Got right in despite being a busy evening with boaters. Had heard about their fish tacos and…read moreenjoyed them too!! Some of the best I've had. Look forward to going back.

Great staff - best Jalapeño margaritas in Idaho…read more Try it you will not be disappointed

Honestly, the only good things I can say are that the location is great (right in the heart of…read moretown, with water views if you get a window seat) and the reservation process was simple online. We made a reservation for 8pm on a Saturday, and honestly, they weren't packed (they still had plenty of tables open). When we arrived there was no one at the host stand, and when they came they didn't check us in right away. Once we confirmed the reservation it took about 10 minutes for us to be seated, and there was a couple that came after us that had a reservation at the same time and were seated before us (okay, no big deal). We did get a window seat, which was nice. But this is supposed to be an upper scale restaurant in the area, and the silverware we were given was dirty, so not a great start. The server came to take our order, we ordered mocktails and a huckleberry lemon drop as well as the bread basket and the cured meat and cheese plate- compared to the Cutwater, honestly, no comparison. The teens didn't even drink the mocktail (which the server did take off the bill, and that was nice) and the lemon drop was okay. The bread basket and meat plate were fine, but we wouldn't order them again. My son ordered the 12oz ribeye (which was nearly 60.00) and I would say at least 50% of it was fat, and his was overcooked. I ordered the flat iron, and mine was undercooked, so he ended up eating mine. The herb roasted potatoes needed seasoning and felt like something they simply tossed on the plate. My daughter's Caesar salad was as expected to a side salad. Our server never came to check on us after the food was brought out, and we waited for her to return after we were done with the food for nearly 20 minutes. Overall we were disappointed and not truly certain why this place is recommended above other similar places in town. Very expensive, seems like it is trying to be upscale or more "fine-dining" but it missed the mark for us.

We stayed in McCall for our 40th anniversary and had dinner here to celebrate. Absolutely charming…read moreinside and out. The staff is wonderful and the menu is not overwhelming and very unique. We had the Elk meatloaf on a recommendation and it did not disappoint. The layers of flavors are off the chart, from the richness of the Elk to the maple bacon gravy combined with the mash potatoes, which had a hint of cheese. The lounge is very warm and cozy as well. We will definitely be back and we give this a 5 must visit.

The service was fast and prompt but the bartender had the mouth of a sailor…read more The beer - the Overhung IPA was nothing special that made me think about having two. The pretzel was good, and the hot, spicy mustard was good. Good for a mid-day snack after skiing. The place was kind of broken/trashy. We were sitting at the bar and noticed that the brewing supplies were a little gross. I thought brewers were clean? The signs were not updated and had a make-shift feeling. Sad to see what was once a great brewery is now trying to pick up its pieces.

Brewery and tasting room with a full bar and five TVs. Plenty of tables and booths to sit at, plus…read morean outdoor rooftop patio. We opted to be inside since winter is still happening. All the wait staff were excellent. They came by several times to make sure everything was okay. The food came out quick, although the pub wasn't busy. Oh yes, to the food. The squeeze and I shared an order of finger steaks and fries. It is our norm to split an order for lunch. The meat tasted good, nice and tender. Spices in the coating decent. The fries were crispy on the outside and fluffy inside. The dip for the finger steaks had a good amount of horseradish in it, wasn't overpowering but put heat into the bite. They did bring an extra plate, which was nice, and not to be charged for it is even better. They may have added some extra fries and fingers, don't know, but we were more than satisfied with the quality and quantity. Hippy Hopped Pale Ale had a nice taste of hops, kind of like a session IPA. The Mackinaw Red brew was oh so malty! It was a little cool in there.

First time in McCall and I love this place!! Super kind staff, clean dive bar feel, everything I…read morewant in a bar while traveling. I will DEFINITELY be coming back every time I'm here

I think there are a lot in f haters out there. This place is across from lake payette rustic…read moremountain restaurant. Super cool inside, hosts 6 taps from local breweries. It's worth being a place to have a drink plus bar is open later than most in McCall. Haven't eaten here but cool, full bar and prioritized local beer. I am looking forward to trying the food

the service was great and the food was outstanding. I got the crispy chicken sandwich and the…read morefries and have nothing but good things to say. Overall the restaurant wasn't too busy either. The outside seating was very cool and we got a nice spot in the shade.

