Big fan of "the juice." I will say when you get "the juice" on a takeout order, there is a risk of the sandwich becoming soggy. Still worth the risk to get "the juice" imho. This location is very friendly and accommodating. It was also clean and welcoming. Parking is quite easy. Tasty sandwiches. I do wish they offered fries. Also wish there was an option to get your sandwich toasted. read more

See all

The takeout veggie sub I ordered was very disappointing. Half of the toppings I ordered through the app were not included on the sandwich, the bread was incorrect and very smushed (almost as if it had been sat on), and a good amount of the lettuce on the sandwich was browning. Very dissatisfied and disappointed, especially as this was my first time to the restaurant in a while. read more

My wife and I are certainly fans of Jersey Mike's when life calls for a fast and affordable sandwich. And this location nailed it tonight. Not all JMs execute equally, and we often run into locations that serve hard bread, too much salt, and old mayo. So we were very satisficed that this location had some seriously soft and chewy bread tonight. We now order without salt, and they delivered on that plus everything else tasted fresh and done to the right proportions. We'll definitely order from this location again. My only complaint is this location is organized a little stranger than other JMs. I'm used to the checkout being right by the door, making it easy to do online pickup. This one makes it feel like you need to wait in line for pickup or otherwise feel very awkward "cutting" line. A clearer pickup system would be appreciated. read more

The food was fine, although there was a Long wait considering I ordered ahead of time. Won't be back to this location for sure. Jury is still out on Jersey Mike's. read more

I'm a big Jersey Mike's fan but this place is either hit or miss. 70% of the time my order is fine and everything tastes great. The other 30% of the time the order is either slightly wrong or is missing some items. If you go into the store everything should be fine unless before closing but online orders/takeout orders are hit or miss. read more

Well....it was good while it lasted. Have you gone in here lately?!? Yeah the sandwich is legit 3 times smaller with less meat now. Started noticing it over the last few months. I ordered a second time a few weeks after the first thinking I made a mistake and ordered the wrong size...nope...the sandwich that used to keep me full for a meal now leaves me hungry and I finish the whole thing in one sitting. Will not be returning here because the chain seems to be cutting corners and decreasing portion size but the price hasn't changed. Just terrible. read more

I've ordered 3 or 4 times and my order is incorrect every time. Very frustrating and disappointing. I don't feel like I should have to babysit someone to make a sandwich correctly. read more

Absolutely horrible service. Placed an order through the app - ordered a #8 (ham, turkey, bacon) with lettuce and mayonnaise on rosemary Parmesan bread. The sandwich arrived with no bacon, no lettuce, and no mayonnaise. Only half the sandwich had rosemary and Parmesan on it. When I called, the only solution presented was for the gentleman I talked to hopefully get a hold of his manager to process a refund, and that he'd give me a call later. I've long regraded this as the worst Jersey Mikes in Cincinnati and they continue to blow those expectations out of the water. Well done for all involved. Two thumbs down. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - How do you eat a club sub with no bacon or mayonnaise? - Fast Food Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I've been wanting to check out Jersey Mike's for a while now, having heard really good things about it. I finally was able to stop by for lunch last week. While I wouldn't say it was excellent food, it wasn't bad. I ordered an Italian sub with added mild peppers, vinegar/oil, & oregano. It wasn't the best or worst Italian I've had. Personally I have always preferred to have my Italian subs hot, I love the way the meats taste toasted, but unfortunately Jersey Mike's only offered a cold Italian. That kind of brought the quality of the sandwich down a notch to begin with. The meat and cheese were pretty good, flavorful but didn't quite stand out as great tasting. The oil might have been the wrong choice to add, should have maybe went for mayo instead. It just ended up weighing down the sandwich overall and making it feel heavier in my stomach than it should have. The bread they used was pretty good. Thick and not too tough. It also helped in sopping up some of the oil they put on it. Would have been a much messier sandwich had the bread not helped contain the oil. The location was nice and cozy tucked into the middle of the Hyde Park Plaza. The employees were all really nice and they made the food super fast even though it was busy. I would put this place on par with Which Wich, maybe a little better than Subway, but nowhere near the greatness that is Penn Station. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Larger chain restaurants are always hard to judge because the food is the food. But this Jersey Mikes stands up due to their service and speed. The managers are always friendly and accurate, talking to people in line or seated. All my orders have been accurate and timely. And for all the chain sandwich places this one has the best food. Overall a very good experience read more

