My husband loves all pie but especially banana cream so I ordered one here for Father's Day. We are new to the neighborhood and this was our first time trying I Love Pies. We will definitely be back! I am not a fan of sickeningly sweet desserts and was prepared to not like it, but it was very well balanced. The crust was just perfect. The pie connoisseur himself also gave two thumbs up. It was a very cute touch that they were giving out extra single "dad tax" slices for Father's Day. My husband also loved the berry pie that he tried. The ordering process was easy, I got a notification as promised when it was ready for pickup and the pie was packaged with care. read more

I ordered a apple pie and it was not so great crust and filling, the apples were mush and poor flavor and not much there. Filling jelly was lacking apple pie flavor and not much there. Crust was over cooked, not over brown but super dry, lots of it though. Lacking flavor. Strange it came off kitchen cart and not a display case item. I had item before and had same thoughts. They should learn from Apple Hill. Big difference! read more

I'm really into banana cream pie and found this place through Yelp. It was a little distance from where I was but made the trek there. It is located inside a place where there were some other food options, sort of like a food court but higher end. Maybe because it was the end of the day they did not have slices of banana cream but did have a mini version that could be for 1 or 2 people so I went with it. Took it back to the hotel and started eating it. I liked that the whip cream on top was not too sweet. The pie was very tasty but was a little pricey. read more

We walked in and the smell of fresh pies was addicting! Those who are strong willed could walk by and not buy one. I am not, so I could not leave without getting a pie. The pie shop is bright and adorably decorated with fun wall art and cute merchandise. The pies are displayed and look picture perfect. Our kids instantly wanted the sprinkle celebration pie. So we got that and the key lime pie. The pies tasted like heaven. The key lime had just enough tartness. The celebration filling was creamy and not overly sweet. What made us fall in love was the crust. It was flakey, buttery, and just perfection. Some of the best pies we've had and we will be back to try the rest of them. read more

See all

There's no where else for pie I would go - I really love I love pie bake shop! Pies are delicious and there are many flavors to choose from. I tried the banana cream pie and the blueberry. Both were delicious. I love that the banana cream wasn't too sweet. Both pies were fresh. These are cravable and will be going here as long as they are open. read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - 6" Banana Cream Pie & Blueberry Pie - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

This review is long overdue! We first tried I Love Pie Bakeshop on New Year's Eve 2024 when we were frantically looking for a last-minute dessert to ring in the new year. We happened to see this place pop up in our search results and were relieved they were open. My partner picked up a pecan pie and a celebration pie -- both were absolutely delicious! Since then, we've been coming back for dessert cravings and special occasions. One thing I love is that they offer both small and large sizes, perfect whether you're just craving a slice or celebrating something bigger. We've tried several flavors -- the highly rated banana cream pie is our favorite! It's not overly sweet, the bananas taste fresh, and the crust is perfection. We've also enjoyed their horchata, corn, and celebration pies -- each one has its own unique charm. Just a tip: if you have your eye on a specific flavor, order online a couple of days ahead since the popular ones sell out fast, especially around holidays. Service is always a 10/10. Everyone is friendly, patient, and happy to help you decide what to try. Sometimes they even offer samples of the pies they have that day. I Love Pie Bakeshop is located inside the Milagro Centre on Fair Oaks, and their shop has such a cozy and welcoming vibe. Definitely one of our favorite local dessert spots! read more

See all

Walking by after having dinner I couldn't not get something for later but decided on a smaller size of their pies. Due to it being later in the day there was less selection. We decided on the Key Lime Pie. read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - 6" Key Lime Pie - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

Have to drop a review. I grabbed one of these frozen pies from the UC Davis cafeteria and omg I'm so glad I did. As a tired resident, I didn't have time to make anything for thanksgiving but this pie was perfect after just taking it out of the package and putting it in the oven! Got me huge brownie points. I had two options: mixed berry or apple pie. I went for the berry. The filling wasn't too sweet and the crust was flaky and delicious. Tastes homemade! Thank you for partnering with our hospital! I'll have to stop by and check out the shop in the future. I see a couple of flavors I would love to try read more

Best key lime pie I have ever had! And the wonderful smell in their shop made me want to move in. Yummy!

