Picked up a few slices for some clients today. One thing I will immediately point out is that parking can be somewhat of a challenge, especially if you're carrying out an order in the afternoon. Greek's Pizza is on probably one of the busiest streets in the town and it's riddled with one way. I found myself circling the block several times before finding a spot. I was surprised to see that there was no one dining in during the lunch hour, but there were a lot of doordashers going in and out. I let the girl at the counter know I had a carry out order that I placed online and was told there would be a 5 minute wait (understandable since I was early). Got the goods and the clients were excited and could not stop raving about the Hawaiian Pizza. Overall great experience despite the parking situation. read more

It's a slow pace. Don't go here if you are in a hurry. If you were looking for a chill vibe and some excellent food, this is your space. I got the chicken bacon ranch sandwich and it was the most delicious buttery crisp soft bread that I've ever had on a sandwich. I could've just thrown all of the toppings off and eaten the bread and Ben in heaven. The crisp bacon and the ranch and chicken and cheese gooey gooey in the middle of all the delicious bread Just elevated the experience. Throw in the cinnamon twist breadsticks that were wonderfully soft, gooey, gooey, and coated in icing and this was an over-the-top experience for me. So glad I checked it out and tried something different. read more

Greek’s Pizzeria - Cinnamon breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Crawfordsville, Indiana

See all

We have ALWAYS had great food at Greeks, but Charity made our experience super. She is the best waitress we have had there. She checked up on us and made sure everything was good. Thanks Charity for adding to the Greeks excellence! read more

After Pike Place event which had lousy food choices we went into Greeks. Again the wrong pizza was brought to table spinach deluxe and Roma spinach are similar but I prefer the Greek sauce to tomato based sauces. I didn't leave a tip I don't know who messed up the order but it's getting annoying. read more

Greek’s Pizzeria - menu - Pizza Near Me - Crawfordsville, Indiana

Great service, amazing food, fast service and employees were kind and quick! Will definitely be back a recommended to anyone looking for a wonderful place in downtown crawfordsville read more

This review has nothing to do with the quality of food. We love their food and eat here often. The new owners try very hard to please their customers and give good service. However, When we used this site to order online for pickup it went through GrubHub. It does not tell you that until after you check out. GrubHub charges you more for this service (even when you are picking up the order) than what you would pay by calling the order in. We did not know this and tried to cancel the order. We called Greeks and they said they couldn't change it because the order had already processed through GrubHub. When I order online through other local restaurants this doesn't happen. Just beware of extra charges if you order online through this site. We discussed this with the owner but not sure what is anything they can do to change it. Not sure if this is a Yelp issue or the business issue. read more

The pizza was fabulous and our server was very good even though she was the only one working. They need two servers for that lunch crowd.

First time visiting. We were in town for a sporting event and decided to stop in. The place wasn't super busy but there were a couple of larger parties. Our server greeted us quickly and took our drink order but then came back probably 5-10 minutes later and almost asked for our drink order again before realizing that she had already taken it. She then took our food order and it took a long while for our drinks to come. She apologized for the drink delay and our food came out not too long after. My daughter had the 9" pizza and it looked very tasty and she seemed to enjoy it. My son and husband both had sandwiches, the Italian herb and the chicken bacon club which they enjoyed and came with chips. I had the chicken parmesan and although it was good and filling, I thought the portion size was small for $10.99. Our server was friendly and appeared to be the only server in the place which I thought was unusual for a pizza restaurant on a Saturday night. I would recommend them for the taste and quality of the food. read more

