I would like to give a major shout out to the staff at this location Sunday 11/2!! They were amazing. We came into our hometown for a family visit and we had a large order. The staff was so patient, kind and made great sandwiches for our large hungry group. People often complain about what's wrong in an establishment however they forget to mention when folks are doing great. The store was clean and tidy. Kudos to a wonderful staff. read more

I came here after years and loved it. Got a chipotle chicken cheesesteak and it was perfect. Bread to meat ration, not overtly dripping with cheese, good balance of onions and peppers. The meat was tender too. The staff was courteous and efficient. I'm coming back here again, sooner. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

While I normally like Jersey Mike's I was really disappointed with this order. I ordered through DoorDash and checked off what I wanted on the app. Easy peasy right? No....I wanted banana peppers (none on the salad) oil & vinegar (none on the salad), extra meat (it sure didnt look like extra meat) AND they added mayo to my salad. I double checked my order on the app and I did indeed order how I wanted it. I rarely order through door dash but I couldn't leave lunch due to coverage issues and I spent over $20.00 (including a tip) for a salad that I didn't even eat! I would recommend going to this store in person so you can see them making your order right in front of you to avoid issues. Unfortunately, that was not an option for me today. read more

The kids behind the counter need to be made more aware of celiac and the gluten free bread option: Besides 3 other sandwiches, I ordered a mini with gluten free bread on the phone app. The app didn't give the gluten free bread option. But having had gluten free bread before, I called to see if they still offered it? I was told, "it was, and that it SHOULD be on the app." So I asked, "if I enter it in the "other instructions", would the preparers pick up on it?" He replied, "yes". When I went to pick up the order, I checked for the gluten free sandwich. When I asked, the young lady explained that they don't offer GF on mini sandwiches. So I asked, "OK. What did you give me?" She replied, "regular bread". Celiac is a debilitating disease. Providing bread either gluten WITHOUT mentioning it beforehand is irresponsible. After all, Jersey Mikes is aware of cross contamination- they wipe down the counter and utensils when ever they need to make a GF sandwich, so why would they think it's OK to substitute GF bread with regular bread? I fault the workers, not Jersey Mikes, as a whole. They had options... they could have called or texted me. OR, they could have waited until I came in to pickup the order. It would have been perfectly acceptable to make me wait to have the sandwich made correctly, rather than risk the exposure to someone with celiac to gluten. To JM credit, They DID make a replacement sandwich with GF as a regular size. They do not offer mini size in GF. Hence, all employees need to be trained on the seriousness of giving regular bread to someone with celiac. read more

I love JMS We take them on the boat We grab one for road trips Just make sure the bread is fresh from that morning. Twice I went in when they first opened and later found the bread was stale. read more

Stopped in for a ham and Provo sandwich. Ordinary sub shop, pretty clean, staff was very friendly and nice! My sandwich was made perfect! Fresh & Delicious! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Giant #3 Ham and Provolone, side of Barbecue Chips! - Sandwiches Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

Great service n great!!food is very good and fresh. Get your sub today you won't regret it.

Best subs around .great service . decent prices. All the veggies are fresh. The only thigh think is parking read more

Inconsistent at best. In this area there are other much better options. This location the meat portions are not what they should be. Ordered a Stickball and it seemed like there was a two pieces of each meat and it was not seasoned correctly. Never again read more

I am very disappointed in this establishment, I walked in and they are out of my favorite bread, everyone is giving me an attitude about the bread and I just wanted the bread I asked when will they have it and they told me that they don't know. How could they not know about the bread I get that bread everytime I get my jersey mikes sandwich. I'll be back next week and hopefully the bread will be restocked and ready to go read more

I've eaten here and gotten take out countless times. My favorites include their turkey sub, the tuna sub, meatball sub, and their version of the traditional Italian sub - which I think they call "The Super Sub." The chili is pretty good too! They will customize your sandwich any way you like - as long as they have the ingredients! Always a line in the place at lunch time - very popular! read more