Awesome! I had the Thai beef bowl, so fresh, healthy & satisfying. Paired it with a blonde beer…read more My husband had the Cod fish & chips which he enjoyed greatly. Our friend said the elk burger with gorgonzola was "Great", she liked the sweet potato criss cut fries too! We came on a recommendation & it did not disappoint! Cute interior & fabulous friendly service!

Such a gem! The whole restaurant experience was incredible and the food was exceptional! The view…read morewas wonderful and it was so clean and neat. It was not expecting the surprise chocolates at the end of the meal. The service and staff were attentive- it reminded me of an El Guacho experience

Truly an amazing experience, they have a couple of restaurants here where the food is very good,…read morethe service from all the staff was the best, The ambience is very picturesque as this is one of the coolest lodges I've ever stayed at. Definitely one of the most relaxing environments to take a vacation in.

Our usual Mexican food, always includes chili rellenos and something. Excellent, service and this…read moreis a place we want to come to dine in come day. Very pleasant decor. You might allow time to be seated on busy evenings.

Great food at reasonable prices. Enchiladas en Mole was very tasty. Restaurant and restroom were…read morevery clean. Noticed that a waitress was cleaning each page of menus. That is exceptional. Will return!

Delicious! Ordered a burger with pastrami and a cheeseburger. The woman that took our order was…read morefun, and made my experience a blast! Food was served in 8-10 minutes in a busy Saturday, it was yummy. What a great lunch spot!

Fun lil burger spot. With good burgers…read more Price was a little high for a burger and fry but it's a touristy lil town so about what's expected. Fun patio area, nice staff, and decent place.

Experience was just that. A great one. Busy enough for a Tuesday night. Steak was prepared and was…read morecooked at just the right temperature. Service was awesome. Always checking up on me. Old fashioned was great tasting. Really nostalgic and beautiful building.

If there was a lower mark I'd give it ! Zen the waiter had no clue , literally had to go find bread…read moreplates at a station for our bread , then had to ask for butter. Watched a woman at another table get additional silverware sets for her guest at her table. Ordered a side salad that he said would be $5.00 , (that we never received) , but showed on the bill for $13.! Bake potato was cold I. Asked him to take off salad 2x's but remained on the bill ! And the prime rib was marginal. Had ate there last year and prime rib was bigger and better. Trust me "Don't " waste your time too many other good place in McCall to dine. Huge , huge disappointment on so many levels. I had brought my sweet girl there , hoping for a nice dining experience. Who needs a waiter arguing with you that he deducted a salad he never served, and you have to take out your calculator and do the math to prove it !!!! I would put on a tattered dirty ski jacket and get in a McCall Soup kitchen line before I went back. It gets the distinguished honor of one of the worst restaurants I've been to. Also no adult leadership or management there. The Mill = " No Bueno"!!!!

We are visiting McCall and looking for a pizza option... there are a few to choose from. I am happy…read morewe picked Hometown Pizza. I've read posts about other items on the menu, this rating is just based on what we ordered - pizza! Pros - great pizza! We order a large cheese and pineapple pizza for 3 kids. A medium 1/2 garden & 1/2 combo for two adults. The garden was delicious (great flavor, fresh, good veggies/ crust proportions of ingredients) -- and no complaints and full bellies for everyone else. - super quick, ordered and it was ready for pick up in under 30. - very reasonably priced $50 for two pizza that fed us and left a few slices for lunch tomorrow. Cons - the website for ordering online was a little clunky, but worked... (not bad enough to knock off a star). - while everyone else liked the crust one kid did not, it was thinner and had a different texture (less "bready") than other pizza places, e.g. Papa John's. (IMO it was good!) The place was packed at 5pm on a Wednesday so that might mean something!

Gluten free pepperoni pizza was delicious! I didn't see gluten free on their menu, but it is an…read moreoption!