Found this pie shop via Yelp, located inside the Milagro Centre on Fair Oaks in Carmichael. It's located past the gelato stand. Did not order ahead, and took a chance walking in a few days after the Thanksgiving holiday to pick up a pie or two for Friendsgiving dinner. Seems like a one-woman run business, and for a Saturday afternoon there were still some good selections in the display case available for purchase and not already spoken for (smaller 6-inch and larger 8-inch pies), including apple (I forget if it was classic or salted caramel dutch), bourbon pecan, chocolate cream, and banana cream. Other seasonal flavors are pumpkin, sweet potato, eggnog custard, and red velvet chess. I got one 8-inch banana cream and one 8-inch chocolate cream ($28 each). The crust is all-butter, and the heart-shaped decorations on each pie are cute and very fitting of the bakeshop's name. Between the two, the banana cream pie was by far the favorite. The chocolate cream was also very good. I'm curious to try their fruit pies and other offerings (chicken pot pie, hand pies, pie pops) in the future! read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - Banana cream pie - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

Yummy! Thick, buttery crusts, the perfect mint of sweetness, and fresh ingredients make this bakeshop so fantastic. We tried pumpkin, apple, pecan, and custard and everyone loved the apple most! It's different from the usual, with syrupy sweet apple filling. I second another persons review that the crust could be baked just a few minutes less, so it has a softer, pure butter flavor rather than a hint of burn to it. But the texture is perfect as is. I'd definitely return and try all their other flavors. read more

See all

Great pie. Had the chocolate and the mixed berry. Has an awesome flakey crust and very good fillings that change seasonally. They have mini pies and full size pies. We got the full size and you should know that even the full ones are smaller than the average pie at only 8 inches. It's probably the best pie in the area but for $32 each you have to really want pie. The store is in a good court kind of place, which could make it hard to find if you were not aware. The shop is cute but i was just there for pie. read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - Chocolate cream pie. - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

The pie shop was very delicious, the company was wonderful. The area was clean.The staff was delightful and very generous with the pie and scoop of ice cream. I definitely recommend this place. read more

Got a key lime pie from here and it was delicious! The flavor was perfect and it had the right amount of lime flavor. Definitely recommend this place for pies! read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - Key lime pie - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

omg love their chocolate chip cookies!! light but thick and dense my new go-to after work

I ordered A blueberry pie, and was not disappointed. When I picked it up it was still warm and smelt incredible - it tasted even better. I'll definitely be back! read more

I wouldn't dare go anywhere else! 1. Support a local, woman owned business. 2. See number one! 3. Best pies around. 4. Sweetest owner ever! 5. Cutest decor ever. Little Paris! I stopped by to buy some mini pies for a girl's brunch. They were closed but I got to chat with the owner. She gave me some pie pops to share with my friend. Next time I'll plan better, but it was a wonderful gift being able to chat about my love affair with her shop and her great events (hello, wine and pie pairing!). read more

Today I attended a pie making class with three other people. Loved that it was a small group because the owner, who ran the class, was able to pay attention to whether we were making the dough, etc correctly. While it cooked we enjoyed a slice of amazing banana cream pie. The owner is delightful. Provided very thorough instruction and guidance. I look forward to taking more classes! Unfortunately the class was on a Sunday and the bakery isn't open. So I look forward to returning to buy a pie and other merch she sells. read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - honey-glazed mascarpone peach crostada - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

I really hate to say this, but their pies were not very good a wayyyy overpriced. I honestly feel like I could have gotten a better and bigger pie at a grocery store bakery. And we tried more than one flavor. We had the banana, key lime, chocolate and raspberry lemon meringue. Very disappointed. read more

We stopped by and decided to try their pies, including the key lime pie. First off, the pies are absolutely adorable--they're almost too cute to eat! The key lime pie was delicious and had that tangy citrus flavor you'd expect, but we did find it to be on the sweeter side, which might not be for everyone. If you love desserts that lean toward extra sweet, this will probably hit the spot perfectly. Overall, it's a charming little spot with tasty treats. While we wish the sweetness was a bit more balanced, it's still worth a visit for the presentation and flavors. Would love to come back and try other options next time! read more

Salted Caramel Cappuccino Cheesecake class was amazing! Fun, informative, easy to follow with a yummy dessert to take home! Can't wait for the next one! Such an adorable shop with creative and delicious pies! read more

