Way too expensive... children are running the store with no courtesy or experience. They burnt my garlic knots. Also did not include the amount of meat on my wise guy's pizza because I added artichoke; which I had to pay for. When I walked in, every single employee was sitting on their ass watching tv, and no one welcomed me to the store read more

New York pizza in New Mexico? Yes, at GoodFellas. The crust is chewy and delicious, just like an East Coast pizza should be. Toppings are fresh and generous with plenty of cheese. My son had a calzone and devoured the whole thing before I could get a single bite. It was easy to order over the phone and our pizza was waiting for us when I got there. They called us back with a question about our order, which I appreciated. Everyone was friendly and you can tell it's a family business where they are happy to welcome you. read more

Hand made pizza mom and pops style restaurant. Dine in area great for get togethers. Family oriented business. read more

Excellent in every way they follow every instruction! I don't care for their mozzarella sticks, but they're deep dish. Well done is freaking amazing! And there Cobb salad salads are amazing. Everything is amazing here. read more

Traveled down yonder south to small town Los Lunas and checked out Goodfellas. True and authentic NewYork style pizza handcrafted by Frank aka Franky the Pizza Boss, was great to meet him as he is a hardworking and true to his love & passion in bringing the best pies to Los Lunas. I'm not trying to be a wiseguy but Goodfellas is whipping out some of the best Pies in town, along with their super duper stuffed calzone delicious pizza rolls and definitely has some finger licking good wings and their creative twist of a Greek style pizza! Mamma Mia Goodfellas you've stolen a pizz-a my heart! read more

See all

Great Pizza. I don't have no complaints on how it's made. Every ingredients Goodfellas puts in their pizzas in awesome. Especially "The Soprano" which my favorite with what else....green Chile. read more

GoodFellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Los Lunas, New Mexico

See all

These people hire teenagers who don't care... Their quality of service and food is not good... Microwave food and and just hurry up and order attitude... No adult supervision... Surprised that they are still in business...Guess The Name Says It All...Goodfellas Will Rip You Off... Fast Food Italian A Place To Avoid... read more

Pizza, wings and garlic knots are always amazing. Workers are always friendly and food always comes out fast.

I would love to be able to rate the Pizza Higher but honestly my tastebuds are blown out due to the overwhelming heaping handfuls of garlic. The pizza description lists a lot of wonderful ingredients but I can't speak to the taste of the house made sauce, homemade mozzarella or dough. I can confirm that the pizza I received was void of fresh basil. Three of us tried to eat this and no one could get through a single slice. Hopefully the deserts are better, will try them tomorrow. I hope this isn't the norm here was really looking forward to some decent NY style pizza. Tried to call the restaurant but they kept putting me on hold and hanging up before I could talk to anyone. read more

See all

Ford is outstanding! Slices are huge. Good New York Style Pizza. Why does this have to be so long.

Definitely not worth a trip out of the way. Several wrong orders while we were here, including ours and very slow. Pizza came out undercooked and garlic knots were swimming in oil. read more

GoodFellas Pizzeria - Chicken pizza. Notice what's missing? - Pizza Near Me - Los Lunas, New Mexico

Pizza was good but there is better in the area. Maybe we caught them on a bad night. It took a long time to get our to go order. All in all I would there again but there are better options. read more

Oh. Baby. This is seriously some fine pizza. As a new englander, it's hard to find authentic NY style pizza around these parts and I've found it. I bought the gyro pizza. No tomato base, gyro meat, olives, feta, gyro meat, red onions, green peppers, tomatoes...all with a side of tzatziki. Wonderful pizza, large slices, extremely flavorful. Can't wait to try more! Was told 45-1hour, delivery arrived at half hour mark. Phone ordering was easy. Delivery guy was super nice. read more

GoodFellas Pizzeria - Gyro pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Lunas, New Mexico

Ordered take out and the Pizza was great, reasonably priced for a large Pepperoni Pizza, I'll definitely order from them again. read more

GoodFellas Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Lunas, New Mexico

Looking for a New York style pizza place in Los Lunas, then come here. This place has some of the best Italian dishes I ever had. They have a lot of other stuff other than pizza like wings, salads, pastas, sandwiches, and the best cannolis. They have a nice arcade with a party room so you can bring your kids there too. read more

This used to be one of my favorites. The owner is great and hardworking. The new staff and the quality of food has gone down hill.. last time I was in I waited almost an hour for a to-go order while I watched others come in after me and leave before me. No I didn't have a large or complicated order. read more

Never call in an order. U still have to wait for another 10 mins. On top of the 15 mins. They tell u in the phone.

