Guido&#x27;s Pizza - Tontitown

I had Italian sausage Bolognese, and halfway through traded it for my friends wild mushroom pasta…read more Both were fantastic, and had rich creamy sauces. The sausage was pretty killer, a tad spicy. The mushroom pasta had a tinge of lemony zest to it. Morels were deliciously panfried in butter. My favorite was the to go order for a third person though: pistachio Alfredo, a similar sauce to the wild mushroom pasta but a bit nuttier. Zero complaints with the food, and i look forward to the owners new location (pizza Lotties) that will be opening soon i hear. This place is dangerously close to five star perfection, if only it were not so crowded (locals know whats up) and it's also a bit loud. The open air kitchen is a nice touch but probably doesn't help with the noise. Imo good food for decent value and would be worth the wait (you can enter into the waitlist online which i will certainly do next time and probably opt for patio seating if possible) All in all very satisfied. This place has a cool menu that seems to evolve and explore the culinary arts. (I love that someone thought to make a sausage/pasta dish with Korean gochujang) I look forward to partaking in many future gourmand adventures here made possible made by such creative kitchen-bound artists

Pizza is great, Caesar salad is awesome. (Try the spicy…read moreranch!) Now a must-stop when I'm in town! Wouldn't pay too much attention to the negative reviews and maybe form your own opinion by visiting yourself. Had about 5 staff members outside of our waiter who checked on us during our most recent visit.

Full house

Vodka pasta

See all

Gusano's Pizza

3.5(39 reviews)

1.3 mi

I ordered Italian Beef sandwich with cheese. It comes without cheese, waitress acted ignorant, I…read moresent it back to have cheese added. I should have just went to the Wedington Gusano s location who deliver a large Italian Beef sandwich with cheese that's juicy and not dried up.

I've been there 3 times in 5 years. Each time the food was not prepared well. The pizza has been…read moreburned or under done. The first time the pizza was burned. The second time the meatball sandwich was burned. This last time I ordered a Chicago Style pizza. It was not a Chicago style pizza in any way the crust was under baked soggy and bland. I rally don't know how they stay in business.

Hostess station

Chicago Style fresh spinach

See all

Happy hour specials

Mj Pizzeria

4.0(203 reviews)

3.3 mi

In town visiting friends and ordered takeout pizza and salad for lunch. We got a supreme and a gf…read morefour seasons, plus a Caesar salad to share. I tried to order online. It required me to create an account which was annoying because it's unlikely I will be through here again anytime soon. Then the system said online ordering wasn't available and please call to order. Aaargh. When I called, the employee was friendly and polite so that was easy. I was surprised they didn't ask for payment. Maybe it's different down here? Anyway, the food was ready in 20 minutes. And soon we had a hot lunch and cold salad--or should I say container of lettuce and one cherry tomato? It was romaine that seemed mostly stalks with small leaves and thin, narrow strips of tasteless cheese. The dressing lacked the anchovy tang that makes Caesar what it is. I would not recommend it, especially for the price. (I wish I'd taken a photo before we'd divided it.) The pizzas were okay, tasty enough. The Four Seasons was salty, with canned olives, artichokes, and ham. Mushrooms were fresh.

Excellent pizza and calzones! Service is fast a courteous. Restaurant has a great layout. Always…read morecrowded so plan accordingly!

Inside dining

See all

Wicked Wood Fired Pizza

4.5(72 reviews)

7.4 mi

Had the pleasure of tasting their wood fired pizza at Orthodox Brewing today. It was one of the…read morebest pies I've had in years! Thin crust veggie pizza was cooked to perfection. Will definitely catch up with their truck again in the near future!

Wicked Pizza is wicked good. We stopped here on our way home and... wow. Just WOW. Run -- don't…read morewalk -- and get yourself a pie. We went with the hand-tossed crust, and it was perfection: crispy on the outside, soft and chewy inside, and packed with flavor that keeps you going back for "just one more slice" (until there's mysteriously none left). Every bite was better than the last -- the kind of pizza that makes you close your eyes and have a little moment. We may have just started a new tradition of "mandatory pizza stop" every time we pass through Fayetteville. Delicious food, great vibe, friendly faces -- Wicked Pizza, you've officially stolen our carb-loving hearts.

Hand-tossed veggie

See all

Hot honey pig

U.S. Pizza

3.5(39 reviews)

1.6 mi

Excellent thin crust pizza! Great breadsticks with cheese!…read more Excellent service and quick cooking too!

