Great service good pizza. I will definitely recommend this place. pizza was hot and tasted amazing. Service was good as well.

Food food. Service was fast and efficient. Overall very nice experience and would 100% recommend read more

Neighborhood gem. Great pizza and service! It's fairly small and can get busy but the food is definitely worth it.

Love the local pizza joint vibe with great deals and quality on just about everything. Best chicken Parm sandwich in town to beat

To me it's the best NY style pizza in AtL area if you get the whole pie, the single slices don't do it justice. You gotta get at least a small and get extra cheese in addition to whatever other toppings you want.....you won't be disappointed.... read more

We decided to pickup a pizza from here after reading all the good reviews. It was a short drive from our hotel. There was a board advertising the daily special for one large pizza with one topping and 10 wings for $25. We placed our order and paid. We decided to wait inside the restaurant until our order came up. The decor inside was fun to look at. Very eclectic and dated. Music was blaring and there seemed to be a steady stream of customers picking up their orders. I saw one guy filling cannolis behind the counter. They looked amazing. I wish I ordered one. The wait time wasn't bad for walking in to order. I haven't had a New York style pizza this good in a long time. Everything about it was outstanding. Crust, sauce, cheese and pepperoni. The bbq wings came with ranch dipping sauce. They were nice and hot and had a good coating of bbq sauce on them. I totally recommend this restaurant. Excellent pizza! read more

See all

I don't venture into Lilburn often, but my friends convinced me to stop by and crash their lunch, even though they had already started eating. That being said, I didn't get to experience the food right as it exited the kitchen, but the food I did eat was excellent. My friend couldn't stop raving about the pizza here. Izzy's is a family run restaurant with some down to earth workers. I was impressed with their supreme pizza, which was chockfull of toppings, without causing the toppings to melt off the thinner crust. The Greek Salad wasn't super impressive to me. Sometimes you just need some veggies to balance out the pizza, but I probably wouldn't order it again. If I'm ever in the Lilburn area again (which is pretty rare), I know this is a solid pizza joint to grab a pie from! read more

Izzy's NY Pizza - Slice of supreme - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

This pizza is really good and extremely large. We got 3 (I wanna say) extra large pizzas for my birthday and we had a couple pieces left at the end of the night. The all meat was my favorite and supreme was second. I really wanted some the next day only to find out it was all gone. So we went back and got some calzones. Those things are enormous. It was really good but too much bread for me so I'll stick with the pizza next time but everything we've had here has been really good! read more

The food is always yummy! $it has a great value! The people are so nice ! Ambience for a quick bite! read more

Living in New York and knowing what New York pizza is I have a very high standard especially when a business states they have authentic New York pizza. I was disappointed in this pizza as an "authentic New York" style. The size of the pizza was spot on, slice size was spot on, grease was spot on, unfortunately the sauce flavor and crust was lacking. The salad was an after thought so I probably wouldn't order it again. They do offer authentic Mexican Cokes so that was definitely a bonus! I would recommend going to Izzy's over any commercialized pizza place because Izzy's is a pizzeria!! Therefore always support your locally owned restaurants and chose Izzy's and support local businesses. read more

See all

This is my neighborhood go to pizza joint. I feel lucky that any night I can get a great pie. The owner learned well to create a great NYC style pizza. Trust me if you close to their restaurant give it a try. you will not be disappointed. read more

This is possibly the best pizza in Lilburn. These folks are real New Yorkers and the ingredients are delicious. This is New York style at its best. My only complaint is that they no longer offer their calamari! It was ALSO the best in Lilburn!!! read more

I don't have a lot to say except this is a great neighborhood pizza spot with amazing, fresh ingredients and delicious pizza! I go here whenever I need a slice and highly recommend you do as well! They have whole pizzas, pizza by the slice, plus different pastas, breadsticks, garlic knots, and more. Definitely hit them up if you're in the area. You won't be disappointed!! read more

This place was bomb!!! Definitely NY style and NY taste pizza. We had a pepperoni pizza large slices with plenty of cheese. We had mild wings which were perfectly cooked and great flavor. I definitely recommend this place. We even took one LG pizza to go for the family. This place is a gem! read more

Izzy's NY Pizza - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

I went there yesterday for late lunch. I saw on Yelp the reviews and thought to give it a try. I ordered a slice of olive pizza and a slice of mushroom pizza (I believe $2.25 per slice plus 65ish cents per topping of choice). I waited about 6-7 minutes before the food came out to my table. Right away I could tell that they used a cheese pizza already made beforehand so all they did was put toppings on and put in the oven for couple minutes. I was disappointed because my food was not fresh and was dry. I wanted fresh pizza from scratch and straight out of the oven with sauce and cheese bubbling. Few hours old to day old pizza... no. The guy working was very nice. The place is spacious with plenty of tables. There is Lion Club Park right next to the plaza- it is a nice park where the trail leads you to the Lilburn Park on Main Street. There is also a gigantic, beautiful Hindu temple on the same street which is open to the public. read more

Izzy's NY Pizza - Slice of mushroom pizza and slice of black olive pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

ALWAYS top quality here. We love to get a large Stromboli- we get 2 meals out of it. The homemade sauce is to die for!

