My go to jersey mikes location!! It is so good! I love getting the Parmesan bread! Their ranch is so delicious. I've tried different things here and it's great each time. I wish we could be able to toast cold subs because I like having melted cheese with my veggies. Clean and friendly. Will keep returning! read more

We ordered three regular subs and when we got them home, we were shocked to find that the lettuce was actually turning brown, noticeably brown!! When my wife picked up the sandwiches, two are in the same last name and they were ordered separately, but in the same bag and when she asked about the third the third sandwich under my name, they looked at her confused like what was she talking about? And then found my sandwich. read more

This was my first visit to a Jersey Mike's, and I was pleasantly surprised to see the differences from other chain sandwich shops. At Jersey Mike's they cut the meat when you order so it hasn't been drying out in the case from being precut and packaged. The staff were cheerful and friendly. Since this was my first visit, they explained their menu and guided me along as I added toppings and dressings. The shop is located in Monticello near the Duck Donuts and batteries store. read more

Eh, it's a franchise and tastes like a generic franchise sub. Took 3 people to make 1 medium sub. Guy#1 sliced the meat and put each slice on the counter, Guy#2, opened the bread, added tomatoes and mayo, and peeled the meat off the counter and onto the sub. That's when they told me they dont have any heating device( no oven. no toaster). Afte #2 wrapped sandwich, #3 put it in bag, tried to upsell and rang me up. Forgettable, except for the price that was expensive for the quantity. Someone's got to pay for all those silly commercials. read more

This is my first time ever getting a sub from this location and a Jersey Mike's in general! Overall it was tasty! Hubs went to order and pick them up. I had the Turkey and American cheese fixed the Jersey Mike's way with onion, tomato, lettuce and the juice and thought it was delicious! Husband had the roast beef without the juice and onions and liked his. read more

See all

Service is subpar.... My sandwich wrap was almost passed off to me with a 3 in torn hole in the middle of the wrap,,, the server did not add bacon to the sandwich as requested, when asked again all I got was a blank stare.... While the store is very clean, attention to detail is lacking . read more

Was a favorite of mine but last few experiences haven't been great. Delivery order was missing items so I reported through their website and requested a credit for the missing items. That was over a month ago never received any response or credit. Ordered today through the mobile app for 15 minute pick up. Went into the store and waited another 15 minutes beyond the expected time while watching two lines of people come into the store and leave with their food. The staff seems like it was everyone's first day. Nobody knew what anybody else was doing. Not sure what's going on, but it seems like things have gone downhill. I would like to provide constructive feedback to the owner however, that information is nowhere to be found and going through the web portal doesn't seem to work. read more

I came there almost 20 mins before close time and they had packed all the food up to go. They said sorry we already packed up the food. They looked young and like they wanted to just go home early. However as a business owner myself if I knew my business was closed earlier than the time on the door I would blow my top. Bad business... Bad management read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Jersey Mike's closed early - Fast Food Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

The service and food was on point! I ordered the mini club sandwich which is the #8 and it was fresh and delicious!

This is my second time having Jersey Mike's but first since I've being gluten free. I was super excited as Italian subs are my favorite and I haven't been able to indulge in 6 months. If I was going to order I was going to go all in and also get chips and a cookie! Be advised not all Miss Vickies brand chips are GF. I am happy to know there is a place in williamsburg I am able to get GF subs from. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Italian sub on GF sub - Fast Food Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Out of bread! Seriously! We came and left since they had no bread and it's a sub place.

Very upset no one informed of the fireeeee that comes out of Jersey Mike's. Have absolutely never been a fan, but tried by default of someone else picking the place to eat. I ordered the chicken cheese sub and boy oh boy. It was beyond satisfying. Maybe it's the restaurant itself or this exact location, but I'm glad Jersey Mike's was our choice of meal! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Chicken cheese sub - Fast Food Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Better than subway but they should add the option to heat up your sandwich like subway

I went to the Jersey Mike's on Monticello Avenue May 17th when they gave me my sandwich. I wanted to say something but they were busy but what an embarrassment on them. There was hardly any meat on it at all like one steak big disappointment doubt I'll ever go back now, at least on my dime and it was expensive read more

