Bottom Line: THE Best Place to Eat in McCall!!! Went there on Father's Day without a reservation and ended up getting take out. We had our retriever with us and it 80 degrees so we couldn't wait for a patio table. All that said, especially if you have kids or a dog this is the best place to eat in Mccall. The Food: we got the spaghetti and meatballs $18.99 and a small Caesar salad with grilled chicken $14.75 and they were both good. 4.5/5 The value was reasonable for McCall which can be pricey being a ski town and inflation. The Venue: this is nicest venue in McCall which is kid and dog friendly. Large lawn area with corn hole games and lawn chairs. Nice dog friendly patio with table umbrellas. Large parking lot. 5/5 The Service: it was Fathers Day and it was really crazy. They were doing the best they could. They are very young adults so be nice and patient, it's probably their first job. 4/5 read more

Toll Station Pizza - Spaghetti with meatballs $18.99 - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

We were looking for a casual and delicious pizza place, and we were so happy with toll station. We came on a rainy Saturday afternoon in June, and we were seated right away. The service was fantastic and our server made great recommendations. The cheese curds are a MUST! Hands down the best we've ever had. They do 1/2 and 1/2 pizzas, which was amazing- so we tried 3 of their most popular and a regular pepperoni. We got the chicken popper (our favorite hands down and a must try) the Mac and cheese (2nd favorite- I would add bacon next time to elevate it even more), the BBQ chicken (our least favorite, but still good) and the pepperoni- classic, and can't go wrong. The location is great, the restaurant is nice and the service was wonderful. A must try if you're in the area. read more

See all

Pizza was not great, expensive drinks and our server that has worked there for many years (their words) was cranky and unfriendly.

Food was delicious, service was fast and friendly and the ambience was pleasant and peaceful. read more

Toll Station Pizza - Artichoke dip was very yummy! - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

No kids menu (not the biggest deal to us but having kid portions would have been ideal. Ultimately the low review comes down to the rude staff. We were seated at 6:30pm and at 7:00pm we noticed a server had not come around to offer us water- so we notified staff that we would like to order. No big deal to us, as we understand how tables can get forgotten. They were busy but we know they were not at full capacity since outside seating was closed. We finally ordered and received our food after 7:30pm, by which time we had seen two other parties arrive at the door, wait for their tables, be seated, ordered, ate and had their food in boxes before our food even arrived. I never usually complain but I decided to let the hostess know about our situation. She responded by saying "Well you ordered your food and your food arrived right? So it's not my problem." I have never been met with such rude service in my life and will never return here. My husband was able to speak to a different staff member and they apologised and compensated our meal. The only redeeming part of our experience. Perhaps our experience would have been better under different circumstances but unfortunately we will not return. read more

We went on the earlier side and waited hardly at all for our food. The service was friendly as well and kept checking on us. My mom got the full serving of the chopped salad and it was massive. We split the spinach artichoke dip and also had leftovers. I got the fettuccine Alfredo and it was delicious. It's definitely good food for the price in my opinion. The space itself is spacious and comfy, with outdoor seating for warmer days. A nice location for if you're staying anywhere downtown. Highly recommend since it has different types of food! read more

Wow! Why the 3 stars??? Great customer service, food and ambience! I had the oriental chop salad with crispy chicken(half order) hubby had 1/2 order lasagna. Plus a buy one get one free Cutwater! Luv it !!! read more

We ate here our first night in McCall. On a Friday night around 8:00. The wait was too long across the street so we walked over to this place. The food was decent and the service was ok. About what we expected. We didn't get pizza but others around us did and it looked really good. A nice place for pizza or a sandwich. read more

We had the "The Hiker" and it was amazing! The waitstaff were very friendly and professional. Can't wait to try other varieties of pizza on our next trip through McCall. read more

Pizza and crust and toppings delish!! Service was nice. Place was clean bathrooms spotless - but.... The tables need a Brillo scrub. Other than that, the pizza was perfect! read more

Every time I eat their chicken parmesan sub I will leave a review and every time I eat it it has always been fantastic but when the day comes and it's not good I will leave that review read more

We'll be back! The Hiker, Mac n Cheese, & Chicken Alfredo pizza were delicious. The prime rib sandwich was just OK. There is corn hole outside and it's spacious inside. Quick and attentive service, even on a holiday weekend! There is a 3% credit card charge. read more

Such a great evening on the patio! Delicious food. Speedy service and great atmosphere! read more

Toll Station Pizza - 1/2 Margarita 1/2 Pantheon with balsamic glaze - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Always great!! I haven't had anything bad here and always order something different! Great little spot!

