It took about 15 calls to get through on a Sunday evening. Ordered our pizzas and one came apart in our oven as it was to heavily sauced and cheesed (buffalo chicken). I wasn't impressed with their dough but toppings were fine. read more

My husband and I ordered two of their toasted sandwiches and my other family members ordered a pizza and a salad. All of us really enjoyed all of our food. I liked the toasted pesto chicken sandwich that I got, but when I had a bite of my sister's pizza I was blown away and kinda wished that I had gotten a pizza. The crust was so unique and absolutely delicious. The next time I'm in town I would love to explore this place further. We sat in a separate seating area on the side of the restaurant since only outdoor seating was available. It was a cute little area with nice outdoor decor. It was quite charming and our food was delivered to us outside. The staff were friendly and helpful. I would definitely recommend this place. read more

Our food was delicious and the service was amazing. If you want pizza this is the place to go!

Best pizza in town in my opinion. Love their Hawaiian pizza and their chicken pesto sandwiches. Salads could be bigger. Staff can be a bit rude at times. read more

Worst pizza I've ever had. First time yelp has let me down. The crust for the pizza and cheese bread was store bought crust. The fried cheese curd tasted like something they made hours before. Greek salad was horrible. Not one thing we purchased was good or finished. read more

We had a WONDERFUL experience at Hometown Pizza. The staff was very friendly, and the pizza was one of the best we have ever had. We ate out on the patio which was an added bonus. I would definitely recommend eating here, and I know we will definitely come back to have their pizza again and again. read more

Great pizza and handled a crowd well. Plenty of seating and food came quickly GF pizza was a plus

Pizza is delicious! Lots of good options for pizza and salad too! Highly recommend and will come back here when we're in the area again

Pizza here is excellent and the owner was amazing. Great beer and wine prices, you won't be disappointed! We customized our own pizza by ordering the Louie and adding jalapeños and feta. The owner also brought out a slice of the baconator and the beach comber for us to try since our group was torn on so many different pizzas. All were excellent and she was such a good host to our group. Can't wait to come back and try more! read more

Good honest pizza at a fair price. The staff is friendly and the restaurant is clean. What more could you ask for from a pizzeria in a resort town? How about take out or dine in? Steve and Cindy (the owners) are almost always on hand making sure everything is as it should be. read more

Awesome pizza- had the 6 shooter and Hawaiian BBQ pizza. Both were incredible and very delicious. We will definitely come again when we come up this way read more

Hometown Pizza - The 6 shooter - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

This is one of the best pizza places and friendly service! They're lunch special is a great deal and they have really good create your own chopped salads! We try to go every time we're in McCall. read more

It was good pizza. Not amazing not terrible. Just Some good pizza, don't expect to be amazed. We ordered a 6 shooter, pepperoni, and cheese garlic bread. It was around $50 for everything. Be aware I'm a bit of a pizza snob ;) read more

My husband and I owned a pizza franchise in CA and we pretty much consider ourselves 'pizza snobs'. We live in CDA, ID now and haven't found many pizza places with pizza as good as ours. We were thrilled to have found Hometown Pizza because it was delicious! Plus we had an error (they had two customers with the same name....it happens.) and my husband had to go back but they handled it exactly as we would have. Great customer service and excellent food. You won't be disappointed! read more

On our recent excursion north we decided to try something local, that was off the strip and recommended by locals. Hometown pizza was the top choice. Nestled just off the main highway this little joint easy to find. Ample parking, but it wasn't busy at all. Hometown offers delivery, take-n-bake, and dine-in. We decided to dine in as it was pretty empty. The menu is decent and offers a good variety of specials. I got the bacon cheese burger pizza and split BBQ wings. The wings were by far the best I've had in awhile. The pizza is classic hand tossed pizza. Great fluffy crust and good flavor. I didn't care for my cheese burger pizza though as it tasted like too much sodium to me. Not the fault of the pizza joint, just my taste. The pizza did taste a little cold which was disappointing as it was very good otherwise. Would definitely recommend and visit again on another trip. read more

Hometown Pizza was pleasant surprise. It's a small friendly place to eat. The pizza was awesome and the staff was great. We will eat here again when we visit McCall. read more

Best pizza in McCall. The cheese bread is amazing. Order early and order ahead they get super busy in the summer season. Lots of drink choices. read more

When traveling with pick kids, you need to find good spots for the parents where kids can eat. I must say this place was great, our pizza was good. The only thing we were a bit disappointed was the salad, I believe we paid $12 for a salad which we thought it was a meal size and it was a soup bowl size. Other than that, everything was good, the service was friendly and they could accommodate us quickly. read more

This place is amazing. We had a pizza, the avocado sandwich and some cookies. We all agreed this was the best pizza, sandwich and cookies ever! We ate an hour ago and everyone is still talking about the food we ate. So 5 stars +, eat here! We will be back read more

Holy crap! Not sure what they're doing differently here but, I'm down with it. I had the Louie, they bake, take out, and it was one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The flavor was COMPLETELY over the top. My guess part of the magic is the way they cook it on a thin piece of paper with the cheese that made it slightly over the edges that wonderful crunchiness. Possibly a hot ceramic floor that cooks it from the bottom and top both? As such, pass on the take-and-bake option and let them bake it (sorry folks that work there. I'm sure you'd prefer the former). This is a business trip for me and I'll be looking for an excuse to make it back to McCall just to eat here again. read more

