Obsessed with this place! It's like a mini grocery store with a great deli built in…read more The employees are always so nice everytime we go. The shop is clean and easy to navigate and find whatever it is you are looking for. They also have this really cool machine that turns cocacola products into slushes in seconds. (It's the only machine on the island that does this- and is what prompted me to stop by in the first place!) My egg sandwiches are always perfect from here too. Bacon is crisp and eggs are plentiful. If you find yourself in the area, definitely stop by.

Every time we purchase milk at this store, it's sour! Stopped buying it there last year but I ended…read moredoing it again this week. Expiration date is June 24th and as usual it was sour. So gross

Excellent food and service specially at the belly counter they make the best time in hero…read more Everything else is fresh never had an issue. Prices are fine and not more expensive than uncle G..

If you're going to shop at Pat's, you need to know what to buy and what to avoid. Some things are…read moredelicious and reasonably priced, other things don't taste as good or are past due or overpriced. The meats, produce and breads are very good. I've had mix-ed experiences with the prepared food. One time I bought a salmon patty for $12 per pound, but when I got home it was rancid. It smelled so bad that it had to be thrown away immediately. The deli is ok but they are painfully slow, which is strange because there are 4-5 people working behind the counter...very slow. Don't bother ordering a sandwich unless you have an extra 20-30 minutes to kill. Very busy from 11:30-12:30. Avoid the deli then, it's even slower. I embrace the cakes in the bakery but avoid the prepared quiche and chicken wings, great rice balls and chicken salad if you are willing to wait on line for a while. Things only seem to be on sale when they are almost past the date.

Absolutely phenomenal sandwiches here Delicious HUGEand…read moreaffordable On your way to #orient ferry #fire island ferry or a beach day ...wonderful petit deserts and small chip bags if your conscious of your daily caloric intake StaFF FRIENDLY. AMPLE parking and accessible

Continues to be a "hidden gem of a deli" don't blink you'll miss this small although packed with…read moreeverything community deli.From sandwiches, breakfast, hero's. Piping hot coffee (many flavors) to the wonderful selection of creamer's! They do catering too. Beads, milk juices, sodas, case specials- cold pre sliced " cold cut" for every budget. A must try. Right off Sunrise, LIE and close to all major rds. Check. Out their flower/ circular

If you're from the Sticks (Mastic) and you just want a simple sammich to munch on either in the…read moremiddle of the night or after school, this Deli is the answer. I've been coming here ever since high school which was many moons ago and I forever am blown away about the food quality and ambiance. Just like walking into a Bodega in Brooklyn, minus the cat ‍ that basically owns and bodega. What you see in this review is their signature Maple Turkey on a roll. Maple Turkey, with freshly cut avocado, lettuce and mayo, yes MAYONNAISE, definitely a late night treat! So delicious, and hey you need a Blueberry C&C to wash it all down, fantastic!'

Grate place good food and grate people They got a great…read moreselection of drinks and food

Go all the time to pick up essentials and Especially from the deli counter. Always friendly staff…read moreand it is so nice to have a small supermarket near us.Prices can be a little better but I understand it is a necessity to stay on business.

I'm extremely disappointed with my experience at Buttercups Dairy Store. I purchased food here that…read morewas expired, and after consuming it, I became sick. Food safety should never be taken lightly, and customers should be able to trust that the products being sold are within their expiration dates and safe to consume. This is not something I would expect from any food establishment. I strongly encourage the business to check the expiration dates on their products and take food safety seriously. I personally will not be purchasing food from here again, and I would encourage others to carefully check expiration dates before consuming anything purchased from this store. I'm beyond disappointed with this store. It's unacceptable that expired products are left on shelves for customers to buy. People should be able to trust that food is safe. The constant need to check expiration dates shows a serious lack of care and responsibility. After seeing this more than once, I've lost trust and I'll be shopping elsewhere.

This was my first trip to this location and I was wowed at the cleanliness and the friendliness of…read morethose that worked there. While I didn't find the prices much different than the local competitor, I was impressed with the layout of the store as well as the well organized shelves. Newer lightweight shopping carts were nice and quiet. When I approached the line to pay- there were two registers open- the manager saw that the lines were four people deep and called to have another one opened. I really appreciate that level of customer service.

Egglands Best eggs 6.79 18 count hurry that's their regular price…read more Well let me tell you. The people makes the business the people makes the business. I've been meeting managers staff butchers at ShopRite and they're all outstanding. Very helpful finding stuff and if they don't have it I asked one of the managers Ryan two days later it was on the shelf . Anthony the other manager unfortunately is in Commack really really nice people he got me something about a week later on the shelf. The butchers Angel and Loui. Phenomenal. I glanced in the window and I saw Angel cutting a piece of meat I'm telling you it was look like he was dancing like the salsa.. slicing that cut of beef you could tell he was a real pro he is. the way he was cutting that meat I wish I had video the window in the butcher shop. Have I got his name I went to a yard sale and this girl was telling me about this guy Angel she left another butcher shop just to come to him. Good job Angel you're giving yourself a reputation!. Your soups as you walk in the door are not bad a little too much salt. Prices are reasonable. My phone broke so I can't upload any pictures except for the ones I just had taken.

I began going to the Setauket store when they opened. Until I moved, back in 2016, it was a weekly…read moretrip from the South Shore of Long Island to the North Shore. Loved their stir-fry, deli and bakery items. I'm going to be in the Setauket area today and can't wait to stop by for the first time in a few years.

Very expensive produce - $14 for a 16 oz box organic strawberries?! That's daylight robbery. Total…read morerip-off.

Came here to pick up a few things. The have a nice selection of Caribbean produce and I was able to…read morepurchase what I needed. There are some marinated meats you can purchase that are completely on the open with tongs, so I question the sanitaryness of it. Checkout was a breeze. They had very short lines.

Great local market with plenty of variety. Prices are fair and never a long line to check out.read more