I called to place a takeout order. I was told the price was over $35 for a large two topping pizza and it included a mandatory 15% takeout gratuity. I was asked if this was OK? My response, "No it's not ok, cancel my order." A gratuity is supposed to be for a service provided. By Toll Station logic, I should be tipping 15% for grocery store purchases. UGH - Tipping has gotten way out of hand. :( read more

Let me just start by saying that we have been patrons for many years. The wait staff did ok I guess. Not really paying attention to details....like giving one water with a straw and another w/o. We ordered pizza and it came to us w/o a spatula. We had to ask for plates. We sat down in the bar area and the bench was horrible....cushion was so broken down you could feel the springs and it was like you were sitting in a hole. On to the food, the bagged salad was good but we sure miss the salad bar. The pizza (which is what we have always eaten here), was gross. The crust was soggy. The sauce was yuck. And then we got our ticket. I had forgotten the name of the pizza that we have always ordered (the Mountaineer) and I neglected to look at the menu. We paid almost 25$ for a cheese pizza and then at least 10$ for the toppings that we wanted.....which was sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms and breakfast bacon. The pizza literally tasted like a frozen that they tried to improve. We won't ever waste our money to eat here again. (If you scroll through other reviews to see pizza pictures, it looks nothing like those pictures any more. It used to but not anymore.). read more

Great food and great service! The artichoke dip is the best. Pizza is great. The sandwiches are off the hook too! read more

Drove up to get out of Boise for a couple days. This was our first stop. From the reviews I was not expecting a lot but I was pleasantly surprised. The Mountaineer. Their all meat pizza. It was good. The crust is more thin and had a nice crispness to it. Sauce is flavorful. Toppings were just right. The service did not take too long. This wasn't the best pizza I've ever had but I wasn't disappointed at all. Most important I would return again if I had a pizza craving. read more

Toll Station Pizza - The Mountaineer. - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Service was amazing. We had at least 15 people at our table. We ordered 4 different pizzas. I tried them all. Pizza was outstanding . If I lived there I would go here a lot. Again the service was the best. read more

It's decent pizza. It fits the craving and they have some very creative pizza varieties.. I think maybe I just got the wrong kind. Wasn't a fan of the Caesar salad dressing as the sauce on my pizza. The service was lack luster. I could tell our server did not want to be there at all and we felt like a burden, but hey, we got our pizza. read more

Toll station pizza is conveniently located in downtown McCall. Fun wooden chairs and interesting atmosphere- feels like it's been there forever. Our group sat down for dinner around 5:45 PM on a Thursday night and we were given menus and put in drink orders. Salads came fairly quickly but the rest of the food seemed to take a while- long enough to finish a salad and wonder where the rest of the food was. Ordered at my table was a French dip sandwich, several custom pizzas, Fettuccine Alfredo , and spinach artichoke dip. One pizza was made incorrectly and took about 10 minutes to make a new one. Overall the service was good but the food was just okay for the high prices. I'm not sure there are many options in this mountain town but I was not blown away by the flavor or quality of anything I tried. read more

See all

We were on vacation and my mom got sick so I called to ask what the soup of the day was. I was told one thing so we ordered it for a take out order. When we arrived they told me it was something different, then someone came out from the kitchen and told us it was a third different soup. They had already charged me for it before I arrived and wouldn't take the 2 soups back so we ended up paying for 2 soups we didn't want and didn't eat. Food was otherwise mediocre. We ordered pizzas and salads- one salad was a raspberry spinach salad and the raspberries were like bagged frozen berries. read more

Ordered a $26 pizza and got nine pieces of pepperoni on it. Seems like a lot to charge to then be stingy on pepperoni. There were two pieces that had zero pepperoni on them. read more

Food isn't amazing. Pizza is quite soggy. Employees are friendly. Service is okay. Prices are pretty high. There are better choices in this tourist town. I definitely won't be going back. read more

We were in search of a sit down Saturday lunch and, after a few failed attempts due to hours/takeout-only scenarios, stumbled upon Toll Station. For starters, COVID precautions are taken seriously here if that concerns you. The tables are physically distanced and there is plenty of space inside the restaurant. Staff is wearing masks and signs everywhere remind patrons to wear masks when not eating/at their tables. We ordered the Idaho Poppers for an appetizer. Think of tater tots with jalapeños and cream cheese inside. My mom and I split a small Chicken Popper Pizza. It was delicious! Nice mixture of sweet and spicy with the jalapeños and hot honey drizzle. Our friend ordered the French Dip and the prime rib was slightly fatty. We decided it was her fault for ordering a French Dip at a pizza/pasta place. Our waitress, Diane, was hospitable, friendly as ever, and prompt. Would definitely come here again and recommend for anyone looking for a nice, hot pizza! read more

Toll Station Pizza - Forgot to take a picture before we started eating. Delicious chicken popper pizza and Idaho poppers! - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Came in over the weekend to get some pizza. The blonde hostess at the front desk was so rude I was stunned. She should not be working with customers. Dishes maybe? Maybe even food prep?? But holy smokes get that girl away from the people who PAY TO BE THERE! The food was excellent but I am hopeful that a one star rating will awaken the manager and get this girl reassigned. read more

Great service, very friendly, and wings and pizza were great. Nice crispy crust, and fresh toppings With a generous amount of cheese!!

