Jerry&#x27;s Subs and Pizza

When we arrived we were seated immediately and everyone was super nice. But I did note that our…read moretable and the floor around our table was dirty and the place had a slight smell. They had a large menu of options where I wanted to try everything on the menu because it looked so good. I ended up ordering the shrimp and scallop alfredo. The shrimp and the scallop were huge and delicious. Alfredo sauce itself was lacking a lot of flavor. I had to add my own salt and pepper and garlic powder. My husband ordered the chicken parmesan and he said the same. It looks really good but it was lacking flavor. Although we had a good experience and the service and atmosphere was fine, we probably will not come back due to the lack of flavor in their dishes.

Side-by-side, I would prefer Olive Garden. And, for the record, I'm not a fan of Olive Garden…read more We stopped here to meet friends for dinner. It was our first and probably last visit. (I couldn't pick from those two opening lines and figured I would include them both.) I had their Chicken Marsala. The chicken was bone dry. The brown sauce was brown and tasteless. The pasta was overcooked. On the plus side, the bread was pretty good. However, not good enough to redeem the rest of the meal.

The view from the front door

The bread that accompanied the entrees.

See all

The tiramisu

La Bella Italia

3.1(134 reviews)

4.0 mi

This place has been closed for a while after covid owner couldn't make it! A shame loved the pizza.read more

Absolutely would not recommend. I went in asking about pizzas, the owner (?) seemed pissed off…read morethat I was looking at a posted menu and said that they only make pizzas. I tried to order one and half the ingredients from the menu attached to the counter they did not have. We worked through that and when I started a second pizza order the guy blew up and started yelling saying you should have called in for more than one pizza (I would have if there was a menu to find!). I just said never mind and left. Next thing I know, this guy is outside yelling at me calling me a f **** guy and A**** plus a lot of other cursing and yelling, I just stopped listening. I am a pretty easy going person and the Pizza may be good but not worth the attitude i experienced. Would have left a negative if possible!

See all

MOD Pizza

3.6(81 reviews)

0.3 mi

Has gone downhill dramatically. Veggies tonight were clearly old -- visibly brown broccoli I could…read moresee as she was making my pizza. Lots of the veggies looked old and were spilling into each other on the prep deck. The plant-based sausage I ordered was clearly real sausage; looked and tasted totally different than any plant-based sausage I had at MOD before! Dough a little sour, and red onions were just as bad tasting. A few hours after and I am feeling nauseous.

So good!!!!!! First timer at this location. I Will definitely be back! This is the best location…read moreI've been to. Food was nice and fresh. The service was great. Probably one of the best pizzas I've had. Will visit again when I'm in the area

The front windows and doors

Customized pizza

See all

Ledo Pizza

2.1(69 reviews)

0.5 mi

The service is always wonderful in Dunkirk. It was a busy Monday evening, and I didn't wait very…read morelong for my my pizza. This is one of the cleanest local Ledo of the four in the area.

Came here to try out their Pizza. I got my husband sausage one, and I got the cheese oh my God, the…read morecheese was amazing. I don't know what kind of cheese they use, but oh it was tastey really good, I will be back

See all

Chesapeake Grille & Deli

3.9(215 reviews)

0.2 mi

It was clean Music was pleasant…read moreDining room was 3/4 full, but the noise level was quite minimal Service was prompt and pleasant Food was very good and enjoyed it immensely Prices were quite manageable I will visit there again All around a very nice place to have lunch

Really gone downhill. If a Rachel is pastrami, cheese, Thousand Island, and coleslaw what is minus…read morethe cheese and slaw!? Food this pricey needs to be prepared better!

Cream of crab soup

See all

To go creamy crab soup

Papa Johns Pizza

2.3(23 reviews)

2.3 mi

Just order from somewhere else & save yourself the headache. They don't follow simple instructions…read more The app gives you the option for contactless delivery they show up and leave with the food because no one answered the door. IT'S CONTACTLESS.

Love the staff at this location! Orders are always on time! Food is consistent…read more Great option for a quick a meal!

