You know those days when you're on your lunch break and realize you still have to go food shopping? Today was that day. Hungry and very short on time, I ordered the turkey and brie sandwich from the Chatham Sandwich Shop. My order was ready for pickup in less than ten minutes. The sandwich was melt-in-your-mouth amazing--the kind of lunch that makes you stop after the first bite and think, "Oh, that's good." There's something comforting about places that do simple things exceptionally well. The Chatham Sandwich Shop is one of those classic sandwich shops that doesn't need to try too hard. Good food, quick service, and exactly what I needed on a busy workday. Five stars. I'll be back--probably the next time I ignore my grocery list. read more

Tried Chatham Sandwich Shop for the first time for lunch and was pleasantly surprised! There's street parking right in front of the shop. We came a little later in the afternoon, probably closer to 2 PM, but there were still quite a few people having lunch, which is always a good sign. My friend ordered the tuna sandwich on sourdough, and I got the chicken salad on sourdough. Everything tasted fresh and yummy, and the sourdough was really good! We also got the macaroni salad to share, and honestly, it might have been my favorite part! It was perfect - not drowning in sauce like how other places make it, and I loved the fresh veggies mixed in. I would genuinely come back just for the macaroni salad, but I'd definitely be down to try some of their other sandwiches too! Not sure if we were the weird ones for getting macaroni salad as our side because I noticed everyone else seemed to be having a bag of chips with their sandwich..... Either way, no regrets! Definitely a cute little sandwich spot I'd come back to! read more

See all

So I ordered from here cause they had a pretty good reviews on yelp, itv says they've been around for 40+ years and they were running a pretty cool Bogo deal on Uber eats so I got the turkey club. Sometimes I like to throw random instructions in there like toast bread, melt the cheese and make the fries well done and surprisingly this shop hit on all points. The bread was fresh and so was the turkey, and the fries were well done to perfection and they had that golden crisp to them. The shop itself looks nice inside and my food was ready for pickup as soon as I arrived. If you are in the mood for a good sandwich then I recommend this spot will be going there again stars. read more

Chatham Sandwich Shop - Turkey Club and French fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

Known for their sandwiches, so I knew I had to get a warm one to try! The Veggie Crave has grilled zucchini and peppers, sliced green apples, melted Brie cheese and fig jam. Really delectable and messy! The Roasted Pumpkin Soup was divine - perfectly herbaceous and creamy. read more

Chatham Sandwich Shop - Veggie crave - Sandwiches Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

See all

Was in the mood for a sandwich and I haven't been to the spot in a very long time. I decided to order it on DoorDash and it arise fairly quickly. I got a turkey club, which is pretty standard, but also filling in good quality the hero of the meal was definitely the sloppy Joe. I got turkey and roast, beef and it was just super delicious. I will be back read more

Chatham Sandwich Shop - Turkey Clubs, Jersey Sloppy Joe sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

Way overpriced. A simple 14" turkey sub with cheese and bacon would have been $36.50!! That's $40 after tax for a turkey sandwich!! I ended up paying $18.50 for a 7" sub instead. It was fine, nothing special. If anything it felt like they skimped out on the turkey. Would absolutely not recommend. Your money is better spent elsewhere. read more

My wife and I got sandwiches from here. My hope was to have a better experience than last time. I got the best sandwich ever! The Monte Cristo! Absolutely delicious! Just look at the picture. The sandwich is larger than expected. My wife got an egg sandwich. It huge!! Got it ordered to the hospital and it was a fast delivery. read more

See all

I have picked up some sandwiches a few times mostly because my buddy lives near by and it is convenient. We pick up on our way somewhere They do have a very large selection and food seems pretty fresh and the service is always good and on time. The sandwiches are good but not great nothing special but not bad. My buddy seems to enjoy more than me so not sure. Like I says not bad at all just not great read more

Was working in the Short Hills area and wanted a sandwich, found this place on here and the menu sounded good. I got the Turkey Gobbler sandwich. Im a sucker for thanksgiving sandwiches when I see them on a menu. It was delicious. Would return when near by read more

It's wild I haven't been here in 8 years but have dreamed about the sandwiches at least 8x a week smh. I was in the area more or less (heavy on less) and made a beeline for lunch. I used the website to order The Gobbler, my fave, even though I was almost seduced by a crispy hot honey chicken sandwich. It was just as good as I remembered. Toasty turkey with little charred ends, velvety stuffing, your fave canned cranberry sauce and warm brown gravy. Sandwich was about $13. Once I picked up my order I also added a Joe's Half n Half lemonade/ice tea. Wait for it: FOUR DOLLARS!!! Honestly, that's outrageous. Like-- However, they make the best gobbler I've ever had so I'm gonna let it slide but that's ridiculous. read more

