While the old-time charm of this little shop on the Boardwalk, where you can buy saltwater taffy by…read morethe pound, is quite inviting, the taffy itself was a bit of a letdown. It consistently stuck to the wrapping paper, even when kept at a stable temperature. I even tried refrigerating it, but it still had an undesirable, overly soft consistency that melted right onto my teeth. I was hoping for a firmer taffy. The variety flavors were abundant though!

Like any other salt water taffy/candy shop on the boardwalk, but unlike the other shops they have…read moreJersey made taffy!!! Definitely worth giving a look when in the area.

Had to stop at my favorite candy shop in Wildwood while visiting for Mack's opening day last…read moreweekend. Delicious fudge, pretzels, buttercreams. Staff is always friendly and helpful. They had gluten free options as well as sugar free. We also paid $10 to use their parking lot in the back for the few hours we were visiting. Always a great experience here. An absolute MUST when in the area for our family.

Pretty good fudge! Most of the prices are decent but some are not. They repackaged maybe 2 dollars…read moreworth of werthers into a box and priced it at 9 . However, the chocolates that they make in there are pretty good. The raspberry filled one tasted like real raspberries. The Irish potato's is a coconut and cinnamon pastry thing. DELICIOUS! the taffy is something I'm not a fan of however. I'd definitely come here again. You can buy buy the box or individually. The chocolate covered marshmallows aren't bad either. Decent variety of pieces :)

Met the owner Jason, he was super friendly and helpful. All the staff were welcoming. The fudge…read moreand taffy are amazing!!!

I was introduced this place several years ago with my first visit to Wildwood NJ. I've been in love…read moreever since! We even did a taste comparison to all the taffy places at Wildwood and several beaches nearby. Hands down Douglas wins! They even will mail you an order with a hand written thank you note. One time, I bought a pound of cream mints and several were on the dry side. They sent me a whole new pound container free of charge. Amazing! By the way, the cream mints are delicious. Great for those, myself, who can't eat a lot of chewy candy. Talk about customer service......Great!!! It's always clean inside, well stocked and always with a helpful staff. I already have my Christmas order started

I'm kinda spoiled because I always go to The Original Fudge Factory but my sister in law was…read moreintrigued by the welcoming smell and the sight of the fudge worker making the whipped creamy fudge on two large tables. I was intrigued by the slabs of whipped up light fudge. That was delicious! I loved the caramel vanilla sea salt. I tried the slab style fudge , the chocolate praline and my sample was dry without any caramel to speak of. The help is very friendly and the whipped old fashioned fudge is spectacular ! I would recommend that but I would personally stay away from the slabs of fudge although my son tried the jelly donut fudge slab style fudge and he loved it! The apples look unbelievable!! My brother and sister in law were very pleased with their fudge purchases and returned the following evening!

If you have ever been on Wildwood's boardwalk, you'd know that there are tons of fudge shops and…read morethey are all having a special sale today! The sales clerks stand outside and tell you about "tonight's special," buy 2 lbs of fudge and get a free box of salt water taffy. If you live in a sea-side town you know that this is the same special that has been offered everyday since the beginning of time. (Not literally, but it's been the same special since I was a fetus. Only the prices have gone up.) If you're in town, don't get fooled by the "special." Check local papers for a coupon. Every fudge shop on the boardwalk offers them. (Fudge Kitchen, Laura's Fudge, Douglas Fudge...etc.) Over the years I have tried every fudge shop on the boardwalk and I think Fudge Factory is the best. It is the only place I ever buy fudge from. The shop isn't fancy by any means, it looks just like all the others, but it's the actual fudge and it's flavors that make this shop stand out. The variety at Fudge Factory is leaps and bounds above it's competition. With amaretto swirl, jalapeno pepper, watermelon and apple pie...I think this shop is in a league of it's own. (Well at least it is in Wildwood.)

Nothing looked American made. The lady behind the counter didn't talk to any customer who walked…read morein. I would have been happy to purchase some chocolate bars if I had any idea what any of it was. There were no samples or easily understood flow to the layout. I was a tourist so it was silly for me to take a chance on a foreign chocolate I would have no idea where to get it again if I enjoyed it.

This is the type of spot that you just wander in & take it ALL in. The aroma of chocolate is…read moreintoxicating & everything is so beautifully displayed you almost don't want to to touch anything. Randomly walked in & was very happy with the selection as I was in gifting mode. Extremely friendly staff & happy I found this gem.

Very sweet lady working when I was there on 7/12/21. The candy I bought was delicious and my dog…read moreLOVED the homemade dog treats a bought for her. Ill definitely be back for more! The taffy wrapping machine in the window, I believe is named "Rosie", is cool and interesting. Its worth stopping in for something sweet!

I want to like this place but the fudge we got was disappointing. The peanut butter mixed with…read morechocolate fudge had little flavor. No peanut butter taste at all. Just super sweet. The chocolate with nuts had very little chocolate flavor. The chocolate mint was not very minty and overly sweet. Sad. It seems as a good cause for teachers but flavors are lacking. Good price but not for what was received. I looked forward to some real good flavors. Unfortunately, I'll stick to the competitors next time.

Great fudge from a great small busines. Because of COVID they have moved to Gurney street across…read morefrom Avondale by the sea. Better quality and service than you will get from those chain store.

Best fudge in Cape May! Every year my family goes down the shore to Cape May and every year we do a…read morefudge challenge. It is a great reason to purchase lots of fudge. Seaside Sweets is hands down the winner.

This was the worst fudge I've ever had. I love sugar and thought my capacity for dessert…read moreconsumption was endless so when I saw they had a 25% off 1/2 pound deal I thought it was a great deal and I bought the turtle and vanilla/nut flavors. It is pretty dry and way too sweet. I offered it up to my family and after some samples it has sat uneaten for a week and I will ultimately throw it out.

Located in The Spinnaker building in the south tower on the boardwalk side. Small shop with cheesy…read moreold school shore decorations that can barely fit 6 or so people inside. Has a nice selection of candy and fudge. Prices are by the quarter pound and can add up fast but we got a small bag of candy for only a few bucks. We did pay by credit card which somehow required the cashier to run next door to another shop to run the card. Probably easiest to bring cash.