Not the sort of place you sit down and chill. There's no real seating, so the first time we visited-we walked back out. Went to the burger spot across the street. Second time around, we were looking for a place to take-out so stopped here. Got a typical Philly wit. Decent. Nice size and the bread was really soft. Not the best I had but still good. Would recommend but wouldn't make a special trip for it. read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Probably the best cheesesteak that I have had. The service can be a little slow but it is worth it. I can see the student eating here often. They have a good sized menu for cheesesteaks burgers and fries. The Classic heavyweight which is a foot long. They were not skimpy on meat! Cheese was all over and so good. Sliders - Nice slider size. Tender bun. Good sauce on a perfectly slight charred burger. Overall I'd be back if I am craving a cheesesteak. read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Very small spot off of Easton Ave with just one counter top to stand at if you plan to eat inside . I definitely had high hopes for this place, thinking that the name would say at all, but it definitely lacked . The cheesesteaks were pretty pricey and very small compared to most other places . You would thing the lighter portion would be half of this size of a full one which was not the case. It was more like a quarter. We were Very disappointed with the amount of meat on the cheesesteak which was very weak I tasted more bread than meat. Service was a tad slow I waited about 20 minutes or so for my food. I'd have to say I'm one and done but I'm sure those colleges kids will enjoy it . read more

Get to this place now. Amazing sandwiches and the boneless wings were incredible. Strawberry hot honey?!?!?! Who would have thought. I was able to meet the owner and he is an amazing person. If I am in the area again I will definitely have this as a go to spot. read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - Boneless strawberry hot honey wings - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

My first time ordering from here. This is a great cheesesteak sandwich. I ordered The Classic, excellent steak, very fresh bread. It's a hearty meal. They did a great job and I will definitely be ordering again. read more

These cheesesteaks are everything! Let's start with the bread, where so many cheesesteaks go wrong. This sesame seed coated rolls are just right. Its slightly crusted exterior gives way to a soft but sturdy interior perfect for soaking up the juices of the premium shaved rib eye without turning into a sopping oil sponge. And about that shaved rib eye? That is some quality meat! Full of flavor and light on grease. The cheese options are plentiful: cheddar, american, cheese wiz, provolone and pepper jack. I went for the classy provolone and added some sweet-n-spicy banana peppers (pro tip: add the peppers!). I ate so slowly because I didn't want to last bite to come. A word to the wise, there is no seating inside. All orders are to-go, so plan accordingly. There is a narrow bar, but that's usually packed with people waiting for their cheese steaks to emerge from the kitchen (which can take a little while, but hey, you can't rush perfection). read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - Classic with Provolone and Banana Peppers - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Placed a mobile order here and was pleasantly surprised when it was ready a little earlier than the estimated time -- always a win in my book! Unfortunately, the chicken cheesesteak just didn't hit the mark for me. The bread had more of a firm bite instead of that soft, pillowy roll I usually associate with a good cheesesteak, and the chicken itself didn't have that thinly sliced texture I love -- it felt more like chunks of chicken breast. Flavor-wise, it was okay, but I've definitely had better (Charlie's still holds the crown for my go-to chicken cheesesteak). To be fair, I don't eat beef, so I can't comment on their classic cheesesteak, which might be their strong suit. Service was quick and friendly though, so points for that! read more

We got this doordashed to our hotel and it was really good. My son wished he got a cheesesteak too and kept taking bites of mine haha read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

Im so happy this joint opened up in New Brunswick. I no longer need to drive to Philly for my cheesesteak fix! Staff is highly attentive, service was quick, interior was clean, and the food was amazing Highly recommend the Patty Melt- It was fire You can't go wrong with The Classic as well. Overall my experience here was 10/10. I will definitely be back! read more

