After a full day of walking, biking, and convincing myself I definitely wasn't tired, Millie's on…read moreMain hit the spot. My daughter ordered the burger, and it was a winner. The patty was juicy, the bun was soft and fluffy, and somehow she still managed to have room for dessert. Kids are magical like that. My husband and I both ordered the pan-fried whitefish because, come on... you're on Mackinac Island. You have to. The fish was fresh, flaky, and perfectly cooked with a light, crispy crust that let the flavor of the whitefish shine. Exactly what we were hoping for. The restaurant has a fun, laid-back atmosphere that feels like the perfect place to recharge before heading back out to explore the island. The service was friendly, the food came out quickly, and everything tasted fresh. If you're visiting Mackinac, don't overthink it. Order the whitefish, steal a fry from whoever you're eating with (it's vacation, calories are on island time), and enjoy a great meal.

It was surprisingly empty when we went in, perhaps because we were there between major meal times…read more But we were greeted, seated and then promptly ordered. Everyone was friendly, the restaurant and restroom was clean. The atmosphere felt very cozy, we had a seat by the window which was lovely for people watching although apparently people line up for the carriage ride right outside the window. Our food was great, a really good experience.

I believe this may be one of the few pizza places on the island. It was a very busy Fourth of July…read morenight. The pizza was mediocre at best and you're going to pay top dollar for it. I would skip it unless you have no other options for food. The staff was pretty friendly at least .

Yummy veggie pizza and pepperoni pizza. The wait wasn't that long, I got a table within 10 minutes…read more The garlic bread was not that great, felt like I was having underdone dough. They have good seating available.

Needed a place to eat and found the Broken Spoke! The place next door had an hour wait, so we…read morechecked out the Broken Spoke. The wait was about 15-20 minutes - so much better of a wait time! I like the theme and vibe of the place - the play on bikes and name of the restaurant is perfect. Decor is bike themed but not overly done. Rustic and laid back. Our waitress was excellent - very friendly and attentive. All staff were wearing masks. Good drink menu in addition to food. A lot of small plate options but the portion sizes of the small plates could feed at least 2-4 people. I went with sweet potato fries and steak tender bites - delicious! The dipping sauces for the fries had three different options - sweet/savory, loved trying each one. The sweet potato fries were not mushy and had a good crunch. The steak was cooked to perfection - I asked for medium and I got medium! Everyone seemed happy with their food. Restrooms were downstairs. Nice dining option in the city - only con there was no outdoor seating. Picking up on social media - looks like this place used to be Huron St. Pub & Grill not sure if it was a re-branding or new owners. Either way, I hope Broken Spoke is here to stay on the island!

Went for dinner and the place had a great vibe, chill music, good food, and amazing service. Our…read morewaitress was super nice, helpful, and attentive. The Po' Boy was our favorite, definitely would go back again. Update: Went for dinner, still a great atmosphere and great service. The tomato basil soup was too salty and we couldn't finish it, the fish tacos were a little fishy, but the Po' Boy was still really good.

You have to make an effort to get off of the tourist main drag to get over to this place. There was…read morea couple blocks off of the main strip. They had a Detroit style pizza, and it was fabulous. For being in such a tortoise spot, I felt they did a good job and the prices were fair. It is attached to another restaurant, so it's a little confusing at first, but you will figure it out and enjoy it.

Great Detroit style pizza! I liked both the mushroom version and the BBQ chicken one...I'd have to…read moreget the mushroom one again. We took the pizza outside to enjoy the beautiful weather.

