If looking for a sweet treat in Breck, go get the best! I Scream was outstanding with a big selection of different and unique flavors. The staff was super helpful and picking the best one and of course the ice cream was exceptional! The little waffle on top was a nice addition and added to the overall presentation. Fun little shop that you should absolutely visit. read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

Great vegan options, fast line and it was a great summer treat for us! Love the extra little waffle that has their logo on it :) read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

I got the white chocolate hot chocolate. I've never had that before but I will again. It was very smooth and sweet but not too sweet. My girls got gelatos and a sorbet and they were all tasty. Also, there's comfortable seating in the window bench. read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - So festive! - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

Quick service right in the heart of Breckenridge. They have an arcade for kids in the back. The perfect place for a sweet treat! I got the Oreo gelato. It was fantastic and big servings! read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Oreo Gelato - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

Delicious gelato with plenty of flavors. You can taste test 2 flavors. You can also order 2 flavors in one cup. The girl that served us was sweet and friendly. Fun little shop! read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

Quick order and experience and great service. Got a crêpe with gelato and it was excellent..

Yum!!! They let you sample any flavor you wanted if you weren't sure which one you wanted which was good. I knew I wanted the pistachio gelato though, and it was great, super creamy and smooth, and had like a real pistachio flavor, not artificial flavor. The two people that served us were really kind and made the experience even more joyful! read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Welcome sign - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

A solid gelato spot in Breckenridge! My family stopped into I Scream Gelato after seeing some great reviews on Yelp. Customers are able to sample the gelato before deciding on a flavor but it is limited to two per person (understandable because I'm sure people can get carried away with all the deliciousness!) I tried the mint which was great but went with a small peanut butter in a cone. The gelato was delicious! I was a little disappointed there weren't many flavors with mix-ins (choc chips, etc) but there are a lot of topping options if that is your thing. There is limited seating indoors available for customers, but I saw most people take their cones and eat on-the-go along the main street of Breck. We all enjoyed our dessert- especially my 18 month old who got to try his first few bites of gelato! read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - peanut butter gelato - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

This gelato store is just great! I didn't have to wait long for my order to be ready. It was delicious. The staff is friendly, too.

The vibe in this place is very nice. The gelato was silky smooth and the servers were nice. The only reason I gave it 4 stars is the fact that it seems a little overpriced. For what you get though, it's amazing. Would recommend, came here twice. read more

Great and friendly service and all the flavors are excellent and tasty! I got the orange chocolate and the peanut butter! read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

Bought 3 scoop $9 only gave one scoop and the server said was 3 scoop equivalent, don't buy here

My friend and I came into I Scream Gelato on a whim. Upon entering, there was a moderately long line. However, the line barely moved as the store seemed to be understaffed. When we finally got to the gelato display, there was a sign stating each customer could only get two samples, and when I asked for some samples, I was only given a minuscule amount. Nevertheless, I was impressed by the creative flavors and settled on two separate flavors. As for the gelato itself, it was pretty good and quite smooth, but it was nothing to write home about. Overall, I felt the gelato was good, but I also felt the customer service was lacking, and I felt nickel-and-dimed by the store's strict stance on sampling. read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

Located on the Breckenridge strip amongst various shops and restaurants, is this cute gelato shop. With fun gelato flavors and toppings, there should be something for everyone! I ordered the s'mores gelato in a cone. It was topped with a waffle cracker that was branded with the shops logo - such a cute touch. The staff was friendly and fast as well. Be aware, there is limited seating inside so you might not be able to get a table. Overall good experience, would come again! read more

See all

Ambience screamed summer! Clean and incredible options of ice cream! The staff was nice and the prices were reasonable considering the amazing choices. read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

Yummy selection of gelato. Service is decent but the ambiance with the loud music makes it less family friendly. read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Coffee gelato is pretty yum with the wafer - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

This is a great little stop on Main Street! The gelato is delicious! I got a KitKat flavor on a bubble waffle. It's a little pricier than you would expect, but definitely worth it! I Scream Gelato isn't just another fake gelato tourist spot, it's legit! read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato flavors - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

What a sweet reward after hiking Quandary! My body felt broken, and I was miserable (unlike the friend I was with) so ice cream was something wonderful to look forward to. I got two scoops, mint and peanut butter. Delicious and refreshing! Would definitely come here again. There's even a two-story arcade, so you can spend more time hanging out. Decent amount of indoor seating, but better to go for a walk around Breck if you can. read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

