I graduated in 2022 and have not been back to this place since '23 but I still think about this pizza so often. The pizza is perfect, garlic knots, are perfect, and if you have a chance to see the owner, he's amazing! Could not recommend this place more. (Also check out his Italian restaurant next door) read more

I've been so curious about this place and finally got there! The two slice special saves you a few pennies. Slices are heated up perfectly. It was 6 PM and the place was empty, but there was plenty of pizza to go around. It was fresh crust, light and tasty, and the toppings were delicious. read more

See all

I placed an online pizza order at 5:45 PM on Super Bowl Sunday through La Piazza's website. The website accepted my order and payment without any indication they were closed. At 6:05 PM, the DoorDash driver called to say he had arrived at the restaurant to pick up my order, but no one was there and the restaurant appeared closed. Their posted hours state they close at 7:00 PM, so there was no reason to believe they would not be open. I attempted to call the restaurant multiple times with no answer and there is no voicemail option. I also tried the email address listed on their website, which was returned as undeliverable. As a result, I was charged $36 plus a tip for the DoorDash driver and received no food and no response from the business. I would strongly caution others about ordering online from this restaurant until they address their ordering and customer support issues. read more

It's 2:07 am and I'm currently devouring a slice outside. These fellas are making genius here. 10/10 the service is amazing especially at 2:07 am. Hats off to the GOATS read more

Good variety of slices of NY style pizza. It hit the spot. The owner, who served us, was friendly as well.

the pizza was really good! definitely loved the meat lovers pizza and will be back to try more! the man who works here is super nice.

good food good people and the pizza is always made to satisfaction if you need a late night bite stop by

Good pizza served in a simple setting. For me, a great test for a pizza place is to try their plain cheese pizza. Nothing to distract you from the pizza itself. La Pizza Pizzeria passed the test admirably. I would definitely recommend here. read more

Meat lovers was delicious, always great service! Fast work on big lines every weekend. Thanks Benny and staff!

Pizza was amazing. So many unique choices . Service was exceptional. Super clean too!

First time ordering, and I wasn't disappointed at all. We love all things pizza but don't like pizza chains. We just recently moved up here and wanted to try different pizza places and I think we just finds out favorite place. The flavor, was on point and left me wanting more. And the slices were huge. read more

Best Pizza I've had since I left NYC !! Closest pizza to NY style there is !! Great owners , place is always clean. And most important the Pizza is ALWAYS Great !! read more

The pizza here is a pizza dream come true. It's the best pizza I've had in years, especially the sausage. I'm from NY State and struggle to find really good, authentic NY style pizza in WI. I've finally found it. We've had friends and family try it and they all love it too. I'm devastated that it's closed for the summer. read more

Best slice of pizza in town. They have many topping options to choose from!! The employee there is always super kind and welcoming. He cares about the quality. If you're ever in whitewater I 100% recommended going. They're open super late which is also nice. My go to pizza place! read more

Wow, bennys got his stuff down. Got the chicken bacon ranch and let's just say, my socks got blow clean off. Talk about a trip to flavortown, I bite this pizza and instantly have to tell people about the gazoonga that this place has. Thank you Benny for changing my life and changing the definition of pizza as we know it read more

Not impressed. We ordered a large sausage to go and all I can say is that is was large. The pie was oily, too much sauce, with too much oregano. Here's the worst part, the Italian sausage looked like it was some pre-cooked crap that was shaved super thin like that lunch meat in the little packages, Buddig....UNBELIEVABLE ! Have you ever had a gyro with that pre-cooked, pre-sliced stuff, it's terrible. I grew up in Jersey, 30 miles from NY city and have never had, seen ,nor heard of SHAVED sausage anywhere, certainly not on pizza! We will not be going back. To the other reviewers that apparently think this place is great, all I can say is: 1. they know zip about pizza down there in the flat land south of WI (that's IL for you non-flat landers) ....they put the sauce on top of the cheese, need I say more #2. Philly has great cheese steak, not so much pizza. It's been a while since I've been back east but it ain't like this ! You don't forget what you grew up with. read more

Wrong name, but food is still great. Finally! A place that sells slices and is open late!! Not only do they have an incredibly logical owner, the food is great. My favorite slices have been the plain cheese, mushroom, and custom vegan (peppers, onions, olives, and broccoli). Let's face it folks - midwest pizza stinks. (yeah, I said it.) Having good pizza - floppy bottom, airy edge crust, and delicious sauce and toppings - in this little WI town is a dream that I never thought would come true. They have about 8 or so pies available for slices in the shop, and will make any pie for you on request. They threw a vegan pie together for me a few times and it was delicious. The slices are a little more expensive than what I'm accustomed to on the east coast, but I'm willing to pay for it. Plus, I'm delighted to support a business that can provide great food after midnight. read more

Had a fantastic piece of pizza. I got a slice of cheese and it was only 2.50$ which is a fantastic price for a good slice. They serve by the slice, it can get pretty busy since they have great pizza but its worth the wait if you have to wait for a fresh pizza to be made. Definitely coming back read more

This is my favorite place to get pizza in Whitewater, love getting a whole pie or individual slices! My favorites are pepperoni & sausage, Mac and cheese, and the UW...yum! read more

We ordered the garlic knots and Bianca pie. Both were great and hit the spot. Staff was friendly and wore masks and gloves.

This place just opened and I've been to it twice. It's the best pizza in Whitewater. Do yourself a favor and go there.