Sign on the door says open till 11pm. Came it at 9:45 and they ignored us when we came in. Waitress sat us at the table after we hit a bell at the register and we asked if we could sit down still. She said that we weren't late and told us to sit down wherever we'd like and went back to the back. She came back and told us at the table that they closed at 10pm and stopped taking orders after 9:45 and that we were too late. We asked for a pizza to go. She went back to the back and we could hear them snicker and say that they already shut off their ovens (at 9:45) and to offer us salads. If you're closed at 10, but shut off your ovens before 9:45, what part actually closes at 10? Do you push people outside of the door after 9:59? The apple maps and many other places online has an 11pm close date, but you really are done with business...when? Not at 10. Apparently not at 9:45...so 9:30? Schedules, on doors and registered places like imaps, are there to give the customer all the information needed so they know whether or not the place is open for business. The pizza is excellent because it is part of a chain that was established in 1969. But the new owner, still a teenager or barely 20, doesn't understand that you can't run a business when things are convenient for them or when they decide they don't want to work anymore. We'll come back in a couple years when the ownership is sure to change...I just hope this guy doesn't run this location into the ground. Pathetic guys. read more

Great breadsticks, good pizza. The staff were friendly. The food was fresh and cooked quickly. read more

See all

Tried this for the first time today, and was very pleased. Food was excellent! Service was quick and very friendly. AND the place was very clean. read more

Haven't tried it since their has been a new owner. But their pizza and breadsticks are the best. I would just stick with this because that's what they are best for. read more

I ordered on line and when I arrived the young man behind the counter stated they had just noticed my order10 minutes prior and they were just starting on it. While I waited the delivery driver came in complaining about the customer that was a regular and complained to him they are always late. The driver continued to say if they saw our kitchen they would understand why we are always late. On my way out I told the young man that it probably isn't wise to talk about customers in front of other customers. He said that customers that call in asking for 6 pizzas can not expect us to deliver them on time since we don't open till 11. Love this pizza but the attitudes are terrible and full of excuses when it comes to service. The only customers in the dining room at the time had to come and ask for silverware to eat. Greeks need to have a huge attitude adjustment or get new help. read more

Stood at the counter for 15 minutes waiting for someone to help me get my pick up order. No less than five employees walked past and never acknowledged I was standing there. One came out from the back and begin talking to someone he knew at the bar. This is the second time I've been there and both times Service has been terrible. The place was nearly empty too. Staff seem poorly trained and customers not a priority Lots of other good pizza options in town and not sure I'll be back based on these experiences. When I finally got my food, it was OK but not exceptional. read more

Placed a pick up order for 1 pizza. Was told 20 minutes. When I arrived I was told they were backed up and it was going to be a bit longer. The guy was sitting at a screen it looked like he was trying to put in an order. Must have been first week on the job. A bit overwhelmed. I think only 1 other person was working the dining room. It was pretty full. They need to remember to wash their hands after working the computer and before handling beverages and to only hold the glasses around the sides and not the rims. Pizza could have used a bit longer in the oven but had good flavor. Maybe will try another night when it isn't so busy. read more

We dined in about a month ago and have ordered carry out. Had great service, played some fun video games while waiting on pasta and pizza. Delicious pizza, fresh dough, and breadsticks if you're a garlic lover like we are. Garlic sticks are wonderful as is the marinara dip! Spaghetti is tasty too! Best pizza around! read more

Greek’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Crawfordsville, Indiana

In town for a soccer game and decided to stop for a quick bite. Not a whole lot to compliment except for the server. Food was mediocre at best, they use the same boneless chicken nuggets for the chicken parmigiana, 3 of us ate and our food came out individually 5 minutes a part. Boneless wings were soggy and not with sauce. read more

There was only one waitress working so it was a little slower than normal. But it was definitely worth the wait. Our breadsticks and pizza were delicious!! Highly recommend! read more

My wife, 2 y/o, and I were staying in crawfordsville for travel. Went downtown without a plan to eat, tried to eat at a place that apparently needs reservations, was turned away. Saw Greeks nearby... glad we did. It wasn't crowded, service was great and helpful! Food was good and we ate it all. Very low key hang with a chill pizzeria vibe. Would go back. Was a great start to a fantastic summer evening in central Indiana. read more

Kim jonnie and the whole gang rock, I had the Greeks special it was awesome the herb and parmesan breadsticks to die for the place is awesome, I waited 10 minutes for my food and it was packed customer service is A plus pricing is A Plus restrooms are clean place is spotless read more

Recommended by our hotel manager...ordered 12" Greek pizza & the Greek salad...pizza was delicious, definitely better than the chains...salad was ordinary but fresh and complimented the pizza perfectly...staff was friendly too. read more

OK, pizza is really tasty and we ordered to support local businesses during quarantine. BUT PLEASE WEAR MASKS! We will not order from you again until you make this your policy. Also, we paid over 50 dollars for 3 medium take out pizzas. It's pricey and we are alright in paying to help local businesses. But respect your customers enough to wear masks. read more

Pizza is very good. I don't like cheese pizza but their 5 cheese pizza is a game changer

The pizza was very good. We also love that there is trivia on Tuesday night. It's fun to have a little something going on during the week.

