Just picked up cookies. Order plenty of time ahead for a custom order. Asked in instructions for all cookies to be half baked and gooey. 2 were completely crunchy and way over cooked. Also asked that extra icing and topping be placed on the ones applicable. As you can see, icing didn't even cover those cookies. Have not ordered from this place in a while due to them not seeming to get it right. read more

Half Baked Goodness - Box of 4 over cooked cookies - Desserts Near Me - Magnolia, Texas

I'm not stranger to HBG, I supported the business when they were home based delivery. I admire how far they've come in short amount of time. I ventured to this location and while I knew the cookies wouldn't be the freshest (I bought a too good to go box), the customer service experience was weird. She wasn't that friendly, didn't answer the phone when I called en route and was picking and choosing cookies to give me in and out the box. It was kind weird; typically that's already decided before you get there. Like would you have served these cookies to someone full price. Idk just stating. Prettier store front than the Mueschke location though. read more

Half Baked Goodness - Desserts Near Me - Magnolia, Texas

I came here once a long time ago and was floored by the amazing cookies! But I have not been back because it's a 40 min drive for me. I saw the advertised pumpkin snickerdoodle on instagram and had to have that. That was worth the drive. I came today and the said they did not have them because they could not find the recipe for it or something. I was extremely disappointed in that. It's important that staff has the right resources. Hopefully they get the cookie they are advertising I just don't know when I'll be able to make it back again. I do want to note they offer keto cookies and I was very thankful and impressed with that being an option. I got the snickerdoodle keto cookie and it was actually delicious. Of course still very clean inside and nice atmosphere. read more

Half Baked Goodness - Crème brûlée, Buckeye, almond joy, and chocolate chip walnut - Desserts Near Me - Magnolia, Texas

See all

I placed an order to be shipped from Texas to Florida! I ordered the "Ship" it "Custom Keto Box" of cookies a Dozen for $62.99 plus shipping! They offer new cookies of the week for what I call classic style cookies ( made with real sugar etc ) That all sounds heavenly. They have some classics that stay and they offer a few "keto", Gluten free, Paleo options that stay the same. They also offer cookie cakes! My "keto" cookies that I ordered were "peanut butter supreme" , chocolate chip cookie, and crème brûlée, all Keto! They shipped promptly in a nice box. Slightly squished and some crumbled a bit. I'm not sure if too much could be done about this as it was packed pretty well maybe a bit too tight. The cookies are a fairly good size and there are instructions to heat in the oven before serving. I heated the crème brûlée right away. Now I do sometimes bake my own Keto cookies and often purchase locally but I've heard a lot of wonderful things about Half Baked Goodness! So I needed to try! I'd say that the keto version to me is indeed good perhaps slightly dry but still tasty I'm not sure if I'd pay the delivery fee again considering that they weren't more impressive than other keto cookies I've eaten and how they arrived. Locally I'd probably stop by on occasion! I love that this bakery considers other lifestyles and makes many consumers part of their Half Baked Goodness family! https://halfbakedgoodness.com/menu/ read more

See all

It's not your typical cookie! There's one for everyone and especially for the ones with dietary needs! So come get your cookie! There was a lot of promotions around Half Baked in the community - so I happened to be in the area to stop by for 4. I had the VF/SF/DF - peanut butter (sooo good. Taste more like PB) Chocolate chip - highly advised to bite with some cc in it. The taste is like cardboard without it, but if you're looking to eat without allergies --- EAT the cookie! ;) Regular cookies : cookie with walnuts & chocolate chip Cute box with instructions on how to warm up. read more

See all

I got the chocolate chip and double chocolate chip at a pop up festival where they had a tent because I kept seeing their ads online and had to check out their cookies. They were solid cookies, better when heated up back home! read more

Half Baked Goodness - Chocolate chip, double chocolate chip - Desserts Near Me - Magnolia, Texas

Great variety of cookies! Flavor of the day as well as their mainstay of cookies! I want to go back and try more! read more

Half Baked Goodness - Desserts Near Me - Magnolia, Texas

10 stars out of 5!! This is my old new favorite bakery in Houston.. or Conroe.. BOTH!! The celebration is the absolute best!! Sugary rainbow sprinkles and white chocolate chips in buttery goodness. Perfection. The staff is amazing. I love the owner and idk how she finds them but all of the girls there are cute as heck and so friendly to boot. They are just fantastic all around and I know that they never fail to brighten my and all my family and employees' day. I love visiting Half-baked and I always leave after an awesome conversation with huge smile and a box (or two lol) full of pure cookie bliss. I STAN HALF BAKED GOODNESS read more

Half Baked Goodness - Desserts Near Me - Magnolia, Texas

See all

So this is a giant cookie place. They have a least ten different types of cookie on display at any time. They are excellent cookies and about 4 normal cookies in size. Current price is 4.65 each. Served in a little cake box when you buy one. They just do one thing, but they do it well. read more

Showed up 10 minutes before closing and was told they're already closed... pretty disappointing customer service.

