We decided to visit this pizzeria during that sweet spot between lunch and dinner to avoid the rushes. When you walk in, you head straight to the counter where there's a large menu board to order from. My wife ordered a slice of cheese pizza and a salad, and I ordered the jerk chicken pizza. It took a little while for the food to come out, but that's to be expected when it's made fresh sono complaints there. A woman called our number, I let her know it was ours, and not long after, our food was brought to the table. The pizza looked and smelled wonderful. The only downside was that it wasn't cut very well, I had to use the edge of the pizza spatula to make better slices, which was a little annoying. But the flavor made up for it. The jerk chicken pizza was very flavorful, and since I got the thin crust, it didn't leave me feeling overly stuffed. Timing was everything, we beat the rush. By the time we were leaving, nearly every table was taken and a line had formed at the counter. The decor was simple and nothing flashy, but it didn't take away from the experience. Overall, glad we stopped in when we did. read more

Yummy veggie pizza and pepperoni pizza. The wait wasn't that long, I got a table within 10 minutes. The garlic bread was not that great, felt like I was having underdone dough. They have good seating available. read more

See all

Pizza is terrible. Barely lukewarm, old (sitting in the warmer for hours), hardly any cheese. Crust is like cardboard. So called deep dish is like a loaf of bread with a thin layer of sauce and cheese. Possibly the worst pizza I've ever had. Quite the ripoff. This is not a pizzeria. read more

Looking to order something to pick up and called to see what their hours were. Pressed number two at their menu as requested and it stated they were open from 11:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m.. Called back to place an order and was told they close at 8:00. Could they not have bothered themselves to waste 3 minutes to update there automated phone system? read more

Can't believe this place doesn't have a higher rating. We walked in here starving for lunch after a half day of sightseeing since the Pink Pony (per our original plan) had a 2 hours waiting (no thanks), and left very fulfilled. You order at the counter and take a seat (plenty of seating) and they bring your order out. We got a deep dish half cheese and half veggie and the veggie section in particular was very tasty. I've only ever had detroit deep dish at Jet's, so I'm no expert, but this was good stuff - would recommend. read more

Stellar food and service as always! We make this a staple to every trip! Can't get better pizza off island. The sauce is the best part so tasty! read more

Island Slice Pizzeria - Detroit deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

This place is fast and easy to either eat inside or take to go. The park is close and on a nice day I like to eat it there. I've had their margarita pizza which is decent with the thin crust. I also like to get order a custom pizza with all my favorite toppings. You can't go wrong. The service is friendly and if you want to plan a head call it in. This place is casual so after a long day of shopping, walking or biking you can grab a nice quick bite. Great for larger groups as well. read more

See all

Not a great spot but that's what you get on island. Service was quick though. Pizza is just ok. read more

Island Slice Pizzeria - people eating in a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

Visited on a September afternoon for a late lunch/early dinner. The place was busy but staff were friendly. We went with a simple pizza combo with a breadstick. We ordered, got our slices, and took a seat inside. Fast service! The pizza was good, hit the spot after a bike ride around the island. Breadstick also had good flavor. TV was playing a video about the snow bridge and winter on the island. A great place for a quick bite to eat. Menu has pizza of course but also salads, subs, and pasta. We had a better experience compared to the first time we visited here. read more

See all

What's nice about this restaurant that you can get an individual slice, salad and fountain soda for a decent price especially compared to the other restaurants in Mackinaw Island. A nice change of pace. read more

I've popped in here for a fast bite when I don't want to spend a lot of time eating. You can get anything off the menu and eat it in the building or take it to your room or the park. The pizza is decent and the other items were not too bad. This is basic food, quick and easy. You order at the register, tell them whether it is for there or to go, pay and wait for your name or number to be called. They are open late in season and for 2023 winter, they will be open during the day. read more

Decent snack if roaming around and hungry. Pizza was average, side salad was ok. Service was good, but restaurant was not very clean and flies were everywhere. The staff were all friendly and the pizza was served hot and fresh. A little pricey for the quality. read more

Island Slice Pizzeria - Pepperoni, basil pesto with sundried tomatoes. - Pizza Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

