Cancel

Open app

Search

Island Ice Cream

4.0 (1 review)

Island Ice Cream Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Island Ice Cream

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 4,401 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Cool Scoops

Cool Scoops

4.4
(147 reviews)
1.3 mi
•$$

I've been coming to Wildwood for years and had somehow never heard of this fun ice cream shop! A…read morefriend recommended it, and I'm so glad they did. The 1950s-themed atmosphere is charming, and every corner of the shop is filled with nostalgic decorations that take you back in time. I was so busy admiring all the details that I forgot to take pictures of the ice cream! The service was quick and friendly, and the ice cream was delicious. We had a great experience and will definitely be back the next time we're in Wildwood.

With a COOL 50s vibe, this ice cream parlor is one to visit in the wildwood area. Pick your flavor…read moreor sundae from the counter and then choose which old school cruiser you'd like to enjoy your sweet treat at. The shop is filled wall to wall with famous 50s-70s icons. Service was quick, lots of quiet younger workers but they were friendly and helpful. The ice cream was delish! I opted for the regular chocolate in a waffle cone and it so good. They have several special dietary options and are kind enough to cover and label those flavors so that there is no cross contamination. My brother in law tried the homemade cookie cup and while it was good it wasn't great. A little too hard and not the best flavor - go for the waffle cone instead. Vanilla peanut butter was also a fan favorite as well as the rainbow sherbet.

Photos
Cool Scoops
Cool Scoops
Cookie dough ice cream in a waffle bowl with crushed Heath bar. Yumm

See all

Cookie dough ice cream in a waffle bowl with crushed Heath bar. Yumm
Banana's Ice Cream Cafe

Banana's Ice Cream Cafe

3.2
(53 reviews)
0.5 mi
•$

Tons of options and the owner is such a nice guy. Banana's is the type of small business that makes…read moreyou feel really happy to support. The Sundae options are overwhelming as there are so many. I will be back to try each and every one of them!

I first discovered Bananas on a trip to Wildwood in 2018 and there was a young worker outside and…read morethey were offering Banana ice cream both Cinnamon dough bits in it. It was homemade and simply delicious. We went every night after....they had Banana ice cream with Choc Chipa, another it was Banana with Strawberries.....simply amazing all home made. Just went back tonightnfor the first time in 8 years. Looks the same but the ice cream is not good. I love Banana Ice Cream but tonight was not like it was 8 years ago. It's safe to assume someone purchased it cheaped out on the ice cream. I was so disappointed and I absolutely loved this place. The charm is still there and the owner was there wIth some young girls working. As a fellow small business owner I respect that.....seemed like a really nice guy. He's actually one of the reasons I gave this place 3 stars. Very professional and courteous. The Ice Cream is average at best and Im being kind. Their Banana ice cream now is canary yellow, artificially flavored bad tasting ice cream. He needs to take it back to how it was in 2018....all the ice cream was homemade and it was simply delicious! Overall the ice cream portions are the same but the ice cream is not good! Take it back 8 years when it was all homemade. That's what made Bananas stand out. Now it stands out for all thr wrong reasons. Sorry but its the Truth! Make Bananas Great Again!

Photos
Fruity Pebble Sundae
Fruity Pebble Sundae
Chocolate Peanut Butter Sundae
Chocolate Peanut Butter Sundae
Banana's Ice Cream Cafe

See all

Utterly

Utterly

5.0
(4 reviews)
0.3 mi

After passing by Utterly many times on Pacific Ave, I finally made it over for ice cream…read more I ordered the banana split which came with a banana (of course), 3 ice cream flavors and 3 toppings. My favorite was the peanut butter cookies & cream, I've never seen this flavor anywhere else and it will be my go to order at Utterly going forward. As a bonus - they have hot fudge - and not just chocolate syrup they are trying to pass off as hot fudge - but the real think and warm stuff - delicious! My husband tried the sampler - 6 scoops of ice cream and 6 toppings. He loved every flavor. A few extra notes; There are a few tables for indoor seating, and some benches located outside. They accept credit cards. Friendly service! The shop is very clean.

First time I came here during my trip I was just needing a glass of water my son. I noticed they…read morehad sourdough items so I grabbed a strawberry sourdough muffin. The lady at the register told me once I had a sourdough muffin, I'll never go back to the regular ones. Wow was it delicious. I can taste the sourdough and strawberry flavors and it was a great combo. The crumble on top was a nice touch but for me, not needed. I came back a second time for the ice cream. I was in a PB mood and tried the PB cookies and cream and I loved it. I've never had PB flavored ice cream but this had strips of PB that were almost frozen so the texture was the best. My son tried the cream ice cream - huge but the crunch from the cereal was really good - they actually mix it together so it's not chunky cereal.... This is a must go when you're visiting wildwood!

Photos
Pb cookies & cream blended w/ Cookie Crisp in a waffle cone. AMAZING
Pb cookies & cream blended w/ Cookie Crisp in a waffle cone. AMAZING
Ice cream flight
Ice cream flight
Ice cream

See all

Ice cream

Island Ice Cream - icecream - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...