I can honestly say that Jersey Mikes on North Atherton is great! They're always very pleasant and helpful and they have the subs ready on time if you order online they do a great job there. No wonder why Jersey Mikes just took over number one fast food restaurant! I will say the employees are awesome at the north Atherton store!!! in today's day but none of the kids wanna work. It's a refreshing place to walk into. read more

Location is a shared building. Hours are normal, parking lot is strange and can be tricky to direct people too. Food is good and plenty of seats. Staff is friendly. Only complaint is the A/C system is drips on most of the tables. Still my go to for Jersey Mike's in the area. read more

Nice portions using high quality ingredients. Staff is friendly and courteous. My favorite is the California Chicken Cheesesteak!!

Terrific subs customized for you, ready in minutes. Online take out ordering is great here, or eat in. Fresh ingredients, well assembled. No disappointments at this place. Nice clean place, no problem with noise level. Thumbs up! read more

Did not received a cookie and basically my turkey and provelone was a lettuce and tomato sandwich.Sub par service.

Fresh clean sandwiches with friendly quick service . Need to offer Coke instead of Pepsi !

If you enjoy chicken 'product' in small quantities, you will love their cheesesteaks. I cannot, for the life of me, understand why this place is popular. The workers are grumpy when you go in, and the prices are absurd for the quality they have to offer. read more

I really like the food at Jersey Mike's, the subs are a lot better quality than other chain sub shops. They slice the meat and cheese on demand as you order it. It's a bit pricey though but the food tastes better. You can get it "Mike's Way" which includes like lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar and oregano, and that's what I'd recommend. The employees seem nice and are willing to have some small talk while they work. (This is probably because at checkout the credit card reader will ask if you want to leave a tip.). They accept Google Pay and Apple Pay. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Delis Near Me - State College, Pennsylvania

Bruh I can't even with this place. Asked for a Philly without peppers. Fire whoever made this. 2/11/22 at lunch time. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Delis Near Me - State College, Pennsylvania

Love the food and the reward program but Prices are too much for one lg ... I think the hot subs are worth the price just not the cold subs

Had the Club Supreme and it was very good. I've been here before and every time the hoagies were good. One caution for you first timers is that when they ask you if you want it Mike's way, which is lettuce, tomato, onion , mayo & OIL. They put a ton of oil on. Now I enjoy a bit of oil but my god its drenched in it. Just my opinion as to what is to much. Other than that I have no problem with their hoagie. I do like them very much. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Roast Beef Sub, mmmm good - Delis Near Me - State College, Pennsylvania

See all

very clean and very good customer service. Would definitely recommend and am definitely coming back

I'm not a big chain guy. Meanwhile, when you need a quick meal there's nothing wrong with visiting a place like Jersey Mikes. This particular location impressed us with friendly service and a quick turnaround on orders. And, as you can expect the quality blows away places like Subway (yuck). Sure you'll pay more for a sub here, but you're getting quality and flavor, which a spot like Subway can't offer. Why come to Jersey Mikes? I can think of many reasons and better ones than just their brewed sweet tea is good. We ate here a few times for lunch while in town and ended up sticking to a few items: the Philly Cheesesteak, Meatball Sub and my favorite creation (they'll charge you for a standard three meat sub) a Turkey, Salami and Pepperoni with provolone. Try these three subs and this could be your regular lunch spot. And, remember you're going to pay more here, but that's the cost of quality, flavor and portions that will fill you up. read more

See all

Well the food was good i'll give them that but the sub that they said feeds 2 (the regular) was literally 6inches. Disappointed when it arrived (had it delivered) but once again it was good we were just still hungry after spending $10 for what we thought would feed two of us. Highly suggest putting the lengths of subs on their website. read more

For a chain it's good. They do forget to have you sign to use your card to earn promo points(all the time). The prices are very reasonable and the food is consistent. read more

This was a nice break from subway. BUT, I asked for triple cut, three times, and ended up without it. I asked for half oil and got full oil. so, they don't do so well with this light customization. but to be fair, they had four people do the three tasks of meat, veg, and pay. the sub was more than subway, and probably less good for us. but there was more meat and the stuff was equally or more so fresh, and the sub is thicker than a subway sub. It was, as folks note, more expensive. perhaps not for regular lunch, but special lunch. I can see why people like them and I can definataely see how customers can feel and be put out. read more