Terrible experience. Called in for a takeout order consisting of 3 whole subs with Jersey way - no onions. Requested asap as I was only 15 minutes away. When I arrived within 20 minutes, they could not find my order. After spending 5 minutes they realized they had not started them yet. As I was watching the sandwiches being made, I noticed the team member was spreading raw onions over the sandwiches. i reminded him I ordered No Onions. He was like, it's too late, I already have them on there. I asked him to remove them and grudgingly took them off. I felt like I was the bad guy for wanting what I ordered to be correct. By the way, 3 subs were $80! read more

Went back again this morning. There were 8 or 9 employees roaming around at 11am (must have been some kind of training). Still NO masks on anyone! Ridiculous. read more

Well run establishment and great sandwiches!! The staff always greets you walking in and they are very friendly which places you at ease making you feel at home !! read more

Just like my husband said. Jersey mikes is turning into a Subway Chain restaurant.They're being cheap with their meats/ cheeses . I received a head of lettuce.. not just a small bed of lettuce to fill the tub but almost a head of lettuce. Also the 3 very thin tomato slices ridiculous ! 2 small rolls of meat wrapped with little cheese and a half Of one of these rolls. I should have gotten the regular roll! It might have had a little more meat and cheese . read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Jersey mikes #1 in a tub instead of a sandwich. - Fast Food Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Worst chicken sub we tried until now ... The sub was salty, chicken quality was not good, no topping added.

Turkey and Provolone with Mayo is my favorite. It's very good. If you get your Sub Mikes way, the bread may be a little soft, but I don't mind it because the turkey tastes so good! read more

Came in first complimentary Jersey Mike's birthday sub. Business is open for dine in or carryout. Tables are positioned to ensure 6 feet social distancing. Greeted immediately with a welcoming invite. I got the #17 Philly cheesesteak with grilled onions & peppers. This was free but I ordered the same sub for my mother. I didn't eat sub immediately however I ate a cut piece at home. Even though reheated in microwave it was so darn good. Full of flavor and fresh sub roll. I will return to this sub shop again. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #17 on menu. Jersey Philly ( Giant) sub with Grilled Onions. Add ons are American & Provolone cheeses with cooked pickles in grill. - Fast Food Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Worst SERVICE ever. Young larger man with glasses was beyond rude to us and me for the 2nd time coming now. I was willing to give the place a second chance and it wasn't worth it thanks to him and the other lady on grill. Ava, a young lady there however was the sweetest human ever. She was super kind and made it a lot better. Thank you Ava, we wish you the best. As for everyone who wants a sub, drive to lightfoot location, NOT Monticello. read more

Sad the meatball sub is no longer on the menu. Consistent at decent subs! Worth a visit!

This place is always on point. They do their best considering the circumstances. They are mostly always busy. They are doing something right because Subway is a few doors down and they are never busy. Staff here is kind and very respectful. The place is clean and definitely worth a visit. read more

Great subs, fresh ingredients and a friendly staff. This is a must if you enjoy a quality sandwich. Prices are reasonable and the app is user friendly. The rewards program is worth it, a free sub more often than others. read more

I'm super excited that we've got a Jersey Mike's in the 'burg now. IMHO it far exceeds the other FF sub chains in terms of quality, particularly for the cold cut subs. My experience here was nothing but positive. Prompt and friendly service, good food. I had the #2, and a regular sub by itself was plenty to fill me up for dinner. All the meats and cheeses are sliced on the spot and the vegetable toppings are fresh. From talking to the line associate preparing my sub I found out that this is the same franchise owner as the one who owns all of the Southside locations. Happy he chose Williamsburg as the first Peninsula location! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #2 Mike's way + pickles - Fast Food Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

My family just ordered subs from Jersey Mike's. Never again. I had ordered a Chicken, Bacon, Ranch sub which arrived with no bacon, no lettuce, no ranch, and some unrecognizable meat! My son ate a few bites of his giant meatball sub (usually a favourite) then threw the rest away. 2 stars only because my husband seemed to like his. Very disappointing. read more

Classic Jersey Mike's. We got two gigantic sandwiches. One was a big kahuna and the other was a cheese philly and both were great. If you want something quick with a good flavor, this is the place you should go. We also added a little spice to tie it all in, which just gave more depth to the hoagie. We had ours made "Mike's Way," which has tomatoes and lettuce and vinegar. Great, fast service! We also called in ahead of time and these sandwiches were ready by the time we got there. read more

I've been eating at this particular Jersey Mike's for about a year. I probably go there, on average, at least three times a month. However, over time I've noticed the quality of the food and service has been dropping. Today I ordered the Big Kahuna cheesesteak. Every bite I took was followed by me removing some gristle or fat from my mouth. This is not the first time, but it will certainly be the last time. This quality, coupled with the inconsistent product they serve is enough for me to find a new place to buy my sandwiches... there are enough venues in the local area to find something better. read more

Meh. A tick better than subway but no where worth the $30+ price tag for to regular subs.

