We ordered a Boston Cream pie and it was so tasty and beautiful. It was a hit with everyoneread more

Was looking to order a custom cake for a birthday. Tried multiple spots and Tessa's was best with…read moretheir quick turn around without charging crazy additional fee's. Got exactly what I asked for at a reasonable price. The cake itself tasted amazing. Customer service was also phenomenal, she walked the cake to my car to ensure it was at a safe location prior to getting on the road. 10/10 Would definitely recommend.

My cake and cupcakes were fabulous; absolutely the hit of our Baby Shower! We did have some…read moreissues, however, and I will note them after saying: my cake was meticulously decorated and glorious, as were the accompanying cupcakes. I wanted each cupcake decorated to the max, like little cakes. I had trouble finding a baker that would do that, and Incredible Edibles did it without question. The cupcakes were perfect and just lovely. The cake itself was done in almond chiffon and it had white chocolate mousse and raspberry filling. Topped with buttercream almond flavored frosting. It was amazing. Cupcakes were the same and also were filled just amazing! Would use this bakery again in a heartbeat! The problems we ran into: we had to rent the actual tiered cake stand for the cake and cupcakes. I thought this was kind of silly, I don't know if it's commonplace? The cake and cupcakes were very pricey, it really should have been factored in that the cake stand was a necessity and came with the order. It was $55 to rent cake stand, unless I could provide my own. I just thought this was crazy. Additionally, I was responsible for returning the cake stand to the bakery after it's used. I paid to have the cake delivered, it seems that picking the cake stand back up would've been a no-brainer but I don't know. Also, I requested paper lace wraps for the cupcakes and they were not available. These wraps are used all of the time and are even featured on their website. This would've been a simple fix. They could've ordered from Amazon for a few dollars and fulfilled my request, but instead I had to get the wraps and bring them to the bakery. I thought this was kind of a bad customer service issue. Also, there was some confusion in communicating exactly what I wanted. I never did speak to the decorator of the cake. Only a receptionist. I did not want white flowers on my cupcakes. I asked for pink, yellow, and a brighter pink. They came pink, white and yellow. They were gorgeous so it's OK now but it's not really what I wanted and I'm not surprised. If I had it to do over again, I would have gone physically to the bakery, met with the decorator and communicated my ideas on paper. These issues may sound petty, but for the price I paid I should've gotten exactly what I wanted, perfectly and had to do no running around for it. They're also difficult to reach and have very limited office hours. Bringing the lace cupcake wraps and stand to them was complicated by their availability. Just be prepared/aware. There are few bakeries that will do this kind of outstanding cake/cupcake, you'll be very pleased! Price: 70.ish for 3 layer, filled 6" cake, 54. per doz cupcakes + 55. stand rental and 55. delivery=342.ish for really small cake and 36 cupcakes all filled with white chocolate mousse/raspberry. Individually decorated cupcakes. If they'd nailed the cupcake colors and included wraps and stand, I'd absolutely say 5 stars.

As the bride and groom, we wanted to capture the fleeting, unforgettable moments of our big day as…read morewe've been told it goes by in the blink of an eye! We were fortunate enough to receive a recommendation from our wedding venue, Norfolk Botanical Gardens, for an incredibly talented bakery team, Incredible Edibles Bakery, who exceeded our every expectation! We mostly interacted with Debra from Incredible Edibles Bakery, and what struck us most about Debra was her ability to capture, transform and bring to life the ideas we had for the vision of our wedding cake without missing a beat. Her attention to detail and artistic eye brought out the smallest, most tender moments that may have otherwise been overlooked, which led to receiving so many compliments on our wedding cake! Debra and her team are not only masters in creation, but they are also true professionals. They arrived on time, maintained a friendly and approachable demeanor, and made every small detail look perfect. Debra's level of communication is impeccable as she was always willing to answer an email or call whenever we had a question, so we knew we were in good hands the day of the wedding. They were also true champions to set up and maintain our cake throughout our outdoor wedding, on July 12th, in Virginia! During our tasting, the Incredible Edibles Bakery team provided many different ideas and suggestions to make sure we could bring our vision to life in the best and most efficient way possible while staying within budget. They asked an abundance of great questions throughout the process to get a feel for what were our absolute "must haves" and even suggested some things we hadn't thought of. In addition to our wedding cake, we also used a gelato cart from Incredible Edibles Bakery and it was the biggest hit of the night with our guests! The flavors were to die for and the service was outstanding. Working with Debra and her team has been an absolute pleasure from first contact until the end of the wedding day. Their exceptional talent, professionalism, and dedication to their craft makes them a stand out choice in the world of wedding sweets! We wholeheartedly recommend their services to anyone seeking extraordinarily tasty wedding sweets! - The Canavoses