A real New Yorker and pizza critic- this pizza wasn't bad. Had a 14" half pepperoni pizza. Freshly made it tasted very good The staff was friendly and the place was typical pizzeria seating. I would recommend read more

This place left me unsatisfied. We were hungry and looking for lunch and the pizza slice combo we got here was a bit disappointing. I know it's an island so the prices are going to be higher, but the price for one slice of pizza and a breadstick was ridiculous. All the pizzas tasted the same, no differing flavor and I felt pretty sick after eating here. It's expensive and not really worth it read more

See all

Would have loved to try it. Hours online say they're open until 11pm, we got there and they close at 7 pm. We understood and tried to go the next day for lunch, entire lobby closed for a private party. Like do you want people to try your food? read more

The decor was great. Loved the Detroit Tigers pictures and the Detroit pictures. Service was good. Pizza was at best ok. Didn't feel it had a lot of flavor. read more

Island Slice Pizzeria ..... I love you. In my handful of times I've been to the island, I'm pretty sure my boyfriend and I have stopped here twice on each trip! If you're not in the mood to wait in long lines for dining in, Island Slice is for you! You simply walk up to the counter, order your slice or whole pizza, and they provide quick and fast service to get you on your way with the rest of your day We typically opt for a slice, which comes with a breadstick and drink. It's fairly inexpensive for island food, which makes it so good! The pizza itself is always seasoned just right, never soggy, with the best crust I've ever had. They do offer a handful of tables if you'd like to dine in and enjoy some much needed AC too! My mouth is watering just thinking about the pizza. Can't wait to be back! read more

Soo many options! So if you want a small to large pizza for a dine in experience you're in luck! If you just want a few slices with some Breadsticks you're also good! The pizza by slice is New York thin style. The breadsticks have an awesome Parmesan sprinkle On them...I mean it's just good. If you go during lunch or dinner be prepared to wait a few to order...or wait for a custom pizza to come out. Lot of people on an island only one real pizza joint. It's not too expensive but the bigger the pizza the more you'll be paying. But definitely a must go eat if you're looking for quick and delicious or easy and casual. read more

Island Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

Good late night option, because it's the only one! Totally fine. Young staff goofing around but were nice enough.

A good spot to hit when you want a slice of pizza. Decent selection and quick. Pizza was alright (C)

No flavor in the pizza. Tried the veggie and cheese. Took 20 mins to get us a Ceaser salad. Not that busy of a day. Overpriced. Would not come back. read more

If paying 30 dollars for a tombstone pizza is ur thing go for it... it's edible but that's where I will stop. I am a bit of a pizza snob but didn't expect it to be that bad. read more

Island Slice Pizzeria - Bill - Pizza Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

Good gluten free pizza! Always visit here while on the island! Cute sitting area and right on the Main Street.

It was a little pricy for 2 slices I recommend buying a regular size pizza. But it's clean and nice theme. Service is bit slow if you want to wait for hole pizza. read more

Pizza was alright but what we ordered was deep dish & it doesn't feel like deep dish. Service was fast enough but when inquired about delivery was told there was no delivery despite the window sign. Staff taking orders was rude. Overall probably won't eat here again and would prefer to eat somewhere down the street. read more

the pizza here is delicious! great for the whole family and something quick and easy to grab. my families tradition is to get a togo and eat it at the picnic tables in the marina. definitely a must eat place while visiting the island! read more

Island Slice Pizzeria - garlic cheese bread - Pizza Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

Pricier than your regular dominos pizza. Was very crowded. Had the thin crust Veggie Pizza. It was good but lighter on the toppings. The Garlic bread was hot and soft and tasty (recommended) Sharing the recent menu (pricing have gone up) read more

Island Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

Very tasty pizza and breadstick. We had the pizza/breadstick combo. Pizza and breadstick were hot and fresh. Enjoyed our visit today. Will come back next time we visit the island read more