Who doesn't love a good cookie? I especially love their crème brûlée cookies. They are especially sweet, so one cookie can last me for two days. Traditional cookies, like chocolate chip, and sugar are also excellent selections. Staff is always friendly and helpful. read more

The place was empty and the cost was ridiculous. The $5.40 a cookie, the gluten free/keto cookies ( chocolate chip and sugar) had to be the most disgusting cookies we ever ate . The Chocolate chip was inedible and thrown out. The sugar cookie was not as bad but each bite tasted like we were eating sand off the beach. I did not taste any other cookie. My friend has a gluten problem. read more

OH MY GOODNESS!!! Can I just say that the name of this place is a perfect fit!! The cookies that Half Baked puts out are deliciously half baked!! Let's get into the review! After a Drs appt I wanted some comfort food, so popped in. They offer keto friendly cookies along with your regular sugar and butter filled cookies. I ordered the Texas Sheetcake, Chocolate Chip Walnut and the Keto Snickerdoodle! I broke a piece off of the snickerdoodle and almost melted in place! The ooey gooey deliciousness of cinnamon just melts in your mouth! The girl at the counter (my bad for not getting her name), was awesome! She told me about the two different types of keto cookies and what all they have. She was super helpful! She even gave me a sample of the keto double chocolate chip cookie! I'm hooked!!! Just sayin'!! Half Baked is still new, so there isn't much to the inside, but I'm not there to look at the decor. I'm there for goodness in my mouth!! I'm not sure about the negative reviews below unless they're competitors, but I wouldn't go by those because they're so far off my experience. Give this place a try!! You'll thank me! read more

See all

We love this cookie place! They have so many options for keto, gluten free and vegan allergies. Family owned and super clean. Their cookies taste so yummy! 5 stars!!!!! read more

Half Baked Goodness - Sugar cookie and keto chocolate chip - Desserts Near Me - Magnolia, Texas

Service was excellent! Cookies were delicious. If you have not tried Half Baked Goodness give them a try.

The cookies are the best I've ever had and I'm not even a cookie person. Definitely recommend.

I tried these a couple of weeks ago and have gone back. They are really delicious and my new favorite. I quit buying Crumbl Cookies a long time ago as they just seemed boring - no flavor seemed to stand out, just blah. I've tried 8 different cookies so far and I love the thickness and softness of these. And every flavor didn't taste the same and were uniquely yummy. And if you're doing keto, they have keto cookies that are surprisingly good. New customer for life! read more

This was the first time for my wife and I to stop here, we were excited that a new cookie bakery was opening so close to where we leave. We buy 4 cookies a week to share and have with afternoon coffee. Atmosphere was a little blah staff wasn't really helpful and also not very friendly. They did not display their cookies in a way that would make their cookies look appealing. I don't light comparing, one cookie place to another but since half baked wants to be somewhat like Crumbles, I feel I need to. At first glance, their cookies don't look very appetizing. The presentation is sad I bought a box of four, just like I do at crumbles. The taste of the cookies were OK the cookies look over cooked as you can tell in the picture, but the centers were still gooey and the cookies felt very heavy and overly sweet there's no consistency on the size. I was hoping that this place would be good but sadly it wasn't so instant if driving 2.5 miles for cookies we'll make the 8.5 miles to Crumbles. read more

Half Baked Goodness - Different sizes look overcooked - Desserts Near Me - Magnolia, Texas

Amazing cookies. Crumbles pales in comparison. I prefer to. Get the medium size cookies but you gotta order them ahead but they will be fresh as you could hope for. You should know the idea behind these cookies is they are "half baked" so they are on the softer side of cookies. If you want something totally cooked throughout this prolly isn't the cookie for you. It's a mother daughter business and they are amazing people. Highly recommend. They are almost a weekly staple in our household now. read more

My girlfriend and I stopped in there on Monday to try the cookies staff was not friendly cookies were the worst I've ever had we spent 20+ dollars and through 90% of everything away run run run do not eat at this place. And the employees all look, the shoveled did not look professional, and the atmosphere was very poor. I feel sorry for sister negative review, but you have to be honest read more

I see a few people leaving nasty reviews about this place. Shame on you. This places boasts some of the best cookies I have ever tried. Their peanut butter cookies are phenomenal. I HIGHLY recommend you come here and try their treats because they are delicious! AND the staff were all very friendly and welcoming!! Also miles better than Crumbl's overpriced garbage read more

So excited to have a local owned Bake shop here in Magnolia!! The hometown vibe along with delicious treats is long overdue. I just had the crème brûlée cookie and it was AHHHHH-MAZING!!! We have found our go to spot for sweets!! read more

Got a box of four and the chocolate chip cookies were amazing better than crumble by far! the atmosphere is welcoming and service was fast. will definitely be going back again read more