Ordered a meatball sub via door dash from this location and received italian something sub wrong bread, wrong sub. Called and the manager on duty was no help at all. Fed the sub to my dog because I cannot eat the meats on it and made my dog sick. I think it was something left out. The manager couldnt even tell me why I got the wrong sub. Nothing done to rectify this. read more

This is twice now I've felt compelled to write a negative review. I promise it will be the last. I tried to order online. No success with either Yelp or their website. I called my order in and was told fifteen minutes. I arrive and stand there while they take care of the the two people who came in AFTER ME, then ignored me for a few more minutes. When I was finally asked if I needed help I gave them my name and was told my order was still being prepared. I could see what looked like my order on the grill so, okay, I'm getting it fresh, right? Not right. A few more minutes and customers go by when another associate sees me standing there, chips in hand, and asks if I wanted to pay for my order. I said yes. She asked me my name, turned and retrieved my order from the shelf where it had been SINCE I GOT THERE and I paid for my meal. Nice, mushy lukewarm cheese steak. Stuff happens from time to time but this was my second time and I am done with Jersey Mike's. Don't ask to send me a free sandwich coupon like the last time. There won't be a next time. read more

The food is what you'd expect, pretty decent but nothing to write home about. What I am writing about is the service. Aside from an oddly long wait when there's nobody in front of me, the masks are an issue here. When I walked it all three guys had masks on, sort of. The one guy on the phone had it down around his chin while leaning over the meat fridge. Not smart as he is over food and right kn front of customers. The guy on the register, who eventually and reluctantly took my order, pulled down his mask in order to ask me what sandwich I wanted. Is it really that hard to understand that these things only work when you wear them? I know it a pain, I wear one 8+ hours a day myself, but come on now. read more

Terrible service. Long line, I am the last person, I get to the counter and the guys wants to start working on a call in order. I had wait 15 minutes to get to this point, then I don't even get waited on. Then doesn't even say anything to me. You need to take care of your customers. No mask and no hairnets. read more

Service was great. The kids pack was great to offer with chips or cookie and drink for 4.95. The Giant size sandwich was huge and could almost feed 3 people. Great meet with no antibiotics. We were greeted upon entering and the vanilla creme soda was amazing and made without artificial sweetners! read more

My husband had one of these in philly and asked me to see if any were near us. I was so happy to see one opened in williamsburg only a month ago. We came in and got a roast beef and a philly steak. I got the steak and it was soo good we will definitely be coming back yum read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Its near gamestop and across from target - Fast Food Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

We are so happy to welcome Jersey Mike's to the burg. JM was a regular stop when we lived in Florida. This location offers the consistent quality we have come to expect. Service is prompt.They slice before your eyes. Our fav is the chipotle cheese steak. We split a Giant. Servings are large, so a good value. Sign up for weekly email offers like $1 off. We go about once a week now. read more

If you're from Philly and you know what constitutes a good hoagie, this is not the place for you. The rolls are horrible, and that is absolutely THE most important thing. I ordered their sub and only ate half of it. Everyone needs to understand what kind of rolls are necessary for a good hoagie. read more

My favorite go-to for when I want a quick meal but don't want the greasiness of fast food. The staff at this location is always extremely pleasant and fast. I order ahead on the app often as well as walk-in. Either way, they always get my order right and get me out the door. The quality of the sandwiches are also superior to any chain sub or sandwich shop. A #6 mikes way with mayo is the best if you're into real roast beef. I eat here at least 3 times a month and love my shore rewards, too. read more

This is by far one of my favorite places to eat in Williamsburg! The food is always good! They recognize you when you enter the door, they greet you with a smile! I recommend this place to everyone! read more