The guy that makes the sandwiches at Jersey Mike's is probably the nicest person in fast food. He was so friendly! The next time I'm craving a sub, I'll probably come back here just because he was so helpful and the service was great. Jersey Mike's is like a better Subway. The cut their meats and cheese fresh, and they also do hot sandwiches like cheesesteaks on the griddle. A regular sandwich will run you around $7-8. Their default toppings on their cold sandwiches (served "Mike's Way") are onions, lettuce, tomatoes, olive oil blend, red wine vinegar and spices. I like that it's lighter than the typical onion, tomato, lettuce, mayo that you'll get at other sub shops. Next week, March 28, 2018 is their give back day where 100% of the proceeds of that day are going to local charities. I love that this company gives back to the local community! Fast food with a heart, how refreshing. read more

Up until recently I didn't step foot in this place. However, they just did a big local charity day where they give 100% of sales to local charity. Greater Cincinnati area was to donate to children's cancer research. Because this hits close to home because good friends of mine have a 1 year old battling right now, I decided to go check them out. I was hesitant because subway is wack and jimmy johns is just meh. This place blew me away. The bread is soft and fresh. They put plenty of topping, unlike other chains. Everything way great flavor. I now have been back a few times and will make this place in my go to places. I really am impressed with the quality of food and leadership from this company. They made over 6 million nation wide that day and all of it went to local charity's. It takes serious character to just hand 6million away to benefit others instead of padding pockets. My buddy and his family who's baby is fighting cancer went and they treated them like royalty that day. Just an awesome company I can get behind. read more

Ordered online for a street party. Subs were not included in the order. Went to the store to pick up, but they closed early due to Covid. Called to request a refund. Store owner told me she wouldn't refund for orders that weren't picked up. So now I won't visit ANY Jersey Mike's. I'll change my review if Hyde Park Jersey Mikes refunds for subs that were attempted to be picked up TWICE and both times the store failed. Ticket # 01-000014-99-054802 read more

Food great. Skinny curly headed guy in back cleaning and making weird noises made everybody in the store feel weird.

Poor service. Sandwich was decent but the individual making it wasn't listening to what was asked to be on it. They had to be told over and over what we wanted to add to our sandwiches and they didn't appear to care or give us the attention needed to hear us. Weird experience and could tell the staff was struggling as they got busier. read more

It's a sandwich shop, right? So how can it be 5 stars? Service. I tried the online ordering for the first time. I like being able to see that my toppings are what I selected. I ordered one hot and one regular sub for pickup, and the pickup time was 15 minutes. Perfect for me to drive over and park. I walked in and as soon as the next person was available to help me, I said I had ordered ahead. I gave them my name, they handed me my sandwiches. The guy who had made the hot sandwich (not the guy currently helping me) even said out loud that he had added the banana peppers per my special request. It's a nice touch to see that the people working there are paying attention to what they are doing, not just working an assembly line. I was out of there in about 90 seconds with my sandwiches, since I had already paid online. Everything on the sandwiches was as ordered, and the quality of the sandwiches was a good as always. Thumbs up for making my lunch ordering experience as easy as possible. read more

I don't know that I have actually ever written a review for a chain before. But how can I not? Stopped in for lunch here today and was met with prompt phenomenal service and amazing food. Workers were sweet. Cashier who rung me up was incredibly sweet. Offered me a small cup for water because she noticed I did not order a soft drink. Never in my life has a fast food place asked me that. I am blown away. A step up from Subway for sure. Good food. Good service. Clean premises. Will be back! read more

