Great people. Great food. Nice neighborhood vibe. ......................................................................................................... read more

This is the best place to order hero's from! I have ordered 3 , 4 and 6 foot hero's from here and never disappointed! I usually do the Italian & American or Italian & chicken cutlet. So good! I also come here for breakfast - BEC so good! Highly recommend! read more

Atlantic Ave Deli - This is The "Godfather" - Delis Near Me - Freeport, New York

I find it a little crazy that they charge $13 for a BLT and only give you like three lousy pieces of bacon it's ridiculous what the food industry has come to and having to restaurants myself I never skimped on food you can raise the price a little but you can't take the food away from the portion read more

Just rude and unpleasant. We come here all the time and spend hundreds of dollars a year here, and I just dropped a $20 tip in the jar two days ago as a New Years gesture. Today their credit card machine is down but instead of saying so when you order, they put up a scribbled sign inside the window. We waited for our sandwiches and went to pay, only to find that they can't accept cards, have no ATM, and are rude about it. The guy behind us also didn't have cash and the man said, "the sign was up here the whole time you were ordering." Wow. Whatever happened to, "I'm sorry, we should have mentioned it when you ordered and before you stood here for ten minutes to not get the food because our systems failed." Or maybe, "just give me your name and I'll write you up an IOU. Pay us next time you're here." Like a friendly neighborhood place would be expected to do. So we left our sandwiches on the counter. He made no sale. I'll be sure to make this my last choice of local delis from now on. I'd like that tip back too... read more

You go to a Deli to get a big o'l sandwich and expect to pay a little extra for it. It should be worth it. NOT AT ALL in this case. $8.14 for Tuna on a Roll. I could have bought 3 cans from supermarket cheaper and made my own. very small amount on Tuna. Never again. Won't rob me again. read more

Atlantic Ave Deli - Very SMALL amount of Tuna for $8.14 - Delis Near Me - Freeport, New York

See all

Delicious food and fast efficient service! Great place to grab a quick bite to eat. Offers breakfast as well as lunch sandwiches. Paninis are my favorite! read more

See all

A lot of potential but execution is horrendous. Every now & then mistakes are made I get that but almost every time I order their is something wrong. Happened again this morning & the kicker was they messed up two more orders in front of me before I even ordered (should have just walked away). I didn't even bother going back & wasting my time just threw out the messed up order AGAIN, went around the block & got the same order perfect with zero issues read more

I understand the prices on everything went up BUT YOU HAVE TO PUT MORE MEAT (pause) ON THE SANDWICH. I just got a godfather (bangin) but it had 1 slice of everything . I basically had a bread sandwich . Step it tf up. read more

Atlantic Ave Deli - Delis Near Me - Freeport, New York

See all

There really isn't anything special about this place. I usually get the same sandwich every time I go and it is never consistent. Just got a sandwich today, and the tomatoes had mold on it and the lettuce was brown. Also the older bald guy that works there is always rude/miserable with sarcastic remarks. read more

I've been coming to Atlantic Avenue Deli since relocating to Baldwin from Oceanside about 3.5 years ago and I'm so glad I found them! Let's face it, Long Island deli staffs are about as a hungry fat kid on a day long express bus trip. They're bitchy, rude and can make the whole experience miserable. That said, the people at Atlantic Avenue Deli are all about "service with a smile." They even sound like their grinning when you phone in an order. This is the only area Deli I know of that makes breakfast sandwiches all day. Yes, 3:00 PM Bacon & Egg sandwich hangover remedies are readily available at Atlantic Ave Deli! That alone would make for a great experience, but their other sandwiches, paninis and entrees are wonderful as well. About the only problem I have with Atlantic Ave Deli is the wait. This place gets busy during lunch and on the weekends. Best bet? Phone your order in! read more

First things first, the conversation you have with the customer should be strictly professional. You should never make a comment that you "wouldn't be able to tell the difference between what you want and what I give you" If someone is asking for something particular that's what they should get. If you don't have it than that's fine but snickering comments are never appreciated as to what I want being the customer. Coming from someone who works in the customer service industry this was just an instance of an establishment being unprofessional and sub par. Whether it's deli meats, bread, sandwiches, or catering orders ever sale should be professional and handled with the upmost respect. Unfortunately this was not one of those cases. read more