Three years ago I couldn't have said anything good about this restaurant. It was bad everything. Fast forward to 4th of July weekend 2022 and we've got a winner. New ownership or management for sure. Bathrooms used to be filthy now they are super clean. Our waitress was fast and friendly and served well. We went two days in a row because there were long waits in other restaurants and it was walk right in and eat delicious hot pizza. read more

Toll Station Pizza - Great food and clean at the right price. - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

I debated between between 1 star or 2. Food was decent with fairly quick service. I ordered take out to take back to our camp site and after a long day outdoors, we were starving! We ordered the McCall and margarita pizza's as well as two kids meals- pepperoni pizza with side salad and Alfredo with the chicken noodle soup. Also an order of their mild wings. I also asked if they could include the silverware for the pasta and napkins just in case it wasn't a given. HORRIBLE SERVICE. I were greeted with a quick "Hey. Just one?" After ordering with the host, and him forgetting to split the order twice, they forgot all dressings and dipping sauces, silverware and napkins. When I returned to get these things, I was sent off with an eye roll and silence. After spending $80+ and finding out after the fact gratuity was included on top of the tip I left, we won't be returning. read more

This is one of our favorite spots. We've tried almost everything on the menu and we've never had a bad plate. The service is excellent and the prices are fair with good portions! It has a great patio, and outdoor games in the grass, great for kids. read more

Just paid $35 for a pepperoni and onion pizza large size Biggest rip off in Mc Call Do yourself a favor and go to Crustie's Better value, better quality knowing the pizza dough costs you $1.49 at Trader Joe's Still speechless read more

1st time in area. Just down from hotel. Excellent thin crust pizza and draft brew. We split the small sesame chicken salad and had the 1/2 vegetarian and meatlover, small pizza. Perfect amount! read more

Toll Station Pizza - Good thin crust pie - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

This place has went downhill. I just got charged $70 for 2 pizzas. I understand prices change, but I was forcefully charged a "carry out service fee" of 10 dollars for getting carry out. They also have restructured their menu to make ordinary pizzas cost more. It's really wrong to require a "service charge" of 15% which I was told from the front desk is a tip for the staff. If I am ordering carry out I am not being serviced by anyone. I am simply purchasing something. Tipping should be up to the costumer. read more

My husband and I just went here for an early dinner. We both had side salads. He was happy to be able to have thousand island dressing which isn't always available in restaurant. I had blue cheese drsg which was so good. We ordered pizza. He had the McCall special which was def loaded with meat. He loved it. I ordered the cauliflower crust pizza since I need gf. I had the chicken Caesar pizza and added jalapeños. It's was so delicious. The crust was nice and crispy. GF pizza can be tricky at times but this was excellent. We will def be back! We are fans! read more

Toll Station Pizza - Chicken Caesar pizza with jalapeños added - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Decent pizza. Odd that they closed at 9. Tons of people in town boating and hungry. Why close so early ? Staff seemed indifferent about being friendly. They were just standing around. When I called to order the girl answered with "hello" and was giggling. Super unprofessional. Didn't even acknowledge that it was the pizza place. Odd experience. Maybe people in McCall don't like out of towners spending money in their town. Not the friendliest bunch. Pizza wasn't thin crust or crusty and was actually cold. Money better spent elsewhere I'm sure. Won't be Beck. Seems to be a theme in this town of indifference. read more

Fantastic family dinner spot. Great customer service and our food was great. We came in April and there was no wait at 6pm. read more

Toll Station Pizza - Chicken bacon Alfredo pizza - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Don't get why the negative reviews. Three of us ordered pizza and all of us loved it! If you are a meat lover then you can't go wrong with the McCall special. My daughter loved hers with gluten-free crust! Lots of seating with very little waiting to be seated read more

Toll Station Pizza - McCall special pizza - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

This is our McCall STAPLE. This is actually the only restaurant in McCall I've eaten at outside of Shore Lodge. Sit outside. The waitresses have always been super nice and accommodating for our groups. We love watching the traffic and boats go by. All I have ever ordered here is the pizza, so I'm gonna suggest you roll with that. The pepperoni & olive has been my favorite. Def. try it out, then swing next door for Ice Cream when you are done! Enjoy! read more

We eat here every time we visit mccall. It's a family tradition. Love the food and the staff are friendly. Our last visit we had a very young server who went above and beyond. We were so impressed. read more

This is a great place to eat in McCall but there's usually a long wait. They have a good salad bar, pasta and pizza. They were able to accommodate our large group. read more