I like Jersey Mikes. When everything is fresh, it's a damned good sandwich..... which makes my latest cheesesteak so disappointing. I ordered double meat and double cheese. I sweari couldn't find ANY cheese on the sandwich, let alone double. And the meat? It may have been extra, but it was sawdust. The 2 stars were for this visit. Often I'd say 4. But not today. read more

Went for the tuna sub guy puts the container on the surface where the sandwich is made it was almost empty I should have asked for fresh this was old and the taste was foul read more

No meat on this #6 sandwich that I just got from Jersey Mikes in Farmingdale. Pitiful read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #3 no meat - Sandwiches Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Second time I've gone here ordered a sandwich online and first time it wasn't ready at the time I requested so had to stand there and wait while they made it. Second time they give white bread instead of the Rosemary garlic bread and they give me someone else's miniature sandwich which I didn't order or like what was on it . Obviously they have mgmt and reading issues!! Won't be going back again !!! read more

My first time at Jersey Mike's and must say, I was in such awe awww... This tuna fish sandwich just stole my heart . This tuna fish was seasoned with mayonnaise, onions, and peppers. Full of lettuce and tomatoes. This tuna fish was so tasty . The service was prompt. The ambiance was friendly. O cannot complain. I was impressed with this tuna fish sandwich. And, I am not even a sandwich kind-of person, but I will definitely have this tuna fish sandwich again from Jersey Mike's. It was outrageously delicious . read more

See all

What went well was the trainee was doing great and she was super kind and obviously trying to learn , the taller muscular gentleman was nice too trying his best to help the other gentleman though must have not been having a good day or is unhappy with his job he was being rude and being very short and it honestly made me upset but instead of saying something I figured I'd make a review , I asked for extra hot honey because he didn't put much and chipotle mayo and he looked at me with an annoyed look then went to the tall man and told him to charge me and I was fine with it but my partner had already paid , he could've asked me if I can pay and I would've or at least smiled and greeted us until we left this is March 5th at 615pm read more

Great food service was excellent but you have to order ahead. The service area and store were clean and serviceable. read more

Pastrami sandwiches were made to perfection, shoutout the lady on the grill. If corporate is reading this, service and food is amazing

Drove 20 minutes to eat and they have the door locked at 8:40 ? Close at 9:00 I don't get it read more

Hmm. I have been wanting to try this place for a while. This afternoon my boyfriend and I were in the area, and we were actually in the mood for a sub/sandwich. We were greeted right away. We took some time to look over the menu. The girl behind the counter was patient with us. I ordered a #7. It consists of turkey and provolone. I got it "Mike's Way." Mike's Way are the fixin's. Vinegar, olive oil, lettuce, tomato, and onion. I got it that way, minus onions. When the sandwich maker was putting my fixin's on, he asked me if I wanted anything else. I saw pickles was an option. So I added pickles! He added mayo by mistake. When I said I didn't want any mayo, he just scrapped it off instead of offering me a new piece of bread. I don't understand this. Kinda left a bad taste in my mouth. My boyfriend created his own sub. Roast beef, bacon, Swiss, mayo and lettuce. He enjoyed his sub. You're able to see them slice your meat right in front of you. It's not like subway at all, which is a plus. I wish there was more condiments for the subs like cucumber and avocado. The subs come in three sizes; mini, regular, and giant. When we placed our orders we were only offered the regular or giant size. For two subs (regular size) +tax it came to $17.36! I feel that is overpriced for only two subs and nothing to drink. Not sure if we will be back. read more

