The Bronx Experience in Shelton If you want the soul of…read moreArthur Avenue without the trip to New York, Gaetano's Deli in Shelton is the undisputed heavyweight champion. Founders Guy and Milanno actually got their start on Arthur Avenue in the Bronx back in 1990, and they've successfully transplanted that high-energy, authentic Italian spirit right into Fairfield County. The Foundation: Arthur Avenue Bread The bread at Gaetano's is legendary. They source it directly from the Bronx, ensuring that every sandwich starts with a foundation of beautiful, crusty sesame seed bread. * The Texture: It has that signature "snap" on the outside while remaining airy and soft on the inside. * The Flavor: The toasted sesame seeds add a nutty depth that complements the salty Italian meats and tangy vinegars perfectly. The Gold Standard Chicken Cutlets Many places claim to have good cutlets, but Gaetano's cooks theirs to absolute perfection. * The "Kovac's Special": Often cited as their flagship sandwich, it features a chicken cutlet so tender and well-seasoned it stands out even when paired with heavy hitters like prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and broccoli rabe. * Crispy & Light: The breading is never greasy; it's thin, golden, and provides the perfect crunch in every bite. Unbeatable Value and Atmosphere Despite the premium quality and the "Bronx-to-CT" logistics, the value here is incredible. You can find several of their least expensive--yet still massive--sandwiches (like the John Wayne or various parmigiana rolls) starting around $11.50 to $14.00, with many hearty heroes hovering right at that $15.00 mark. The service team is a well-oiled machine. They are fast, friendly, and carry that classic deli "swagger" that makes the atmosphere feel alive. It's loud, it's bustling, and it's unapologetically Italian.

I imagine this place is absolutely slammed on weekday lunch. We went in mid afternoon on a Saturday…read moreso the wait wasn't too bad. I went for the kovac special...a hero loaded with chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, prosciutto, and sautéed broccoli rabe. I added balsamic and it really set it off. All of their food is fresh and the bread is unreal. I believe they get it daily from Arthur Ave. My wife got the Stratford & main which was just chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, balsamic and roasted peppers. Only nitpick was that we felt a little rushed to order, and maybe we would have gotten something different but you really can't go wrong with anything at this place. The shop is loaded with various Italian imported foods, but didn't see any tables to sit and eat inside, so be sure to grab & go. Highly recommend.

Love their eggplant parm. Picked up a few from the refrigerator. Tried the chicken Marcella too and…read moreit was excellent!

Authentic & Delicious! Quick and easy for lunch. I Got the eggplant parm grinder (it's huge! save…read morehalf for tomorrow!) I grabbed their catering menu on the way out, and their prices for trays is hard to beat! I will definitely be giving them a call for my daughter's birthday! Amazing customer service, and classic Italian deli ambiance. 10/10

I've always enjoyed Super Sandwich, and the recent renovations look great. The new indoor seating…read moreis a nice addition. That said, on my last visit the sandwich had more bread than chicken, with only one small piece. I remember it being more generous in the past, and the photos and older reviews reflect that as well. My mom and brother also ordered on different days and had a similar experience. Hopefully this is something that can be improved, because it's a place we've always liked.

This is my go to sandwich place. It has a massive menu so you can try something new every time but…read moremy personal favortie is the chicken cutlet Italiano. Fair warning though, the serving size is MASSIVE. I always get at least two meals. As for the service, everyone is super friendly. Highly recommended.

We used Roma Importing to cater my daughter's bridal shower yesterday. Everything was delicious! We…read morereceived a lot of compliments on the food. Thank you Pedro!

Great little deli in Huntington Center. Wonderful Italian meats, cheeses, fantastic Italian combo…read moresandwich. Highly recommend these folks!

Went on Christmas Eve and while it was very busy with a long line out the door, it moved fast and…read morethe staff was efficient and friendly. Love Portuguese bread and pastries! They have everything you need including some frozen and tinned food. The pasteis de nata aka Portuguese custard cups were delicious as was the meat pork bread. Friendly service! Wish we had one in la! Great bakery with plenty of parking. A must visit for delicious deserts and fresh bread.