If you are looking for something quick and deliciously filling, look no further. My cousins and friends were really craving cheesesteaks, and luckily Heavyweights just opened up in the area, so we stopped by. This local gem specializes in quality Halal cheesesteaks that are both hearty and flavorful. Upon walking in, we found the atmosphere at Heavyweights Cheesesteak to be casual and welcoming, perfect for a quick bite or a laid-back meal with friends. If you want to dine inside, there is a bar area where you can stand and eat. With six of us, we decided to order different thing so we could sample a wide variety of items. The staff was incredibly friendly, knowledgeable, efficient and accommodating- they even cut the cheesesteaks into six pieces so we could all share everything. The food came out very quickly and we ordered a lot of food! We ordered the following menu items: - Loaded Steak Fries: Shaved ribeye, cheese wiz, onions, with a drizzle of house sauces - Parmesan Garlic Fries - Beef Sliders - Patty Melt: Two smashed patties, American cheese, onion, grilled peppers, and mayo And for the cheesesteaks, we ordered a heavyweight of the following: - The Classic: Freshly shaved ribeye, Cooper sharp cheese, onions, and mayo - The Works: Freshly shaved ribeye, wiz, onions, grilled peppers, mushrooms, and mayo - The Firecracker: Freshly shaved ribeye, pepper jack, onions, habaneros, grilled peppers, and spicy mayo - The Buffalo Ranch: Buffalo chicken, ranch, provolone, and onions Each item had the perfect ratio of ingredients and the portions were very generous (excellent value with portions that reflect both quality and quantity). We loved every item we tried and were thrilled to find a place where we don't need to go all the way down to Philly for a decent cheesesteak. In fact, I prefer Heavyweights over any Philly cheesesteak spot I've tried. The ingredients at Heavyweights are top quality--take the bread, for instance. They use bread from Rockland Bakery, one of my favorite bakeries, and its texture is perfect: tender enough to bite into easily, yet robust enough to hold all the delicious fillings without falling apart or becoming soggy. The crust has the right chew to it with the interior remaining light and fluffy making each bite just that much more enjoyable. The meat was cooked to perfection with the perfect balance of fat and meat (most other cheesesteak spots, I find it to be way too greasy) and sliced thinly to ensure it cooks evenly and retains its juiciness. If I had to pick a favorite cheesesteak, I'd go with The Classic. The Cooper sharp cheese on it is outstanding; the sharpness complements the meat and onions nicely. But honestly, you can't go wrong with any of their options, it just really depends on what you are in the mood for. I also never had chicken cheesesteak before, and I was surprised with how delicious it was. If you are looking for a lighter option, definitely go with the chicken. You can also make substitutions to the default cheese, with choices including Provolone, American, White Cheddar, Cooper Sharp, Cheese Wiz, Pepper jack, and extra cheese. We also ordered all the sauces to try (Spicy Ketchup, Ranch, Smash Sauce, Garlic Aioli and Spicy Mayo), they were all good but honestly each menu item is so flavorful to begin with, it's not a necessity but more of a nice to have. I do have to say that the Patty Melt paired with Garlic Aioli was phenomenal. We had such a great experience here from start to finish and we're already looking forward to our next visit to explore more of their menu (that we weren't able to fit in our bellies this time!). Heavyweights has definitely earned a spot on my list of must-visit/go-to spots and I can't wait to go back when I'm in the area! read more

See all

Philly is an hour away, south Jersey spots 30 min away, save time and come to heavyweights cheesesteaks in New Brunswick. They did their homework on the top Philly spots and made them their way. Cooper sharp ftw! read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - Lightweight classic with hot sauce - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

This was bomb! I will definitely be looking forward to ordering from here again. (Adding a few more characters because it asked me to) read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - The classic cheesesteak with no onions, pepperjack and cheddar cheese plus the extra cheese option. - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Came here on their 2nd day open. The photos of their food on Instagram show big, loaded cheesesteaks that live up to their namesake "Heavyweights." Unfortunately, that's not what I got for $16, which is the price of their large (aka Heavyweight) cheesesteak. The steak itself is delicious, and I love seeing Cooper Sharp cheese this far north in NJ (it's usually just a South Jersey thing)! But my cheesesteak was small (3/4 of a pound with the bread), not much onion, and the extra sauces I paid for were half full. I'll be back again when I'm craving that Cooper Sharp cheese, but I'll need to order double meat and double onion just to get a true "Heavyweight" sized amount, which is over $20. read more

See all

I've been putting off trying this place for so long mainly because this taco place right across the street that I eat at often however I decided to give this place a try and boi oh boy I can't believe I was shutting myself out of this place for so long this may just be my new favorite place in New Brunswick. The food was amazing service was fast although had to go ambience. I wish they had some seating so I can enjoy it there rather than driving home any of my food there but nonetheless, it was well worth it. The Cooper Sharp cheese is to die for they know just what to do when it comes to making cheesesteaks great job. Glad you guys are in town. read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - Classic - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

I want to recognize how consistently they deliver quality. Heavyweights Cheesesteaks delivers on convenience, employee kindness, and good value. The kitchen delivers quality. The quality of customer attention is outstanding. This restaurant stands above competitors. read more

They're closed I showed up with the fam to eat and there's no sign of the place at all.