A day at the island isn't complete without a quick stop to this local joint! We found this place through Google, as we were looking for something vegetarian (slim options on an island!), and decided to try it for dinner. We got there right in time before the big rush (and boy, do they get busy!). While the sign said no strollers inside, the establishment was nice enough to allow us to bring ours as it wasn't as busy when we got there. We ordered a couple of pizzas (14in in size) and a small kids spaghetti with marinara. While it's a bit expensive, we didn't expect any different from a restaurant on an island and in a relatively busy touristy spot. The spaghetti came almost immediately, and my 2 year old niece ate quite a bit pretty quickly. Our pizzas came within 15 minutes as well, and were pretty delicious as well! Our family of 6 adults and a kiddo ate a hearty meal within this order, and we'd definitely stop by again if we make another trip to the island! Thank you!! read more

Island Slice Pizzeria - Vegetarian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

See all

Stopped in here cause line not as long as all the other restaurants in town...got the Italian sub and the club, Caesar salad, chicken wings and bread sticks. Everything was super yummy!! The other half of my Italian sub was even yummy cold when I ate the rest later that night. Bread sticks were so yummy, soft and tasty. Worth the stop!! read more

We stopped for lunch and did the combos, I'd recommend this...you could choose a slice of cheese or pepperoni pizza, a breadstick or salad, a fountain drink or bottle of water. Pizza was very yummy. You order at the counter, pay, and get your food. Workers were nice. Lots of seating. They do carry out and delivery. read more

Island Slice Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza, side salad was very fresh and fountain drink. - Pizza Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

The pizza was just so-so for taste. It was quite crowded and the service did take a while.

Very solid pizza joint. We asked several different islanders where to go for good pizza - not one person hesitated with their answer - "island slice!! and get breadsticks!" We ordered takeout - very good. The crust was good and the sauce itself had a good flavor. Cheese was fresh and much better than a normal pizza place. Hot wings were HOT, very HOT. Can't wait to go back. read more

Island Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

My wife and I split a small sausage pizza here and took it to go so we could eat outside. No complaints about the service, and the pizza was pretty solid. Good, but not great. If you're looking to satisfy your pizza craving while on the island, I recommend this place! read more

Like several of the reviews here, the pizza was just okay and like most of the restaurants we dined at while on the island, priced high for what you get. We waited over 15 minutes for three small slices of cheese pizza to go and except for one nice young lady at the counter who apologized for the wait, the staff here seemed annoyed by the customers ordering at night. A very odd feeling for a place serving mostly tourists and advertising "open late." The slices you could buy in the case, ready to go, were all pepperoni pizzas and no cheese, which I also found unusual and seemed to add to their frustration because the people in back had to make more for those customers in line wanting cheese slices. I know it's past the end of summer, but it's always irritating to me to visit a place that doesn't seem to appreciate its customers, or use basic common courtesy. Hopefully, others have a better experience than we did and sounds like the sandwiches might be better than the pizza. Also, it's very clean, bright and cozy inside, which were the positive things we liked about the place. read more

First time on the island and Island Slice was highly recommended. When visiting to get a pizza it was explained to me by the staff that they were out of cheese!! How do have a pizza place with NO CHEESE? Very disappointing. The staff was VERY kind and apologetic! read more

Counter salesperson lacks hospitality skills, pizza is edible at best, however not recommendable.

Everything is always fresh and made from scratch! A true and real pizzeria that never disappoints!

We waited over 45 minutes for our pizza. We had to ask for the salad we ordered, which we got 15 minutes later. We then got the sandwich we ordered 25 minutes after that, after asking a third time. Multiple dirty tables that no one cleaned, we were here over 2 hours and saw 5 different customers clearing tables so they could sit. Very inefficiently ran. One of the Staff members was handing paper plates out, didn't seem to make sense since multiple tables needed clearing. Wouldn't come back, If anyone knows any other good pizza places on the island, please comment. read more

Island Slice Pizzeria - It is hard to see all of them, but there are 4 dirty tables in this picture. - Pizza Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

The pizza and salad combo were good, and the line moved quickly. However I have to only give this two stars due to this establishment airing a far-leaning political news channel on the main TV. I will tend to give low stars to an eatery when I see it airing a news channel that brainwashes people, no matter which side of the aisle the channel leans. I want to enjoy my experience, and in this case my vacation, not be reminded about how awful the news constantly is. read more