Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    McGuire's Coney Island

    1.0 (1 review)
    Closed 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

    McGuire's Coney Island Photos

    You might also consider

    More like McGuire's Coney Island

    Recommended Reviews - McGuire's Coney Island

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 years ago

    first time there chili sauce was cold. Second time hot dogs were cold. WONT be back. Cant beat Jays

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - McGuire's Coney Island

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for American 537 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Jay's Famous Hot Dogs

    Jay's Famous Hot Dogs

    3.8
    (49 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    $

    Personally, for me no hotdog will ever top what you can get here! These are the best thing to…read moregrace, my stomach, and I don't know if it's the nostalgia talking or they've just been doing it that well since I've came onto this earth. However, it's great, consistent, and always cheap. My family has always eaten Jay's, I feel like they're hot dogs are integral to being from this part of Ohio. On this day, I placed a relatively large order sadly, a portion of my order ended up on the floor because it fell through the paper bag, and my small fry was forgotten. But what we could eat was amazing. I don't think I've ever eaten hotdog that quickly in my life, and I never will because they just won't be as good as the ones I get here. It wasn't crazy inside, yet there was another party, placing an order, and a few people dining in inside. The space is pretty small though, so just a few people can feel like a lot. The concept is pretty open so you can see the hotdog rolling around on the grill in the back once you make your way in. You can't go wrong with a classic one, with chili cheese, onions, and mustard all the good stuff I prefer shredded over liquid cheese, but either options are great honestly, if you have a chance, just get them both you won't regret it and with a side of chili cheese fries too.

    Amazing food!!! Great service. Very reasonably priced Workers are so friendly!!!. Food is…read moredelicious every time!!! Affordable!!!!

    Photos
    Dining Area
    Dining Area
    Menu / Kitchen
    Menu / Kitchen
    Menu

    See all

    Menu
    Jay's Famous Hot Dogs

    Jay's Famous Hot Dogs

    3.5
    (12 reviews)
    5.1 mi
    $

    Jay's in N. Lima is closed. Now have to go to Boardman for Jay's. So sorry to see them close…read more Gyros, burgers but hot dogs were their best.

    Ok, this is a perfect example of a place that should get 3.5 stars; definitely better than a 3 star…read morebut a few things would knock it below 4. Let me explain: This is the definition of fast-food AND greasy spoon. You need to know that before you visit. If you are looking for a "restaurant" this is not the place for you. However, if you understand that some of the best food, and food experiences, come from the most unlikely places, then enjoy my friend! Small place with a drive-thru. Inside has 4 tables and 7 stools. Grill is right behind the counter so you see everything they do. I ordered the #6 Hungry Man because I wanted to try both a gyro and a hot dog. Let's talk about the food: Gyro - It was really, really good. The pita was perfect and the meat had great flavor. The negative on the gyro was the tzatziki sauce; it was incredibly runny and didn't have a very strong flavor (3.8 stars). My only guess is that it is watered down. Even still, I really enjoyed the gyro. Hot dog- They call them "Jays" and there are a lot of ingredient options. I went with mustard and chili. This is obviously why the place is called Jay's Famous HOT DOGS. This is the way to go! The hot dog was great. The chili had an awesome taste: kinda smokey and peppery. The bun was very fresh too which was unexpected to be honest. On future visits, I will definitely just get hot dogs! Fries- Fresh cut. There was basically no salt so I had to add quite a bit. They may have been just a little undercooked too. However, I still thought they were good and had no problem eating all of them. But...it is one thing that would keep the stars below 4 so keep that in mind. (3.6 stars) I ate in and as I was eating there was a steady crowd of people coming in and going through the drive-thru. The girls behind the counter did a great job but I did see more than a few people wait 10+ minutes for their food. (3.5 stars) Just know that if you visit right at lunch time you might end up waiting a little bit. If that happens, be patient!! Long review but some important things to know about this place. If you are considering it, I say go for it! Enjoy the atmosphere, experience, and surprisingly good food.

    Photos
    Jay's Famous Hot Dogs
    Counter and grill
    Counter and grill
    Ordering area and stool seating at front window.

    See all

    Ordering area and stool seating at front window.
    Riser Tavern and Grill

    Riser Tavern and Grill

    4.4
    (75 reviews)
    2.5 mi
    $$

    The reviews were good so instead of another place we came here. It's 1:40pm on a Sunday. We were…read moregiven a brunch menu (very limited) thought about leaving so we could get a burger but decided since we have 8.5 hours left to drive we would just get something. Not 5 minutes after we place an order the table behind us gets a full menu, with burgers and sandwiches on it. Am I a bit PO'd.... YEP Also the waitress doesn't smile. She looks miserable, geez, at least make an effort! So I ordered chicken and waffles and my husband ordered a few wings. As for the food..... The chicken tenders are AAMazing! Waffle is good and the hubs like the ginger lime wings although a small side of sauce and a few celery and carrots would make a better presentation. But for the diamond in the rough. I can only assume it was the manager/owner that delivered our food. I asked why we had a limited menu as I read here on Yelp I should have the prime grilled cheese. This man offed it to me on the house now that is some great customer service. I had to decline bc we have such a long drive ahead of us but he hands down was so kind. So I'm going with 4 stars. To sum this up I would happily come back just bc of his kind service! As we were finishing up Doug the owner came by again and he is a great reason to visit this place. He definitely has a heart for customer service!! Thanks Doug

    Don't judge a book by its cover, or in this case, a restaurant by its exterior. I almost made that…read moremistake when I walked into this place. What looks like a nondescript bar with a modern twist is actually a goldmine of appetizers. My family of five descended upon the place today and we ordered a slew of appetizers. Let me tell you, it was a feast for the ages. The place was immaculate, the staff was warm and welcoming, and the service was impeccable. I had a hard time choosing a favorite, but if I had to pick, it would be the Brussels sprouts and crab Rangoon dip, closely followed by the lime wings. We're all from different parts of town, but we'll definitely be back. It's a hidden gem worth discovering.

    Photos
    Bar
    Bar
    Riser Tavern and Grill
    Sriracha Chicken sandwich

    See all

    Sriracha Chicken sandwich

    McGuire's Coney Island - tradamerican - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...