Stopped by Smith st deli to try some bagels. I dieted a tuna on whole wheat bagel and croissant…read morewith egg, bacon and cheese. The wheat bagel was tough and the tuna was flavorless. Didn't finish. The croissant was okay but the bacon was undercooked. Overall customer service was acceptable. Pricing was on the high side for what was purchased. Don't mind paying any price if the food warrants it. Unfortunately I cannot recommend based on this experience.

I have been to smith street deli about 6 times now. Every time it is consistently great. The staff…read moreare warm and friendly and service is great. They have a great selection on packaged products and seating to eat in. The sandwiches are awesome. I have gotten the garbage pail and the extra hero. The extra has eggs, bacon, sausage, ham and cheese. This time I added a well done hash brown for crunch. Delicious! The best deli around!

When I'm in Merrick I always stop here for my usual sandwich. Always Great all the time. Always…read morefriendly.

Seems like the reviews are way too high for this place ... I agree with Frankie a few reviews down…read more. I wanted a vegetarian option they only had an eggplant mozzarella roasted pepper wrap which sounded amazing the only problem it was basically all dry eggplant ... that's all you tasted , can you guys stop being cheap with your sandwiches and add a decent amount of dressing and fresh mozzarella, I had to post a pic cause I couldn't believe it myself .

The Deli was recently renovated; it is clean and well stocked with expanded varieties of drinks and…read moresnacks. The new owners still take pick-up orders over the phone, and continues to keep the overall transaction quick and easy! Edit: as of September 2025, they have Lottery.

What a great deli. They have a ton of different type of sandwiches. I had a chicken salad…read moresandwich. It was great. It was not drowning in mayonnaise. The people there were very friendly. It is on the way to the beach. The prices are great. Great place to get food before going to the beach.

What can I say, I love my "Local" places, and my gf took me to this place near her house…read more. All I can say is yum!!

Understand it's covid but at least honor your menu prices on the board. The chicken cutlet sandwich…read morewas huge but extremely salty.

Best sandwiches around Personally prefer to call ahead but…read morethe line is part of the experience when I bring visiting friends or family Champ with works is my fav Or chicken club

So, I gave my old spot another chance. After my last review, I got a lovely message from the…read moreowner, letting me know they changed their bread and to give them another shot. Today was the day(finally), and I am so glad I did! My Hero is back on my list for a great sandwich! I am really happy to have my fantastic sandwich shop back. Bravo!

7/24/25 unassuming from the outside but what a great little gem. Service was friendly and fast…read more Shout out to Jennifer. Went for breakfast but they have specials all day.

Very good food, all I've ever gotten is bacon and eggs sandwiches, great service and fair pricing…read more Very welcoming environment, spacious for a deli and clean. I would recommend. It looks like it's just a tire place but that's where it is. Plenty of parking.

Great people. Great food…read more Nice neighborhood vibe. .........................................................................................................

This is the best place to order hero's from! I have ordered 3 , 4 and 6 foot hero's from here and…read morenever disappointed! I usually do the Italian & American or Italian & chicken cutlet. So good! I also come here for breakfast - BEC so good! Highly recommend!

As always, I found this deli by chance. What a wonderful chance it was. "Sopranos Deli" has all the…read moremakings of an epic find. I only noticed street parking, but it was fine. I was hungry and nothing was stopping me from going in. The outside of the building was interesting to say the least. Let's just say it stood out. Inside was a bit small. I was surprised, but there were people getting food so I know I was at the right place. Once it was my turn I looked over the options. The staff were friendly and the guy joked with me a lot. He mentioned the lasagna was still fresh. He forced my hand so I went with that. I am glad he did. The lasagna was perfect! Second to none! They used ricotta, meat and the right amount of cheese. I definitely would rate this high. My only wish is that it was closer to my home, I would go more often. But maybe it being far is a good thing. I mean, I would be there every day.

First off, I don't usually post reviews, but lately the quality of service AND of products from…read moremany different places has been horrible and I am tired of paying good money for garbage. Now the review. 1. A simple order that they couldn't get right. Plain bagel, scooped, toasted with cream cheese, plain bagel with butter and a large iced coffee. I got plain bagel, not scooped, not toasted, with cream cheese. 2. The quality of the bagels are maybe 5/10. 3. The iced coffee was horrible. Zero flavor. So watered down that it tasted like sugar water and 1/2 and 1/2. Sorry.