The service, the food, the casual ambience is absolutely phenomenal. I love that the prices are affordable and you get your bang for your buck. If you're from the area you're bound to run into someone you know. The fried thicken salad can be fried or grilled, I always go fried and it never fails. read more

GoodFellas Restaurant & Tavern - Chicken Salad - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

The burgers are huge and taste great. Cool local type bar with super staff and fun people.

This restaurant & bar was a great pick. The mural on the wall is great. The service was amazing. The food was delicious. I'm a huge wedding soup fan and theirs is great, even tho it had carrots in it. Wedding soup should NOT have carrots. Fortunately, there weren't too many and the taste of the soup was great. The Italian egg rolls were delicious. The shell was so crisp and perfect. My friend said the chicken parm was also delicious and that was a lot of food. Prices are reasonable. I'd definitely go back if I lived closer. read more

See all

We love stopping by Goodfella's! The service is always good, the food is always delicious, and the drinks are always cold. read more

See all

Went there for dinner for the first time. Not a fancy place but it was clean. Had the wedding soup and a grilled chicken salad. Both were good I would go back and try an entree or burger. Prices were very reasonable. Service was fine read more

Wedding soup was delicious. Reuben was piled high and delicious. Wings are huge! Service was exceptional. Nice neighborhood pub for friends and families! Nice on the wallet too. read more

Service. I ordered an appetizer and they took 40 minutes to make it. I understand that orders can create a backlog but to wait 40 minutes for something very simple read more

Food is always excellent. Don't often get a Muffalletta - theirs is wonderful. Beer is fine, but nothing exceptional. Service was a tad slow, but pleasant. Certainly a place for locals and regulars. read more

Stephen makes one of the very best Reuben sandwich around and Sandy is one of my favorite bartenders! The daily specials are always delicious. read more

April 8 2025, I place two order of Lasagna $18.50 each , thinking that the lasagna would have hamburger meat inside of it, but no it was just some pieces of sausages and sauce and lot of flat noodles, now if I wanted spaghettis with meat balls , I would of order it, but the lasagna was nothing far from being an Italian lasagna , The taste was great but the presentation of a Italian lasagna was not, I wish there was a restaurant that would let you order the kind of lasagna you want, can I order an vegetable , meat and cheese one, They say they from New York City , now I am a New Yorker and how I love those Italian read more

This is more of a local bar than restaurant but still enjoyed our visit. Sat at a high top next to the bar! Italian wedding soup was very good, although I tried to order the French onion that was listed on the printed menu, they weren't service it that night; only soups listed on the chalkboard ! I wanted a nice cheeseburger but apparently the food delivery hadn't come in so they could offer any burgers! I tried ordering a Ruben, but again they were out. Settled on a grilled cheese with fries! The Sandwich was big and cheesy! Fries were plentiful!! Service was from the bartender, I think her name was Michelle and she was very friendly and attentive! read more

Good service, kind and attentive, clean environment, and delicious food. Best French fries! Gyros, meatball sub, hang over burger with chili, kids pizza, and chicken salad were all great, would stop again if in the area read more

GO TO THIS PLACE Absolutely incredible. I had the Italian Egg Rolls, which are like an egg roll filled with Italian meat and cheese with marinara to dip in. Order comes with 2 that are a little bigger than the egg rolls you're used to Also had the shrimp pasta which was similarly fantastic Feels like everything is homemade and has a very casual atmosphere. All the stars read more

Attitude, maybe the owner was having a bad day but boy did she have a bad attitude last time we were in there, will not be going back

Stopped in yesterday for a late lunch. Service was excellent and friendly. Three of us had the Italian Hoagie and it was very, very good! One had the meatball hoagie and said she loved it. This is a very nice place in Swissvale and I highly recommend GoodFellas! read more

Great place for locals to hang out, grab a drink, or watch some football! This is one of our new favorites since moving nearby. Love their chicken tenders & fries, fish sandwich, italian hoagie, etc. Can't go wrong! We really like the one bartender here she's super nice I wish I remembered her name. Will ask next time so I can update this and give her a shoutout but she was so sweet and remembered me & my drink order after I had only been here 1 visit. I've seen a couple of the other bartenders argue with the manager and be super unpleasant-but the one girl is an absolute sweetheart and our favorite waitress/bartender! read more