Expensive but good.. but expensive. Nice big deli, seems to do lot of business in the morning for their famous "mess" sandwiches. I love the triple mess -- 3 eggs, bacon, sasuage and friggin' ham on a roll with salt pepper and ketchup. Yep... a fat kid's dream breakfast minus the pancakes. They seem to have a regular crowd -- everyone is known on a first name basis -- I was the only dope that was clearly an "outside" from the deli's morning club. No matter though -- fast service, abysmal brown water coffee, awesome sandwich and I was on my way to work. Can't make this a daily habit. Why? I'll either be dead or have an empty wallet -- either is inevitable. read more

Atlantic Ave Deli - Triple Mess Breakfast Sandwich - Delis Near Me - Freeport, New York

The deli he is super convenient for a quick pitstop before the beach or if you're going fishing But other than that it does not live up to expectations, the sandwiches are very small with not a lot of meat,not very tasty and the guys behind the counter are not friendly at all and rude,almost like they don't want to be there, And beer selection is horrible, they have a better selection at my local gas station for crying out loud, Truly a shame because it could be so much better if they just cared and tried harder. read more

2 slices of ham and hash brown on aluminum foil, with western omelette on toasted roll(low class) for $10 ....taste like shit!!! Not worth it read more

Atlantic Ave Deli - 2 slices of ham and hash brown on aluminum foil, with western omelette)$10 shitty - Delis Near Me - Freeport, New York

Small deli we went to get bagels at before our fishing charter. No public bathroom in the seating area. Good bagel, but the new guy up front kept rolling his eyes at us when we were asking if he had a certain bagel (e.g. everything bagel). read more

I recently went here and ordered 2 bags of chips ($2 each), a small fruit cup for $4.99 and a sandwich for $13.99. I have no problem with the prices, but I was rung up for $29. That should come to $23 under the math I learned. If you're going to charge a credit card "fee" it should be publicly stated. I will not be back. read more

I waited 7 minutes to get a cup of coffe at 2 pm the 2 guys making sandwiches seamed to be in the nowhere zone ; finally some tatto guy walks out from behind the wall and never acknowledges 5 people on line ; I bluntly said can I have a cup of coffee ; he said sure and made me my coffee / had I not interrupted him he would have never acknowledged me ; those poor 3 guys behind me just left read more

Been going there recently. Their chicken cutlet sandwich tastes really good, and they use sweet baby rays which is the best bbq sauce. Haven't ordered breakfast but their home fries look good. I'm going to have to try soon. read more

Prices are high & food quality has suffered since the new owners took over. Ordered my go to "double mess" had only one egg & was way over cooked. Used to visit here at least twice a week, not anymore. They have a new grab & go which is nice. Wish they would replace the ceiling tiles which have been stained for years!!!! read more

I was recently visiting a friend in Long Island and happened upon Atlantic Ave Deli. What I thought was a nice family establishment turned into an uncomfortable situation. One of the employees (an older bald guy who reeked of marijuana) started bragging about not being vaccinated and was not wearing a mask. It was really alarming for someone to make light of such a serious situation during this pandemic. Not surprised if these other negative reviews are about the same guy. This deli for sure will not be receiving any business from my friends and i moving forward. read more

Best deli in LI A HIDDEN GEM. New owners new look best coffee in town. A must if your local or in the neighborhood.

Let me tell u why pricey doesnt matter Because you get what you pay for The food is excellent here. The staff is very attentive. Its easy to make this a loyal deli spot. Also the home fries have so much flavor, im pretty sure I made a mistake putting ketchup on it. read more

I'll start out by saying the food was delicious. This would've been a 5 star review if it wasn't for the service. I guess because I wasn't a local - as they appeared to be nice to people they knew. The guy that took my order was rude, even my daughter commented on him being "mean". I hate places that act like they're doing you a favor. I wouldn't return based on the service. read more

Atlantic Ave Deli is the only place you should stop for breakfast and lunch. Whether you're on your way to work or if you live in the area. This is the place to go. The staff is above and beyond. Matt makes the best breakfast sandwich hands down. No matter how large or small the order is, Matt nails it every time. Place is always clean. My normal wait is about 5-10 minutes, which is outstanding because there is always a crowd of people at the counter awaiting their delicious breakfast. Im always greeted with a smile and I always leave anxious waiting to eat my meal. Sometimes I race to work a few miles away just so I can eat it sooner. Never had a complaint and I doubt you will if you are reading this. Now I will go enjoy my BEC SPK on a roll. read more

Best Egg Sandwiches I've ever had. I moved down to Florida recently and everytime I visit family back up here, I have to stop in for breakfast. My family and I have been coming here for at least 15 years. read more