See all

Harris Teeter

3.2(35 reviews)

0.6 mi

The pharmacy staff are Top Notch, My Prescription was ready when I arrived and Patricia M. Answered…read moreall of my questions. I felt welcomed at this pharmacy, unlike the nearby competition. Thank you

Always well stocked with excellent customer service. Clean…read more Great lighting. Pick up lane/parking for easy retrieval of call ahead orders. They also have a RX pick up lane

See all

Skipper's Pier

3.7(510 reviews)

6.6 mi

Great location at the end of a small town road and on the shore. Big dining rooms and a fun bar…read more Service was just ok. Young girl didn't want to be there but I get it. Probably a summer job. Crab soup was a 5. Delicious with chuck of crab. Fish Tacos a 5. Big, well seasoned fish with a corn salsa. Could have used more sauce. Crab cake was a 5. Choices are blackened, fried, or broiled. Went with broiled and it was excellent. Great cakes here with not too much filler. Fries and onion rings a 3. Nothing special. Orange crush. cocktails are a thing here. Refreshing for sure. Ok selection of beers on tap.

We came to Skipper's for the Mrs. Maryland Club sandwich. The last time my wife and I were here, we…read moreremembered just how delicious this sandwich was, so we decided to make the trip back. We arrived around 6:30 PM and were surprised to see the parking lot pretty empty. We sat at the bar and were greeted quickly by the bartender, who took our drink order. Both of us ordered the Mrs. Maryland Club, which is made with shrimp salad, a crab cake, bacon, lettuce, and tomato. The sandwich arrived fairly quickly and looked good, but right away we noticed something seemed different from our last visit. The biggest disappointment was the size of the crab cake and amount of shrimp salad. The last time we were here, the crab cake covered the entire sandwich and shrimp salad was falling off the sandwich. It was one of the reasons we remembered it so fondly. This time, the crab cake was noticeably smaller just a little bigger than a golf ball the shrimp salad was just 7 baby shrimp and the chips I got maybe 12-15 chips and half of them were rubbery, overall the sandwich just didn't seem as substantial as we remembered. The little shrimp salad had good flavor, the bacon was cooked nicely, and everything tasted fresh. It just didn't live up to the memory of our previous visit, not worth $21 for sure. Service was friendly, and the food came out quickly. The atmosphere was relaxed, and as always, the waterfront location is a nice place to enjoy a meal. Overall, the Mrs. Maryland Club is still a good sandwich, but based on our experience, the portions seem to have gotten a lot smaller. We'll likely return again, but we hope to see the sandwich brought back to the size and quality that made it so memorable the first time.

Main inside room

Seafood Steamer / Orange Crush

See all

Watermelon Crush

Domino's Pizza

2.0(21 reviews)

0.2 mi

Well, don't place an order here if you have hungry kids at home. It took nearly 2 hours for one…read morelarge pepperoni and sausage pizza and chicken nuggets. I placed order at 5:58, called the store at 6:50 because there was no status update, and they said it should be delivered in the next 20 minutes. It finally arrived at 7:42. Funny thing is; the receipt from the store said they started the order at 6:50, when I called to check the status. He said "we're really busy" and would not sway from that. I am in the hospitality business, I understand busy, however, I do not understand being lied to. I also only live 4 minutes away, so why did the delivery go from 7:18-7:42? Don't lie to your customers. There aren't that many places to eat in Dunkirk, don't lose any more customers than you have to.

They really need to do a better job of how they keep track of their credits especially when they…read moreare the ones messing up an order ! Called today to get credit that was due to me and was told they didn't see anything , imagine that. I know from now on i will be getting something in writing or the name of the manager that stated they were giving me a credit or just getting a refund right then and there.

See all

Timing of order

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Lexi M.

10 years ago

I have been patronizing this Jerry's restaurant for several years. The cheese steaks are the BEST! The restaurant is clean and the employees do a good job getting the food out quickly. read more

James M.

10 years ago

I want to give a shout out to the Dunkirk Jerry's location. Everyone at this location is friendly & awesome, food was awesome! Definitely coming back! read more

Jon P.

12 years ago

Great pizza! The staff was friendly and attentive. The place was clean. We will definitely be back.

Lester H.

4 years ago

My wife loves the white pizza. I stop on the way home from DC. Service is good and quick.