See all

This is the place for a sandwich! The service took its time because they make everything fresh to order. The meatball sandwich has 3 large meatballs that are warm and tasty. Outside seating along the Main Street is simple and beautiful on a nice day. read more

The crispy chicken on focasia bread was very good. I would order this again Service was quick . read more

What was going through your mind when this place was destroyed by fire several years ago? For me, the $1000 question was - will they reopen? Well, I'm glad they did and they've blazed on past that terrible day. I come through Chatham occasionally and made a point to stop in. Had to get the local classic, the Sloppy Joe. My boy got a delicious looking Italian. First time back since the Fire and I look forward to my next visit!! read more

Excellent sandwich shop! Flavorful and fresh! I Excellent service! Pickles are good too! Highly recommend!

Great place!! Staff are super friendly and happy to serve you. Place is very clean . Floors are spotless. I love a place that's bright and they greet you as soon as you walk in. It makes me feel welcome . I ordered a turkey sandwich. I added the works. Bread was soft and fresh and the portions of everything in it were perfect. I took my order to go as I was just passing thru. I recommend stopping in and having a sandwich or two. Sorry no pictures. Next time! read more

It was just okay. Ordered online a wrap and a sandwich - arrived 25 minutes later and waited an additional 25 minutes inside. Food was good not great. I was surprised how busy it was given the food and experience was just okay. read more

Was getting coffee in the area and wanted something to eat! This sandwich shop was across the way so we decided to try it out. Shop was aesthetically pleasing, very clean inside. Can order from the cashier or self order from the screens. The Tuscany sandwich was phenomenal!!! I would definitely go back and have it again. The main reason I'm leaving a review is for the customer service. My sisters boyfriend ordered a sandwich and the chicken was very pink. He and I are very cautious when it comes to chicken as we've both gotten very sick from bad chicken. We showed it to a guy behind the counter, maybe the owner or manager he looked like, and explained to us that chicken can tend to look pink from the pigment, although thoroughly cooked and safe to eat. That being said, he offered us without question that he would make a brand new sandwich as he didn't want us to be uncomfortable. The new one was perfectly made and delicious. We appreciate customer service like this, it truly goes a long way! Thank you so much we will be back! read more

Chatham Sandwich Shop - Tuscan Crispy Chicken - Sandwiches Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

It's different from most delis and sandwich shops in the best way - you're not stressed out and having employees yell out "what do you want who's next" as soon as you walk in. It's clean, organized, and the staff is extremely friendly. The food is fresh and the sandwiches are priced fairly. This is much better than the deli I grew up with (a certain one originating from Millburn). I'll be trying their catering services soon and I'm looking forward to it. Definitely come here the next time you're craving a sandwich read more

Chatham Sandwich Shop - Turkey and cheese sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

Absolutely delicious sandwiches! Great, friendly staff. And a clean, welcoming atmosphere.

I ordered from here twice recently. Once we did take out and once we dined in for dinner. The place is very clean. I ordered the veggie craze both times, absolutely delicious. I will definitely be back! read more

Sloppy joes are good. Fresh ingredients and fresh bread. Prices are a tad high but maybe that's only due to the area. Owner is always there keeping things clean and running ship shape. read more

Locally run place,consistently delivers great fresh sub options in any combination you can imagine with or without the lettuce onion and tomatoes on top. They have a special menu of sandwich dejections to choose from or create your own. They make great sloppy Joe sandwiches. Options include lots of salad varieties My favorite is a chef salad but you do you. Even if there is a line it will move quickly smoothly and they will be gracious if they make a mistake or didn't hear you right to quickly correct your order so you will be happy. Lots of good and drinks options available to compete your meal. Lots of seating and if it gets filled up you can take the order to go and sit on the benches across the street outside the library. Please stop by the next time you are on Main Street in Chatham. You will find something you will like. read more

The Chatham Sandwich Shop is a classic in this area - the subs are great whether you order just one or order catering for business or an event. read more

