and they only put two thin slices on the sandwiches. I usually ask for extra meat to deter that from happening. Also, the eggs are almost ALWAYS overcooked. Eggs should not be brown. Other than that, the food is good, you just have to be particular about how you want it cooked, deal with an attitude, then you can go home with a decent meal. read more

Delicious bagels for an affordable price. One thing I really enjoy about Goldberg's is that their staff wear gloves when handling the bagels before ringing them up at the register. I've been to many bagel shops where the employees handle the money at the register and then touch the bagels. Yuck! Fortunately, Goldberg's has a clean and friendly environment and great bagels to go with it. read more

This businesses has truly gone bad. Staff is very slow and customer service is non-existent. When the owners were present, the food was well prepared and fast service. Now the food is skimpy and when it is cooked it's mainly burnt. Not worth the time or money to go back. My suggestion would be to replace staff with experienced crew. read more

Goldberg's Pompton Lakes - Very disappointed in the way the business has become. Sandwiches have become skimpy and poorly made. - Bagels Near Me - Pompton Lakes, New Jersey

Best bagels in town. Highly recommend the everything "flagel" toasted with butter. Pancake platter is also delicious.

I have a biweekly ritual of getting morning bagels for about 10 years of living in NJ. Bagels, like any food, are a personal preference & taste, so no one person can say "these are the best in the world". That said, this is my "go to" place for the past year, I get the same thing every time and the staff remembers it & makes it perfectly. Simply put: the bagels here are awesome. They have enough of the normal bagel variety, with options for coffee, local baked goods like croissants, muffins, etc (really like their chocolate coffee cake sometimes as a treat). Their wait staff is a younger high-school type crowd, but they are good kids. One reviewer said they had experience with them chit-chatting, but I've never had that experience personally. If anything it is the reverse, they seem to like the work environment in the shop and take their job seriously. I don't know who drives it, but the place is also unusually clean, so it points to the employees having pride in their work environment. CONCLUSION: Overall, I feel lucky to have such a great bagel on my commute to work. Good luck with your decision! (we are talking about bagels, you can't go too wrong) PS: They have TONS of lunch options, hotdogs, burgers, etc. The lunch stuff seems very appealing & cool but I always forget to think of them for lunch so I have not gone. read more

Bagels are good. I know bagels, I used to work at a bakery. I did not experience any shoddy service whatsoever. The "kids" work pretty good. I personally don't go to a bagel shop expecting Michelin star service. But that's just me. Give this place a chance and you'll be pleasantly surprised with the quality of the food that is produced here. There are other locations as well. They are all really good. The one in wyckoff is exceptional! Everyone has a bad day, everyone has been young, starting out in the work force. Good things come to those who wait! read more

Great bagels! Fresh and delish! First time ordering from them today and the sandwich and bagels were great! They must be new to Grubhub..the delivery is very fast too! read more

What a great place with excellent service & extremely friendly & knowledgeable staff!! I highly recommend stoping in for fresh bagels and service with a smile!! read more

We like the sandwiches for breakfast. Always taste great. Service is prompt and accurate. Wish they woulkd put a little bit more meat on those sandwiches. That would give a true 5 star rating. read more

Great food. Service is sub-par. Staff will be nice when they choose to, and mess up order every other day I visit.

Honestly, I am extremely satisfied with this Goldberg's. The food is great and tasty, just like the other stores. However, unlike the other stores, the service is a little bit uncivil. I went in last week during my trip through P. Lakes. There was a fairly short line but the two girls there were aloof. One was busy in back with something and a young blonde haired girl, literally stood there, looked right at me with disinterest and contempt, and continued to play on her phone! There was one tall black haired boy who was busy with people's orders at the grill. I had to wait for him to finish because the other girls obviously had no interest in serving me. The boy genuinely apologized even though the wait was anything but his fault. I will definitely come back because of the pleasant young man and great Hemicuda (Hot cappy ham with 2 eggs, Taylor ham and pepperjack cheese) they offer. I highly recommend this goldbergs. read more

Great bagels - rude help, actually one in particular with a smart mouth. Complaints accomplish nothing.

Go out of our way to come here for lunch often. The best Goldberg's that we've found so far. All of the food we've had has been fresh and well made. The owners are very friendly and make sure that everything is how you like it. read more

Bagels done right. Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese classic. Good simple service. Cheap. Good decor. The owner is always on site and the cashiers and food prep are always helpful and attentive. They make a hell of a good bagel and slather on the cream cheese when I want a simple bagel. It makes for a hell of a breakfast. It would be a shame for someone to ignore a good simple bagel shop for a review by a scorned customer. read more

Close to my parents house and the bus stop... We stopped in there this morning for 3 sandwiches and 1/2 dozen bagels and iced coffee... Took 25 min which seemed a little long but there was only two younger girls working... On a Sunday. Both were polite and didn't seem phased by my cousins super picky order, and got it all correct. The sandwiches were good and the bagels were amazing... Love their cucumber cream cheese. The ice coffee was off though, it tasted horrible but we can't win them all. read more