Small quiet shop, nice people & super knowledgeable about their craft. Definitely will continue to…read morego back with it being a 10 min walk away

I was honestly surprised how great the hamburger paddies were. Delicious!! They call them steak…read morepaddies. U can actually taste the freshness. The staff behind the counter were ok. Friendly but they need to be a bit more organized. I'm sure they will learn.

I stopped into The Meat Shop into after calling in to order 5 Days before (Recommended) an Order of…read more10 Pounds of Grass-fed Beef Roast and 4 Pounds of Pasture-raised Chicken. I was also given a sample of D.E.L.I.C.O.U.S. Pork Sirloin Chop Man let me tell it was DELICIOUS. Local Sourced and with the Pork comes with a fantastic source who cares about their product. I continue to buy my Grass-fed and Grass-finished Chuck Steaks here a year later and just as delicious as the first day

06/27/26 Arcadia has decent meat's but it doesn't compare to THE MEAT SHOP! I'll just wait until…read morethey reopen!

Wow, what a special find today. We went and had great conversation with Brandon. He was awesome. We…read moretalked about where they get their beef and pork, and they have unpasteurized milk, love that! Feed yourself, know where your food comes from, be healthy, research, and remember you are what you eat. Super excited about the meat, both beef and pork really sad that they were out of the homemade chorizo and breakfast sausage. Just gives me excuse to have to go back. Thank you, Brandon and Dustin. Also, if anyone's interested, they do have duck eggs. I WOULD RECOMMEND

While super far from me, if I'm ever in the area I'll stop by to grab beef here. First time visit &…read morethe owner made me feel like I was a regular. Very knowledgeable with a decent selection & quality is top notch. Will definitely stop by & gladly support locally owned businesses!

We got a gift card here and WOW! As soon as you walk in, you're immediately blown away by the…read moreincredible selection. The variety of meats alone is impressive, but it doesn't stop there! They've got everything from barbecuing essentials and specialty seasonings to bold hot sauces and even a cold beer to enjoy while you shop. And then you make your way to that beautiful deli counter. That's when you truly appreciate the value of a real butcher. The quality, expertise, and personal service, it's a completely different experience compared to your typical grocery store. They also have 'cuts' of bone for your furry friends. We grabbed a bone for our dog and can't wait for him to enjoy it! Von Hanson's isn't just a deli... it's a place for anyone (new to grilling or professionals) who wants to enjoy quality meat and find whatever they need to cook it!

I haven't experienced this issue before, which is why I was surprised by my visit today. I…read morerequested five center-cut filet mignons, all cut to the same size, and trusted that they would be prepared as requested. Unfortunately, when I got home, the steaks varied significantly in size, and one was clearly not a center-cut filet. It was disappointing, especially since I was preparing a special meal on short notice. Update to my original review: After reflecting on my experience, I realized my original review didn't fully represent the business. From the moment I walked in, everyone was as friendly and welcoming as they have been during my previous visits. The staff was also very helpful in recommending some of their prepared side dishes, including the mac and cheese, twice-baked potatoes, and potato skins. They even provided cooking suggestions for both the air fryer and grill, which were appreciated. Although I was frustrated with how the filets were cut, I have to say the quality of the meat itself was excellent. The filets were incredibly tender, full of flavor, and everyone enjoyed them. The sides were also a big hit with our guests, especially the potato skins. I also want to recognize their outstanding customer service. The owner responded to my review promptly, and the store manager called me first thing the following morning to discuss my experience and make things right. That level of responsiveness and genuine care for their customers is becoming increasingly rare and deserves recognition. While my initial experience with the butcher counter was disappointing, I appreciate how seriously they took my feedback and their commitment to customer satisfaction. Because of that, I'll gladly continue shopping here and look forward to seeing the same high standards reflected in future visits.

New York Butcher Shoppe is such a great addition to the neighborhood. I love that it is a one stop…read moreshop -not just great meat. Their prepared meals are delicious- the chicken parm is our favorite with the Mac and cheese close behind. I usually grab a marina sauce and a bottle of wine and the meal is complete. Delicious!!

Here are the photos/time stamps you wanted. Funny to try and state that you don't believe this was…read more"your" shop. You were actually the one that took my order, didn't tell your guy to get the cuts that I asked for. Also, when is the last time you have seen someone do 2" cuts and just close an eye and wing it without measuring it? You should probably be taking "actions" against yourself.

I almost hate to leave a review but only because I'm selfish and I don't want anyone else to find…read moreout about it. First, I've never had one of their burgers, I only go for the meat. We go through ~5 pounds of ground beef a week along with other cuts, and theirs is the best. We've been buying their meat for a few years now and I don't care if it's less expensive elsewhere, the quality of theirs is just better. Unfortunately they've had to raise their prices but it's understandable. Everyone has had to raise prices lately. But, like a junkie, they got me hooked. I don't mind really, it's worth the extra cost.

Burgers 5 star--- FRIES= 0 stars! Went here after a long day…read moreto pick up a bite to eat and head home. All I can say is: when you worked hard for your money, take your time and gas to visit the place all we want is a good meal without conflict, getting stale, cold fries from a place that literally specializes in burgers and fries just feels disrespectful. We waited for our food expecting it to be fresh only to get cold stale fries in our meal. I normally don't leave reviews, but we felt let down because half the meals I bought ended up being an edible. Le me tell you - if the fries had been fresh this honestly would have been a 5-star experience because the burger was excellent. But the FRIES...the fries why? There's no way those fries came out fresh and hot!

I had my wife and son pick up some prime tri-tip, and it smoke and grill up perfectly on the grill…read more Great quality meat and I'll definitely be back for more. I originally called to make sure I'd make it in time, but when I realized I wouldn't, I asked my wife and son to stop by instead. I called the store to let them know my son would be picking it up, and the person who helped them was super nice and easy to work with. Next time, I'll be stopping in myself to thank them and check out the location in person.

Jesse does a great job in explaining all the cuts of meat…read more And they offer well prepared cuts for you to put on the grill, okay, after you season them the way you like. Just picked up jalapeno, poppers and mushroom poppers - stuffed with sausage! It's a very clean shop and you can see all the prep space is immaculately maintained. Can't wait to be back to get some of the other cuts.