If you want to be treated with common courtesy, skip this place. The two people I spoke with were rude, told me the problem occurred "because she's new," and hung up on me. There's no manager or owner available, so they said I had to call tomorrow if I wanted my credit card refunded for the order I canceled. Ridiculous. DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME. read more

Wonderful pizza! Gluten-free crust is delicious! I also live the baklava for dessert.

Ok hear me when I say that I did not expect the slices to be beyond GIANT. I tried this place through DoorDash and ordered 2 slices, which at most pizza places is how much I would typically order, and a side salad. When my food was dropped off, I legitimately thought they gave me someone else's order before I opened the box. There were two full sized pizza boxes and a giant container. Nope. It was my order. To my surprise, the slices are basically just the size of an entire pizza and the side salad was almost family sized. Food was just ok, not a huge fan personally of their style of pizza, but they definitely brought the wow factor read more

Their garlic knots are hard to beat!! Local business, which I like!! Not much for the decor, but get it to go & eat in pizza heaven at home!! They also have salads, which I like!! read more

Since we relocated to Albuquerque from just north of Buffalo NY on Christmas Eve, we've been on the lookout for a real Brooklyn style pizza. As we've yet to close on our house, and are living in a Casita in Bosque Farms; we found Goodfellas just south in Los Linas. A long day of orientation at UNMH for me, my wife at Faith Comes by Hearing, and our Jack Russell terrier at the casita necessitated a search for a tasty pizza and we found GoodFellas (not to be confused with Goodguys, which is equally as good in North Tonawanda, NY) and ordered the Soprano and a garden salad. Both were excellent and reminded us of NY. If you're from NY, or are just interested in a great NY style pizza; head to GoodFellas. You'll not be disappointed. read more

Great pizza!! Friendly staff!! Love their pizza roll and garlic knots. Best in Los Lunas. Jessica is the best!! Thank you! read more

GoodFellas Pizzeria - Love it - Pizza Near Me - Los Lunas, New Mexico

The restaurant itself is very simple. No ambience to talk about. However, the pizza was excellent. The best I've had in New Mexico. I will definitely be using them for takeout and enjoy their pizza tremendously. read more

AMAZING! You have to try it to believe it. Best New York style pizza this far side of the globe

Really nice people, great service and really great food! Y'all if you are on a diet don't come here cause it's addicting but in all seriousness if i could rate this business 15/10 I would but I give it 5 stars read more

Hands down best pizza and best customer service!! We ordered an 18" pizza and garlic knots. They thought the slices were too small so they gave us 2 additional GIANT slices to compensate. Amazing! read more

Food is good, however be patient because the wait time is forever...if not in a hurry it is worth the wait. Be sure to ask for salad dressing if you order a salad sometimes they give it and sometimes they don't and when they don't they expect you to pay extra. read more

Very good food & very reasonably priced! I had the Italian combo & wings for $11. Cheesecake for $2.99...delish..nowhere can u get NY cheesecake for that price. The Italian sandwich had lots of meat , cheese & veggies with the right amount of dressing & dressing was delish not tangy or salty! The bread was nice & didn't get soggy. The wings were really good! My friend had the meatball pizza roll & it's huge enough for two people. The meatballs had a really nice spice mixture. The garlic knots were great & the marinara is the bomb! They have nice combos that include pizza drinks tokens for game room. They have a huge game room & they host lots of birthday parties. I am dying to try the pizza now! read more