I work very close to this deli and we ordered for a meeting at my job and the guy was very nice when I called, they came right on time and the food was ok. So I figured I try them again and I ordered home fries with an egg and cheese sandwich on whole wheat toast. The home fries were burnt and too many seasonings on it and by seasonigs i mean like some orange seasonigs were on the home fries and they tasted more like crunchy small french fries. I did not like them. The egg and cheese sandwich was ok The cheese wasnt good. It tasted like the sliced pre packaged cheese. The service was very good. They were smiling, quick and efficient. Which is why i gave 2 stars. Will never return. read more

This is definitely one of my go to spots! They have the best breakfast sandwiches! And their cold cuts are always fresh. I always get the mess - ham, bacon, sausage, eggs and cheese on a roll with some hot sauce. And you have to get the half and half- half iced tea and half lemonade. The staff is always super friendly also! read more

Went here today around 4:30. Asked for hot pastrami with Munster cheese and mustard on hero. Sandwich was not warm and they put honey Mustard instead of regular mustard. This is the second sandwich that they messed up on so won't be back. read more

OMG Amazing!!! Use to live in Freeport & moved, came back for a visit & morning breakfast here is the best. Already miss it. Great lunch too. Definitely must try & you will be a regular. Can't wait go go back read more

One of my favorite places to go for sandwiches. They make the best bacon egg and cheese! Their rolls are so soft, makes the sandwiches extra delectable! I try to order ahead of time so that my sandwich is ready. Only once did I have to wait and instead of apologizing the lady told me "it happens!" For the most part, staff is friendly (unfortunately it depends on who you get) and the food is delicious! read more

I have been using this deli for years. The coffee is always fresh and very good. The sandwiches and salads are excellent. They have a very friendly staff, who are quick to take my order. This is a good place to stop for breakfast, or lunch. read more

Great local deli. We have been going here for years now. Feel we have a rapport with them now. Everything from breakfast to catering for our parties, they do it very well. For me, 4 stars for a deli is huge. Only my best restaurant picks get 4-5 stars. Not delis. So hat's off to them. Good spot! read more

I really liked this deli. Their homefries are awesome, especially when you crumble their bacon on top of it. It was pretty busy when I went in, but I ended up getting my food without waiting too long. I've had their lunch sandwiches a couple of times and they've been good too. One of the better delis in this area. read more

I stop in every morning for breakfast and two or three times a week for lunch. The food is always fresh and well prepared and the service is always great. I love the fact that I can call my order in and have it ready when I get there. Truly the best deli in town!! read more

Disclaimer I haven't eaten here more than once, but the salads I had here were just mediocre. - Green salads and cucumber salads freshness mediocre to poor, tasted like bottled dressings or sugared white vinegar with onions. - Mozz salad just average. - Coffee was yuck, even for deli coffee. read more

Been going here for 30 years always good but went last week I guess there's new owners order a roast beef hero they didn't slice the roast beef fresh I watched the man take pre sliced dried up bits of roast beef out of a bin I was speechless and just walked out bad business will never return nor will anybody I know return read more

REVIEW ABOUT CATERING ... because who doesn't love the deli. Full disclosure, I used to work @ Atlantic, but years ago ... I'm not sure if Lou is still there, but Joey sure is. Awesome. That said, I have had Atlantic cater a few parties, and the service and products are excellent. BUT - and here's the basis of the five-star review - the food is surprisingly good. I say "surprisingly", because really, what do you want from deli-catered food? The food from Atlantic is really delicious. For the most recent party I had the eggplant rollatini, the chicken francese, and the sausage and peppers. Wow, was that good. Even the macaroni salad was amazing. I also had a party catered recently by Happy Hostess. The staff was great, but the food was barely edible (also surprising, but in a bad way!) Do not hesitate to call Atlantic for your catering needs. And like I said, even though I used to work there, this is -not- a shill - the food really is delicious. read more

Not a good experience with the new owner. The tuna on white that I got had very little tuna for $7 and the egg salad in the case was old looking and watery read more

Good deli, sandwiches are a good size and taste good. But occasionally they forgot the orders. One time I went to go pick up a sandwich and they said they never received a call for my sandwich which wasn't true read more

This is the best deli around - a real neighborhood stop. The staff is always friendly and helpful. The egg sandwiches in the morning are great. And the special subs are huge and taste great (I like the #10 and the godfather). Definitely the place to go before or after hitting the water. read more