See all

Good overall experience my first trip to GoodFellas! I placed my order online ahead of time around 5pm on a weekday. It said the order would be ready in about 25 minutes. I showed up right on time and the order was ready! I entered through the bar however I didn't realize there is a door on the side for takeout- I will enter that way next time. When I got home all the food had transferred well and was still hot. I ordered the fish sandwich and my hubby got the eggplant parm sandwich. No pictures because I devoured mine so fast. It was really good! I will definitely be ordering it again!!! There is SO much on the menu to order and they have a cute outdoor area for when its warm out. They don't do table service outdoors but you can order takeout and sit there. We will definitely be back! read more

i walk into the place am there for an hour or 2 before the dyed red haired waitress tells me i have to leave that i had a tab from awhile ago tells me i have only a few seconds to leave before she calls the police! if i knew the person i was with at that time wasn't going to pay the tab and be a gentleman that i would have happily payed the tab off that i was unaware of until just yesterday!!! totally humiliated me in front of my friend that ive known for years who was there with me and did pay the one thing i had there. read more

Worthy place if in the area. Good wings Service is good too. Good vibes as well good people read more

Good spot to have a drink and/or food. Always super clean and the service is good. The Goodfella hoagie is a cheesesteak x italian hybrid which is loaded read more

GoodFellas Restaurant & Tavern - The "GoodFella" Hoagie - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Local pub/restaurant with amazing Italian food!!!! Ask for Heather; she is hysterical and we'll take great care of any size party. Be sure and try the spinach with cannellini beans. all of our food was homemade and really delicious. It was a good pick for our last night in Pittsburgh. read more

As long as you set your expectations correctly you'll absolutely be satisfied aka get tavern food...no need to get creative and expect a bit of a wait, given normal Covid staffing. Starting positive, the burgers were amazing! My friend had the hangover burger and I had the bourbon bleu cheese mushroom burger. Both were excellent! My friend described the hangover burger as a bunch of things you wouldn't think makes sense together but was perfect! Beyond the burgers the rest of the experience was okay. The cheesesteak egg rolls were like beef stew wrapped in a fried shell and they were topped with lukewarm, shredded cheese. The service was slow but the server was apologetic and very friendly. As for Covid friendliness, the hand sanitizer on the table was a nice touch and they have a lot of clear directions about mask wearing posted everywhere. It wasn't really enforced well, for those who are sticklers for that but we weren't bothered. We'd absolutely get a burger here again! read more

I've passed by this place so many times and one night I finally stopped in. It's a no frills bar, but that's what makes it so great. The service is always good and the food is so so good (hello wings and fresh cut fries). I went with a group and we ordered a little bit of everything and all of the food was very good. If you're in Swissvale and are looking for a place to grab a drink and a bite to eat, then this is your place! read more

GoodFellas Restaurant & Tavern - Hot dog and fries - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Great Italian food and friendly atmosphere. Our go-to place when in Pittsburgh. We come to Pittsburgh 2-3 times a year and always go there at least once every time. read more

Great place to stop and a couple of cold brews. Very clean and great patrons too. The staff is both friendly and professional. The service is outstanding. read more

Nice place to eat. Have some drinks. Listen to music food is good. Service is good it's right off the parkway. Plenty of parking. Drink specials bingo on Wednesdays. read more

Kitchen is open till 10pm not Midnight, not sure why yelp has modnight. Please update on yelp

I had never heard of this place prior to my visit and I'll say I was pleasantly surprised. It's a neighborhood bar that serves food. Though we didn't eat, the regulars raves about it. The place is clean and fun and though some may classify it as a dive I just say neighborhood bar. Prices were super affordable. The bartenders friendly and the patrons just as nice. read more

This tavern was wonderful. Portion sizes were large, prices were good, and food was seasoned well. Highly recommend the spinach artichoke dip. All sauces and dressing are house made and the Italian dressing is divine. The staff was wonderful and very friendly. Would highly recommend! read more

See all

After being turned away from the nearby Firehall fish fry, we decided to satisfy our fish cravings at GoodFellas. We ordered the (Lent special) fish sandwich and the fried butterflied shrimp and hushpuppies to share. Everything was hot, and the hushpuppies had a delightfully crispy crust with a good cornmeal flavor and texture. The shrimp batter was light and crunchy, while the shrimp were tender and moist. The fish sandwich was standard but executed well. Service in the bar area was quick and friendly, but the draft options were limited--only six taps, and none with an IPA. We look forward to eating here again! read more

GoodFellas Restaurant & Tavern - Butterflied shrimp and hushpuppies--both executed very well. - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

The food and service were excellent!! The server was very friendly. We went for lunch but I had linguine Alfredo and added shrimp it was really good with nice size shrimp and came with a large side salad! Took a lot of it home. My husband had grilled chicken parmigiana with linguine also came with salad both had delicious garlic bread! We will go back! read more

Best bar in Swissvale. Tons of space in both the bar and dining room (and a separate smoking area behind a glass door, can't smell it anywhere). Beer is super cheap, solid selection, and the specials during Pens and Steelers games on Miller Lite are great. Dollar off drinks during happy hour too. But the food! Man it's good. The pizza is great, the crust is the best I've had in Pittsburgh. Tons of veggie options. Homemade chips are killer with their honey mustard. Love that they have trivial pursuit cards on the bar. AMI jukebox. Tons of parking. Good TV's. Can't beat it. read more