Probably more like 3.5 stars but the often disjointed service led me to round down this time. Located in a small strip across from airport plaza on 110 this Jersey Mikes outpost serves up the same fare you find at their other spots, made to order subs of all varieties both hot and cold. A huge upgrade over anything Subway has ever served, but at the same time also in my estimation a peg below what you'd get at a good neighborhood deli. Kudos for the slices to order cold cuts and very fresh & tasty tuna - just avoid the turkey, more like the pressed & formed fake stuff than a fresh roasted turkey breast which to me is no bueno. The roast beef however is superb. As I mentioned the service isn't always the greatest. On my most recent visit the kid making my sub disappeared halfway through to do god knows what leaving the young lady in charge of the toppings part grasping at straws to figure out what I was having and where he left off. But it's fast food and they've never once been rude so I can't complain that much. A little pricey in my estimation for a sandwich keep your eyes peeled for coupons and you'll leave with a very filling sandwich. read more

Place was great. It reminded me of the subs back in Baltimore (which are also great). Maryland also calls submarine sandwiches "subs" instead of heroes which is a New York thing that I've never really gotten used to saying. I prefer calling them subs. I got there and the place was busy and it took me a min to order and get the food but everyone was nice but strictly business. Workers were in 'work-mode' to get as many orders out as possible. A small mistake was made where a guy behind me got my sandwich and I had to wait an additional few mins but I used their restroom (which was nice and clean with no odor) and when I came back the food was ready so no harm no foul. I would absolutely recommend this place and I plan on going back. Just not too much because the kind of stuff i order from there is unhealthy. But delicious. I got the cheesesteak and it was no joke. The original Italian was pretty good. Big. The sandwich comes in 3 sizes, Mini, Regular, and Mike's Way which was the largest. I ordered regular and it was plenty. They asked me if I wanted the sandwich cut, which I noticed because not many places do that. Jersey Mike's was great for a sandwich shop. Give this place your money. read more

I recently tried Jersey Mike's for the first time and really enjoyed it. I ordered a regular California Chicken Cheesesteak sub, and it was huge! Like, not only was the bread long, but the sandwich itself was pretty loaded. I don't fully remember what bread I got (rosemary?), I do remember how soft it was! I normally shy away from subs because I dont like how rough the bread can be. This bread was soft! The chicken was really good, too, and I liked that the sandwich came with lettuce and tomato. I don't really have a location near my home, but so I won't be frequenting here often, but I would defintiely come back, and I'd recommend it to anyone looking for a good sandwich. read more

First time I went, great. Big portions, quick service. Two times since, a fraction of the meat. Service was very slow one of those times. I ordered in advance. Went 30 minutes later, they didn't even start making it yet. I would not go again, at least to this location. read more

I called to fix my order and the lady over the phone was polite . great customer service

I only recently discovered Jersey Mike's a couple of months ago, I praised it to everyone at work. It was the best Philly cheese I've ever had. It was a hit, until the 2nd and 3rd time was garbage. They began to have barely any meat or cheese. I decided to give it one last chance at this Farmingdale location, instead of Lindenhurst or Massapequa. I ordered a #44 Giant Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak. I had scraps of meat, I literally ate a loaf of bread with some cheese. They used one flat slice of that chicken for my giant sized Cheesesteak, worst 17 dollars spent. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Gave me scraps of meat when I ordered a giant sized buffalo chicken cheesesteak. - Sandwiches Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Placed an online order that was missing items. Employees at store were rude. It's been a week and I can't get a manager on the phone to call me back to get refund. read more

After years I tried it again and I have to say it's amazing. Maybe when I first went there they didnt know what they were doing but they sure do now. read more

Went back a few months later on a Sunday early and it was like night and day. Everybody there was diligent and professional; location is neat and clean. Great sandwich! I'll be back! read more

Ordered 9 subs for Father's Day. Sent my kids to pick it up. We only got 6 subs but I paid for 9. The subs were smaller than I thought as well. Don't thin I'll be back. read more

Not gonna lie...I don't see the hype with this place. Don't get me wrong, the sandwich was good...but that's all, just good. I actually prefer the flavors and toasted bread of subway to this but definitely a better quality of meats inside. I don't think it's worth $15 for a footlong at all tho! I got a roast beef sandwich with all the works-I do like the addition of oregano to spice things up but I won't be rushing back any time soon. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Roast beef foot long - Sandwiches Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Jersey Mikes is 10 times better than Subway. The food is fantastic and so fresh. I highly recommend this spot in Farmingdale. The place was super clean and I felt real comfortable when being inside, I actually ate at the little table. The menu has a large selection across the board also, as you can see in my photo. The ham and provolone sub with the works is where its at. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