Half Baked Goodness - box of 4 - Desserts Near Me - Magnolia, Texas

I went in for the first time ever not even knowing what this place was but was hoping it was sweet stuff by the name of the company. I walked in and was looked at by the staff with no cordial welcome as I looked at the menu. I bought 2 cookies: Chocolate Chocolate Chip, the outside was crunchy but the inside was almost soggy, and Creme Brûlée, the whole thing was absolutely amazing!!! That's the only reason I'm giving some stars. I would go to a Crumbl Cookies instead. If they had better customer service and the cookies more cooked then I would come back, but unfortunately they don't. read more

Stopped in after my dentist appointment next door (sorry Doc!) and grabbed 4 cookies. Got a nice warm welcome when I walked in and the young lady that helped me was very friendly. Cookies were huge and tasted great. I'll definitely be back! read more

Very yummy, better than crumbl imo, not as sweet and just as big. I love the Keto options, I had the snickerdoodle and was amazed. I believe it is made with erythritol. My whole family loved them. The gentleman at the counter was also very kind and patient with us, definitely recommend! read more

their keto cookies are amazing. The peanut butter is my favorite. You have to try the pumpkin chocolate chip, although it's not keto get it while it's in season take a look at the fresh flowers on their counter by Magnolia Flower Patch in Boutique. I have to deliver them every week and I can't resist the cookies. read more

These cookies were so warm and fresh when we ordered. They taste amazing and are the perfect consistency. I love doughy cookies and these definitely seem "half baked."The service was wonderful and the young girl cashier was super knowledgeable on sizing and the cookie cakes. In comparison to crumbl, half baked goodness cookies seem more fresh, homemade and are bursting with natural flavors. When walking in it does look fairly new so there's not a lot going on in terms of decor. They do have really cute merch though! 10/10 will be coming here a lot. read more

Half Baked Goodness - Sugar cookie and raspberry lemonade - Desserts Near Me - Magnolia, Texas

This place is amazing. Their Crème Brûlée cookie melts in your mouth. It is beyond incredible, which coming from a French person is a high compliment. The staff was super kind and helpful. Really good bang for your buck. Can't wait to see what they do with the place in the future. Have and will be returning often! read more

Just got some cookies! Soooo goood. If you love soft cookies (who doesn't) you need to get some. I'm enjoying every single one I've tried. read more

Half Baked Goodness - a variety of baked goods - Desserts Near Me - Magnolia, Texas

Love these cookies, such a good variety of options! I'm typically not a fan of keto desserts but loved the keto choices. The staff were super friendly. Definitely recommend & will be returning. read more

Cookies are what the name says! The carbs in the Keto cookies are low and they still taste good! Peanut butter was awesome and good portion. Friendly staff as well. read more

We were so excited about this new cookie place opening nearer to home since we like Crumbl so much, but it's farther. Unfortunately, the premium price does NOT guarantee premium cookies here. My chocolate chip cookie was literally running liquid/raw throughout the entire middle. My two oatmeal raisin cookies were noticeably two different sizes, and with somewhat burnt raisins just stuck all over the top surface of each. The chocolate peanut butter chip cookie was more chips than cookie. Just enough cookie dough to hold together a huge wad of chips. We had high hopes for this place, but it wasn't even mediocre, I'm sorry to say. Probably won't give them a second chance any time soon. read more

Wanted to give a huge shout out to Half Baked Goodness for donating cookies for the Magnolia High School cheerleaders homecoming gift exchange with the opposing team. The cookies were a huge hit! They were beautifully baked and packaged and the girls were proud to present them. Thank you for supporting the students in our community! read more

These cookies are amazing. The Keto snickerdoodle is amazing!! So far we have had the chocolate chip cookie which is perfect! The peanut butter cookie has a layer of yumminess in the middle. SO GOOD. I need another! read more

Delicious!! Soft, gooey, warm cookies! We haven't tried one that we haven't liked yet!

Oh great heavens this place is the very best place I have ever bought cookies from in my entire life. If I could post a 10 star review on a 5 star review I would. The emoyees gave me the best service of my life and made my day by asking me about my family life at home. Crumbl cookies has nothing on this company. I drove 40 minutes just to get these cookies. By far the best place I've ever been to in my whole life. If Jesus came back to life and told me his body and blood was made of these cookies I'd believe him. If you don't come here you're stupid af, this by far is a game changer. I will come here every day of my entire life if it means I will be satisfied for life. read more

These cookies the best. crumbl could never, and the service was amazing this girl named lola took my order very loud but i love it. recommend this place to anyone in the area read more

Better than Crumble Cookies in my opinion! They're very friendly and kind. The inside is very cute, and there are a couple of chairs to sit and wait if need be. read more

Best cookies ever! Fresh ingredients and great customer service. They even deliver! I compare to Crumble, which was dry and over cooked last time I went. These are like eating grandma's cookies straight from the oven. I will definitely be back! read more