See all

Got my husband a pecan pie for his birthday and a banana cream pie for myself. And let me tell you, these were the best pies we've ever had! The staff was kind and had my order ready as I planned for pick up. Highly recommend this place and will most definitely be ordering pies again! Thank you!! read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - Pecan pie - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

Really good pies! We got the apple and banana cream a little while back for a party and they were a hit, both really delicious. I went today and got the blueberry sour cream as a little surprise for my wife's bday. That one was decent, not quite as good as the previous two, but maybe part my own fault because I was expecting a sour cream pie more like how Heidi's Pies make them which is more like layers of blueberry and cream. This one is mixed together, idk, decent but no wow, wouldn't get it again compared to their other flavors. read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - Blueberry sour cream pie - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

My wife was hankering for sweets. He had these guys before but at the old location. The new location is the easiest to find but it's tucked inside next to the ice cream place. But that whole complex is an awesome video. Restaurants and dessert/coffee options. I got there pretty late so there wasn't a huge selection, but that's on me. They had multiple types of apple pie - Dutch, Carmel, crumble. We went with banana cream. It was exactly what we needed. Perfect creamy but not overly sweet. Plus a super flakey crust. We will be back! read more

See all

I love the banana cream pie here but the last few times we got it either the crust was burnt so it gave a slightly bitter taste or there was more whip cream than filling. Unfortunately this week we got the combo of both burnt crust and barely there banana cream. If I'm going to pay almost $30 for a pie, I don't want a burnt crust and barely there banana cream filling. Hopefully they'll do better quality control checks on these pies. I hate that I still love them though! read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - Banana cream pie - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

Stop by!! This is Pie shop is absolutely adorable! It's in the Milagro shopping center off Fair Oaks Blvd. they offer mini pies ($14) and regular sized pies ($25-$30). The pie pops were only $3 a piece! Everything was absolutely delicious and the workers were baking right in front of us. You could tell effort and love went into those pies! read more

See all

Picked up an amazing cherry lattice pie today and a chocolate cream pie. The cherry lattice pie is one of the best pies they make here. Buttery, flaky crust with sugar crystals baked in and super sweet cherries - so good. The chocolate cream is a classic and is always fantastic. Check this place out. Sorry, I cut into the chocolate cream before I took the photo. read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - Cherry lattice pie - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

Looking for a small pie shop, this could be the place for you. Walking around the milagro center and you will stumble upon their shop space. Decorated with cheer for the holiday season and a lit up bakery case. They employees are working hard behind the case while they wait to take your order. I purchased the caramel apple pie. The crust was flaky and the apples tart. I do wish the caramel was a tad more potent but still tasty. Stop on by and support local. read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

Oh my goodness! I tried the Mexican hot chocolate mini pie and it was the best pie I have ever tasted! The filling was light, like a mousse, with a hint of cinnamon. The crust was perfectly flaky. Just a delicious little pie. I can't wait to try the other ones. I'm giving my mom the apple pie for Mother's Day . I'll definitely go back! read more

Great location and the pink pony pie looked awesome, but my family was very underwhelmed with the taste. We were expecting more flavor in a strawberry cream pie filling and it just tasted like whip cream. I'm sure a lot of work to assemble, but with that, the smaller size and for $32, I can't do that again! read more

The banana cream pie is the best pie Ive ever had! The crust is so buttery and crisp, it doesn't get soggy like most pie and the filling & whipped cream is delicious and not too sweet. Can't recommend this place enough, and definitely am going to try more pies! read more

4.5 I like using less sugar, but the lemon pie could use just a little more. very good crust. chicken pie tasty, but maybe a little more sauce. read more

Saturday, 7/06/2024 - We went to the Milagros shopping Plaza. I happened to walk towards the back and saw this cute little pie shop area. It's so cute. If you're in this area, stop by there and try their pies out. Address is 6241 Fair Oaks Blvd, Ste L, Carmichael, CA 95608. read more

'Eh' ... I've had this bakery on my list of places to try for awhile. . . I don't know. When we went, there weren't a ton of options, and it was still early in the day. Prices seemed a bit steep, as well. Just because you add artisanal to your business name. I found their selection AND flavors to be lackluster. The business website looks more appealing than the in-person options that were available. I only give 5 stars because there wasn't anything inherently incorrect during this visit. read more