Excellent excellent bakery. Service is good. They have really delicious pastries. They make…read morebeautiful cakes. Everything is delicious and fresh. The egg custard tarts are really excellent. Prices are reasonable compared to other places. Convenient location. Good parking.

I ordered two grinders (#1 and #2), and the food was amazing. The hot honey sub was elite…read moredefinitely a standout. The service was outstanding as well. The two guys working there made me feel very welcome, took the time to explain the menu, and even had a genuine conversation with me. They also gave me a free mac salad, which was super fresh and refreshing. Overall, a great experience I'll definitely be back soon!

Great sandwiches and meal prep. I love their meatballs as well. The staff is friendly and helpful…read morein recommendations.

Tried this deli for the first time…read more PARKING - while on a busy Main Street they have some parking spots available so you should be in good shape OUTSIDE - they have these tinted windows so from the outside you can't see the inside. One reason it took me so long to try AFFILIATION - I learned that this place is a second location for massiminos in Bridgeport which is a pretty Italian place in its own right ENTRANCE - as you come in you can see the main counter in the back. There are a few tables around if you want to sit and eat/drink coffee. AMBIANCE - it's a very clean and deli looking decor. DRY PRODUCTS - they have a small selection of Italian items from dried pasta to jarred sauces. Typical brands that you see in supermarkets or other Italian stores. There are a few imported from Italy brands but I'm no expert to say yea or nay PIZZA - they have at the counter a pizza station where you can a buy by the slice. They looked pretty good with a lot of variety. COFFEES - they have regular plus they make expresso, macchiatos, lattes etc. I tried the macchiato which was excellent PASTRY- they gave a few at the counter. The breakfast buns and treats. I noticed a crème pastry which I tried. It was OK but in reality the pastry part was super good but the inside crème would have been better if it was like a Boston cream filling SERVICE - definitely 5+ stars. The employees couldn't be more friendly and helpful. Very congenial with small talk. Not the usual cold QSR attitude you get from the fast food chains PRICES - I only got coffee and a pastry that was over $8. I'd say average or a little on the higher side but I didn't look at the menu on the screen too closely although it was a little difficult to see.

LOVE THIS PLACE! Local spot with exceptional sandwiches. Service is friendly, the restaurant is…read morespotless and the menu has something for everyone. Can't wait to try the Pizza! Don't skip this one!!

Love this place the food is great staff nice and dunkin doughnuts is inside place is greatread more

Missed the grill by a few minutes. Odered a pastrami grinder/yellow mustard and Cheddar cheese…read more There was no mustard and they took one piece of cheese and broke it in half for the 2 halves of sandwich. Very disappointing especially for the price I paid. This is my second try there and my last! Too bad people can't build a sandwich to go along with the higher prices.

Amazing polish food, especially their homemade kielbasa Customers are treated with kindness and…read morepatience. Selection is always well stocked. Their pierogis are delicious and easy to prepare. I have been going to this one for many years and it doesn't disappoint !

Good place. Nice selection of kielbasa and other dried sausage.read more

I'm going to be fair here and preface this with the fact that I haven't been back to this place in…read morequite some time. Nothing much has changed... it is still cash or check, which back in 2017 didn't really phase me... but I'm pretty surprised this hasn't changed. I knew the menu prices could never have been what they were nearly 7 years ago but I was surprised even when taking this into account. A chicken parm sandwich plus a peace tea (which really should be somewhere between $0.99 and $1.99) ended up at $18.35. I was totally floored. The $6 sandwich (+ toppings) has nearly tripled in price. $2 per extra topping? I really can't fathom $2 for a little bit of some topping (onions, peppers, whatever). I know things are different but it isn't like I've been under a rock for 7 years. A chicken parm grinder depending on where you go is about $8-$12. I can name 5 delis off the top of my head that can back this up. Let's get to the sandwich itself. It was bad. Way too much breading and soggy. So so soggy. This sandwich had been wrapped up for less than 10 minutes and I nearly pulled out a fork and knife to eat it. I'm so sad. I gave this place 5 stars before. I won't be returning I'm sorry to say. PS: He wasn't the nicest either. I know you don't work for free. But I do have a right to ask about the price.

It's not too far from where I live so I go there sometimes. I like the short and sometimes long…read moredrive to this place. The food is ok.