Personally, for me no hotdog will ever top what you can get here! These are the best thing to grace, my stomach, and I don't know if it's the nostalgia talking or they've just been doing it that well since I've came onto this earth. However, it's great, consistent, and always cheap. My family has always eaten Jay's, I feel like they're hot dogs are integral to being from this part of Ohio. On this day, I placed a relatively large order sadly, a portion of my order ended up on the floor because it fell through the paper bag, and my small fry was forgotten. But what we could eat was amazing. I don't think I've ever eaten hotdog that quickly in my life, and I never will because they just won't be as good as the ones I get here. It wasn't crazy inside, yet there was another party, placing an order, and a few people dining in inside. The space is pretty small though, so just a few people can feel like a lot. The concept is pretty open so you can see the hotdog rolling around on the grill in the back once you make your way in. You can't go wrong with a classic one, with chili cheese, onions, and mustard all the good stuff I prefer shredded over liquid cheese, but either options are great honestly, if you have a chance, just get them both you won't regret it and with a side of chili cheese fries too. read more

See all

Amazing food!!! Great service. Very reasonably priced Workers are so friendly!!!. Food is delicious every time!!! Affordable!!!!

Jay and Silent Bob own this. Silent Bob is a Silent Partner, of course. The Gyro and the attitude did nothing, nor hot dog I got a Hot Dog and a Gyro, and the prices were pretty damn decent. The hot dog was ok, but definitely not something I would ever go back for. The wait time is eternal when they're busy. About 5 people in line ahead of me and about 10 mins to get served and 5 to 7 more for the food. Wasn't expecting that. At least the prices are ok. But my goodness, their Republican, good-old-boy signs are so awful. Proud Republican, met all the Republican presidents, member of Republican party. Most of your customers are dirt poor blue collar NE Ohio types who have barelya spare dollar. They're not interested in your capitalist ideologies. Keep them out of the restaurant, no? I mean, sure, free country, free speech, you can put what you want on your wall and then I can rip the sh** out of you on Yelp for it. Welcome to America. The Gyro meat was pretty good actually, and generous in terms of portion and price, but the bread was cold and it tasted sweet which is ew. I mean the bread and veggies on this thing, and the white sauce, were so bad that I gave 4 fifths of it away. Disappointed AF. Picked off some of the meat though. Nom. Anyway I may be a bit Jay ded by now. But for Gyros in NE Ohio, try Best Gyros (both locations) East of the CLE. Or Gyro World in the West burbs. read more

See all

Jay's Jay's Jay's. It is a must stop when I come home to visit. This place is grimy, greasy and I LOVE IT. Jay's with everything....mustard, chili and onions...LOTS OF ONIONS. The gyros, lamb and chicken and the fresh cut French Fries doused in vinegar. NOM NOM NOM to all!!! Is it the best dog Ive ever had? No. But it is a Youngstown area staple and you will NOT be disappointed. read more

Jay's Famous Hot Dogs - Hot Dogs Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

Was a long time customer for about 45 years, always have been the go to place for dogs and gyros, except within the past several years has drastically gone downhill. Once Frank was gone, so was the quality. read more

Great seeing Greg today and having a famous lunch at Jay's! I had the Gyro which was fabulous. We also had dogs, fries and Spanakopita - all excellent. Haven't visited here in years and it didn't disappoint. read more

Jay's Famous Hot Dogs - Seth, Rosemary, Greg and Andy outside of Jay's. - Hot Dogs Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

Having Lunch at Jay's Famous Hot Dogs in Boardman, Ohio. A great local Hot Dog Shop in The Youngstown area. With Locations in Boardman and North Lima. Having two Hot Dogs, Fiery Chicken Strips and A Chocolate Milkshake. It's all very good and tasty. Remember to support your local small businesses! A great place to grab lunch. Open Monday-Saturday from 10 AM to 4 PM. North Lima hours could be different. Located at 68 Boardman Canfield Rd. Boardman, Ohio. read more

Jay's Famous Hot Dogs - They have pretty good milkshakes. Made with real milk. - Hot Dogs Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

See all

100 years of Hot Dog Goodness. Jays HotDogs / Jay's Famous Hot Dogs in Boardman. I wasn't too ambitious just two chili dogs with Onions no sides. Over the years this is probably my eighth visit. Solid, consistent hot dog with great homemade chili sauce. No-frills. Cash only. What you see is what you get. read more

See all

I ordered 4 chilli cheese dogs with onion and chilli cheese fries with onions. There were no onions and when I called I was told by the cashier that she asked if I wanted onions and I didn't answer. I said I wanted onions so they didn't ask and if they had asked and I hadn't answered wouldn't you ask again thinking the customer hadn't heard you. Instead I got the "you're an idiot, I asked if you wanted onions you should have replied" treatment. I just wanted some onions put on my food. I will never eat there again and wouldn't suggest it to anyone else. Mistakes get made, that is fine but don't act like I am an idiot. Every chilli cheese dog I ever ordered I ordered with onions. Worst customer service ever. read more

I don't think the hotdog was particularly good. It was cheap but pretty small. The chilli on top was just ok. The gyro was not really different from street vendors. Perhaps this location was not particularly good... We ordered our food to go thinking that we would sit outside. When we saw that the outside seating was wet from the afternoon rain, we wanted to eat inside. However, the people in the store said it would cost an extra dollar to sit inside. I thought that was kinda lame. We gave a good tip when we paid. For them to ask for a dollar made it seem like they didn't really want people to sit inside. read more

Jay's Famous Hot Dogs - Hot Dogs Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

See all

I've been going to his place for hotdogs my entire life. Anytime I'm back in Youngstown I definitely stop through and grab a few.