Izzy's New York pizza is the most authentic I've had anywhere outside of NY itself. The sauce is right on. I ordered the largest pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, bacon, bell pepper, feta cheese, and extra cheese pizza. It was "to die for" and everything was done perfectly. I also ordered a calzone with feta, pepperoni, mushroom, extra pepperoni, and extra cheese. It was also amazing. One of the things I loved about their pizza toppings was that they don't do that ball sausage, that's frozen and you know it's just that grows "Italian" sausage. There is sausage was the finely sliced, really thin just amazing- that juicy...I don't know- it was SO good. The owners really are from New York and from what they told me, they owned a pizzeria in New York at one time, but moved here in order to bring that taste somewhere that it could be fully appreciated. It didn't take them very long to make my pizza and calzone. It only took about 30 minutes and that was with me ordering the pizza at the counter. I love that they have Stromboli's and calzones. Usually, in Atlanta, you have to go somewhere that's a sit-down restaurant and pay a stupid amount in order to get both in the same sitting. I highly highly highly HIGHLY RECOMMEND Izzy's to anyone wanting a taste of NY or just some amazing pizza! read more

Heard of this spot from my instructor for class and decided to buy a couple pizzas for the class potluck! I ordered ahead of time (1 large cheese, 1 large supreme, and 1 large meat lovers) for a total of $60. When I got there, the place was so busy but it was built like a well oiled machine. Orders were going out, an endless stream of pizzas being made, and customers being taken care of at the register. I took it to go, so not much to say about the location itself, but for the pizza: these slices are HUMUNGOUS -- literally the size of your face. The dough is nice, cooked all the way through, and was still crispy almost 45 minutes later (ATL traffic amiright?). I think if I had a slice fresh out of the box from the oven -- I'd definitely give it more than 5 stars. I've definitely never paid this much for pizza but honestly, I was not disappointed at all. Worth the price! Will drop by for a slice or two if I'm ever in the area. read more

We got a cheese pizza. Closest thing to NY Pizza we've found since moving to Georgia. Service was quick, employees were kind, they had proper precautions set up for covid-19, & the restaurant was sparkling clean. Prices are great. I promise you this is some of the best NY pizza in the Metro Atlanta area. I'll definitely be back soon! read more

Izzy's NY Pizza - Large Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

I've had pizza from NY and it was amazing. I tried a pie from Izzy's and it literally took me back to the place in NY. It's a family business and the family is really down to Earth and friendly. I got a chance to talk to Izzy, it's hard since he works his butt off. He told me his stories from living in NY to moving to Atlanta. He's a great dude and his pies are amazing so he's one of my favorite people already. Food is Environment is Service is read more

Neighborhood eatery that offers by the pie and by the slice. From pizza, to calzones, to wings and salads, everything I've had tasted great. read more

Izzy's NY Pizza - Vegetable calzone. - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

See all

Now that is some good pizza. And I was surprised. Because first glances at this place are deceiving. Small, hole-in-the-wall storefront. Old strip-shopping plaza. Staff that probably speaks neither English nor Italian, nor Brooklyn as a first language. But man, the food they make is outstanding. That was some first-rate pizza! Izzy's serves largely what you'd expect from a pizza place. You can order by the slice if you don't want an entire pie. And they also have Stromboli, calzones, subs, salads, bruschetta, apps, wings, and pasta. The spices just smell right, and most everything is made to order. Still, our food reached out table in good time. My slices were generously large, thin crust, NY style pizza. The sauce had a good flavor. They weren't stingy with the cheese, but nothing was overloaded with it, either. I had two slices that day. I wanted a third, but I behaved. I'll be looking forward to my next visit to Izzy's. Holler if you're coming with. read more

I have gone a couple of times when I want a close to NY slice of pizza. No complaints I have enjoyed the two slices I unusually order when ever I frequent the location. I went to NY last week and did not make a good pizza spot choice , they now have some 99 cent spots. They say you get what you pay for. I will be visiting Izzy very soon. read more

Now that's how you make a pie!!! My dad and I came in for a lunch and everyone was so nice to us. We ordered a large pie and garlic knots. WOW!!! Hot, cheesy, genuine New York pizza. Will definitely be back! read more