Excellent place to order a cake! Working with them to find a cake style and price point was very…read moreeasy, and their quick and professional communication gave me peace of mind when paying through their secure portal. When the cakes I was interested in were out of my budget, they offered inspiration pictures of what they could do within my budget. The cake looked beautiful and got so many compliments. It was moist and tasty, not dried out like some professional cakes are. When I wanted more of a certain color scheme, they pivoted and accommodated quickly and were very nice about it. The "icing on the cake" of their customer service was that they were worried about the meringue pops melting if I picked it up the night before because of the temperature change from their cake fridge to a regular fridge, so she came in early the next morning so I could pick it up right before the party. So many companies would have left me to deal with that on my own, but they went a step above to make sure I had a cake and experience that I was happy with. Cannot recommend them enough. Thank you Custom Cake Cakery!

I stopped by Custom Cake Cakery today to pick up some cupcakes. I used to come here before when it…read morewas a different bakery years ago. So it was my first time here since they changed. I was greeted right away. The young lady at the counter was nice, she was patient, and she answered all my questions. The store is a vibe. There are beautiful flowers and decor, and it's pretty and clean inside. There's a table inside, but it's not much space to eat there. So it's more of a pickup type of bakery. They had several different flavors of cupcakes in the display which all looked tasty!! They also sell custom cakes and other baked goods. I grabbed my cupcakes but I was taking pics for my review. So as I'm taking pics, I'm smiling and minding my business. A lady walks in and you can tell she was in a bit of a mood. She started talking to the girl behind the counter in a rude tone. So I went on taking my pics, and the counter where the register was, had several boxes, so I sat my cake box down on this little cart that had toppings. I thought it was too cute not to get a pic of. All of a sudden I hear the same tone say "please don't sit anything there"! I wasn't aware she was talking to me at first so, she said ma'am and I turned around. She told me no, don't put anything on that, we take that to shows or for catering. She said it could get scratched up or dinged. I apologized and moved the box. She was still talking. So I said ok. I mentioned there wasn't a sign up or anything to alert me that it was a problem. But I wasn't being rude or weird. I mean it literally was a small dessert box. When we both walked outside I told her I wasn't trying to be rude, I just wasn't fond of how she was speaking to me and thought the sign would help avoid conflicts in the future. She obviously didn't want to talk about it, so she said we never needed a sign because no one has ever done that before!! As if I'd broken some unspoken law. Lol. By this time I was confused as to what I did that was so wrong, I even had to giggle because this small situation didn't warrant her being snappy. I tried to give her grace because I don't know what kind of day she was having. But I'm assuming she's the owner at this point. She should definitely get her tone in check, because customers can pick up on your nice nasty approach. I thought this was going to be a good experience, but it left me confused and a little disappointed. The whole vibe was light and airy before she walked in. As for the cupcakes they were not what I expected. I got a mystery box so it was a mix of cupcakes they pick out that are leftovers from the previous day. But these had to have been from several days ago because each and every one was hard, none were moist. Very heavy cupcakes. There was carrot cake, I think a maple one, lemon blueberry, and chocolate. I noticed the carrot cake one had the after taste of raw flour.. . The chocolate one and the lemon blueberry tasted the best out of all of them, but each one of them had to much extract, except the chocolate one. I'm not just saying this because of the encounter we had. I don't hold grudges, this is an honest reaction. I had been excited to try this place because I have a sweet tooth. Maybe the fresher cupcakes taste better, so I'll give them that. But these weren't good to me. That's just my opinion, but still check them out, maybe it'll be a different experience and you may enjoy the flavors!! Again it's a gorgeous store!!

Our wedding was on July 11th and we ordered from Storybook Bakery because they were the only bakery…read morewho had reasonable prices for a 3-tier wedding cake. Our cake was only $326 which was phenomenal because other places were charging $800-$1,000 for a 3-tier wedding cake. I really loved the user-friendly website they had. Ordering was so simple and easy and I was able to order a gorgeous pre-made, 3-tier cake, that Jessica and Erik were able to add our wedding colors to. The cake was a vintage style cake and it quite elegant. The top two layers were vanilla with the bottom being chocolate. The cake was delicious, moist, with the perfect amount of buttercream icing. The guests absolutely loved the chocolate as it had layers of what looked like fudge in between the layers or cake. The slices were a mile high tall and did I mentioned the moistness of the cake?! It was amazing. The vanilla was delicious as well, but the chocolate was the crowd favorite. Our guests loved the cake. We will be ordering from Jessica and Erik in the future for events and milestones. We also support veteran owned businesses. Look no further if you want a beautiful and reasonably priced wedding cake!