GoodFellas Restaurant & Tavern - Spinach pizza! - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

food was so good and the server (nathalie i believe) was so sweet! i was nervous going in as it was a bit late (9:10 or so) but the server sat me with no issues as the restaurant was still quite busy, i believe it was bingo night. i got the diablo shrimp pasta with spinach and had a side salad and french onion soup. the side salad was a great portion and included olives and banana peppers (in addition to traditional fixins) i would definitely come back!! read more

GoodFellas Restaurant & Tavern - French Onion Soup - American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

What an interesting and fun place. Kind of sketchy location and the food was bad but the place was alot of fun and the bartenders were great

What a nice surprise. I always like to go to neighborhood bar restaurants-they just seem to have awesome food. GoodFellas fit that bill. Don't expect tablecloths and cloth napkins-that would take away from the feel. Otherwise, homemade is prominent!! We ordered a chicken sandwich, a burger, chips and slaw. But, I must say the BEST item we ordered was the Greens and Beans!! A*M*A*Z*I*N*G. Plenty of seating. It seems they also have a nice group of regulars. All the ingredients for a great neighborhood stop. Will definitely come back-there were way more items on the menu I wanted to try. read more

5/5 This place has a hometown feel that you just cannot replicate at any chain restaurant. The food is all cooked fresh daily and out of the tens of times that I've been here, I have yet to be disappointed. You also cannot be disappointed with price, you'll pop before you're wallet empties. If you want a local bar that has a great domestic beer selection, home cooking, and is run by kind/honest local folks; look no further. I will absolutely be back and would recommend to anyone looking for a great place to watch the game or grab a delicious bite to eat. read more

Where do I even begin? We arrived at 7:30 pm on a Tuesday. There was indoor and outdoor seating available, and we walked into the bar and i asked if it was self seating. A female bar tender looked quite annoyed, and said we could seat ourselves. She then came over to our table and loudly proclaimed that she was "supposed to be done hours ago", wiped our table off, and walked away. We weren't sure if that meant she wanted us to leave, or if someone else would be serving us. She then stayed for the entirety of our meal, going back and forth behind the bar pouring herself drinks and was also screaming at someone at the end of the bar (an older gray haired man). There was also a few patrons seated at the bar who were screaming at each other, loudly, with multiple swear words thrown about (mostly F***), for close to 45 minutes. They were also screaming at the gray haired man at the end of the bar (same one the bartender was having words with). From other reviews i read, this may be the owner of Goodfellas. I am not sure why an establishment would allow this behavior, especially with a crowd of people attempting to watch a a hockey game and eat dinner. The ONLY good thing I have to say, is the male bartender ran around like a mad man, taking phone orders, serving, taking table orders, making drinks, and grabbing take out orders. Our food would have been tasty, had it been served in a reasonable time frame. We waited an hour for a salad and pasta. The pasta was warm, at least. But my salad had ice cold fries and cold chicken. I feel bad I recommended this place to two friends, who happened to order take out this same evening. When they came in to pick up their take out order, we talked for a few moments. On their way out the door, there was a mouse that ran across the floor. They texted me and told me they threw their food out. So disappointed because i really wanted to like this place. read more

I ordered a hamburger and my wife ordered a fish dinner. I was done eating when her meal arrived. Unless your ordering the same thing, go someplace else. read more

I had this place bookmarked to go to for when I was in the area. It has a 4 1/2 star rating. Today we were in the area and decided to check it out. Bad decision. When we walked in there was no one in the dining room and maybe 3 people at the bar. The bartender was a very friendly woman. She was very welcoming. She told us all about the specials. The restaurant was updated and clean. We were off to a great start. Then we ordered. We waited. . . . and waited. . . and waited . . . And waited for our food. The bar became full and people were seated in the restaurant. And still we waited. It took us over THIRTY MINUTES to get our lunch. We were starving!!! Our orders were simple-a fish sandwich with coleslaw and a Buffalo Chicken Sandwich with tater tots. Nothing special. Items that they make every day. Yet the wait was outrageous. One of the two cooks even came out of the kitchen and sat at the bar and had a beer. I guess cooking the food of the patrons wasn't a priority to him. IF the food was outstanding. . . It's a smidge better but this food was barely average and they messed up my husband's sandwich. The bartender asked if he wanted it grilled or fried. He said grilled. It came out fried. The sauce was sweet, not hot. My fish sandwich was long and appeared to be huge. Instead the fish was very thin and you were mostly eating bread. No. Nope. Nada. Never again. read more

See all

Amazing food and friendly service. The eggplant parmesan hoagie is so yummy, and Hubby loved the Italian egg rolls and hot sausage burger.