I have been to this Jersey Mike's location a number of times since living in the area. I have to say they have always made me a great sandwich but it wasn't until the last few trips that it has become absolutely out of this world!! The staff are so friendly and good at customer service I started letting them have more control over my subs! I order an Italian and just let them take control when it comes to toppings and extras and my subs have become out of this world! They know exactly which oils, spices, vinegars, or veggies are going to make my sub above and beyond. I highly encourage people to give this Jersey Mike's a try and let the workers put their own spin on your sandwich! read more

This is my local Jersey Mike's and it's consistently amazing. The manager, I think his name is Rob, has been there since it opened (15 plus years ago) and he's super friendly and always smiling. I've never had a bad sandwich here, the ingredients are fresh and the store is clean as well. Lately I've been ordering online and have had no problems zooming in to grab my prepaid sandwich. Highly recommend. read more

Consistent awesome food from this Jersey Mike's - generous portions, fresh fresh food, friendly and to-the-point staff that gets you your order ASAP. Service is fast and the store is always clean! read more

I have been going to Jersey Mike's for over 10 years, and I have been to almost every JM location in Cincinnati and N. Kentucky. I LOVE JM's sandwiches. They are sliced right in front of you, and every meat is premium. Nothing compares to their club sub. Their roast beef is the best I've tasted in my life. They also have wonderful pricing. You can get a HUGE 12-inch sub for less than $15. My roommates are always going there too. I would give the JM as a whole 5 stars. I am giving this specific location 2 stars though, and here's why. The first time I walked into here, there were a few young gentlemen working and watching the game at the same time. This didn't really bother me, but what got to me is that they were so engrossed in the game that they didn't pay attention to my order and it was wrong! The final time I went there after giving it a few more chances, a young gentleman named Josh was extremely rude to me. I pointed out a simple mistake on my order, and he proceeded to sigh, roll his eyes, and grudgingly fix my sandwich. And when I say fix, I mean he was practically throwing the extra meat on it with such a disgustful attitude. I wish I could give this location a good review, but after several poor customer service experiences, I cannot. Find a different location if you want a good JM sandwich. read more

Stopped in for a bite and was impressed by the incredible service. The staff is extremely friendly and willing to help. Chick Fil'A has a reputation for having good service but this JM beats them all. At Some Chick fil a's the service becomes stale and the people are just courteous becausee they have to be but at this store the staff actually cared. The manager was the epitome of steward leadership and was elbows deep help his employees. You could see how his amiable actions and personality rubbed off on them. People came in and he greeatedd them by name and I felt like he genuinely cared about the customers. The food was incrediBle with generous serving sizes and the staff out of nowhere brought us out a couple plates of cookies fresh out of the oven. Leaders like the manager at this place make the world a better place. Good food great service. read more

This is my favorite Jersey Mike's to go to. The owners and all of the workers are really nice. They go out of their way to make sure you have a wonderful experience every time. I can't sum up in this review how appreciative I am of their kindness. They always smile and make my day a little brighter. read more

This was my first time to a Jersey Mike's. My coworkers swear by it, so I went with them one day to get lunch. I have to admit, it was pretty awesome. Definitely my new favorite sub shop. The bread, toppings, meat, cheese, everything was just so fresh. I really like how they slice the meat right when you order a sandwich too. Definitely recommend, and definitely will be back! read more

I use them often for group meetings at work because the sandwiches are tasty and the crew here is very reliable. They are top notch when it comes to service. Why can't everyone offer service like these guys! read more

I am a happy chick! I have Celiac Disease and they did an awesome job avoiding cross contamination for my sandwich!

Been to 4 different j Mike's. Hyde park is THE Best j Mike's in town. Saw Nick lashay there. Do it.