BUYER BEWARE! I would review this as ZERO if I could. I ordered 4 dozen cookies for my daughter's…read morebridal shower. They were delivered on time but EVERY SINGLE cookie was broken into pieces. I immediately contacted the owner, Jessica, via email (that's the only way to communicate with them), she stated that UPS probably mishandled the package and I should send her pictures. UPS had no fault in this, as the box they were in was small and not sturdy and FRAGILE was not marked on the box. The box was squished. It was the way they were packaged and sent that caused the entire contents to be smashed. Once I sent her pictures, she would not respond to me any further, I sent 3 more emails asking for a refund and never got any response. I don't understand how a business can operate like that. I had to file a claim with my CC and finally received the refund. This Jessica does not care about her customers in the least, I was devastated that I could not use the planned cookies as favours for my daughert's shower and scrambled to get something else, 3 days before the event.

I wanted to order a retirement cake and I was at square one trying to find a good bakery. I turned…read moreto good ol' Yelp for suggestions and came across Blue Honey Bakery. I called and was able to get through right away. I was happy to see that the gentleman who took my call (maybe the owner, not sure) already had ideas on how to design it. I was alittle nervous I will admit to get something sight unseen but I had hopes that it would be fine and I was not disappointed. It looked great! And tasted delicious. Everyone had something nice to say how the cake looked at the party. And it was delivered at no charge. That's great service. Would definitely recommend.

I was simply BLOWN away with the cake Eman made for my Dad's 30 year military retirement ceremony…read more They perfectly captured the design I sent to her. I have absolutely no complaints - AND the cake was delicious! It looked just as good as it tasted! I ordered a huge cake, and it was gone within SECONDS. That has never happened before. I also wanted to applaud the excellent customer service - they are not open on Sundays, but they still delivered the cake to our home (with 4th of July weekend traffic, mind you) regardless. I cannot recommend them enough. I need to plan more parties so I can order more cakes. Thanks again!

The cake was delicious and beautiful. Tonja was responsive and creative on this request for a…read morecombination cake for two different grandaughters. The process was very convenient as we were visiting form out of town

Tonja is amazing to work with. Not only are her cakes divine, but she is also a warm, inviting…read moresoul. We ordered the strawberry cake for my aunt's 75th birthday. The cake was delicious and the decorations were perfect. The cake was so good that we ate some for breakfast the next day. Please look her up if you're in the Sandbridge area!

Oh My Stars!! Five stars to be exact and if I could give…read moremore I would. This place is fan-tas-tic!! We tried it on a whim about a month ago, then I had them at my daughter bridal shower and will have again at her wedding. I love them- service was great each time!! This is a must do!!

I have a new obsession everyone, and it is this heaven sent bakery. This place really took me by…read moresurprise in the best way. I came in, and immediately you smell freshly baked goods, it felt like the cartoons where the smell of a pie in the window drags you by the nose to the dessert itself lol. I immediately walked to the counter and was greeted by the sweetest man ever! He was so kind, willing to ask questions, and had such a smile! We went over the options they had, as they have a rotating menu (I love a good rotating menu! Keeps you on your toes!). We went with various options. My favorite was the DOUBLE CRUST CHEESECAKE! People don't get it, something about the crust is just so....perfect. We've gotta start doing more double crush cheesecakes out there! I also did espresso, sweet potato, and a chocolate one! I also added cookies, brownies, and cupcakes. Everything was soft, fresh, moist, and the flavor profiles were perfect. Every flavor we ordered tasted exactly like what we were looking for. That sweet potato pie cheesecake one was amazing. The guy at the front even gave us a free cookie as a first timer. We've gone twice now and I must say I WILL be a regular. They can count on that. 10/10, no notes at all. Not a single one, which is not easy for a loud mouth NYer like me! Hahaha. I am a fan!

Discovered this bakery while visiting another establishment. The service was okay. I purchased the…read morebanana pudding and it tasted like the box pudding. There were hardly any bananas in it and there were a lot of cookies. There is no seating and it is small inside.

Gimme the Sweets - Just got a chocolate chip cookie…read more - A small business that runs out of pastries fast! - great service!