A hidden gem! Went to Shipshewana for a concert and we're looking around for anywhere to be open…read morepast 4/5 for dinner. Stumbled upon this place and it was excellent! First off fantastic service, and recommended the garlic chicken as the most popular dish. It was very good and huge portion. Wife had the special and it was even better than mine. Really cool atmosphere, very popular spot at least on the Saturday we went. Doubt we will be in the area again, but if we do, we will be back!

Fantastic! Love the garlic buns. Whiskey selection is best around!…read moreLove the craft beer for $4/can. Service is great and the ambiance is upscale for other places around the area. Jayce is a great server!! Go IU!

Authentic! We stopped into this out of the way place for a bite of Mexi food, but very surprised…read moreat how authentic the dishes were. We felt like we were stepping into the kitchen of a Hispanic family for dinner.

Good stuff! Arroz con pollo was tasty, great presentation. The steak chimichanga was large and…read moredelish!

Food and service were both great! The menu was full of great choices…read more We also like the ambiance of the restaurant. Didn't expect this in such as all town.

Stayed in Shipshewana which most restaurants close before 8. Stopped here since it's 15 minutes…read moreaway and they closed late. We really enjoyed the food! The bbq sandwiches were delicious. The corned beef ruban was a favorite. Drinks were great and so was the service. We sat outside despite it being hot and our waitress was so friendly. Definitely reccomend and would return. We were surprised with how busy it was being a tuesday night!

I really didn't feel like it was anything special. I felt like the food was way overpriced for a…read morepiece of cake. My husband came in and seemed like the price of a cookie was, and we decided to leave. We did meet a friend there. Had a nice cup of coffee It's a great place to meet somebody. Nice place for a treat.

I've been here twice, once to chat with a friend over coffee & another for a quick drink on my way…read morethrough town. I enjoyed my coffees both times- a cappuccino & a lavender latte. It seems really clean & the staff has been very friendly both times. It's definitely a gem in the middle of Lagrange.

2.5, maybe. We were…read moreso disappointed in this food! We got our pizza to go, so I can't comment much on interior or what the dine-in experience is like. We ordered the garlic bread- and it's quite possibly the most bland garlic bread we've ever had. Where's the actual garlic flavor? Cheese? Italian seasoning? It needs... something! We ordered two pizzas and for the first time, probably ever, we didn't even finish half of either one. The pepperoni pizza was insanely greasy. I couldn't hardly stomach it. My husband loves a good chicken, bacon, ranch pizza and this just wasn't a good one. The chicken seemed frozen, he felt like there was too much ranch- the flavor was just off. We did try calling and speaking to a manager to see what they could do for us- which was nothing. No desire to go back.

The pizza was amazing! We got a cheese pizza with a garlic parmesan flavored crust and it was…read moredelicious; the garlic parm crust was definitely a hit. The trivia cards at the table are a fun touch as well and we loved playing with them while we were waiting for our food.

The Gathering Place is exactly what a small‑town breakfast spot should be, and it's become a yearly…read moretradition for us whenever we're at Sylvan Lake. It's the kind of classic small‑town breakfast that feels familiar in the best way, nothing fancy, just really good food, big portions, and prices that make you double‑check the bill because it's that reasonable. We literally drive 35 minutes out of the way every year because it's worth it. The service has always been great and genuinely kind every time we've gone. No rush, no attitude, just people who take care of you. If you want a dependable, affordable, no‑nonsense breakfast with that small‑town warmth, this place nails it every time.

Great service! Quick meal service. Big portions. I had the skillet breakfast and it could have been…read moreenough for three meals. Great taste. You will not be disappointed if you try this restaurant. Go try enjoy!! I will go back. I want try their homemade cinnamon rolls! Great local diner feel.

It's the middle of baseball season and the dog days of summer are on the way! So the wife and I…read morestopped for some food and a nice cold Margarita (we hoped). Words of wisdom from me to you: DO NOT order a Margarita from a Mexican restaurant if they do not have a Margarita menu with all of their variations or if you see a large jug of Finest Call Margarita Mix on their counter!! Get a cold draft Modelo instead!! Strike One! One complimentary bowl of chips and salsa with a meal?? Who the Hell does that? And the Salsa was awful! Pretty sure it was enchilada sauce?? No onion, no peppers, no cilantro... the worst "salsa" ever! So glad we were only allowed one! Strike Two! Now the food wasn't terrible. Wife got a Chicken Chimi and I got the 20" Monster Burrito with steak. But when I didn't eat the entire burrito and heated it up the next day at home (added sour cream and homemade real salsa); it actually tasted better! Strike Three! Maybe I try this place again and most likely it will be carryout only! But my first impression was not a good one for this little town restaurant.

Prices were great, food was even better. Quesadillas were smothered with queso, hardly any place…read morestill does that. Definitely recommend and will be back again.

Had breakfast here, we both had omelets. Not only were they very good but they were served HOT…read more Normally we are lucky to get a luke warm meal when we eat out. My husband had hash browns that were cooked perfectly, not limp and soaky. Service was great and meal was reasonably priced.