First, I just want to say, I wish there was a Jersey Mike's Subs in the Harrisburg area! This place rocks! Awesome fast service, excellent employees (some of the best I've encountered!), and prices relatively on par with other sandwich shops in my own area. My wife and I started eating here sometime last year and today was our third trip here. I have a very healthy appetite and have eaten sandwiches at Panera's that barely fill me up. At Jersey Mike's, that's not the case! I consistently order the #17 - Jersey Mike's Famous Philly (Cheese Steak) and my wife has ordered both the #15 - Meatball & Cheese Sub and the #5 Super Sub, although not on the same trip. LOL! Today, I helped her finish the Super sub and I felt satisfied. We will continue to come here for the great food in the future. You need to check this place out! read more

It's simple and it's awesome. Ways it's awesome: quality ingredients. Freshly sliced deli meats. As in, you order your sandwich, they start slicing. They bake the breads in-house. It's December, yet all the vegetable toppings look decent. The staff is pleasant and efficient. In food service, well, the default is for the job to suck. If staff seems un-miserable, the manager deserves a great deal of credit for doing something right. That appears to be the case here, at least from a customer perspective. I chatted with the manager (owner?) for a few minutes and he seems very invested in the business and on keeping customers happy. It's rare to feel like the manager actually cares whether you had a good lunch, but it's really nice to see. They haven't been open long but I've already been here a few times, with a great experience each time. The space is sizable and bright. It's in the first floor of the Fulton Bank, and there's a huge sign, so it's easy to find. Do stop in for a decent sub on this end of town! read more

I lament for all the years of my youth because I had not yet found Jersey Mike's. It only comes to me now closer to the middle of my mortality. If I had a second chance, I would have eaten there earlier. I try to stay positive and be thankful I found it when I did. It's just that when I think of that pepper relish I cannot help but feel I wasted 30 years of my life in mediocrity when i could have been happy, like I am now. Thank you Jersey Mikes. You make life worth living. read more

It's rare that I would rate a fast food (or fast casual) restaurant 5 stars but the staff is some of the friendliest I've ever encountered. How many times do you have employees asking you how your day was, while busy preparing your sandwich? I'd wager almost never. On top of that, I've never been disappointed by the subs at JM. All the ingredients seem high quality and the sandwiches are well constructed, right there in front of you. It's one of the best food stops on North Atherton! read more

I'm never disappointed when I see a jersey mikes! These are like the Morton's of sandwich shops! Today I got a #9 and cup of French onion soup. I always feel good after eating here. If your looking for a killer sandwich that actually tastes awesome this is the spot!! This location in particular had a very attentive staff. Adam was awesome at helping us out. The bathrooms were clean and the dining room as well. read more

See all

So good. This place is fast and delicious. I usually always get the Reuben. But, I've also had their cheesesteak with mushrooms, jalapeños, cheese, onions etc. The sandwiches can be pricey but it's 100% worth it. Meat is fresh and always cut right in front of you. read more

As a native son on NJ it's great having this taste of home here in central pa. The staff is always fast and the food is awesome. The bread is always made fresh and veggies are great. The best part? Going to a sandwich place where the meat isn't presliced. This new place on North Atherton has plenty of space for sitting and you can order the subs ahead of time for a quick run in and grab to go. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Delis Near Me - State College, Pennsylvania

My go-to place for subs. Ignore the rest of the places and head here. Get your sub Mike's way and enjoy. The service is friendly and the staff is extremely quick with its work. read more

In my opinion Jersey Mike's has the best subs in State College at this point! The Giant 56 is extraordinary! Very clean restaurant takeout is smooth. read more

Jersey Mike's has gluten free sub rolls and the employees at this location took every precaution to make sure my order was prepared carefully. They wiped down the slicer, the counter, used new gloves, separate condiments, the whole nine yards. And they were very kind about it! Aside from their kindness, the sub was also delicious and the restaurant very clean. I appreciate this restaurant and the employees that work there! read more

I recommend J-Mikes over any chain based sub shop. The employees are always friendly. The hot food is always HOT (temperature). And the cold food is always COLD. They are a definite win on taste which has been falling in most food chains these days. I knocked off a star because the sandwiches may lack consistency, and especially because there is no Italian type sandwich without ham. read more

This is a very good place to go for subs. I didn't even know what Jersey Mikes really was for the longest time, when I first moved here. I wish I knew sooner. I have a gluten intolerance and these subs are worth the 2 days of suffering to follow on a splurge day. Great subs, lots of bang for the buck! Great staff too. read more

Dare i say no respect here. Take whats given and walk away anything beyond that death stare 3000 and likely gradual decline of service.

