Pizza (and Italian food) Medium sized pizza place located in a small strip mall on the edge of the Walmart parking lot, Goodfellas is pretty good actually. We have only had pizza here so review is limited to pizza. My kids, who are notoriously picky eaters, ask to come here and for good reason- the pizza has been very good every time we have been here. We have tried both take-out and eaten in the place and no matter which option you go with, the pizza is hot and fresh. Location is adorned with a lot of photos of NYC and various landmarks withing - except for one oddball Ford photo of a 1-millionth car that has nothing to do with NY... it just irks me personally. With the name they are using, maybe some pics of the movie Goodfellas might go better - just sayin. The big guy behind the counter is ok - tends to be on the quieter side but he gets the job done. Tables and the restaurant are clean and restrooms are usually in good shape. Slices are large and there is a self-serve soda area and there are some bottled beer / wine options for the dine-in people.... (the wine bottles are those little single serving bottles). Prices are average and there is parking in the front. All in all a solid pizza option. read more

10/10 pizza and service! It's great to see people in the area who can make a true NY style pizza. From the New York photos on the wall to the hot and fresh pizza paired with homemade garlic knots it's the best spot to stop in and grab an order if you are in the area. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port St. Lucie, Florida

See all

This is definitely one of my favorite spots and always good for a quick bite. I come here with the kids if they have a really good week at school and they love it. The staff is always very nice and accommodating the pizzas are pretty big slices and they always recommend for me to cut it in have for the kids . The buffalo wings are top tier also ! read more

See all

They have a very tasty pizza, especially deep dish. The delivery is relatively quick Shrimp Alfredo and Greek salad are also very good read more

I would give this 0 stars. Eggplant Parmesan was awful. All breading almost no eggplant. What looked like several cutlets was actually only breading. . Spaghetti had very sauce. Baked ziti was all pasta negligible sauce. Dry and bland. The pizza was so so. Again lacked sauce. Bland. . Would not eat there again. Don't recommend read more

Stopped in on Father's Day for a Large pie , First time at this location . The Pizza was Excellent very NY style , Crispy, No Flop , Quality ingredients, Good Sauce , Good Cheese ..We shared a house salad it was an average salad . The Front guy who rang us up could have been a bit friendlier, No greeting when we came in or left . But the pizza was really good and also reheated well .I did like the large photos of old New York they had printed and framed .. I would definitely go back read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Large pie - Pizza Near Me - Port St. Lucie, Florida

Pretty good pizza!!! Clean place and service was great. My children liked it and that says alot read more

Amazing food that was fresh, came out quickly, and great customer service from Anthony! After a bad experience at Jimmy John's, we decided to come here for subs. Anthony hooked us up with freshly made sandwiches, that not only tasted amazing, but were huge and 100% worth the price. Bread was fresh and super soft. 10/10 recommend! Truly the goodestfellas lol read more

Ordered through uber eats about 30 minutes before the restaurant closed and was accepted while driver was there waiting for pickup. Then I received another delivery driver trying to pick up my order to no avail. After the 3rd delivery driver tried picking up my order, I realized that my order was not being picked up or cancelled by Goodfella's. Will never order from again. read more

Order online, was easy, and the driver was very nice, the sent me someone else's order and when I called to let them know, they couldn't care less... So sorry John S who ordered on Slice you're not getting what you ordered. And it seems like you ordered a lot... read more

Goodfella's Pizza - The receipt for someone else's order.. - Pizza Near Me - Port St. Lucie, Florida

My wife and me are regulars. Whenever we want pizza we go to Goodfella's. The place is unassuming, and simple with great pizza.