Haven't dined at this location. Used to at the one on Dickson. Best pizza that I've had in a long…read moretime. The supreme was excellent, the bbq chicken pizza is the bomb. Definitely going back

Kitchen

Bbq chicken pizza

See all

Exterior

Pizza Navona

4.4(28 reviews)

9.2 mi

Finally got to try this place, as I'm only in the area 2-3x a year. Service was amazing and the…read morefood was incredible! We got a large meat lovers pizza. I've never seen a pizza with so many toppings! We even ordered it with extra cheese and sauce, but the meat overwhelmed those extras, lol! Even our server said she's never seen so much meat on the pizza. Maybe they mis-read the order and put extra meat! I could only eat 2 slices. Very filling and very tasty! Our other pizza was half Hawaiian and half Margherita pizza, with extra cheese on both sides. This pizza was really good too. Ordered a house salad (came with garlic bread) and a caprese salad. The caprese salad was amazing! I did t eat the house salad, but my friend gave it good reviews!

We were seated on the patio and it was lovely, overlooking the city park. It was quite breezy and…read morepleasant to be outside after a long stretch indoors for everything! The portions were quite generous as well! We each had our fill and everyone had a takeout box for home! Highly recommend the stuffed mushrooms! I will definitely be back!

House salad with ranch dressing

See all

Navona Supremo without the Italian sausage

Geraldi's

4.4(286 reviews)

8.8 mi

Garlic bread with artichoke dip was good. Good pizza…read more Pesto spaghetti was also good. Service was wonderful and we went in late and was well served

This is a small hole in the wall, not here for ambience! The pasta and sauces are made in house,…read morewhich is rare these days. We had the large antipasto dish, which was brought out at the same time as our entree . It had a good amount of food but the dressing (served in side) was not good to me. We loved the garlic buttered bread ! The lasagna was good, just not amazing. Maybe more seasoning? I added red pepper flakes which helped. I would send folks for the noodles and pizza...

Front dessert counter and register area.

Antipasto large portion. Ask for it before entree!

See all

Restaurant from the outside

The Odd Soul

4.5(127 reviews)

6.1 mi

Great bartenders, beer, pizza, atmosphere, drinks and service!…read moreChill vibe. Good bourbon selection.

Decent pizza - we got the supreme. But the star of the meal was the giant pretzels. Not sure the…read morepizza was cooked all the way, the crust was a bit gummy. They were busy but not full busy. While I get the seat yourself thing - we were not greeted when walked in. Others after us were. We had to clean off a table ourselves to be able to sit down. When we went to the bar to order the bartender continued visiting with customers at the bar and then refilled a drink of another customer that walked up to the bar after us before taking our order. The food did come out in a timely manner.

Calzone (forgot the type but it's one of their specials! I think the whitey tightey)

See all

Beer menu

Guido's Pizza

3.4(59 reviews)

5.8 mi

Pizza is perfect everytime ! Service is great as well…read more Wish the bar area was bigger but def live the pizza and that's all that matters !!!!!

Locally owned Tonitown style Italian-American. Great standby for garlicky good spaghetti with meat…read moresauce, old school buttery toast, and a salad. Pizza is a great pickup option for quick meals. Nice people and very good service.

See all

Wood Stone Pizza - Downtown

4.1(225 reviews)

9.2 mi

First time in Arkansas and this was our first restaurant we stopped at here and we're glad we did!…read moreFood, service, ambiance were all great! Cocktails: The Sarsaparilla old fashion, very approachable old fashioned. Bloody Mary, they make their own mix, very good and solid! Golden hour is also a great choice and not too sweet! Food: The food all came out at a good time! We had the grilled chicken wings with house wing sauce which perfectly grilled. We had the queen margherita, thai curry, and P.B.R. They were all solid, but Queen Margherita was definitely our favorite! The pizza crust was made to perfection. The side sauces, spicy honey and ranch were both great as well. The bartender was very nice, she gave us great recommendations. Overall, definitely 100% would recommend!

Great local spot with plenty of unique salads, pizzas, and full bar. We ordered the pepperoni…read morepizza, salad, and the meat lovers pizza or the three little pigs as they call it. They offer dipping sauces for that extra flavor added to the crust. Excellent wait staff and laid back atmosphere. The restaurant was reasonably priced and the food was fresh.

Inside on a Sunday afternoon

Ozarkansas

See all

Beer Flight

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Christy O.

0

5

0

5 years ago

Always great pizza!!!! We have been going here for years and have never been disappointed.

Shannon B.

0

7

0

8 years ago

Great food, great service & cold beer! Love the ranch dressing too.

