One of the nicest restaurants in the Whitewater area! The food is always delicious and the…read moreatmosphere is so pretty. The servers are also great! On our last visit, we enjoyed their tomato soup, as well as penne Ala vodka with chicken and fettuccine Alfredo with chicken. They also have great salads and desserts. We reviewed their lunch menu after the meal, and may try one of their sandwiches on our next visit. This is great place to stop if visiting a student at UW-Whitewater or for a special occasion. A step above other restaurants in the area.

Food is very good! Fanatico feels very nice inside but is inexpensive for the quality and…read moreatmosphere it provides! I went here for a retreat with 8 other guys and once else with my girlfriend for Valentines Day! Service both times was very good too! Would recommend

We visited for the first time yesterday, after driving by many times previously. The parking lot…read morewas packed, so we weren't sure if we would be able to be seated spur of the moment. Thankfully, we were seated right away. We were served water and a wonderful tray of bread and focaccia with marinara -- everything was delicious, especially the sauce. (OMG!) We explained to the waitress that we wanted to also order an entree to go, and asked for the best timing to do so. Our waitress remembered this and returned at the perfect time to take that order -- rigatoni with marinara and meatballs. We had a 30 mile trip home and the dish was still warm when we arrived! It did take a while for our food to arrive. We were a little concerned because we did not want to drive home in the dark. Our food was very good when it arrived -- the Chicken Vesuvio was amazing, and the leftovers are even better today. Our family member liked the Alfredo, but thought it was a little watery. We were too full for dessert, but carried out a tiramisu. This was also delicious. The dining areas are Italian styled supper club. We were seated to the left of the bar. It looked like the dining area to the right of the bar was a little nicer, but again, we did not have reservations. We were appreciative of the table we were given. Some updates are needed, but we were comfortable. The service was amazing. The host/hostess was friendly and welcoming. The waitress was terrific. The bus boys deserve a special mention -- they were back and forth with water multiple times, and one even offered additional bread to soak up the Alfredo sauce. They were humorous and kind and for being so young, they were very professional--said how much fun it was to work there. (They deserve some special kudos!) Overall, this was a wonderful stop. We'll be back and will try other dishes. We hear that the vodka sauce is also amazing.

Best Italian food in Southeast Wi. Service is also superb!!!!!!!!…read moreKeep going back for more.

What an awesome Italian restaurant this place is! The vibe is very quaint inside. You MUST make a…read morereservation. It's a chef and a server. The flow of dinner was very nice. To start we ordered 2 appetizers. They came out timely. They were very delicious! Highly recommend the meatballs and spinach artichoke dip! All of our pastas were cooked to perfection as well. Served hot. Anything you pick will be amazing. We were served bread with dinner as well. Portion sizes were plentiful. Cannot wait to come back and try other pasta dishes!!

I was in the mood for an Italian pasta meal and found Mangiami Italiano online. It said they were…read moreopen until 8pm on Saturday, so since it was only 6:30, I decided to take a ride over. From the outside, the place looked inviting.., even had a big free-standing sign on the sidewalk that said OPEN. When I walked in, though, the setting felt dark and dingy. There were about 20 tables total, and only 5 of them were occupied. I asked for a table for one, and the host asked if I had a reservation. When I said no, I was told they were "reservations only." I even asked if they were expecting a big rush, given the number of empty tables and more than an hour left before closing, but the answer was still no. So instead of serving a paying customer, they turned me away. Honestly, what a poor way to run a business, especially when the place was 75% empty. Extremely disappointing experience. I won't be back

Got takeout pizza to take back to our campsite. It's a good sign when you walk in and there are a…read morebunch of folks wearing high-vis vests. They know what's good. Got a 16 in with pizza and black olives for four adults. The crust is really quite thick... more so than what I'd call NY style. Not a complaint! We just got so much pizza for the money! Sauce was very tomato-y. Not too much on the pie. A generous amount that stays under the perfectly baked cheese. Sausage was top notch. Will definitely get again, sine we come to DL at least once a year.