Have heard a lot a good things about this place for the Scary Good Eats App.. You definitely have to have a game plan if you want anything here. Parking is not fun since you are in the heart of Rutgers. You have to hope you can snag a spot out front. The place itself is very small, no indoor seating, just order and you are on your way. Was not a cheap lunch for 2 sandwiches and some fries. Around $50 I believe. The sandwiches were good. Got the basic Cheeseteak with the Cooper Sharp. It was an exact amount of meat and cheese to fill the roll, which was soft and fresh. Was a solid Cheeseteak. The fries were very good as well. I will go back, but not out of my way. Very Good job for a new business. read more

The complaints I'd read seemed petty after my visit. The employees deliver outstanding customer experiences. Heavyweights Cheesesteaks benefits from its central position in the area. They really do let the food do the talking. I want to come back and taste what else they offer. read more

A newly opened hot spot on Easton Ave. service was good quick and easy. The place does not have any seating (not sure if they intend to add bar stools? In the future) but its more of a to-go spot. Their location is perfect for Rutgers students. We tried their chopped cheese hot dog and philly cheesesteak. And both were delicious. I definitely liked the hot dog a lot and the cooper sharp cheese stood out on the cheesesteak. I'd recommend them to toast the bread a little more and add more meat to the cheesesteak. Meat wasn't dry but a little more stuffing would've been nice. Overall id say it's a good bite to grab. read more

This cheessteak is one of the best tasting I've had in a very long time! I ordered the small, should have ordered the large. It left me wanting more. read more

This spot has become my favorite topic of conversation lately. Goodness gracious, everything was so delicious. I built connections with the employees, who are excellent and notably kind. The attention to detail here is noticeable. Our family will come back for special occasions. read more

They sure are the heavyweights! this truly lived upto the hype I've seen all over social media..I got their classic cheesesteak which packed a lot of flavor, and also got their sliders which were so tasty! Definitely coming back for more!!! read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - classic - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

Very very very dissatisfied last night. My buddy took me for lunch on Friday for my birthday and bragged about heavyweights cheesesteaks. So we ordered them last night for dinner only to get home and be disappointed beyond belief. There was barely any meat and very little onions. I basically ate a loaf of bread for dinner. I wish they told me they were running out of steak and onions when I called and ordered. I'm going to add a picture if I can. read more

One of the best places I've ever been to in my life. I have had a plethora of cheesesteaks from the NJ/Philly area and Im not talking about the tourist trap spots. Real hole in the wall spots and this place is one of the best. I couldnt even take a picture of my cheesesteak because I ate it quickly. I got a picture of the chopped cheese dog and its so good. High quality ribeye steak and all halal. I got the Firecracker and it had an amazing kick to it and their Cajun Fries is amazing with their home made spicy ketchup. The service was amazing and they were very attentive. They have all Boylan sodas so you know this a top notch place at amazing prices. read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - Chopped Cheese Dog - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

Amazing cheesesteak ! Classic heavyweight with cooper sharp is my go to. They use the best ribeye and fresh bread along with cooper sharp you cannot go wrong with this. So thankful there's a local cheesesteaks now in New Brunswick. Anytime im around or visiting friends from Rutgers I'll definitely come back. read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - Classic with cooper sharp - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

These cheesesteaks are literal fire. I normally am not a fan of cheesesteaks, especially in central Jersey, but now I can't even eat any other cheesesteak besides heavyweights. I get the firecracker with cooper sharp and mushrooms and it always hits. No other place does it like this. Halal, fresh juicy ribeye, fresh bread, and all the right flavors cheesesteaks are supposed to have. I also love the heavydog, it's got crispy yummy garlic on it and it's so addicting. The Cajun fries are also SO good, crispy on outside, soft on the inside, and unbeatable flavor. I can't stop at one and dipping them into spicy ketchup, omggg! Everything pairs great with a Boylan but sometimes I want the martinellis so I wind up getting both. So so good!! read more

See all

I did a double meat, and maybe that was my mistake, because all I tasted was grease. I hated the flavor of the meat and could not taste the veggies or cheese at all. My wife said the seasoning on her meat was too much. Maybe I'll give this place another shot becuase the reviews are so good, but I suspect it may just be late night drunks eating here. read more

After first try, I can never forget it. I like the heavyweights firecracker . I have been there twice so far. I will be there more.