This is absolutely the best jersey mikes location in Cincinnati. The sandwiches are amazing and my order is always correct. Customer service is good and the staff is friendly and engaging. We come in all the time! Thank you for such a great location. read more

Literally the best place for cold subs you will prolly find. Quality def beats Jimmy Johns, my go to for cold cuts or the occasional club sandwich. Very good food with fast and friendly service would recommend!!!!! read more

I've been a J. Mike's friend since I was 16...I held my first job at the chain! This location is everything I love and remember about working Jersey Mike's. The meat is sliced in front of you. Ingredients are fairly fresh. Onions and Tomatoes here are sliced daily! Hooray, no super moist veggies. The employees tend to be younger guys who are pretty funny and amicable. There's the freshly baked bread every morning and since I'm definitely a red meat kind of girl - their roast beef is amazing. Freshly sliced and not slimy like *ahem* other sandwich shops. Also to add fuel to the fire, regular sandwiches are definitely plentiful enough to convert into two lunches! read more

Sub for 1 or a Sub for all! This place has a basic concept for a sandwich shop but the fresh cut meats does make a difference. I love the bread and the seasoning on it, just don't order a large unless you know what you are getting holy crap. The menu is pretty solid and this place makes a great lunch spot! read more

My first Jersey Mike's experience! I was impressed by genuine friendliness and the sub in a tub option. Pity it doesn't serve Coke products. I'd be there all the time. read more

Very friendly staff - they are always talking with you and always have a smile on your face. The meat is freshly sliced in front of you as well as the cheese. It seems very fresh and the subs are tasty. Would definitely choose J. Mike's over Subway. read more

My wife and I order lots of food from Jersey Mike's, several locations and usually spend over $300 approximately every other week. We have accrued a substantially large amount of points, as one would expect when you spend this amount of money. We don't usually complain, but the owner at this location was very unprofessional and disrespectful. I ordered a sub and it was missing items and had way too much jalapeno, so I asked that it be remade. Since we could not eat the food we agreed to bring it back. The owner initially agreed to do this, then called back a few minutes later and said that she was not going to allow this since we dont spend enough money at her store!!! What kind of nonsense is that!!! read more

Never had a bad experience at this location and I've been here a lot. Nicest dudes ever. Even the owner acts like he genuinely cares about every customer...not to mention the subs are great. read more

I've lived in Oakley for 5 years and this Jersey Mike's consistently makes great sandwiches. Been here probably 25 times now. A working guy needs to have somewhere you can count on a sandwich being made quick with quality fresh meats and bread, and this Jersey Mike fills that order. I love the staff here. They're usually young guys that have fun with their job, but take your sandwich seriously. I'm always laughing and joking around with the guys, but the sandwich always comes out great. Do not go to the subway or other shop, hit up Jersey. read more

Jersey Mike's is a classic east coast style sub shop chain. Situated in the Hyde Park Plaza strip mall, Jersey Mike offers made-to-order subs on white or whole wheat rolls. Boiled ham, turkey, roast beef and various cheeses are sliced before your eyes. No fancy ingredients like you'd find at places like Quizno's. JM has the requisite tomato, lettuce, yellow onions and some banana peppers. The fountain sodas are all Pepsico brands. What I like about JM is that every location has a flat screen TV, usually tuned to a football game or ESPN. A solid sandwich shop! read more

Wonderful service! The subs were enjoyed by our entire school and we look forward to more subs next year!

I eat at Jersey Mike's more than any other restaurant. Its the perfect option for a quick, cheap, healthy sandwich. You can't go wrong with a turkey wrap and make sure to ask for the sun-dried tomato tortilla. The honey mustard sauce is delicious as is the red pepper spread. I usually stick with turkey but I have tried many others just by stealing bites from friends. The hot sandwiches and wraps are great, especially the phillys. The best thing about this particular Jersey Mike's is the staff. The regular guys are friendly and efficient. Now there is a pretty solid rewards card that delivers free subs at different point levels read more

Stopped in to pick up sandwhiches for a team lunch. Easy to order ahead, god website, nice interior. Food was really good and the break was definitely baked fresh. Will be back! read more