The food is really good and we wanted to support a local pizza place. We were pretty excited when they started delivering to our area. We have ordered twice now and both times they forgot stuff. The first time they forgot our soda which is almost $4 for a 2L. We thought we'd given them the benefit of the doubt and have them another chance. The second time they not only forgot the extra ranch I paid for, but the ranch that went in the bbq wings as well. The food is good, but there are too many other places in town for us to try a third time. read more

The food is normally very good. Tonight, my daughter's sandwich was burned and hard on top. I called to let them know. I was told that they would send a new sandwich, but I had to bring the burned sandwich out to their driver. My daughter had eaten the bottom. I told them to forget it. I also told them that our order was not that great. They have also forgotten our side sauces on three other occasions. They need to pay more attention to what they are sending to their customers. read more

Hello fellow Yelpers! I am the daytime/nighttime manager at Greeks Pizzeria in Crawfordsville I go by Robert! I'm sure you've seen me before! We also have Macie, and Kim Harpel as the owners if anything is wrong with your Order please let us know ASAP! We will make things right with you! Please come in! We have Dine-in, Carry out and Deliveries vary if we have drivers. Our customer service is very welcoming! If no one gets to you ASAP! Ring the bell! We do get busy in the back making the best order for you we can, also making it as fast and amazingly as possible! read more

The food was amazing! Service was good, staff was very accommodating. Will make this one of our regular haunts!

The pizza was excellent! The service was great and the food come out pretty quick. I would highly recommend this restaurant to any locals and anyone passing bye! read more

Going to keep this one short. This was my second visit. I had the "chicken wings" pizza the first time and this time was the chicken club and breadsticks. Both pizzas were absolutely fantastic and the breadsticks were just as good. I upgraded to the flavored sticks with the garlic/parm or whatever. I almost regretted getting the dipping sauces because the sticks were so good by themselves. That being said, the cheese sauce was surprisingly good. I was expecting a cheap, flavorless cheese dip, but this had just a little bit of spice in it. And the marinara is on the sweet side, which I like. All that being said, I'm going to restate a previously mentioned pet peeve which is that I think the staff should have some sort of uniform or matching shirts or something. Although I ordered and took home, the first time I went there were patrons eating there and I Can't say that I saw any employees ever go to check on those customers. Need a refill or a box for leftovers? Better head to the bar. And it appears to be a seat yourself situation but I'd propose a sign verifying that. Also, the only wings that I've seen on the menu are boneless wings; which as we all know, aren't even wings at all. Boo. There's one more pizza place in town that I have to check out, but for now this is my favorite pizza in Crawfordsville. read more

Stopped in before a movie date with the family. We got seated and then waited for 45 minutes before I could flag down the guy that sat us and tell him that we haven't even gotten our drink order in yet. He took it upon himself to be our waiter. We then waited another 45 minutes for the food to come out. The appetizers were good, (other than the fact that there was Unmelted butter on our garlic herb breadsticks). Pizza was also good. Got our bill and left just in time for our movies, but we definitely had to scarf down the food. Second visit I ordered a couple pizzas for carry out. I go there 5 minutes later than when they said it would be done. There were 2 people in front of me waiting to be helped when I got there. Multiple employees walked by and looked at us but did not help us. Finally a "manager" I'm assuming told a young girl to see what we needed...so 20 minutes after I should have had my pizza in my hand I finally find out it's gonna take another 20 to finish my order. I sat patiently and got a coupon for free breadsticks. Won't be going back to use it. read more