I first tried Jersey Mikes on a road trip to Michegan after 12 hrs of driving the first place we stopped at when we finally arrived was a strip mall with a Jersey Mikes . i had to try the Philly Cheesesteak very close to an original . So I was excited to see one open in Farmingdale. The place was clean and the girl slicing all the cold cuts was very friendly and she kept every customer informed about their order at the same time. I of course got The Philly cheesesteak sub minus the peppers it was just like the one I had in the Michigan location . Very Good and stuffed ! I noticed alot of people were getting other subs as well the were assembled with care and piled high with the final touch of Mikes Way ( lettuce, Tomato, herbs and oil and vinegar with mayo) . I am so glad they have opened here in Farmingdale. If your looking for a great Sub Shop try Here !! read more

I guess I have to give a 1 star because zero is not an option. Last visit I stood in line for 30 minutes because online orders were made while I stood in front of the counter. I was told to download the online app. I downloaded it for a 12:37 PM pick up. I arrived at 12:47 PM and it was not ready. I watched 50 people get sandwiches in line without mine being made. Finally I got in the line to get my ONLINE order made as a new walk in. Received my sandwich at 1:30 PM. Had to cancel a meeting at work for a sub sandwich to made over an hour time span. If you have any general life requirements or simply don't want to waste an hour of your time then do not go to this location. Also meat left In counter loose and the deli cutter has not been cleaned all day. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

See all

Super slow not organized 45 min to get two sandwiches more worried about grub hub and to go orders then the people in line everyone complaining about the wrong orders the wrong food . Not worth the $30 for two sandwiches ur better off anyplace else then here . This should not be a chain store this is a joke . I hope the head of there cooperation reads this and does something about it it's now the second and last time . Go to Freeport much better or go to any subway instead stay clear read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Terrible derstoyef the order - Sandwiches Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Don't advertise contactless payment if it's not an actual option. Stickers on the door say Apple Pay and google pay, but you don't find out until it's time to check out that oh sorry that doesn't actually work. read more

Great store! Ordered ahead, and my food was waiting for me! Staff is efficient and super friendly. And food was delicious!!! Will definitely return. read more

Finally got to try this place out yesterday. Was glad I did. Stopped in and grabbed the Philly cheesesteak sandwich and chose the Parmesan Rosemary bread. It was fantastic! Definitely will come back again. The person in charge who I assume to be the manager was super friendly and helpful! Much better, in my personal opinion,than Subway read more

Ordered via the app, entered when it should be ready but it was not. Took 20mins for them to maybe finish other people before getting to me.

While the food was great as usual, I was appalled at the fact that the 2 people making the food were not wearing their masks properly. The ladies packing up the food and doing the register were but the people leaning over the food were not. One of them (who I believe was the manager) had their nose exposed. The other had their nose exposed and the mask was too big and barely covering their mouth as well. I don't see myself returning until well after this pandemic is over. read more

This is NOT by any means a gourmet sandwich shop, BUT if you compare it to Subway, then you're going to think it is. One thing I like is they freshly slice their cold cuts when you order your sandwich, which I think makes a pretty big difference. Same idea as Subway when it comes to your add-ons, but they offer a cherry pepper relish that is really tasty and adds just the right amount of "zing" to any sandwich. Their bread is good as well. So if you find yourself in a neighborhood that you're not that familiar with and you see a Jersey Mike's, you can feel good about it being a safe bet. A step above Subway, Quiznos and Blimpies. read more

Friendly knowledgeable staff, can always count on a good experience here. So many different options for all to enjoy.

