Met these guys over 22 years ago, recommended by a friend. I cannot recommend them enough to…read moreanyone who needs work done on their car and people you can trust to do it. They are pleasant, accommodating to your schedule and the work they do on your car is superior.

Great experience getting pa state inspection on my wife's PA biz car…read more Highly recommend this garage is an old fashion father son biz that reminds me of neighborhood garage from my 1950's and 1960's childhood

I was stuck between 2 stars or 3. I decided to choose 3 stars because of the gentleman at the front…read moredesk. He is very friendly, very thorough, and a great salesman. The prices here are high but it's good work. Typically pretty quick and have the things you need in stock. I got an alignment and tires when I was in there. When I left it was way better but still pulled pretty hard. While my vehicle was in there they took it upon themselves to remove the rear drums and check the brakes. Which is ok but I'm sure I paid for that on the hourly rate and they quoted me almost $350 for rear brakes. I can do that myself for less than $150 and less than an hour and that's including the drive to get parts and beer. Good people though and not everyone can do their own work. We are all just trying to make a living I rather pay good people than cheap bad people and pay for it in the end.

A week after spending over $1,300 on repairs and getting a full inspection giving me the all clear,…read moremy car stopped working while on the highway, they refuse to take responsibility, DO NOT USE. They even said "they see this all the time" when I called about it.

These people are wonderful, very professional and know what they are doing! They are very…read morereasonable on their prices and I will continue to bring my car there even if it takes days to fix. They are very honest, kind and friendly. Thank you Michael and your team. Janice Smith Hagerstown MD

These guys are the best in the repair business. They are busy so it is sometimes a wait to get…read moreyour vehicle in for service. This is because they are very good. As for price, it's very fair and I trust them to do things properly. I've been taking my vehicles to them since 2006 when I moved to the area. They are trustworthy.

I rarely do reviews here but felt it necessary since the service we received was above and beyond…read morewhat we ever expected! We had damages to our car from a hit-and-run (2013 Honda Civic) that were fairly minor; however it required at least two new tires. Our insurance company recommended a place to get the body work done. We would normally take it to the Honda Dealership. After the body work was completed at this place, they recommended we get new tires at Will McCarthy's. I could explain the whole saga with our insurance company but that will be a different review that will not be receiving anywhere near FIVE stars. To say the least, we only needed two new tires but due to the excellent service from the staff and especially the GM, Will, we went with getting four new tires! Will helped us with several issues that should have been caught but weren't and even made phone calls for us, as well as got us in contact with people we never would have been able to otherwise! We are so thankful for everything he did! Our car drives great and we our very happy with this experience!

I was having one of those days, the when it rains it pours kind of day, and Matt @ McCarthy Tire,…read morereally helped turn my day around. I came out from a dentist appointment on Leitersburg Pike, to a VERY flat tire. I think they call it pancake flat . lol . The road side assist guy that came to help me put the donut on, advised that a tire shop likely wouldn't plug it because the "injury spot" (a nail) was so close to the side, but he thought they should be able to do a patch from the inside but likely wouldn't' do a plug. As a woman and knowing nothing about tire repair, I was taking notes, for the common fear that as a woman or a person not knowing or seeming to know anything, I might get taken for a ride. I Yelp'ed nearby tire places, and by circumstance / situation, McCarthy was one of a few that was closest. I called to give them a heads up that I was coming, fearing an appointment may be needed and they said come on over! I drove over and my roller coaster of a bad day continued. The guy at the counter, comes out to assess my situation. He takes a look at the tire, and says he can't patch it because of where the nail went in.. I think great now I have to get at least 2 tires because they will never replace 1 (I'm familiar with these tire scenarios ) . But then he says , to my surprise and some skepticism, that he will just do one tire (what?!), um.. thank you universe, I don't have to get 2 new tires! We go inside, he checks inventory, I say I want, no I NEED the cheapest one please and a little typing later he declares he can do it all for 91 bucks. Yahoo, thank you , yes I'll take it. But no wait... damn we don't have THAT tire in stock. But we can order it and put it on tomorrow.. ugh no that won't work.. I'm in Hagerstown now and don't want to be driving all over the tri state with a donut or having to drive back into Hagerstown where I otherwise have no need to be, and adding this to my day the next day.. so I ask what's the cheapest that can be done today? Now we're at $150.. then he gets it down to $130 because I think he feels bad for me and my bad day? He takes my car into the shop and moments later comes out saying, you guessed it: you want the good news or the bad news first? And I'm thinking, seriously?! Another one of these moments! Come on!!! NO more bad news.. I say: Good news. He says: I can repair the tire after all. I leap with joy. Like literally leap from the curb I'm sitting on. Note I'm sitting on the curb outside because I want to sit outside because it was nice out; they had a very pleasant looking waiting room, I elected not to use ;) Then I ask, what's the bad news? He says I'm only gonna make $25 . And I think: 1) Holy moly this day is turning around. 2) Did he mess up the good news, bad news line? ;) 3) Where's the next curve ?! Nope, no more curve balls. He patches my tire, charges me a grand total of 25 bucks! And I promise him a review that will more than pay for the money he "lost" on me today! I'd be happy to share this story! Thank you, honest tire sales/ fixer guy Matt! You turned my whole day around when you took a second look at my flat tire and didn't elect to just take the easy, profit wheeling direction and you did me a solid. There's no doubt he could have just planted that $150 tire on my car, and sent me off. He took the extra time, to check, to do " the right thing", whatever you want to call it, and for that, he will have my loyalty and anyone who asks me about car stuff in Hagerstown, I'll send that way. Doing well by others matters and Matt @ McCarthy, who I learned recently acquired the business, totally has my vote. Your karma is coming for you buddy! ;) And my mini woe is me, bad day party turned into a: people are so good sometimes, SO good. You never know how much you can affect someone's day. Thanks Matt! ~Kym