We had a reallllllly good lunch here. The lunch special is a steal. The cheese pizza was fresh and crispy, and the service was excellent. Honestly, the service made the experience even better. The ghost chili honey sauce was the perfect finishing touch. Make this a stop. read more

Solid local place. They can be a bit grumpy at times, lol. Prices are a bit high. But, pizza is good...I'd say 7.2 on the "Portnoy Scale." Wings are decent too. If they were a bit nicer and went the "second mile," they'd be in the high 7's. Ambiance isn't too bad...I rarely see people eating in there--seems like mostly people do takeout, which is what I've done. read more

We got take out from Goodfellas for dinner. The menu on line is accurate. We had cheese slices, cheese calzone with bacon, Bronx bomber sub, and NJ French fries. Good food and reasonable prices. read more

See all

I've had pizza here before and it was only OK. But I went tonight and the pizza was delicious!!! I had half cheese and half pepperoni and it was sooooo good. I don't know what they changed but keep it up and I'll be back. read more

The crust was burned on the bottom. Couldn't find the ham on our Hawaiian pizza. Not very tasty. A big disappointment. read more

I had a very disappointing experience at Goodfellas Pizza. I placed an online order on Easter, but the restaurant was closed when I arrived. When I called the next day to request a refund, I was given a hard time and pressured into accepting store credit instead. Later, I placed a pickup order for 9 PM and was told I had to arrive by then because they close at 9, even though their website says they're open until 10. The food also was VERY appalling--the salad was bland, and the stromboli was UNDERCOOKED with RAW dough inside. There was so much raw dough I ate multiple bites, thinking it was a mild chewy mozzarella. The Male running the place is rude and the way my food was given to me almost feels intentional. Overall, the service felt unprofessional, and the experience was not worth it. This place needs to be shut down for health violations. I would not recommend this location. read more

Good pizza very reminiscent of New York for service and ambiance- nice local go to no frills spot - pretty much what I want from a pizza place. Good sauce and crust read more

We finally enjoyed a good meal at this restaurant and we. Will come back again,we stop and didn't go anymore because the cashier/manager with a bear made us feel uncomfortable and was really rude with my mom a couple times and now finally find out that he didn't work there anymore and the restaurant was busy with a lot happy faces . Thank you Goodfellas we will cone back more often now read more

Stopped in to try pizza & garlic knots We are suddenly huge fans of this family owned pizzeria. It's tucked away in the Jupiter Square Plaza beside Publix. They have a great NY Italian theme going on. Service was friendly,fast & easy We will definitely be back to try a few dishes on their menu. The slices are a nice size & garlic knots are hot & fresh They have 7 tables inside & some outdoor seating. Plenty of parking read more

Goodfella's Pizza - a close up of a piece of bread - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

See all

Super good pizza! It had great flavor and was delicious. We got the grandmother pizza and it was great! read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Grandmother pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

Veggie pizza was the best I've ever had. It was delivered by Door Dash very quickly. Pizza was hot, fresh & delicious!

Ordered 2 small(14" inch) pizzas, $15 each One had extra cheese and mushrooms. The other had half pepperoni and pineapple and half mushrooms and extra cheese. Final bill $50. So $20 in toppings for 2 toppings on each pizza. $5 per topping folks, highway robbery for lackluster cardboard football pizza. Each pizza is $15 and 2 toppings are charged at 70% of the original pizza price!!!!! Person on the phone was rude when I asked for pricing which makes sense cause their prices are so high they are afraid of losing the sale. Ever since they received a lackluster review from Portnoy of 7.5 they are gouging. $25 for a small 14 inch pizza is bonkers crazy gouging. Go to Vinny's, D'Angelo's, Baldino's or Zips read more

Goodfella's Pizza - (2) 14" inch pizzas for $50 dollars. Crazy town - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

Ordered an eggplant parm hero, which is a sub down here in Florida. The roll was a hot dog roll. Didn't enjoy it. You need a good Italian bread with eggplant [arm hero. The calzones and pizza are good. I'll stick to pizza when I order from them. read more

best philly cheese steak, boli or stuffed roll in florida!!! truly tried several from stuart to boca raton!

Great pizza and pasta! We ordered take out after a long night at the beach and they were fast and very friendly!

I live on Long Island and have literally 9 pizzerias within 3 miles of my home. So I consider myself a tad picky when it comes to pizza. I've tried several in the Jupiter area and all were lacking and bordered on store bought quality. However Goodfella's is by far the closest I've had to NY pizza. We ordered a large cheese with sausage. The crust was excellent. It was cooked to perfection. Nice and crispy but not Over cooked. The sauce was great and the sausage was great. Plus we had a Greek salad that was perfect! I won't try another while in Jupiter! read more

Ordered a Margarita with sausage and the chicken wings. Both were tasteless. I was very disappointed, because I have always enjoyed their pizza. read more

Stopped by for a couple of slices in my never ending search for best pizza n area. They have a $7.50 lunch special , 2 slices and a fountain drink . Slices are huge with a nice undercarriage. Unfortunately not a lot of flavor. Something was missing. My search continues. read more

Very small quantity of toppings. This pizza sucked. The toppings are really sparse, it appears someone was trying REALLY hard to save money. At nearly $3 a topping, I want to see more than 20 pepperoni on a whole 18" pizza. There were maybe 4 or 5 tiny mushrooms per giant slice. And maybe 4 or 5 pepperoni. I'm not mad about there not being a lot of banana peppers on there. But the pepperoni and mushrooms - you get way more toppings at Domino's It looks like they paid someone $8 an hour to make this and told them if they use too many toppings they're fired. This is one sad pizza with a sad quantity of toppings.​ read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