Great meat lovers and cheese pizzas ! We love to get their baked ziti as well. The only thing we wish they would change is their garlic knots. We just are not fans of the raw almost sour taste of the garlic. But out of all the pizza places in psl I do think this location is the best read more

I went here and ordered pizza and garlic knit's. we had an issue and contacted the manager and he was rude and didn't help us. they kept hanging up and blocked our number from calling then when I left a bad google review; they doxxed my information by giving out my phone number and what state my tags were in and insulted my weight and called me a scam artist. this was our first time coming in there and first complaint. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Here's proof - Pizza Near Me - Port St. Lucie, Florida

Had high hopes . Like in the movie Saturday night fever where John travolta father said about the sauce "it don't drip and it doesn't taste ". The sauce needs LOVE. Meatballs are tasteless. read more

11.8.24 Ordered a Pizza with Pepperoni and bacon Pie and there was hardly any bacon on the pie. Called to complain and was told that I needed to go through door dash and hung up on me, would not help. I asked for a manager and was told no one was available. Will never order with your company again. door dash is a pickup delivery not the restaurant. They took the order should be filled accordingly. Asked for a refund, asked me to take it up with door dash, what a joke. they don't make the order. Thanks Billy for your professionalism that is if it's your real name that you gave. does not deserve 1 star but yelp requires it. poor customer service. read more

This restaurant used to be a go-to for myself and my co-workers. We would dine in and order take-out. The quality of the service and food as severely gone downhill. It is a shame. The last 3 times I or my co-workers have ordered from Goodfella's there have been issues: missing multiple food/drinks, receiving burnt food (see photos), drivers displaying a lack of knowledge of transporting food (putting food in the trunk of their car with no padding, resulting in food leaking and spilling out of containers (see photos)), etc. On one occasion the restaurant attempted to correct their mistake by providing a 2-liter of soda and a set of plates and utensils. I am not sure what caused this all to happen but it is very unfortunate. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - a variety of pastries - Pizza Near Me - Port St. Lucie, Florida

See all

Love the pizza . Never disappoints . It taste exactly like ny pizza.always hot and delicious.

Pizza slices and huge & the pizza is delish! Great service. Pizza is always ready in a timely manner.

We tried this location today. Have been to another location on US 1, but this one is closest for us. Quick service, right as you walk in, greeted and order taken. Young man was very nice, took our order and we got our drinks. Food was ready in less then 10 minutes and was very good. Hubby got sausage, pepper, onion roll, I got two pieces pizza. Both done correctly, and very flavorful. Will definitely be back read more

We again tried delivery. Yesterday I felt sick after eating the pizza. One pizza had a liner, the other one wasn't so lucky. And even though we ordered the same size we got different sizes. The shape was strange too not round. And to add insult to injury, the onions must have been forgotten because raw onions was dumped in the middle. Pretty awful. Sorry. No more pizza from here. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port St. Lucie, Florida

See all

The pizza was too greasy but the chicken wings are good. Not better than pappys or Frank and Al's tho

This place started out great, but then they started burning the pizza. Not a little overdone, I'm talking a full-on incineration. I let it go and chalked it up to a busy night, but after the second time, I decided to find a new pizza place that actually cared about what they were serving. (We always picked up our order, and took it home.) When they don't torch the pizza, it's good. But I got tired of throwing away my money because it was inedible. No, I didn't complain because I worked in a restaurant and know that the squeaky wheel complainer often gets more than he bargained for. Here's a picture of the last straw. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Burned pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port St. Lucie, Florida

We used to eat here before we moved two years ago. It was pretty good - no issues. Came here today for an easy slice and after thirty minutes, I was told that I was charged for toppings and not the pizza. So, I pay for pizza and I'm just sitting here almost an hour later. The place is freaking trashed. Food all over the floors and tables, but someone is cleaning the back. Staff is nice enough. The wait is absolutely horrible. read more

buffalo chicken pizza was spectacular had and abundance of chicken and buffalo sauce the steak gangster is a personal favorite would recommend to anyone looking for italian food in the port saint lucie area read more

As my first time here. I ordered stuffed shells to go. The bag was dripping of grease and the container had sauce coming out of it. I took it back and the person who takes the order. Was understanding about it and told me they would remake it. The ambiance is nice but poor way to hand a customer. read more

I drive 20 for this pizza every time. The reason being, it's the closest pizza I've tasted to NY pizza. I'm not saying 100% obviously, but this is actually pizza. Wings are pretty good. Zeppole is good. Fries are good knots are good. Salad is good. I love the pictures hanging. Makes you feel like home. I like that they remember you wherever you come in. Really nice place. Id definitely recommend it to anyone. read more

Excellent pizza, great, fast service and good prices make this our go-to spot for regular pizza. Try it; you'll love it too!