Hometown Pizza - Yeah I did that all by myself to a medium. It was that damn good! - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

We ran in here to grab a Take & Bake after grabbing groceries on our way in for the week. Had a beer while waiting for it to be made. They have a nice selection of bottle beer. You can also get wine by the glass. The pizza had plentiful toppings on it. Instructions were easy & it baked up exactly as per instructions...great pizza! We even served the leftovers as a snack the next day. Just reheated in the oven wrapped in foil. I wish I could speak on the atmosphere but we ran in during a huge thunderstorm & we're just grateful for a moment to dry off & gather our thoughts. We would absolutely go back!!! read more

The customer service was great bad had a very friendly front desk worker. The pizza was average but they had it prepared at the time we needed it to be. read more

What a disappointment, we waited over 30 minutes for a small pepperoni pizza and a salad. And the salad was the same bagged salad I buy from Costco...Ugh Never again!! read more

Just stopped in here on the way to McCall, "" Out standing Pizza"" and the service is very nice and friendly. . read more

I really great pizza. We had the garlic chicken supreme. We're also surprise to find New Zealand wine. we had a bottle of Oyster Bay at a very reasonable price. The proprietor and his wife who is also the chef we're very friendly and made our dining experience very pleasant. although we are from the Bay Area and don't find ourself in McCall very often I would be happy to return do this restaurant. read more

Great food!! Great people!! Very nice atmosphere!! We'll be back. This business and many like them are important to support. The employ good people and strive to be part of what's good in a community. This pizza shop is no exception. read more

Delicious pizza and super friendly staff :) we got the pepperoni pizza and a cheeseburger pizza. Delicious

Had a busy day and is close to our place and needed to relax with a nice glass of wine Ect. We had the mighty Cobb salad and some wings Great salad with full of everything plenty Enough to eat and we shared some wings . Food was great and the wine was at a super Price on the bottle great place will make it a regular spot. read more

Great pizza and great prices! Super cute place and they made us feel welcome! This was my second time coming here and I will be back!

Ehh nothing great to me. What was the kicker is we tried to order a small one topping pizza. The pizza was almost double the price, and we were confused. They explained they don't have a 1 topping price just a two topping price and charged us extra. Who wants to pay for something they didn't order or won't be getting? They also have a baking charge! Who goes to a pizza joint and gets charged extra for their pizza to be cooked? It's a sit down place- indoor and outdoor spaces to eat. So a charge to cook the food seems absolutely absurd. As for the taste wasn't the worst but wasn't the greatest. Just ok/ mediocre EXPENSIVE pizza. However, they do sell just slices and don't charge a baking fee for them. So that is an option when you are looking for something easy to satisfy your hunger. Just again seems ridiculous to charge to cook some food and not others. read more

So delicious, friendly staff, and reasonably priced! A must go to pizza spot in McCall, ID.

Very yummy place. Very small though, but super super super friendly people. The pizza is super yummy. Their breadsticks and dipping sauce is awesome too! This place gives you options, you can eat there, carry out already made or take and bake at home. Yummy stuff. read more

Really delicious pizza in he heart of McCall. I was highly impressed with the quality of the food and the fast and friendly service.

I was not impressed about the pizza. I am not sure what it was. I think the homemade crust was bland. The owner waited on us and she was as friendly and as sweet as could be. read more

Glad we tried this place. House salad was small pieces of romaine lettuce--well trimmed--only the yummy green leafy parts. The garlic cheese bread was delightful. The crust on the bread and pizza was on the thinner, crispier side (just the way I like it). Italian pizza was great. Very fresh toppings. We dined in. Service was very good. read more

Great pizza. We tried the one called something like the Idaho pizza. We loved the baked squeaky cheese. And their cheese bread was wonderful too. Great pizza place our our family to visit while playing in McCall, Idaho. read more

Delicious pizza & great hospitality! We ordered 2 pizzas today- one was a louies which was pepperoni sausage bacon and pineapple the other pizza we ordered was a bacon pepperoni black olives and pepperoncinis. read more

Hometown Pizza is a solid pizza joint which needs to update the technology that runs the place. I started this review when I visited a year ago and remembered to finish it today. We had a great experience when I ordered a year ago so planned a pizza night this trip. This restaurant has friendly staff, great salads and pizzas, and a nice atmosphere inside. I decided to plan another pizza night but made the mistake of calling at 5:30PM which is apparently after things get busy. I got the busy signal 36 times over 30 minutes - a little crazy but I wanted pizza. I finally tried at 7:30 PM to see if the phone system was broken - apparently not, just busy and I was told to try at 4PM today. We ordered early today and had a great meal - the gluten free crust was one of the best I've had. So 5 stars for food, 3 for infrastructure - telephony equipment, lack of online ordering, and one cash register without a POS. If this place gets into the digital age, they could crush it. I'll still come back but only at off hours. read more

Saw the sign and took a chance. What are the chances? An Italian finding Hometown Pizza. On my first bite,my taste buds recalled my Italian Grand Mother's homemade pizza. Bursting with flavor, I savored the double pepperoni , mushrooms, cheese and crust. Top it off with great service,it was great. Stop in , you won't be sorry. read more

Tasty pizza and very friendly staff. A must hut spot for some pizza. Easy to find and atmosphere is inviting.