When my college friend and I travel, we always try to find some top tier restaurants to dine at. On…read morethis year's expedition -- a tour of the Upper Peninsula of Michigan which included a visit to Mackinac Island -- I booked a table at the 1852 Grill Room. It was probably the best decision I made on this trip. I'm ranking it among the five best we've dined at--and that includes some famous restaurants in New Orleans, Memphis, Louisville, Albuquerque, Kansas City, and New York City, not to mention the nationally acclaimed crab shack we found in rural Delaware. The service was impeccable. Our waiter was the consummate professional. She promptly greeted us and took our drink order shortly after we arrived. Unfortunately the bar was out of one of the essential ingredients for the drink my companion ordered but the other "Old Fashioned" options were fine and he eventually ordered a second. My "007" Martini was also quite good. The starter menu was amazing. I went with one of my favorites -- if prepared well -- beef carpaccio, and it didn't disappoint. Micro-thin slices of raw beef topped with arugula, parmigiana reggiano, and a light dressing was the perfect start to the evening. My companion ordered gazpacho which he reports was excellent. I didn't plan on it at first, but I decided to order a whitefish dinner for the second day in a row. Instead of a sandwich, this time the entree was a beautifully planked whitefish filet with duchess potatoes and roasted asparagus spears. The fish was perfectly seasoned and cooked. The potatoes were outstanding. A few of the asparagus spears were not perfectly trimmed at the base, but overall they were fine. My companion ordered perch filets with a side of creamed spinach. I tasted the spinach and it was probably the best I've ever tasted. He gobbled it down. After a meal like that we had to have some dessert. We went with their crème brûlée -- a rather standard option-- but executed perfectly and with a generous pour of a single malt Scotch whisky it was a wonderful finish to an outstanding meal. There are lots of choices when it comes to dining on the Island (and I tried a few of them on a previous trip) but this is one I'd come back to again and again.

Anniversary dinner in a very nice atmosphere. Normally I'm not big on hotel restaurants but the…read more food was excellent. I took the waiter's recommendation on the filet minion and I think it was prime beef and cooked as ordered. My wife had white fish and we swapped half's. We also ordered a Canadian lobster tail which tasted great but it was tiny (maybe 3-4 ounces cooked). We went all out and spent $240. I think you could have a great dinner here for half of that.

Food, service, ambiance is everything you would expect at your local watering hole…read more The bartender was also our server. Very pleasant conversation and friendly. An establishment that is in the running for the longest ran tavern in the state, it has quite the history inside those doors. If you're expecting classy, bright, elegant- this is not the place for you. But if you want a hometown feel with history and great service, this is your place!

Popped in for a quick cheeky drink. I didn't have any children with me, and I didn't see any…read morechildren or families while I was at Mustang Lounge, so I'm thinking this place is more geared toward adults. It's a lounge and tavern! Those words, and kids, do not usually go together. But looking at the food menu, it's pretty appealing to all ages, so I'm sure kids are not turned away. I didn't get any food when I visited Mustang Lounge, just drinks. I almost never get a cocktail because they're usually too sweet, but I got some sort of citrus and honey cocktail, the name of which escapes me. It was really good! We also got a beer, and the beer was served in a cold, frosty glass. They have a lot of beer options here. Mustang Lounge is quiet and intimate -- a nice place to get a drink and relax for a while.

We were looking for a quick bite while we were on the island. After reading YELP reviews, we…read moredecided to give this a try. We were delighted that we could sit out on the back patio that overlooked the lake. What a great view. We also were entertained by a mama otter and her three pups. Super cute. Our server was delightful. Very helpful and guiding us through the menu. We asked what's her favorite thing on the menu. She said not only is this my favorite thing on the menu. It's everyone else's favorite. She suggested the chicken tenders. Not normally something I would order at a restaurant, but boy, I'm glad I took her suggestion. Probably the best chicken tenders we've ever had.

We would highly recommend getting the chicken strips and the truffle fries!!! The patio required a…read moresmall wait, but it was quicker than we expected while we shopped near by and it was worth it to be on the water. There is a new stone pizza oven and would like to try that next time.

Great spot for pizza! Especially gluten free! I mean, it wasn't the BEST but it was very adequate…read more Next time I'd order it with extra sauce. However, my wife LOVED her regular pizza. She said the crust was the best she's had in a long time and she's Italian. Not really but she's been to Italy. Great place, good food.

Stopped at BC Pizza in St. Ignace on a busy night. Fresh pizza, great breadsticks, house ranch was…read morea win. The BBQ on the Hawaiian ran a bit sharp. The dining area felt tight with the to-go crowd, so waiting was a bit cramped. But the staff kept things moving and we left happy.

I have been here a numerous times and somehow have not written a review…read more With overdue the place needs a face lift outside and inside. The staff is great and very welcoming. The food is somewhat hit and miss White fish cakes are phenomenal perfectly crispy on the outside and flaky inside. Burger was huge but was ok needed some seasoning. Chefs white fish creation is definitely different but not bad by any means. Great view of the lake. May be some music in the background during lunch time would make this place a bit more lively.

Always enjoy stopping here on our way to Mackinac. Eat outside so you can enjoy the views of the…read moreMack Bridge and lake. Servers are polite and prompt. Food is average. Nothing to write home about. It's probably best for a quick bite at an affordable price.