See all

Second time here, but my first time reviewing the restaurant. The pizza, as I recall from my first visit, was completely competent pizza shop style pizza. This time, I got their antipasto salad and wings to go. I was greeted promptly and placed my order at the counter. The restaurant is super clean and they had a hand sanitizer pump right on the counter - no concerns over their COVID protocols. Upon getting home and unpacking the food, I did notice my order of 12 wings only contained 11. Certainly not the end of the world, but not ideal to get fewer than I paid for. At least they weren't over cooked or skimpy wings. Fine size and taste (went with hot). Overall, the food was good, not great. Keeping in mind it's just a salad and wings after all, still giving them 4 stars. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Antipasto salad - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

Horrible! Beware of service! My credit card was mistakenly charged $1000.00, and they would not credit me back my money. Criminal! read more

Best Pizza around Juno Beach. Most of the time I call ahead and order for a pickup. Small shop in front for table seating read more

Consistently decent pizza. Could be cooked a bit more when asking for it to be well done. Love the fried ravioli

We called in a pickup order for a large pepperoni pizza and asked for extra pepperoni. I don't necessarily think the pizza came with "extra"pepperoni which is why I am giving 4 stars. I also wished the crust had some type of seasoning or flavoring. It is somewhat bland. However the pizza was cooked to perfection and the sauce is delicious. I asked for an extra side of sauce and the portion size was large. I didn't receive an itemized receipt so I don't know how much they charge for it. They ask customers to wear masks inside but none of the workers had masks on. Not even the guy collecting money with direct contact to all take out order customers. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

See all

Great pizza, amazing crust and sauce. This place is legit. NY style pizza with great service. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Fantastic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida

See all

They make Calzones worthy of the name "Calzone". Packed full of cheese and whatever else you desire and then perfectly baked. ALL made fresh to order!! read more

Ordered on the phone. Ordered 7 items. Mine was missing. Called and they remade my food after everyone else had eaten. And it was wrong so I couldn't eat it. They said they would refund. They never did. I had to go back to get the refund. They offered nothing as a compensation. read more

Nasty customer service! Guidos! Veal parm was leather and was chopped up chunks rather than a veal cutlet, pizza was burned. Called to complain and the wanna be guido hung up on me. Called back and guy said he didn't care. Do not order from this dump! Save your money. Go to McDonald's before going to goodfellas. Beware to customer! Probably a money laundering operation. New York attitude. Go back up north! read more

Like most of the reviews, I came to try the pizza, and left unsatisfied. It's not awful, but just doesn't have that pop of flavor you know good pizza has. It's pretty average, a little doughy, a little floppy, and just not that tasty. HOWEVER, the calzone is actually pretty good, and is definitely better than the pizza. Great filling, great crust, properly baked-very nice. Would only come back here for the calzone. read more

Placed an order for the first time 'for a company meeting - my order never came ' Restaurant blame ubber for the service. I will blame the Restaurante, you have to be careful with the reputation you get as a Restaurant. First time and never again - what a shame! read more

Exquisite NY Pizza! Service is superb! Awesome array of Old NY Little Italy's black and white historic photos allover! read more

if I could give them 10 stars I would the service was fantastic i always found myself to be an avid pizza enthusiast for years and I'm from Chicago so I know we have good pizza but Joe and David amazed me the hospitality was fantastic the craftsmanship and time taken in every slice is ungodly the staff is a well oiled machine working together and going above and beyond. This pizza is the best pizza I've ever had in my entire life 100% will be back. read more

Hit or miss. Sometimes good. Sometimes not so much. Tonight's Grandma Pizza was soggy and not too good.

Meat Lovers pizza. Super thin crust w/ a greasy, tasteless cheese, a few pieces of ham, meatloaf?, bacon & pepperoni.Service was unfriendly, 'don't give a shit' attitude. The previous pizza shop was Bonzo's which was very good for years. Heating up the pizza the next day only made it worse! I've never seen crust this thin! I won't be back.. read more

Ordered a Sicilian Pie , half plain, half sausage pepper and onion. Asked for well done, was not well done, had very little sauce, very little cheese, very little sausage pepper and onion. It was one of the worst pies i have had for $30.00. read more

Decent pizza...BUT, beware of delivery times. I ordered a pie at 3:05pm, for delivery at 6:50pm...at 7:15, I called and was told "it's in the oven, and we got kinda busy". I'm not sure what time I had to order to have it delivered on time, but you'd think 4 hours would have been sufficient. read more

Go somewhere else. Terrible service. The employee in charge of phones and orders really screwed things up. Complete and total waste of time and effort. Called well in advance and when arrived 30 minutes later to pick up my order it hadn't even been started yet. The employee was simply taking all orders and not putting them through to the kitchen. Never again. read more

As authentic as any of my old haunts on Long Island, right down to the pizzaria smell (which is a good thing). My parents live here now part time and fully back this place. Nice friendly staff, lots of options, and great wings too. #ProTip: They HAVE gluten-free crust, but it's not on their website menu (as of today), so if you want that, call and mention it. Stoked all around. read more

I've lived in Jupiter for 7 years now. Pizza places here are everywhere, and everyone has an opinion. Yet, my wife and I and seemingly everyone I talk to can agree on this one pizza place. Not necessarily that it is above all others, but that it is objectively, truly excellent pizza. So, if you are struggling to find a solid, consistently good pizza place that everyone can agree on, you should try Goodfellas. Their pizza is a New York style thin crust pizza. I'm quite partial to their thicker crust bambino pizza. They also make an excellent Sicilian pizza. Their fried mozzarella and zeppoli are also excellent as sides. read more

Best Grandma Pie south of Staten Island. Always have a great meal here. The entire menu is wonderful. Great lunch Specials during the week as well. Thanks Goodfellas! read more

Goodfella's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Jupiter, Florida