Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Holy Pie Pizzeria

    4.9 (7 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Holy Pie Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery

    Holy Pie Pizzeria Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like Holy Pie Pizzeria

    Recommended Reviews - Holy Pie Pizzeria

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Mozzarella fingers
    Amanda H.

    This location offers carryout and delivery, but no onsite seating is available. As for the food though, it is delicious! The crust is really good, the cheese sticks are some of the best I've had, and everyone is so nice. They have a great lunch special and a great carryout special.

    Apps, Wings, Greens, and Bowls

    See all

    8 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    16 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Kendall W.

    Kendall W.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    Ask the Community - Holy Pie Pizzeria

    You might also consider

    Baldinos Giant Jersey Subs

    Baldinos Giant Jersey Subs

    2.6
    (17 reviews)
    0.2 mi

    With the new management, things seem to be taking a positive turn! Food is great; when they say…read moregiant, they mean giant. Quick service, neatly packaged, really high quality ingredients. I got a family sized turkey and provolone and I'll probably be able to eat this for the next two days.

    I give up on this place- its gone downhill since it was sold to these "new owners" who can barely…read morespeak or read English- I placed an online order for a sausage sub with extra onions- I get home and its sausage & onion ONLY- the sausage was old & dry; I had no other choice than to eat it because I am diabetic and was very hungry and I wasn't about to drive all the way back there in this cold rainy weather to argue with them to fix it- this happened to me a few years ago as well & I stopped going there; I thought I'd give them a second chance but things are just worse. I walked in and there was this Indian woman & her 2 kids running around while she was mopping the floor with, you guessed it, Pinesol! I almost got sick from the smell. It was about 6pm, store closes around 9 or 10pm, why couldn't she wait until after they close? Its disgusting! "Jersey subs"? NOT ANY MORE- ALSO- they are deleting any negative reviews off of here, I wont be taking any chances eating here again

    Photos
    Worst Italian in Statesboro. Where is the meat??? .  #17 The Sicilian "Spiciest Italian of All"
    Worst Italian in Statesboro. Where is the meat??? . #17 The Sicilian "Spiciest Italian of All"
    Hardly any tuna. And it wasn't fresh.
    Hardly any tuna. And it wasn't fresh.
    Hardly any tuna or toppings.

    See all

    Hardly any tuna or toppings.
    Bites

    Bites

    3.9
    (121 reviews)
    0.5 mi
    $

    The food is more or less what you would expect. The service is questionable. When the waitress…read morestarts to suggest changes to your order, ie, salad instead of fries, more chips & salsa - they should also tell you that there is a charge for it. I had a mushroom cheese quesadillas & it came with chips & salsa. Since the person I was with was also eating the chips & salsa I asked for more. No problem until we got the bill. The "suggestions" cost extra, and we were charged for the additional chips and salsa. If that's their policy okay, but please let the diners know ahead of time. Also, my quesadilla consisted of 3 pieces. Every other place I've ordered one there were 6 pieces & I took 3 home for the next day. Also, I'm considered tiny - 4'11", about 108# & 3 pieces was not enough food.

    Drove past this place many times the past few years during visits back to GSU. Looked more like a…read moretypical college student hangout so opted to not stop in. Most recent trip a lady at the GSU football game recommended it. Me and my two alumni buds opted to check out. It has a decent outdoor area and an interior that reminds me of Taco Mac. Atmosphere was good and our server was great. The Buffalo chicken artichoke dip with points was the only thing I enjoyed food-wise. The fried green tomatoes weren't really seasoned and the tequila lime chicken sammie wasn't anything to write about. Ordinary. I guess if you're a college student, this place will suffice for price, food proportions and atmosphere. I do like it's not a chain and always want to support local. Average, however. Maybe I need to try a different menu item ...

    Photos
    Inside
    Inside
    Hamburger patty from Bites .
    Hamburger patty from Bites .
    Bites

    See all

    Jimmy John's

    Jimmy John's

    3.1
    (24 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $

    Service is always mid. There's a tall white guy that acts like you walked in 10 min before closing…read moreno matter the time of day. My sandwhiches are always missing something, or not cut in half, or missing napkins.

    Definitely my 1st Choice for sandwich delivery in S'boro…read more Sandwiches are ALWAYS tasty & accurately made to match the order. Delivery is ALWAYS FAST & friendly. ... Sandwiches are not what you'd call "cheap", BUT you do get a pretty decent weight of meats/cheese & other fixings for the money, so they are a decent value. AND you can order delivery via their app & avoid the excessive fees & price markups that can often RUIN the DoorDash or UberEats ordering experience. PLUS if you sign up for the JJJ app they will send you special offers & rewards, which makes the price paid very reasonable. The "Favorites" sandwiches are my usual choice, & the wheat bread is almost always my choice. ... My ONLY real complaint with JJJ's is that they no longer offer sprouts as an alternative to lettuce. The sandwiches with sprouts were pretty awesome!! I do miss that. (...I'm assuming the discontinuation was either due to the price of sprouts, perhaps the shelf-life, or perhaps a food illness (...E-coli? or other farm-source illness?) issue or concern.) .... A couple of suggestions would be for them to offer sides in a larger container (4x) option, & to offer a discounted price for ordering multiple sides. (...either multiple cookies at a discounted price, or maybe a "The Full Jimmy Experience " option that includes sandwich, pickle, chips, side item, & drink all at a well-discounted bundle price.)

    Photos
    Outdoor seating
    Outdoor seating
    Jimmy John's
    Jimmy John's

    See all

    Sugar Magnolia Bistro & Bar

    Sugar Magnolia Bistro & Bar

    3.9
    (134 reviews)
    2.6 mi
    $$

    My goto spot in Statesboro when anyone comes to visit…read more OGreat food expertly prepared, a luscious cocktail menu, desserts that are off the charts, pleasant and helpful staff, and a tremendous bonus to find out that they locally source as many items and ingredients as possible.

    Absolutely great bistro in Statesboro! We arrived 10 mins before 11, when they opened for brunch on…read morea Sunday, and there was already a line of people waiting! Must be a good sign. We promptly got sat by the lovely staff working. We sat outside, I ordered an Aperol spritz and my husband got a Bloody Mary. All of our drinks were delicious, reasonably priced. The Bloody Mary wasn't spicy (although a table next to us was complaining it was...), and the Hugo spritz was SO refreshing! They for the fresh mint from their herbs out front! Only complaint was we prefer our espresso martinis to be mostly espresso heavy, and this one was more cream heavy. We ordered the Brussels, country breakfast (subbed cheese grits instead of pancakes because we're gluten free) and got a side of fresh fruit. It was so much food. We didn't finish it all! The grits were nicely seasoned and cheesy. Brussels were super crispy and not drenched in grease or sauce. Eggs were nice and salty, potatoes were fried nicely. Everything was great. We would love to come back for lunch or dinner - especially happy hour. It wasn't too loud and we felt there was plenty of seating.

    Photos
    Espresso and bar!
    Espresso and bar!
    Sugar Magnolia Bistro & Bar
    Sugar Magnolia Bistro & Bar

    See all

    Holy Pie Pizzeria - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...