There's something special about this place....inside and out. This is a very basic GFS hot dog 70/30 pork/beef....but the time it spends on the flat top gives it a nice flavor. Now I wasn't blown away by this place and it certainly wasn't one of the best dogs I've ever had.....BUT you have to acknowledge that this is a wonderful dive in a "non strip mall" setting where you can grab an everything hot dog for $1.20. I had two dogs inside....went out to my car and said to myself....."OK....one more". I had another loaded dog to go....drove to the back of the parking lot along the fence and had a cold beer with that dog......bliss. The only thing better than the dogs is the character this place exudes. read more

See all

The chili dogs are awesome! It a nice thicker chili sauce with a little bit of zing to it. Very tasty!

Love the grape leaves. They are not typical. Most places use the pickled grape leaves, and the taste is a little bitter, which is good. But the grape leaves at jays are larger more stuff than any others I have had. And they are tender. They taste like they have been steamed in chicken stock. Really a great taste. And the dogs are great, and cheap. The chili sauce is your typical Greek style chili sauce. Couple hot dogs with chili and onions some mustard. Order of grape leaves. Good lunch, or dinner, they got burgers, that lemon egg chicken soup. Good food. Cheap. read more

I am a strong fan of this place, although I feel like at any moment this place is going to be shut down by the health department. Aside from the greasy, dinginess and potential from getting Hepatitis just from sitting there.....I enjoyed the food. This is a nickel and dime you place. They charge for everything. But the Gyro is whats up and the greasy fries are pretty good. They would be a lot better if they made them extra crispy and salted them generously. All in all its a good place for some quick eats read more

My first experience with Jay's was at the one in North Lima that I thought was great so was excited to try the one in Boardman. Not sure where to start my review as i kinda feel like I should give them just one star as the place really does give new meaning to the term "greasy spoon" but their gyro is so tasty that just isn't fair so giving them a solid 3. While eating I watched a steady stream of regulars coming in for their hot dogs for lunch and the guys working knew every single one of them so how can you go wrong? It's definitely a dive, greasy and grimy so if that bothers you this is not your place to go but you'll be missing out on a tasty experience that is a Youngstown institution. read more

Used to go to Jays while growing up in Y town. Have not been here in 15 years. Place is the greatest hole in the wall u will ever try. Love the chili dogs and Gyros. Great hangover food. Cheap prices and greasy food. Had lunch for 6 and bill was $34. read more

Jay's Famous Hot Dogs - Greatest sign.....EVER - Hot Dogs Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

Best Gyro in Ohio Chili Dogs are the best. Im a Chili Dog Connoisseur read more

I had the gyro for lunch and I wasn't real impressed. It was so so. On the plus side it came out really fast. I'm also not real wowed by the shop itself. It's greasy. Everything is greasy - seats, tables, floor. I've driven past here for years and just thought I would stop in and try it out today. read more

This place is absolutely terrible, first of all the place is filthy...saw flies all around. The food wasn't much better as far as quality, it was very bland tasting and the cheese for the fries tasted like it sat for way to long. Surprised this place hasn't failed a health inspection yet. read more

I've only eaten here once, but I know a good chili dog when I get one... and these were not. They were not particularly bad, but they sure wouldn't be called ''famous''. The chili was watery and bland, the bun was a bit too doughy, and the dog itself was low quality. The fries were only ''ok''. I won't bother to go back. I've had a lot better. read more

Favorite hot dog place in THE WORLD! Whenever I come back from California I eat here. Great Gyro's as well. Definitely a dive, but part of what makes it a great local place and not a chain. read more

Jay's is an experience. Everyone who works there is a ball of personality / wit / humor / kindness, (and they always remember who you are / where you work / random stuff you may have told them) The prices are unbeatable, and if they cleaned the place up it just wouldn't taste the same!! -- joking... but, although it's far from pristine inside it has the character and hole-in-the-wall charisma that is lacking in so many chains and other generic places. It's also important to note that at first glance the apparent cleanliness may throw a newbie or picky person off I have NEVER in over 20 years had any concern about the food or it's cleanliness. You can eat here for under $4 with two "Everything" dogs and a fry, or knock it out the park with a gyro and a chili cheese fry for under $10. Definitely a valley staple, and any naysayers are too prissy to ever be satisfied. Hand-cut fries, REAL cheese, and the BEST chili sauce ever. Keep Rockin' read more