Jerry's Subs and Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Jerry's Subs and Pizza also viewed

Five Guys

3.2

(24 reviews)

Was excited to eat my food, but then I found a hair embedded in the middle of my burger. So…read moregrossed out. They remade my order, but I would be hesitant to go back. Would recommend better hygenie standards or mandatory hats/hairnets for kitchen staff to prevent an incident like this from happening again.

It's really hit or miss. Sometimes the burgers are spot on and awesome. Other times they smell and…read moretaste like chemicals. Sometimes the fries are bangin, sometimes they're too salty or gross to consume at all. At those inflated 5Guys prices, I expect the food to be consistent and you know, EDIBLE, every time. That said, these stars are mainly for the employees, they're all pretty great.

Chesapeake Grille & Deli

3.9

(215 reviews)

Really gone downhill. If a Rachel is pastrami, cheese, Thousand Island, and coleslaw what is minus…read morethe cheese and slaw!? Food this pricey needs to be prepared better!

Burnbox

3.4

(88 reviews)

Umm has this been a secret all this time!? I finally decided to try this place out especially…read moreseeing that it had a drive thru. I needed to know how that worked. Apparently the drive thru is for online orders...noted because I will definitely return. I kept it basic and got my usual which was their version of a Meat lovers pizza, believe it was called meat me up. Mannnnn this was absolutely delicious. I got half the pizza drizzled in hot honey, and the other half drizzled in balsamic glaze. I favored the balsamic but both were so good. The toppings tasted premium to me and were plentiful. The size is perfect. Everything was good. I will be returning. I think I found me new fave pizza place.

I ordered the burnbox and the seafood scampi today. The only issue I had with their purportedly…read more"healthy " pizza is that it is super greasy. But besides that, they are also super delicious! I enjoyed the burnbox the best. It has a delicious spicy sauce that has a kick but not too much. It also has pepperoni and milder jalapeños. Flavor wise, it was one of the best pizzas I have tried. The seafood scampi was good in its own right. Not as good as the burnbox but I liked it too. It has a nice garlic sauce with shrimp and crab and tomatoes. I normally don't like tomatoes but theirs was pretty good. This is a nice pizza place that I'll certainly order from again and again again!

Jiffy Shoppes Restaurants

3.7

(194 reviews)

Jiffy's been my #1 spot when I would head home on my many late nights!! Years ago...my late…read moregrandmother turned me on to their fried fish sub...L/T/M/K is a must. When I say...I luv it...I luv it!! The staff is like family to me, lately I seen some new faces, however it's the same friendly respectful vibe. As you know on the late night they see all different types of customers...Yet they still treat us all with the same respect, and luv. I've witnessed it #TellemMekeSentYou

This is my neighborhood quick stop for good reliable food. Whether you want a sandwich, wings,…read morepizza, or whatever they got you. The folks in the kitchen are always friendly and the food is always good. I always get a hero and wings. That combination NEVER misses.

Firehouse Subs

3.0

(51 reviews)

Me and my girlfriend was just in there and she ordered a gluten free bread and who ever cut it to…read morethin and her sandwich fell apart spilling everywhere in the bag and when we took it out

It was very good subs and Mac and cheese and a lot of stuff have not had a drink from threeread more

Domino's Pizza

3.2

(25 reviews)

They forgot to add my meat toppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage). They forgot to add my meat…read moretoppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage). They forgot to add my meat toppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage). They forgot to add my meat toppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage). They forgot to add my meat toppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage). They forgot to add my meat toppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage). They forgot to add my meat toppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage). They forgot to add my meat toppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage). They forgot to add my meat toppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage). They forgot to add my meat toppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage). They forgot to add my meat toppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage). Lastly, they forgot to add my meat toppings (Pepperoni and Italian Sausage).

Service awesome but pizza and wings were garbage just being honest. Ordered the plane stuffed crust…read morecheese pizza plus wings. Wings were tiny, more bread than meat. I love pizza so I'll eat it no matter how bad. This was like some lunch pizza from high school. Doughy aka undercooked. And the stuffing was cold and pulled apart like string cheese. I mean how bad is it that you can't get a pizza from the east coast that's highly rated and see what they are doing and copy that these days. The wings, yuck, i mean talk about bulk order, order local and see what the locals are eating, it's not hard. Terribly run store, staff awesome, food terrible. Get better management and enable them to produce better quality, it's not hard.

Pizza Hut

3.4

(16 reviews)