I'll admit I was skeptical walking in. The restaurant is attached to a hotel that isn't the nicest,…read moreand the entrance had a strong hotel‑cleaning‑supply smell that made me apprehensive. But from the moment we sat down, it was all uphill from there. The Italian wedding soup was excellent, rich, flavorful, and clearly homemade. The pizza was decent, nothing extraordinary but solid with plenty of cheese. We also ordered the lasagna, the spicy chicken dish, and spaghetti and meatballs. The standout was the spicy chicken: the "spicy red sauce" turned out to be more of a creamy, spicy blend, and it was fantastic. Everything came out piping hot, which I really appreciated. They also bring out warm rolls, and those were surprisingly tasty, soft, fresh, and perfect for dipping. Overall, I highly recommend this place. Despite the rough first impression, it turned out to be one of the best restaurants in the area.

Mama T's is an unexpected delight! Located in a strip mall across from the High School, you would…read morethink it wouldn't be worth visiting. But trust me. It's definitely worth it! All their food is delicious but their thick pan pizza is AMAZING! It takes 30 minutes to cook and just melts in your mouth. Their Ho Ho cake is also fantastic! Baked on Monday, it usually sells out by Thursday evening. You need to go!

Suzanne was our server tonight. Very knowledgeable about…read moremenu and specials. We decided on tonight's special which was Chicken Tetrazzini. There's made with fettuccine topped with a cream sauce made with honey Dijon and wine. It came with either a grilled or breaded chicken, and we both chose the grilled chicken. The grilled chicken was cooked to perfection in season perfectly. Tender chicken breast meat, which was moist. The cream size was made to perfection and very tasty. You could actually taste the honey Dijon and wine in the cream sauce. Nice and thick and tasty. We also decided to try a bowl of their homemade chili. Mama T's does not hold back on the meat! There was plenty of ground beef in their chili with lots of beans and a sauce was thick and not runny like many places make it. It was seasoned spicy, but not over spiced. For me it was perfect. We also had the breaded mushrooms as an appetizer, and I will tell you that their breaded mushrooms are nice size and moist with a nice breaded coating over them deep-fried to perfection. I have these breaded mushrooms every time I eat there. Our waitress Suzanne recommended the specials to us and we are glad that she did. They are very good waitresses at Mama T's. Prices for the meals is comparable to going to places like Olive Garden and other Italian restaurants. Portion size are more than adequate and you'll definitely not leave hungry. The restaurant is very clean and very appealing to the eye.

The best place to eat in fort Atkinson ! Always a pleasure to pull up and eat some real comfort…read morefood in a town with not much to do this food is true!

If you're visiting Fort and looking for good italian, this is a must visit! The pizza is some of…read morethe best in the area. The thin crust is my absolute favorite of their crusts. It's not paper thin, but it's still a great classic. The cheesy garlic bread was super crisp and delicious this night too!

very warm service. I had a cod / calamari special which was one of the best fish dishes I have…read moreever had. Will def. be back

I'm in town visiting and stumbled across this place. Great atmosphere and great service from the…read moremoment we walked in until the moment we left. The food was incredible, very authentic. I had the carbonara and it was the best carbonara I've ever had. The lunch portion was more than enough. My sister got the chicken parmigiana and said it was amazing also. Free ice cream at the end with kids meal which my son enjoyed.

Let me tell you, this place if fucking phenomenal. I love Italian, always have. This place stands…read moreout to me. Their spaghetti is so damn good. Their service is amazing. They once held an order for me 30 minutes after they closed. I was running way late and they were super understanding.

The reviews I read about this establishment make it sound like the place to get Italian food in the…read morearea. We set up to meet friends here but we're disappointed when we arrived to see signs that said take out only. Be sure to check it out, but be prepared for it be takeout only. Next time we are in town, we will call ahead and make an order for pick up.

The food is wonderful. The service is friendly. It was our first time there and the people were…read morevery attentive. My wife and I ordered three different things to eat there and checked out all the deli items while waiting. We ended up getting a lot food to cook up a huge meal and invited our kids and grandkids out to help us eat it all this Sunday. We live about 45 minutes away but decided we would try to get there at least once a month.

Cute stop if you're in the mood for some good Italian food. The smell is amazing when you first…read morewalk in. We did grab some provisions for a later date but would love to eat at the deli for lunch some time. They have alot of great options frozen (cheese, sauce, etc) as well as shelf stable for all of your Italian needs. The deli counter was pretty busy when we stopped in so it got a little claustrophobic for a few in our group. However, they seem to use all of their space as well as they can. Staff were friendly and tried to help people as quickly as they could. There's only one register by the front door though so it can get a little bottlenecked at times.