When I first moved here a few years ago the food was good. Always hot and on time. Last time I ordered it took 2 hours and the chicken parm tasted was old. It was chewy and when I cut it with a knife all the breading came off. Something has gone wrong here. I would stay away read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Worst chicken parm - Pizza Near Me - Port St. Lucie, Florida

I ordered a simple margarita pizza with tomato, cheese and basil.... and there was NO BASIL! What a disappointment. The basil makes the pizza and it's not there... The fried mushrooms are good but who knows if they are homemade or not. read more

Born in Brooklyn and have lived in NYC for 48 years until moving down here 4 years ago. This is my go to place for Pizza. This place is always on point. Great pizza! Always a few different pies to choose from and they always have Sicilian slices which is hard to find down here, and they are on par with most NYC Sicilian slices. They also make a great Grandma pie as well. Anyone telling you to go to Frank and Al's over this place, does not know what good Pizza is. read more

We picked up a huge Chicago style pizza and brought it home to the family... it was gone in minutes! Growing up in Chicago, I think I know a few things about deep dish pizza! This pizza from Goodfella's was amazing! Great ingredients, sauce and crust!!! Thanks, Chris & Shannon R. read more

I HATE giving a bad review because people work so hard just to make a living and our food industry is suffering now BUT I'm sorry... this was not good. The sausage was old (could taste the freezer burn) and the crust was extremely soggy. Ordered a meats lover. I'm new to FL from NY but have had amazing pizza from PSL. Go to Frank and Al's!! read more

Pizza was average. Would've been better if it was hot. My main issue was the wings. We ordered 12 hot wings and 12 honey garlic wings (They wouldn't split the flavors on an order of 24 which was annoying) They only gave us one blue cheese for all 24 wings and the cup it came in wasn't even filled up halfway. Luckily we had some dipping sauces at home. Worst part of all: The honey garlic wings were dry and barely had any sauce on them. They also thought it was okay to pass these skimpy bones off as "jumbo wings" If you're gonna offer wings on your menu, you had better do them right. I'm visiting family this week and this was my first time trying this spot. Can say with confidence that I won't be trying them ever again. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port St. Lucie, Florida

See all

So glad they opened in SLW! Great food and service! My husband lives the meatsauce spaghetti! Can't beat the pizza deals!

Food is awesome and we have always consistently received great food and the correct order every time. I've never had anything bad from here. We've always ordered delivery and it comes in a timely manner. read more

Something happened, it was good but it is sucking now and there rude on the phone . Looking for a new place

Completely disappointed. I'm a New Yorker recently moved down. I ordered a chicken parm with penne and the sauce was absolutely horrible. Not what I was expecting from "Goodfella's" pizza. Won't be ordering from there again. read more

The Margarita pizza is amazing and a must try!! It is always on point and a regular favorite of ours. We usually have it delivered and they are at my door no later than 20-30 mins after I've ordered, presenting with a hot fresh pizza that is drool worthy haha I would say this pizza is a must try and would highly recommend this place to anyone looking for some delicious pizza and timely delivery! read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port St. Lucie, Florida

Ate in on 2/17/20. Sat facing the kitchen. Saw the guy who had just brought our pizza blowing his nose, walking around. He threw the paper towel away and then opened the pizza oven to check something. He then finished wrapping a sandwich that was sitting on the counter for pickup and handed it to the man waiting. He was watching the tv so he didn't see it. I then saw him walking around scratching his beard. He just now washed his hands, five minutes later. When we first got here, the girl at the register brought out our fries. I said thanks. No response from her. I went to get some lemonade. Sat down, took a sip, and it was completely watered down. I mentioned it to her and she just said, "oh, yeah." Like she knew about it. Then she walked out with an "out of order" sign to tape to it. Really disappointing because the pizza was really delicious. read more

Excellent pizza!! Love to go there for all the different slices they have. Quick dinner to pick up on a busy night. You will not regret it, the people are extremely nice as well!!!! read more