Izzy's NY Pizza - AMAZING PIZZA! - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

Terrific pizza! My husband stumbled on this place one day at lunch and now we both crave it at least once a month. It is one of two of our very favorites around! Two thumbs up!!! read more

I normally don't leave a review but this pizza was great. So was the garlic knots. Give them your business. read more

Izzy's NY Pizza - I normally don't leave reviews but this pizza was great. So was the garlic knots. They are legit. Give them you business. - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

Best pizza and wings right here in little old Lilburn!!! Friendly staff and welcoming environment! We will be back! Thanks Izzy!! read more

Great pizza! Past by this restaurant and I had to give it a try being from NY. The sauce was great although I would have liked it to be a little more tomato based, and the crust was a little too doughy. But overall if I'm in the area again i will definitely return. The owner is from Long Island and knows how to make good pizza read more

Izzy's NY Pizza - 2 sausage slices - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

This is a weird review. Placing the order over the phone was simple enough even though I was disappointed that they didn't have delivery. However that's nothing to ding them for. The parking lot was empty with plenty of parking and getting my order was a breeze. I order the 10" pie with black olives and mushrooms. I loved that the mushrooms were fresh and not canned and the cheese was melted perfectly! The crust was thin not by choice but i liked the thinness to it. I also ordered the 6 piece wings with mild and lemon pepper but they made them just mild which was disappointing to find out once I got home! So the food even though it looked AMAZING it was so BLAND!! Like nothing had flavor! The wings barely had any sauce on them and they white spots on them. As if it was old. They didn't taste old but weird looking. I didn't like the food at all! The reviews were so good so I opted here as oppose to the chain restaurants and maybe that was my bad! I had to doctor the pizza up with parmesan cheese and red pepper flakes and every bite of the wings I had to dip into the blue cheese to make it edible. The blue cheese was definitely homemade and the highlight of the entire meal. Would I return, maybe to give them another try because I like the fresh ingredients even though the flavor was bland. However, I definitely will not be in a rush to go back. Also I had to tell one of the employees to change her gloves after coming from mopping the floor to going to retrieve my food. She didn't have a problem doing so and didn't seem offended but being in the restaurant business that should be second nature. Overall the customer service was excellent. Enjoy read more

Best wing in town. Ask for hot and crispy. Amazing. Plain cheese pizza is delicious. read more

Absolutely love this place. Until they found the need to sing an extra charge without telling us for some damn marinara sauce. Considering it was the "owner" who we were supposedly talking to, we' have appreciated the fact that EVERY WEEK we go there. Every week we spend $20/$30 and you argued over an extra marinara sauce in a small container and then tried to hide it in the pricing. Shameful business tactics. We're your local customers. Your regular customer and you got so upset over a small plastic container of marinara sauce! Was it worth our $20/$30 a week that we've been spending for months? Clearly. read more

Every thing is perfect about this spot. The pizza is amazing you have to try there blueberry Lemonade. it has this mom and pop feel.

We're from the northeast and lived in NY for several years. We know pizza. This is legit real deal. Great find for us "damn yankees!" The fact that Izzy's is a small family business, all the better. read more

Amazing pizza! I lived in NYC all my life and this is the best thing you can find in metro Atlanta. The only other place I like here is Rosas but I can say this place is better! Highly recommend this place from a girl from the Bronx who has had the best slices NYC has to offer. read more

This is authentic New York pizza! No better pizza can be found south of New York. The restaurant is owned and operated by a genuine, and friendly family. read more

Izzy's NY Pizza - The best pizza in Atlanta without question! - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

Excellent service and the food is awesomely delicious the price is so affordable and such a great variety of food to choose from.

Excellent pizza. Good atmosphere. Great choice for either a one on one date or a meal with the whole family.

Pretty much a disappointment in every way possible. I went for lasagna since it had a good review but they were out. I got spaghetti and meatballs and it was fair. The pizza was nothing special although apparently the dough is made fresh. read more

Bomb.com. I was tired of the typical pizza chains and really wanted New York style. I went to my trusty yelp app and Izzys came highly recommended. I ordered a Large for the family and added our special mix of ingredients, pepperoni, sausage, onions , green peppers, and pineapples. And it was delicious! The crust is flavorful and crispy, it had the perfect mix of toppings and it wasn't greasy. We'll definitely be eating here when the pizza cravings hit! read more

Izzy's NY Pizza - We call it "The Dillinger" - Pizza Near Me - Lilburn, Georgia

See all

Prices are good Pizza and Pasta were just amazing. I gave a 4 bc the girl at the counter didn't know the answers to any of my questions if she's working there she needs to learn the menu. The cook answered instead of her. Overall though the dinning experience was good and so was the service. read more

See all