We stumbled upon this little hidden gem of an arcade while looking to get some ice cream, hidden upstairs was a fun arcade filled with games and prizes you could earn with electronic tickets that go directly to your game card. The prize station is located downstairs in the back of the shop which had many different prizes to choose from. Overall we had a great time with the kids, I love that there's another arcade with different games on Main Street. Next time we'll definitely be back to try the ice cream as there was a long line when we went in. read more

See all

3 words: peanut butter gelato!!! It's smooth, creamy, and delicious. A little expensive for a small thing of gelato, but that makes sense for a tourist area and yummy gelato in the US. read more

I was drawn to the name of this place..."I Scream Gelato" but I really wanted ice cream. Now I'm not really a connoisseur of gelato by any means but this place looked fun and I'm always down to try new dessert places. This place had a nice charm to it and if it wasn't so crowded it would have been nice to be able to sit in and enjoy the atmosphere. I was super indecisive about what I wanted to get and I decided to just wait and see what "popped" out at me when I saw the case. I admit it wasn't easy cause all of them looked so good. I ended up getting the salted butter caramel in a cup. I figured it would be less messy than a cone but the cones did look really fun so maybe next time I will try a cone. There was a whole lot of choices of toppings that you can add to your gelato from sprinkles to cookie crumbles to cereal. I didn't get anything on mine cause I wanted the purity of just a good gelato. The gelato also came with a cute "I Scream Gelato" cookie wafer which I wanted to purchase separately. You can't by the way. I enjoyed the flavor of the gelato but with the warm weather it started melting pretty quick. I think because it started melting I ate it faster than I would have liked. If I could have, I would have gone back to get a pint or 2 to take back to the house with us. I won't dub this as my go-to since there are other gelato/ice cream shops in Breck but given the opportunity I would definitely come back to try some other flavors. read more

See all

Gelato was good, but portions are small for the price and for reasons that are not clear and NOT POSTED BEFORE PURCHASE this business charges two additional fees to your purchase: a resort fee (??) and a service fee (gratuity - even though there is also a cash tip bucket at the register). What?! None of the other businesses or food establishments we visited during our five days here charged either of these extra fees. We paid over $27 for three gelatos. We also visited the arcade over the gelato shop and there were extra fees there as well: a fee to get a card and also tax charged on the game card. When we went to Downstairs at Eric's a few days earlier, they had neither of these additional charges for their arcade. Plus, at least a third of the games seem to be out of order (both VR games, a Wild Tuna fishing game, skeet ball, etc). read more

Super cute spot for gelato. We enjoyed a nice family post dinner treat and will come back again. A bit pricey for what it is, but such is life in Breck. read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

Venue***** A gelato shop with creative flavors great customer service and neon lights I mean come on. Service***** The gentleman at the counter was very attentive and a woman helping out was catering to our every need and helping us find seating Food***** They allow you to sample different flavors and they have very adventurous flavors along with your classics. Sometimes when one gets too adventurous the flavors taste a little off but that's not the case with these guys give them a try it's great stuff. read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Kinder chocolate gelato - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

When you need a gelato in the middle of winter so you can eat ice cream outside at 6 degrees, this is the place to go! Been here a few times, it's always delicious. And there are pastries to boot. read more

So yummy! Hard to choose! Loved the dark chocolate. I also tried my daughter's mango flavor and it was the creamiest! Very delicious waffle wafer adds the perfect touch. A must try in Breckenridge! read more

See all

The product......no different than any other place but it would have been better if the service was better. The customer service.....they want you out of there ASAP. I got an affogato and waited for the guy to come back I was gonna get some gelato to go. He left for the register tho. His co worker told me I need to move along and meet him at the register to pay so she can help other customers. I asked him if u want anything else you need to go through the line again? And he looked confused.....I said it's ok I'm done. Paid and left. read more

I scream Gelato was amazing and hit the spot. As soon as we walked in we were greeted and the music choice was on point. Lots of delicious flavors to chose from and all flavors a great so it's going to be hard picking the ones you want to get. Was pleasantly surprised to see an I scream gelato up here when I've been to the one in Aurora CO. Definitely a place to stop if you want to stop your sweet tooth craving. Will be back before heading out of town. read more

See all

Super cute ice cream shop in the Breckinridge area. I got the brownie flavored ice cream on one of their matcha waffle cones. Great spot to bring the family. read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Brownie flavored ice cream - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