Yum ! This isn't a food snob Facility by no means , truly a workin mans place for a fair price meal ( ok p.c.... womans & whatevha's too). For as long as this orange roof oasis has graced our lovely Boardman, I've been enjoying a tasty e.t. dog + lg fries ;honest- regular- wonderful people serve up the finest grub Ive had the pleasure of dining on , enjoy eatin mine outside the work truck , can get rather messy at times... my fault for being a fiend, stand and hunch - hits the spot everytime ; I like to bring my own vinegar / salt packs = perfect fair fries ... Deeelishious!!! read more

Only the best hot dog shop in Ohio. I get excited just thinking about those greasy dogs in the wax paper inside a brown paper bag..... Yes..this isn't fitness food, its the real deal (contruction worker hard day's work kind of food) that'll keep you full till dinner. Their fries are great ...especially with cheese. Lets just say that all dogs should come with greek sauce, onions and mustard. Jay's understands this. read more

Let me start off by saying that I used to frequent Jay's a lot back in the day. I haven't been there in ages and had a craving so I went to rekindle my youth. With that being said... This is absolutely the most filthy, dirty, disgusting food establishment that I have ever been in. The dirt and grease is on everything. My shoes were literally sticking to the floor. The grime on the garbage can was probably 5 years thick. I have no idea how the health department doesn't make them clean this place up. read more

I wish I could be more generous with my stars but I really used to like this place when the original owner Frank had it . The recipes are still the same and taste pretty good. But there's something I learned while being in the restaurant business, if the customers can see the "filth" what they don't see is really bad ! You can still have good taste and be clean, even a little clean would help. This place is beyond filthy , even the employees look unkept and dirty, very carny like. Maybe someone should be looking into the health department to see how easy it may be to bribe an official. Clearly someone isn't doing they're job ligit. Sorry for the harsh review, but this place shouldn't be allowed to operate like this. Save your $1.20 for your loaded hot dog , it's not worth it . read more

Jays is the most authentic, traditional coney dog on the planet. I've been a fan since the 50's when the dogs were going for 10 cents. No frills and not for the modern "foodie". Just the real thing. read more

The best hole in the wall ever. Gyro chili dog and a shake, yum!

As with the other reviews, this place feels like a tetanus shot or Hep A outbreak waiting to happen. But the dogs are pretty good, as was the shake. They used real cheese on the fries and not that nacho cheese crap. But seriously people, clean the place up. Duct taped garbage can? For real? read more

During a recent visit to Jay's my experience was very basic and bland to say the least. The food was very reasonably priced and came out quick...but the overall cleanliness of the restaurant is severely lacking. I took my food to go because I did not want to sit in the restaurant because of its condition. If anything I believe a long overdue visit by the health department is in order. My hotdog was ok and fries way to done. If your looking for low quality food then this is your place...otherwise I would not recommend visiting this place. read more

This place is a Boardman institution, which I respect, but it is showing its age with a very dirty, dingy interior. The gyro I had left a weird chemical taste in my mouth. The fries were limp, greasy, and flavorless. My first meal there were a couple of hot dogs, which were fine. Don't know if I'll be back. PRobably not. read more

Best hot dog and gyro place in the Youngstown area. Dogs are huge, chili sauce is excellent and when you get a large fry it is huge. Great prices all around. read more

This place has the best chili dogs,fries the gryos are great. It has not changed In years. Yes it is a throwback place with the old pics of Boom Boom and other local celebs. read more

"Just" a greasy spoon... BEST GYRO in the area. Get a Jays (with everything) for a great chili dog. Home made fries ... make sure you douse them with malt vinegar and salt. Been a customer for years! read more

Great food! But run down and old location. So dirty inside makes me sick. They also only take cash which is very annoying. Wouldn't recommend unless your just picking food up. read more

For those old timers Jays started in downtown Youngstown, I believe around the WWII days. The steel mills were busting at the seams and after work the mill workers dove in for Jays for hotdogs and a cold beer. Jays was a blue collar place for the working man ( no such thing for casual wear, come as you are ) . Old Jay would line up about 6 to 8 hot dogs on his sweaty harry arm up to his arm pit and slap some mustard and ketchup on with a paint brush, people did not care because the dogs were so good. If you had a hangover from too much booze a Jays hotdog was the perfect antidote to rid you from a hangover. I wish Jays were back down town again, truly miss those days! Truly miss those days, Richard... read more

Yes, this place leaves something to be desired when it comes to cleanliness and you'll most likely get a verbal battering if you stand dumfounded looking at the menu while there is a line behind you but If you want a killer, reasonably priced gyro or hotdog this is the place. For those of you who cry about the cleanliness and staff, feel free to go across the street and pay triple for food that tastes like cardboard. read more

Great gyros & chili dogs. Also love the fries. You get a HUGE portion for the larger size-big enough for a whole family

The only thing I can think of when people tell me that Jay's is amazing is that they've never been outside of the northeastern Ohio area. Amazing? Um, no not exactly. How about greasy, small, flavorless, stale buns, I could cook a better hotdog at home in less time and with less money? That's more like it. read more