Coming back in after the horrific fire that put this place out of business for a while. The inside is beautiful. There are kiosks for faster ordering and takeout. That seems to be the way to go here. It may have lost a bit of charm but that comes with renovating! The turkey and roast beef sandwich was so fresh. I enjoyed every last bit of it. The pickle was also just so delicious. It's a pretty expensive sandwich! But extremely tasty. Happy to see them back! read more

See all

I decided to give them a try again after the fire and remodel. The service was eh. I was the only one in the shop and it took forever to get my THEC SPK. Also after I ordered, the clerk had to ask twice what I wanted. The THEC SPK was eh. There was too much bread. All I tasted was bread and ketchup. Should've been more egg and more Taylor ham. The ambiance was that of a new shop. It was clean and new looking. I will not be back. Go at your own risk. read more

See all

Placed a pick up order for a smoked turkey club sandwich. They were quick and the staff was super friendly upon arrival. Place was busy and the parking wasn't bad. I was able to pull up to a pick up spot without any issues. Large menu and the sandwich I had was delicious. Very filling and came with a side pickle. Will be back again in the near future. read more

Chatham Sandwich Shop - Smoked Turkey Club - Sandwiches Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

Food service. Bought a sandwich toasted bagels Bagel tasted stale. Butter had tge taste of refrigerator Simple things matter. very disappointed read more

Everything is good, soup arrived hot..I am a repeat customer. I often get their soups and home made salads.

Ordered Italian hot dogs. Really good. Best in the area. Just wish they'd consider using round Italian "pizza" bread cut in half.

Clean, efficient, excellent quality throughout the menu. Their sandwiches are wonderful.

Prices are sky high . 13 $ for a half sandwich . This place used to provide vale but no longer .

I've ordered from here via online and also dined in. Haven't had issues with my order so far but I was disappointed with my recent dine in experience. While the general staff members are pretty nice, I feel the manager does not like having kids dining in. My son and his friend were having their lunch and kids being kids, they like to talk. My son's friend is in ESL so he's been working on his speech and he does talk in a higher pitch/tone. I already noticed he was giving us looks when we were walking in as if we were causing trouble. Then while we were eating, he told us to "control" our kids because he was talking on the phone/ or with someone. Mind you, our kids were sitting in their seats eating and were not running around. They were just talking. I was very disappointed with this kind of treatment and would not be coming back. Even if it wasn't for this bad experience, I would give them 2 stars because their sandwiches are just mediocre. Their bread is stale and taste like cardboard. The paninis are slightly better but I feel something is still lacking to make it enjoyable. read more

I'm very happy they're back! Great owners, high quality food. Plenty of parking nearby, but good luck finding a spot on Main Street.

Fantastic Sandwich Shop Clean and efficient Magnificent Presentation Delicious Reasonably Priced read more

Excellent sandwich bacon egg and cheese. very clean. Plenty of bacon on the sandwich. Not easy to park

The best breakfast sandwich I've ever had honestly. The owner saw me struggling with the payment machine while he was working and helped me out. Overall good vibes. And again the food was amazing. Everyone should try and bacon and egg sandwich. read more

Chatham Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

Great subs here! There cheesesteaks are pretty good. Believe it or not there potato skins are really good. Wish there was a create your own sandwich on the website ordering menu - being able to customize a sub with all there ingredients would be great. read more

Woo! This tiny joint has the best sandwiches! We got a meatball sub and sausage sub, and we have no other comments on the flavor other than YUM!!! The restaurant is tiny, don't expect open seats here, we had to sit outside. Iced coffee was good, and service was friendly and pleasant!! Little bit pricey for my range, two subs, coffee, coke, chips for $35!! Because these sandwiches were so delicious, we say it was worth it as a good treat. What a nice place in a great area!! read more

Chatham Sandwich Shop - Meatball Parmigiana - Sandwiches Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

I like their good.Good quality ingredients. But be on the lookout for day old tasting sandwich rolls. read more

I recently tried this sandwich shop during my lunch break from work. With so many different sandwich choices to chose from, I went with the roast beef, turkey, and swiss sloppy joe. This was an excellent sandwich I must say. It is stacked as a triple decker sandwich, and was just really good. They used plenty of meat on it, which is an A+ in my book, as I love lots of meat on a sandwich. The slaw was fresh of the sandwich and both the turkey and roast beef meats were delicious. They were perfectly sliced thin and everything was so fresh. The sandwich came with a large pickle on the side too, which was a nice bonus. I definitely will be coming back here to try out some of their other delicious looking sandwiches they offer. read more

See all