I have been coming to this location for many years. Always a pleasant crew. Great fresh food. I order about 12 catering boxes a year. A great value and always appreciated wherever I bring it. read more

Failure all around. I was hosting a house warming party and ordered $65 worth of sandwiches. THEY WERE ALL WRONG!! I called back to ler them know and they were like " sorry nothing I can do." read more

My first time here and sandwiches was more than I expected... they really load on the sandwiches with everything no complaints from my party read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

Stressful times for sure but this Shrewsbury Jersey Mikes makes it easier to handle. They have a great system and very friendly staff. Subs are still amazing. They are working hard and the service is clean, safe and quick. I feel more than comfortable coming here. read more

Fresh food great taste. You can't beat the giant super sub with ham turkey with peppers. However time for a new floor. They forgot to lay tiles. Also be careful when you sit you might pull up the duct tape from the holey couch. Couch has more holes than Swiss cheese. read more

See all

For being a chain, This is a decent sub place. They give you a good amount of insides to make you feel like a proper human eating a meal. And if there is a line, don't worry, it moves relatively fast. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #7 - Sandwiches Near Me - Shrewsbury, New Jersey

I recently moved back to NJ from the West Coast (where I first discovered Mike's) and this particular location is, bar very far, my favorite and worth the bit more of a drive. With some research, I think I know why it's superior. Turns out, the several others I went to are corporate stores while this one is not. I would have thought, perhaps naively, that corporate stores would excel. I was wrong. Call me crazy. read more

Raced to get there before they closed. Got there at 8:54 and the place was cleaned up and shut down, even though they were supposed to close at 9:00 Why publish hours if you're not going to keep them? Change your closing hour to 8:30. read more

Here's the deal. I do love Jersey Mike's always quality sandwiches & good service. I would say the one thing about this chain which annoys me is the check out process and how they ask you IF u want to leave a tip read more

Love Jersey Mikes! Good food, a little expensive for what it is, but it's light years better than Subway. Fair amount of choices in sandwiches a bit less on toppings. The counter is usually run by teenagers who are occasionally attentive and at least in good spirits. No one likes these kinds of jobs so I appreciate their enthusiasm. The place certainly can get busy, and with fresh cutting meat the line can back up. I often call ahead or use the online ordering so I can walk in and walk out with my goods. Filling an a way better lunch then most fast food joints. Jersey could have a worse representative nationwide. read more

Best subs in the world lol..... I get the Italian with double mayo EXTRA ONION & EXTRA vinegar etc......They raised the prices so took one star away. read more

Jersey Mike's is always consistently good. Fresh cold cuts and toppings. Friendly service.

Nice business. Very busy. Stood in line maybe 5 minutes. The price for roast beef and provolone was good 8 and change. My concern was with the guy putting the veggies on my sub. Asked him to change his gloves before working on my sub as he had put his hand under his underarms the rub them on his apron. He compiled. But then when I was paying for the sub I saw him do it again. I called him on it, he replied "it's just something I do". Yuck! read more

Super Bowl Sunday and they were mobbed. My order was ready early, and they were kind to let me add to it on the spot. I don't know how all of the employees make those subs so fast...dizzy watching them. Great job & service! read more

I never wait more than a few minutes for my lunch here. I get in and out very quickly which is perfect because I work close by and can run and in and out quickly without it having major impact on my lunch break. I normally get the turkey but I've had the roast beef with Swiss and it was pretty good. Definitely worth trying. read more

I was home visiting and stopped in to Jersey Mike's while doing errands because my travel partner gets faint if not fed on the hour. I was actually really surprised with how nice the line staff was - at least, for being in New Jersey. They were all friendly, smiling, and looked to be enjoying their day. The sub was decent - portions were good for the price. I have to say, I've been sad since my favorite sub shop in Eatontown relocated to Ocean Township - but this wasn't a bad option at all. read more