Really not a great experience. Came here with the family and there was way more bad than good. The kids sandwiches were tiny, my wife's sandwiches was made incorrectly, and mine took over twenty minutes, and was made completely wrong. They also didn't ask me what I wanted on anything. The service was off and the manager knew it. Go to a different location if you want Jersey Mike's; this one is not good. read more

Omg... the food is super tasty and fresh. They need more locations and they would easily knock Subways out. The meats are cut right in front of you and the bread is so delicious. Definitely a good meal. I recommend using the app that way all you need to do is walk in and walk out. read more

A warm welcome to jersey mikes 7th location here in farmingdale. I have to admit normally the first day open is crazy and confusing but the owner and staff here was on point quick and friendly welcome,sub made fresh to order and tasted great. I had a Philly cheese steak the subs here come in 3 different sizes small regular and giant, bread was soft n fresh sandwich was awesome much better then the other fast food sandwich shops looking forward to trying the other locations. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Philly chz steaks - Sandwiches Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Ordered a famous philly without cheese. When I returned to work and opened my sub it was smothered in cheese. Tried to take it off but lost most of my sandwich to the garbage. Tried calling the location since I cannot just leave work and go back. Called about 8 times and no one answered the phone. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

I cannot believe I am giving a chain restaurant/sandwich shop a 5 star review. Honestly, cant believe it. Especially being in NY for 33 years I have always been surrounded by great Delia but this was awesome, so much that I had to go 2 days in a row. I had the original Italian, Miley's way (which is lettuce, tomato, onion, olive oil, spices and vinegar) plus I added sweet peppers on their rosemary cheese bread and it was awesome. All cold cuts are fresh and sliced right in front of you then placed on the bread. Excellent! I will certainly be going back eventually and enjoying a different sandwich. The only qualm I have is that it was a little pricey. I got the "regular" which is about half of a hero and it came to almost $12 for a sandwich with a small bag of chips and a fountain soda but you get what you pay for and in this case it was worth the money! read more

LOVE their Philly cheesesteak. I often order from here and can't seem to order anything different because the cheesesteak is too good. I have ordered from another location before and it was not at all the same. This location does it right! The workers are friendly and the inside is always nice and clean. The Italian is my second favorite, loaded with meat, cheese and toppings! read more

My review is not about the food it is about the treatment I received at this establishment ( broadhollow Road). I ordered a #43 for my husband out of error which is a Chipotle cheese steak. I realized this mistake after the counter clerk in blue who took my order gave the order over to the grill attendants. My husband pointed out the difference between #42 and #43. #42 actually is the sandwich that he wanted which is the Chipotle "chicken" cheese steak I asked the Counter clerk (wearing blue) that I was now standing in front of if I can change my order because I ordered the wrong sandwich by mistake; she informed me she will let her co-worker know in which she did. The male co-worker (the only one wearing a red shirt) had the audacity to say "WHAT? WHY? IT IS WRITTEN CLEARLY SO IT CAN BE READ AND UNDERSTOOD". I was Livid to say the least. Not only was I offended by his disrespectful, unnecessary comment other patrons and his co-workers was as well. I addressed Mr. Big Red (not feeling very nice right now) and told him "everyone makes mistakes and his negative comment was not necessary at all. All the time I was speaking to the guy in red he has his back to me-Rude! The young lady in blue apologize to me which I did appreciate. Her apology brought ease to the situation. The sandwiches I brought there today are between $7-$14 dollars which are pricey but are tasty enough that you would make this your sandwich shop. But not me... I treat people the way I want to be treated and as I said earlier the way I was spoken to was totally unnecessary. I wish location well and you can accomplish success with if Mr Red is send to an Essential in customer engagement course. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

See all

Terrible experience. Male employees are totally non compliant with Covid precautions. Manager had mask hanging below his nose. Male employee making sandwiches had his mask hanging under his chin. When I complained about the lack of precaution, the male employee told me I should buy him a new mask if I didn't like his. I walked out and left the half-made sandwiches behind I won't ever be walking back in. I suggest you don't either. If they are this lax about a pandemic I'm sure their day to day sanitation can't be very good. read more