Phil L.

0

3

0

7 years ago

Good pizza, and good salads. Not had a bad meal here.

Louie H.

0

2

0

8 years ago

Wonderful place to eat! Wonderful place to eat!

Truth T.

0

4

0

6 years ago

Decent food for a decent price.

Guido's Pizza - Tontitown - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Guido's Pizza - Tontitown also viewed

Guido's Pizza

3.4

(59 reviews)

Pizza is perfect everytime ! Service is great as well…read more Wish the bar area was bigger but def live the pizza and that's all that matters !!!!!

Locally owned Tonitown style Italian-American. Great standby for garlicky good spaghetti with meat…read moresauce, old school buttery toast, and a salad. Pizza is a great pickup option for quick meals. Nice people and very good service.

Ria Pizzeria

4.8

(31 reviews)

Stumbled into this place and glad we did. The pizza was delicious. Seemed expensive but hands down…read more- most authentic Italian style pizza I've had on this side of the pond. Sauce was delicious and did not take over the pizza. The cheese was definitely "real" cheese. IYKYK and the toppings were good. Could have added a few more olives but there was enough to taste. Crust - well - that made the pizza. It was perfectly fired and crisp. Not too thick and not too thin. What's not to like about sourdough? One has to go the extra mile for that and Therein makes it all worth the price. Service was excellent. Refilled our drinks, checked on us and cleared the dishes. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend. Con: we always like a green salad with our pizza. I didn't see any on the menu but maybe I missed it. We did not get the appetizers because it was more bread - but others reviewed them as excellent. I just don't think I'd have room for those and the pizza. If they were anything like the pizza I'm sure they're great.

Wow! This place is DELICIOUS. I came here with my mom and we loved how charming Ria Pizzeria is…read more The staff is great and they were able to provide recommendations for us. We got the bread, burrata and two types of pizza. My mom loved her marg pizza and I loved my pepperoni/sausage pizza. They have hot honey at the table as an option to put on top of your pizza. Big fan! I will be back!

Outlaw Pizza

3.3

(12 reviews)

Last night was my first time trying Outlaw Pizza and it was pretty good! 4/5 but a bit overpriced…read more The flavor was good and they had some fun choices. The crust had a good chew and the cheese was good. We did get the breadsticks and they were a bit too powdery with whatever they put on top. I'd recommend the Undertaker though and their ranch was good!!

Excellent Detroit style pizza. Light and airy crust with crisp edges and good, somewhat sweet…read moresauce.

Pioneer Pizza

4.2

(23 reviews)

Nice locally owned pizza joint. The owner clearly loves racing! Our server was incredibly friendly…read moreand helpful. We had a Mexican Spud, Reuben sandwich, and Club Sandwich. The food was tasty and came out fairly quickly.

Highly recommend, so happy this is our home town pizza place. Family owned and Operated…read more Crust is unique but delicious! We had the 1/2 Super 1/2 Pep and the Tomato-Basil . Recommend either one or both! Service was great, and again being family operated just feels different.

Hideaway Pizza

4.2

(39 reviews)

Came here with my family and it was packed! They were able to get us in quickly, so I appreciate…read morethe amount of seating they had in the restaurant. The food was fantastic! I got a spicy pepperoni pizza and LOVED IT! Everyone at the table loved their food and their garlic bread is great. I cannot wait to come back! This is a great place to go for great food and great vibes!

This place is one of the better pizza places in town. The ambiance can be loud and very busy on a…read moreFriday evening, so plan ahead. The pizza is well worth it. I highly recommend.

U.S. Pizza

3.5

(39 reviews)

Excellent thin crust pizza! Great breadsticks with cheese!…read more Excellent service and quick cooking too!

Haven't dined at this location. Used to at the one on Dickson. Best pizza that I've had in a long…read moretime. The supreme was excellent, the bbq chicken pizza is the bomb. Definitely going back

Geraldi's

4.4

(286 reviews)

Garlic bread with artichoke dip was good. Good pizza…read more Pesto spaghetti was also good. Service was wonderful and we went in late and was well served

This is a small hole in the wall, not here for ambience! The pasta and sauces are made in house,…read morewhich is rare these days. We had the large antipasto dish, which was brought out at the same time as our entree . It had a good amount of food but the dressing (served in side) was not good to me. We loved the garlic buttered bread ! The lasagna was good, just not amazing. Maybe more seasoning? I added red pepper flakes which helped. I would send folks for the noodles and pizza...

Pizzeria Ruby

4.2

(415 reviews)