I drove all the way over here and the place closed at 8:40 pm when the website says 9 pm... ugh. Bad Business model

I like jersey mikes subs, I just feel like this particular one does not give you your money's worth, $9 for a half a sub and a small fountain soda and the sub never has a lot of meat on it. I feel like I'm eating a lettuce and tomato sub most of the time. read more

Customer service skills is the most important thing in todays business world. I stopped into the jersey mikes location in Shrewsbury earlier today around 4pm to inquire about purchasing 2 boxes for a work meeting. I was told they could get it done for me but they close at 8pm so dont come right when they're about to close, which is understandable. I returned there at 6:20pm to place my order but the gentleman i spoke to earlier was no longer there. The young lady who was taking orders asked if she could help me, i said yes I'd like to order 2 boxes. She we cant do that because they close at 7:30, I informed her that the gentleman told me they closed at 8 when I inquired about the boxes earlier but ok. She said nope sorry we close at 7:30. So i said well ok thats still over an hour & half away.. what can i get? And she said, with an attitude, we can make you one box but thats it. I said ok and gave her my order. I asked how many pieces are in a box. She said 4 subs cut into 3s which makes 12 pieces. So since I couldn't get 2 boxes, i asked if they could cut them into 4s instead so it would have 16 pieces and she replied with attitude, No, we only cut in 3s.. so i said ok. Paid for the box and she said give is 15min.. it was 3 workers there and they finished making my box in 5min. At this point i was the only customer in the store, there was still over a hours worth of open business since they didn't close til 7:30pm, they made me 1 box within 5min, there were no other customers in the store and it wasn't even close to 7:30 so why couldn't i order another box? Just seemed like a bunch of young employees who didn't want to do any work towards the last 2hrs of work of their day.. I wouldn't be surprised if they locked the doors early and hungout in the back of the store until closing time. All i wanted to do was by boxes for a work meeting for my company PepsiCo beverages, which could've turned into a weekly year long profit for that location but now they lost out on that opportunity. But thanks for the one box that im going to take to my office and try to cut into smaller pieces so i can hope it's enough to go around.. as i left the store around 6 something with no customers in sight. Hope you all got to relax for the last hour & 30min of work and scroll on your phones to check who posted what on Instagram lol read more

Sub was average, nothing special. Way over priced for an average quality sub, no better than subway. I don't think I'd return here.

GREAT SUBS!!! Good quality food. Nice personnel, sometimes they miss the smile though. Pretty clean.

Probably one of the worst hoy sandwiches I've had in a while. I was greeted upon arrival which was nice. However, upon ordering, I was not able to clarify my toppings as the young man quickly ran off to the kitchen and never returned, so I got what was standard on the sandwich. It wouldn't have been so bad but after a 10 minute ride, the sandwich basically turned to soup. Disgustingly soggy bread which cannot be handled with your hands. I'm normally all for young folks in the work place, but the only staff I saw were young folks and once my transaction was done all 3 hid in the back. I could hear shouts of laughter. Again, I don't mind a little fun in the workplace but when quality suffers, there's a problem. I love Jersey Mike's but this location needs to get it's act together. read more

Just came in for a quick sandwich. On this particular day with this particular submaker, I got the perfect sandwich. Roast Beef piled high and totally fresh. I am not kidding, the roast beef is the best out there. Juicy!! This location and west long branch are my favorites read more

Came here for the first time - WOW what a great place - friendly and welcoming staff and the food is fresh and great tasting. Manager came over to our table to make sure we were happy - and boy were we ever!!!! We will be back. read more

I have traveled the world as a sales professional and have visited all the great sandwich shops that exist. Jersey Mikes of Shrewsbury, NJ is far and away the best of the best. Great food, great service, great staff, very clean environment. Its my number one stop whenever I visit NJ either because of work or when I'm on vacation. read more