Best hoagies! Love them in state college and Altoona and service is always great and inviting staff!!

Great food. Terrible service. Coming from the service industry, you must communicate and work as a team. I've never seen such a long line form in 10 minutes over 3 subs. read more

It is what it is in terms of the food - good in my book - but what made me take the time to write a review was that when I ordered a veggie sub, the woman making my sandwitch (she had a bunch of ear piercings) without my asking took the time to wipe down the slicer before she sliced the cheese. Bravo. It was a small touch, but as a lifelong vegetarian I really appreciated the gesture. Give these guys your business! read more

Excellent subs, but roughly twice the price of a sub from most locally owned sub shops. Not worth the price in my opinion. And unlike the local shops, most of the profits leave the local area and go to CEO's and shareholders. I'll keep going to Penn State Subs and others. read more

Meatball sub was good but cold. Services was slow. The subs were handled by the maker with the same gloves used to work cash register(not good). Although there was an attempt to be friendly by the manager the price customers are paying should get more than an attempt. I would expect at least a hot sub when I paid for one. Need to do better!!! read more

I'd give it 5 stars but I think it's a little bit pricey. If you get the meal (drink + chips) it is $2.49 extra so it will be about $9.50 for a meal. Otherwise, the service is good and the food is tasty and fresh. I like how the meat is cut per order. Since this location is brand new, it's very clean and inviting. When I stopped in earlier today, all of the employees were smiling and happy to help which is refreshing. read more

I went to my first Jersey Mike's in Dover, Delaware and fell in love. Now we drive the 40 minutes to State College. The service is fast and friendly, the subs are so yummy! They are big and everything is fresh! Yes, a little pricey, but I think they are the best subs, so I don't mind paying for them. If you want to leave with a full tummy and eat an awesome sub, check out Jersey Mike's! read more

Went to Jersey Mikes for the first time this evening and it was more than I expected. Got the club sub, Mikes way and it was really good. In addition, I want to complement the employees. They were very friendly and engaging. Honestly it was one of the best experiences I've ever had at a sandwich place. Will definitely go back. Keep up the good work guys! read more

Yummy. If your in a hurry and want a fresh sub this is also a great choice. Fresh, made exactly as you want and fast friendly service. The only negative is I'm not fond of Pepsi products. The ice tea was good so I was pleased. read more

Went here on a Saturday evening at 8:00 pm. This was my first time at a Jersey Mike's Sub. The place was not busy. Football game was on the TVs inside. The employees are clearly trained how to greet customers - but it comes off rehearsed and insincere. I ordered a regular turkey and my son ordered a roast beef. There was a presumption that we should know how to order and what "Mike's way" is. When we inquired what "Mike's Way" was - the person taking the order looked annoyed she had to explain anything to us. There was a sense of rushing us through the order like there was a big line behind us - but it was only us in the restaurant. The prices are about as high as you could possibly charge for a sandwich without pointing a gun at the customer and demanding more. Then, when I went to pay with my credit card the first this that comes up on the screen is how much of a tip I want to leave. Are you kidding me Mike?????? Really? I pay an enormous amount for a sandwich and I should compensate your employees for doing their job too. Did you want me to take out the trash or clean the bathroom too??? Get real - pay your own damn employees dude. The food quality and taste was well beyond what we would have expected. In fact, it was great. But, I don't think I would come back to this location again. The employees seemed bothered that we were there - and just appeared to want to rush us out. They even started mopping the floor around us while we tried to eat - which we thought was really strange and inconsiderate. Poorly managed location with an attitudes. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Delis Near Me - State College, Pennsylvania

See all

So happy Jersey Mikes opened up a more convenient location then downtown. Plenty of free parking, which is a big perk. Since I grew up in NJ, this place hits home. Great subs all around. My only gripe about them is they are a bit pricey, but worth the little bit extra compared to Subway. read more