See all

I ordered a 16' cheese pizza with sausage topping, June 14, 2021, along with 8 garlic knots, no cheese. I received a beautiful looking pizza and the knots where perfection. I got comfortable and enjoyed a very good quality FIRST SLICE, then bit into a second. AS I PULLED MY BITE BACK I COULD SEE A LONG DARK HAIR BAKED INTO THE SLICE AND STARTED TO SPIT THE BITE OUT AND EXPERIENCED WAVES OF NAUSEA ROLL BACK OVER ME. I quickly called the restaurant, was transferred to a manager, he claimed, I explained my experience, he said he was so sorry, had the order in his hand, knew my name, said I could call anytime and have the order replaced and delivered, because I don't drive. Now, I called Monday to have that promise delivered and was passed around and said I would be called back. Hours later I tried and couldn't get past the cashier, who asked if I was Susan, as soon as I asked for a manager. Bottom line, because I used Doordash, they will replace my order, if I pay their delivery charge of $15.00 and up. I live 1.3 miles away. My previous review says I have tried several times to have that magnificent first time experience and am disappointed, now I am disgusted. read more

GoodFellas Pizzeria - Replacements worse than ever/ owner and staff rude beyond belief/ - Pizza Near Me - Los Lunas, New Mexico

See all

You can count on GoodFella's for excellent pizza and tasty meaty wings. They don't skimp on the toppings. I would highly recommend.

Went here and ordered the calzone and a slice of pizza. Calzone was super greasy and barely able to eat it. On the pizza we had ordered sausage on the pizza and they put a gyro meat? Not the best I won't be back read more

Great pie, friendly service at a decent price. They also sell other stuff like pastas and things. What more do you need?

My husband and I really love the pizza from GoodFellas. They make more than pizza with a sizable Italian menu including delicious salads.

I just moved to Los Lunas and saw the ad for Good Fellas pizza. The pizza was great one of the best pizza I have tasted here in NM. I ordered a salad, pizza and a meatball sandwich. Tasted good and you get a good proportions. Good job keep it up!! read more

This place is usually really good. I don't know what happened tonight but the pizza roll was totally unacceptable - overcooked and hardly any meat even though it was supposed to have two different meats in it read more

GoodFellas Pizzeria - Overcooked pizza roll with hardly any meat. - Pizza Near Me - Los Lunas, New Mexico

I'm intrigued by this place because I like a local business. This was my first time so here are my first impressions. The menu is a bit odd. They offered a Greek and Hawaii style pizza but did not have many of the more traditional pizzas I have come to expect. They even had a pizza that looked like 1/4 of four different pizzas reassembled into one combo. Great for a picky family I guess. I ordered four different pizzas and found them all to be just ok. All of them were over sauced so the crust was mushy in the center. Contributing to this was the fact that most of the toppings were concentrated in the center of the pizza rather than evenly spread over the entire pizza. Also the pizza had gyro meat on it which seemed odd on the combo. I will say that the edges of the pizza had well flavored crust and was much better than the soggy center. I did get the feeling that the people did care and part of the pizza was good so I will be back but I will talk to the staff and see if they can address my concerns. I will be as interested in what they say as I am in how the pizza comes out. If they blow me off then this isn't the place for me but if they are nice and make an effort I will be back read more

This is absolutely without a doubt the best pizza place in all of New Mexico! Not even joking. I've been coming here for a while now and it's exceeded my expectations every time I've came. The pizza is authentic 100% New York style pizza which is what I grew up eating and it's so delicious with lots of great seasoning and great cheese, holds good and amazing varieties. The wings are also to die for, so tender and savory. The subs are incredible as well, made me think I was back in NY again. They also have a cool arcade where kids can play. Thanks Amanda and Frank for delivering the best pizza I've had in NM. read more

Love the pizza and the wings are bomb to make sure you call and ask what specials they have they say they always have it

Goodfellas pizza has an amazing diverse menu with lots of different options to choose from, they're salads are amazing they're calzones are amazing nearly everything you'll get from this restaurant will be absolutely amazing I highly recommend grabbing a pizza or salad and stopping by Daniel Fernandez park to have a nice little pizza picnic. In the summer this is a great place to grab a bite and enjoy some fresh air due to its amazing location right next to the park located off of 314 in Los Lunas New Mexico read more