If you've been considering signing up for one of the classes offered here, do it! Diana was very friendly and knowledgeable. With such a small group (4) the environment was very welcoming. She did a great job describing what to look for and what to make sure and avoid in our at home pie making adventures. read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - Bloomberry Pie - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

Did I walk in expecting to buy one slice and then instead bought two? Yes. Was it worth it? Yes. No one else was there, they have social distancing protocols. You do need to touch to sign a screen to sign your credit card statement, but they have hands sanitizer on the counter for you. I came here once before covid and while v empty inside, it is v cute and I would love to dine in on those cute chairs again sometime. Banana cream pie: I love real bananas and I love that synthetic banana flavor (RIP original bananas - you can Google that), so this was a hit with me. Of course, the supreme banana pie is still the one from frank fats, but $2 less for a slice this is an excellent pie. The crust on this was dense yet somehow light and buttery. It tastes like banana cream pudding with slices of slightly underripe banana, which I think pairs nicely for the overt sweetness of the pudding. I would, however, be interested in knowing if it tasted better with caramelized banana slices (like homemade dehydrated ones). Also, and this is really more so I personally remember what to expect next time I order this: I tend to get this burning sensation when I eat refined sugars (it's almost like a ginger or whiskey burn lol), and I got that with this pie at the end. Honey walnut pie: This is like a pecan pie, but with the more savory flavor with slight bitterness of walnut. I guess you could describe it as more "mature"... I still prefer it with pecans, but it was very good. The crust was like a buttery, light, crumbly shortbread tea dessert for your pie dessert, fabulous. It seems like the walnuts are roasted for a deeper, smokier kind of woody flavor, but not sure if they are soaked in salt water before roasting to further reduce their bitterness. If that's not already done, may be worth trying! (I didn't get the burning with this slice as I did with the banana. ‍) The memory of today: I ate both slices at the del paso regional park. Parked in front of the 3 hour parking sign, I could see lots of flittering blue birds, a ground squirrel, and a larger black, white, and blue streaked bird that I'm not familiar with. read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - Honey walnut pie - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

See all

The crust one theses pies are perfect! I hate when pie crust gets soggy and these don't get old and gross even after they are cut.

I had this bakery bookmarked for a while in search of the best apple pie around and was grateful for the opportunity to come in this weekend for a friendly customer appreciation day with pie slice giveaways! The salted caramel apple pie is amazing!!! A comfortable crumble with just the right texture and crunch. I was a bit more unfamiliar with a salted caramel flavor tbh, but it was delicious and balanced excellently with the sweetness. Sweet but not too sweet and quite natural with the saltiness. The crust and crumble is the right amount of buttery too, not too much. The apple tastes fresh and cooked at the right tenderness. This would be great with coffee (I mean maybe I'll have some for breakfast hehe). So fresh and delightful! I also bought a slice of the chocolate cream pie, which is chilled. The texture is quite smooth and thicker than I expected. I prefer a lighter whipped type of chocolate cream pie. While this was good in its own way, I was rather disappointed that more cream was present than chocolate. Staff are friendly, and COVID-19 precautions are in place with only 2 customers allowed inside at a time. The shop is so cute and lovely! I'm so glad to have discovered and finally tried this pie shop close to where I live! I'll be back for an apple pie for the next holiday I celebrate and maybe try a slice of another fruit pie! read more

See all

Little boutique pie shop in the Sac area. I wanted to try the OG banana cream pie but it wasn't available on the day that I visited (make sure you call ahead to know which pie varieties are available at the time). I grabbed a black-bottom banana cream pie instead; along with the banana cream there's a layer of chocolate ganache. The pie was decent. The ganache overpowers the light banana cream. Also, the crust is a bit on the bland side. On the plus side, the banana cream was delightful and complemented well with the whipped topping. It's a pretty pie but overall I wish it tasted as fantastic as it looks. read more

I Love Pie Bakeshop - Black-bottom banana cream pie (banana + ganache layer) - Desserts Near Me - Carmichael, California

Absolutely love this place! If you're looking for a pie shop with delicious pies and a huge variety to choose from, this is the place! I drive all the way from Elk Grove to get my hands on these pies. Banana Cream, Chocolate Cream, and Salted Caramel Dutch Apple are a few of our favorites. read more