It doesn't look like much from the outside, but inside was nicely decorated with Italian pizza…read moredecor with Italian crooner music for ambience. Friendly server took our orders and the drinks and food came out timely. Our loaded nachos were good, though the nacho cheese was a bit runny and pooled in the bottom. My grandsons loved their pepperoni calzone and Mac and cheese. My personal pan Meathead pizza was very good; tasty with a nice crisp crust. My wife enjoyed her chicken Tuscany pizza. Both personal pizzas were bigger than expected and very filling. Would definitely stop in again if in the area.

Had supreme pizza for 1 and wife had cream of mushroom soup. Both were serviced warn and were very…read moretasty. I had a bloody Mary with plenty of trimmings. Will eat there again soon.

GREAT PIZZA. It's the crust and sauce. More like a traditional Chicago pizza from a neighborhood…read moreplace. NOT thick like a GINO's East pizza, but real Chicago neighborhood pizza. (actually like old Cicero neighborhood - real Italians) Only downfall is they do NOT have a big Menu to choose from. They should be making Ravioli, Lasagna, etc. If they are as good with those dishes, as they are with the pizzas, they would have a non-stop crowd. Noticed a lot of people picking up pizzas to go. That is their forte - their Pick-up service. They need to expand the Menu. Many people would go for other Italian dishes. We would.

It's the best pizza in Wisconsin good sauce. Good cheese. Fresh like dough. I have nothing to…read moreinsult it's the best in Wisconsin

Medically, I cannot recommend this pizza. It's a cardiac bomb! But if you are adventurous and like…read moregood pizza, and your doctor isn't worried about your heart, this is very good pizza!

Delicious "stuffed" pizza! Easy and efficient ordering. Ready on time and piping hot. We loved it…read moreand will be back!

Ok so I moved here from Chicago and tried some of the pizza out here and man this place is awesome…read moreloved the pizza!!!

We absolutely love their pizza. The price is a little more but totally worth it…read more The only problem is the last 2 Saturdays we've tried calling to order a pizza. We know to call right away at 4 so we can have dinner at 5. But after trying both weekends with no answer for 50 tries. Guess we will stay with another place in town. They answer the phone. Really sucks, their pizza is great. But 50 try's and 20 minutes later I give up. I'll go to another place where they answer the phone.

One of the nicest restaurants in the Whitewater area! The food is always delicious and the…read moreatmosphere is so pretty. The servers are also great! On our last visit, we enjoyed their tomato soup, as well as penne Ala vodka with chicken and fettuccine Alfredo with chicken. They also have great salads and desserts. We reviewed their lunch menu after the meal, and may try one of their sandwiches on our next visit. This is great place to stop if visiting a student at UW-Whitewater or for a special occasion. A step above other restaurants in the area.

Food is very good! Fanatico feels very nice inside but is inexpensive for the quality and…read moreatmosphere it provides! I went here for a retreat with 8 other guys and once else with my girlfriend for Valentines Day! Service both times was very good too! Would recommend

Great addition to the Evansville pizza scene now that Trapper's is closed. We tried the meatball…read moremadness pizza and it was very tasty. The meatball chunks were huge and they were the first things the kids picked off the pizza to eat. The crust had a nice chew and held up pretty well to the toppings. The middle got a little floppy when eating slices, but it tasted good. I will say though, that this pizza benefited from a hot honey, but then again, I think most benefit from that. Can't wait to try out their bbq chicken pizza in the future, especially because they do their own smoking of meats.

So good!!! We had a thin crust pepperoni and sausage pizza and garlic bread delivered and everyone…read moreLoved it in our house! I loved the thin crust, and the flavor was perfect! Definitely plan to order again!

Pros: -Good pizza…read more-Nice staff -Easy parking Cons: -Underwhelming steak sandwich -Some items over-seasoned We recently tried out Marty's Pizza on Mother's Day because it was my MIL's choice. She has great memories from going to a different Marty's location for work lunches years ago. Apps: -We started our order with some of the mozzarella sticks, which my wife and MIL liked (I'm not huge on breaded mozzarella sticks, so I didn't try them out). Mains: -Pepperoni pizza (Wife)-- really good thin crust pizza -Spinach lasagna (MIL)-- over seasoned to me, but my MIL seemed to enjoy it -Steak Sandwich (Me)-- not great, one little slice of overcooked, thin steak with some cheese. It also came with a cold side of fries. Overall, I would stop back in for pizza but probably would probably skip for anything else.

Three of us had the lasagna and found it very tasty. Two of us had it with Italian sausage and the…read moreother person had the homemade meatballs. I would order it that way next time. Our fourth had a pizza which he said was also delicious. Our server was very attentive and pleasant. The environment is OK could use a little TLC.

Paul Revere's Pizza in Milton is on the top of my list, great food a professional and friendly…read moreservice. I love their Deluxe Pizza. Put them on your list, you won't be disappointed.

Great Pizza and great people! Tasty, hot and very enjoyable. This is my favorite pizza in Milton.read more