PSA!!! Be aware of the extra "snuck in" charges!!! We have spent 4 days in Breck/Frisco area and made purchases in roughly 20-25 establishments, and any extra "fees" were openly listed on menus, explained by servers, etc. I Scream Gelato, however, is quite deceitful. This business does not disclose these extra charges, and thankfully I asked for a printed receipt. We got back to our condo and called to inquire. The staff that answered said she wasn't sure, including that the "resort fee" was an "extra tax for the company". I challenged this, so she called a manager (she told me there was not one there). The final explanation was this: The "resort fee" is "sort of a city tax; an extra charge for the town"--on top of state taxes (however note that not one other business tacked this on). The "service charge" is "like an automatic gratuity" (also note that the electronic check out system, like most companies, prompts buyers to add gratuity as well). The call ended with the employee stating "if you want to come back tomorrow and complain to a manager, you can". *May be helpful if we didn't have to leave at 6 am to catch our flight home* DO BETTER *I SCREAM GELATO*!!!!! Your product is great, but it is incredibly wrong to do your patrons this way!! read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

I paid about $10.00 (almost $12.00 with tip) for one scoop of ice cream on a sugar cone. The ice cream (chocolate peanut butter) was good, but not great. The sugar cone tasted stale. The one scoop was rather small. Was not worth it. For what it is worth, the clerks were very attentive and pleasant. The ambiance is not much to speak of -- just a small shop on Main St. You buy your ice cream and leave. read more

Avoid if you have a food allergy!!! They were very accommodating in the summer of 2024 but summer 2025 is a no-go. Employees seemed to be stunned by "do you have any nut-free options" and were completely unwilling to accommodate. Left with 2 disappointing kiddos. Every other ice cream/gelato shop we've been to is always willing to open a new container, new scoops, change gloves, etc. Very disappointing. read more

Pretty forgettable unfortunately. I understand that it's gelato but it was pretty soft even for being gelato. Probably around twelve flavors to choose from. The lemon meringue was the best but we ultimately ended up going with coconut and melon. The melon was really refreshing and tasted just like cantaloupe and the coconut had shavings in it which gave it a nice texture. We paid $15 for two of the smallest cup sizes they offer. Staff was friendly and let us try samples when asked which was nice. read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Coconut & Melon - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

The homemade gelato was delicious and so was the bubble waffle cone, expensive with $6.50 for a 4 oz scoop but very yummy. Was very busy on a summer Sunday night and we ate upstairs in the arcade which was cool but overstimulating. read more

Super cute interior decor!! We love the green turf grass wall and white animal cartoon heads. Nice selection of flavors to choose from. We all loved our gelatos! Nice spot to duck into to escape the summer heat on our stroll down main street. read more

See all

I AM SHOCKED. BEST ICE CREAM IVE EVER HAVED. I was eating my ice cream and some space goblin eating unicorns came and started looking at me! I love! I live here now, come say hi! read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

While the nights and mornings are cool in Breckinridge, the midday sun can get pretty warm making an cool, sweet treat (like gelato) very appealing. The store has a cute and trendy interior and exterior with decorative neon signs that catch your eye walking by. The captivating aroma of waffle cones and other sweet treats fills your nose when you walk into the shop. As you step in you will most likely be greeted by a long line of likeminded individuals patiently waiting for their gelato. The upside of the long line is the time to debate your gelato selection. One scoop? Two scoop? Toppings? Bubbly waffle cone or dish? After much debate I settled on the peanut butter gelato in a dish but would love to try the bubbly waffle next time. Warning, the gelato does melt quickly once served. I would have like a slightly larger "small" which means I guess I'll have to upsize next visit. read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Neon sign inside. - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

The price is high, at over 8$ after tax before tip for the small, but the ice cream is perfectly smooth and creamy. The flavors could be stronger, but it was so smooth and also not too sweet that it was a great ice cream overall. Service is nice, but very slow. read more

Great service, fun decor, clean, organized and tasty gelatos. They allow a taste sample of two per person which is perfect since my husband and I shared our samples and ended up having to choose between four amazing flavors. They all tasted just like the flavors they said they were, I thought the Ferraro was so spot on on to those delectable choco hazelnut balls. They also had a dairy free and vegan option which is nice to see too. They have three sugar cone flavors made in house, matcha, red velvet and chocolate and they actually tasted like their flavors. I think the matcha was the most subtle and had a hint of that bitter bite that happens when matcha gets heated on high, IYKYK on this one. They also have Hubble waffles and an array of espresso drinks I can't wait to try next time when I stop in a little earlier. Oh and who doesn't love an Instagrammable wall when the food is actually good and Instagram worthy too? read more

I Scream Gelato - Breckenridge - Gelato Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

Fantastic gelato! They had a lot of special favors. I had the cheesecake flavor. It was a bit sour, not too sweet, but have a right balance of milky flavor. Their display was very beautiful and attractive! No wonder this was one of the busiest shop on Main Street. read more

See all