Great family owned deli. Everything I have tried so far has been solid and fair prices. Friendly…read morestaff, good service and great selection

The best chicken salad I've found in a very long time! Everyone is so nice here, it's the perfect…read moreold school deli. Love it

*CASH ONLY* This 40…read moreyear old, family-owned, deli is a true gem! I went here because of a Yelp elite review and it was the best decision I've made today. TGIF! Service was quick and friendly! The lady at the counter knew both of the other customers by name. Regulars are always a good thing in any establishment. The sandwich was excellent, and I miss my Long Island, Deli's! I didn't know it was cash only and came up short $.50. She told me not to worry about it. That won me over and every time I'm on Long Island I will attend this deli as well as tip her. I highly recommend you check this place out.

Good food, good service. An excellent example of small, local business that beats the corporate…read morealternatives. It's cash only, so no credit cards, debit cards or cash phony cryptoFake money. But that's understandable. The originators of this business have passed but their daughter (I am told) carries on in their footsteps. I hope she knows they'd be proud. It's a great deli.

Good food and salads here. Chopped salads have a lot of variety of add ons and were fresh and…read moredelicious every time I've ordered them

Having been in catering for 30 plus years I can say without reservation that Seaqua St James does…read morean amazing job! we had our son's graduation party this past weekend and the food was delicious. The compliments from our guests keep coming in...what more can you ask for? Can't wait for our next event, we will definitely be using Seaqua!

The service was amazing, the people here are really friendly and patient with first timers. They…read moreanswered all of my questions about the menu. You can tell this place is good because there was a line outside the door when we arrived. Inside it's the typical deli/ began shop. A lot of options. The bagel I had was the rainbow bagel with the birthday cake creamcheese. It tasted like a cupcake. The bagel was so fresh and soft in the inside. It melted in your mouth. I definitely will be visiting this place again. Especially since I see they have a location in Boca Raton Florida which is very close to me. Highly recommend!

Stopped into LIBC for a Sausage, Egg, & Cheese on an Everything Bagel. The breakfast sandwich was…read moregreat! Eggs were cooked nicely and the bagel was soft and tasty. It was super busy there the day after Christmas, but the service was still nice and quick once I got my order in. The parking lot is a bit chaotic, but that's just Long Island for you!

I thought this was just another Deli. I stopped in because it's next to the post office! It's very…read morevery clean and the food is delicious!!

Tried to love this place but I really can't recommend. Been several times (I'm a lake grove…read moreresident) and they're just not up to par. Bacon,egg,cheese consistently isn't hot, cheese not melted/cold (weird) etc. Sandwiches don't have any real depth to them. it's a shame - great location and I love a local business but can't recommend. Even with their recent makeover the food hasn't improved. Coffee is awesome though!

We came here as a quick stop leaving families house from out of town. Very cute place lots of…read morepeople in and out that seem like regulars so we were excited to try it. We had a bagel egg and cheese sandwich and a bagel with cream cheese. We enjoyed them both! They had plenty of other treats too but we didn't have time to dry them sadly. Next time. Thanks Terry!

This bagel shop is so nice and clean. The bagels here are always consistent and fresh. They always…read morehave a nice variety of assorted bagels and cream cheese. The service varies from some days being very fast to some days being extremely slow. I'm not sure why. They have deals on the white board when you walk in. The staff is always friendly .

I just stopped in this morning to get a bagel and lox and I was so impressed with Kevin my server…read more he made the most beautiful little platter I couldn't get over how beautiful it was and I couldn't get over that it was $11. I usually pay $17 for bagels and lox in Commack With nothing extra but a salad a little baby salad.

Never had a issues with the food only for the price it's not enough. They are over priced !…read moreService takes forever very slow ! The store is always a mess. I ordered a omelette and it was 12 dollars and it came with just the omelette no potatoes or toast. I won't be back !

Obsessed with this place! It's like a mini grocery store with a great deli built in…read more The employees are always so nice everytime we go. The shop is clean and easy to navigate and find whatever it is you are looking for. They also have this really cool machine that turns cocacola products into slushes in seconds. (It's the only machine on the island that does this- and is what prompted me to stop by in the first place!) My egg sandwiches are always perfect from here too. Bacon is crisp and eggs are plentiful. If you find yourself in the area, definitely stop by.

Every time we purchase milk at this store, it's sour! Stopped buying it there last year but I ended…read moredoing it again this week. Expiration date is June 24th and as usual it was sour. So gross

Gave daughter free water in the heat. Very nice people…read more Was a fair and they could've charged me up the arse

Ordered from door dash. Pastrami hero and tater tots awful. Tater tots were soggy sandwich was just…read morethe regular pastrami you get at the supermarket slimy

I was immediately greeted with a smile and waited a short while before making it to the counter…read more Claudio was excellent! My first question was "do you have turkey bacon?" Claudio answered absolutely they have turkey bacon turkey sausage and of course deli turkey. I ordered a turkey BLT with a chamomile tea with honey. He took my order then walked to the register to ring me up. He then informed me my food would be bought out to my seat. Few minutes later, my food arrived after a quick seat at the window seat to people watch. The sandwich was delicious! I ordered the cucumber side salad which was refreshing and I enjoyed the tea/honey ratio. Im sorry for those who had anything other than an amazing experience as I did.

Have ordered breakfast sandwiches from Strathmore on four different occasions and despite what…read moreother reviews have stated I've been satisfied with both the food and service. Granted each time the store was packed but I was able to place a phone order with an estimated pickup time. The sandwiches and omelets were cooked as requested and were well portioned. Prices are competitive with other restaurants although all food retail pricing has dramatically increased over the past few months. Overall a good bagel store worth visiting offering a wide variety of breakfast and lunch options with ample table seating and parking.