Nice cheesesteaks! Great addition to the neighborhood. Simple menu not flooded with a bunch of items and great quality

Excellent food. We walked from the hotel to Heavyweight Cheesteak and we were not disappointed. Great job

I support small businesses! Today, I visited Heavyweight Cheesesteaks in New Bruswhick, NJ. They have a fresh new store front, assumingly properly licensed and permitted, the utilities are on, the social media machine is running strong, and they have a good location (RU) and positive attitudes. These are the makings of a successful business except one important thing is missing - EXPERIENCE! The place looks good & so do the sandwiches - why doesn't the food taste great(?). It's a lack of experience! Yes, the sincerest form of flattery is to imitate, and that is what's being served here - Imitation "Look-a-like" Cheese Steaks, Dog and Fries. Sliced (shaved) tasteless, overcooked and over chopped Ribeye steak, served with minced and overcooked onion & peppers with melted cheese on a soggy bun is not what you get from an experienced purveyor of delicious Cheesesteaks! If the business classes you took in school (or maybe you didn't take) did not stress the importance of mentorship programs, especially in the food services industry, they did you a great disservice! The GOOD NEWS is that it's not too late to make some (cost free) adjustments before the college students return for classes. Don't overcook the meat or mince the peppers and onions (if you're using frozen pre cut vegetables - look for a larger cut), get rid of styrofoam and use coated cardboard service boats, stop wrapping the sandwiches in thin sanwhich wrap paper - it sticks to and become one with the cheese and other wet ingredients. Lastly, cut the large sandwiches if half - all the way through! Even though nobody asked, these are my recommendations. With time, hard work, and attention to detail, success will come - good luck! read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - Storefront - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

See all

Took a while to get the food. The meat had more grissle than you'd like and the "wiz" didn't taste right. No marinara sauce option. Pretty weak overall. read more

Ate a cheese stake once and it was delicious. Ate another a few weeks later to see if it was a fluke. Not a fluke just f***ing delicious. Best cheesesteak around. read more

The cheesesteaks here are incredible! After eating here, it only makes sense for me to head back if I'm craving a cheesesteak!

Not many meals compel me to leave a review but Heavyweights warrants the time and gets 5 stars! I wouldn't say I've ever craved a cheesesteak but since having The Original, I've been back for many more! Their sliders are also out of this world and a must try. After meeting the owners and seeing their passion, we decided to have Heavyweights at our home for a private party. They were professional, prompt and catered to each guest. I am still getting text messages from friends raving about their meal! To say they were a hit is an understatement. read more

Amazing cheesesteaks! Some of the best I've had in a while. Great service. Pretty clean space more grab and go than sit down. My new favorite place for cheesesteaks for sure! read more

First time trying it. Ordered a plain chicken cheesesteak with cheese only. Picked it up, brought it home and it was loaded with pepper and onions and microwaved chicken. $10 in the garbage. read more

I had the classic cheesesteak, and it was delicious. The bread was super soft, and they were generous with the meat portion. The place is more suited for takeout, but it's perfect for grabbing a hearty meal, especially on a cold day. For the price, it's a total steal and well worth it. read more

I usually go down to Lawrenceville or Philly whenever I'm craving a cheesesteak but now that this place has opened in central jersey it'll be saving me a lot of time and gas... the steak was plentiful and not overwhelming, and seasoned perfectly. And that Rockland seeded roll is just perfect... customer service was great too. read more

Heavyweights Cheesesteaks - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Brunswick, New Jersey

I got the Buffalo ranch cheesesteak today and it was one of the best cheesesteaks I've ever had in my entire life, and I used to live in Philly. Highly recommend. I will definitely be coming back. read more