was extremely apprehensive to go to this location once I saw the star rating, but when you want Jersey Mike's you get Jersey Mike's plus today they were donating all proceeds to charity so that itself is a great reason to go not only did they greet us as soon as we walked in they were extremely friendly and kind. They made sure to ask my friend if she wanted to use her rewards and after I donated, I got a free sandwich for my next visit which i had no idea i would receive. we took our food to go and so we didn't get to sit and enjoy the ambience, but the restaurant itself was extremely clean, stocked and organized read more

Came here for the first time for giving day March 26. On this day they give 100% of proceeds to charity which in this location (all indy locations) it was Riley children's hospital. I figured what better time to try this place. It wasn't the most convenient location either but not bad. The cheese steak was very good. I'd def come back. The service was great and fast. Parking was limited due to all the businesses in this area. read more

See all

An excellent Jersey Mike's location! Employees were very friendly, restaurant was clean and my food was perfectly made to order. I ordered the grilled portabella mushroom & Swiss with added tomatoes and mayo. My favorite sandwich! There is a small but pleasant patio for outdoor dining. Jersey Mike's has the best tomatoes of any restaurant. They are always red, ripe, and delicious. If you are looking for bacon Jersey Mike's always has perfectly cooked bacon. read more

See all

Very Good service this afternoon amd clean place. Great Grub too I'll continue to come by read more

My food was hot and fresh. He even cleaned the grill and cheese grater before making my order without me asking. Now that's great customer service. It was somewhat busy because it was lunch time but I was in and out. It was definitely better than my last experience. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Mini veggie sandwich with ranch - Fast Food Near Me - Zionsville, Indiana

We stopped late after a hard day of volunteering. It was our first visit and we ordered the Italian sub whole to split. The sub as prepared quickly by friendly staff. The sub was so delicious that I can't stop thinking about it. The bread was soft, yet chewy. The dressing was tart and juicy. The mix of lettuce, tomato and onion was refreshing. And the blend of Italian meats filling. Loved it! The sub shop is at an awkward corner of a strip mall, but fairly easy in and out. We'll be back. read more

I am a regular Subway customer and had heard that Jersey Mike's was better so I tried it. NOT IMPRESSED! Seems like it is a Subway with a guy who slows down the process by slicing the stuff to order, and charging you double for the sandwich. I saw no noticeable difference in quality, and Subway offers a wider array of vegies and sauces. I learned to appreciate Subway more from my visit to Jersey Mike's. I hate to offer bad reviews but Jersey Mike's cost more and in my opinion is not better. read more

Staff was super helpful, and I got the perfect timing as no line when I arrived and the two sandwiches were made so quickly! Also delicious even after 20 min car ride. read more

See all

I could tell the gentleman who greeted me was the manager! He immediately greeted me with a friendly demeanor and asked if I was picking up an order - I told him no and he asked me to step to the ordering side of the counter where he would assist me. He grabbed gloves, took my order and was quick - no errors! I got myself a #7 and it taste pretty darn good! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #7 Turkey and Provolone - Fast Food Near Me - Zionsville, Indiana

Original Italian with "Mike's way dry and pickles". Meaning, no vinegar. Sad that The Mike's near my place of home or and business all have closed, Little out of my way home but worth a trip. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Zionsville, Indiana

I will be honest. I am rarely compelled to give a negative review. In fact, this is my first. However, I just had the strangest experience at Jersey Mike's. I had never been to Jersey Mike's and asked if cold subs could be made hot. They emphatically told me yes! I said "Great! May I please have a tuna melt?" The staff looked at me like I had two heads. I told them it was just tuna with cheese melted on top... so I giggled a little when it came out and the cheese was on the bottom. One guy said "look I just did the best I could" a bit accusingly. Another shouted across a few other customers that no one had ever asked for that before, no one wants hot tuna. My cheeks flushed, I was really embarrassed. I graciously said everything was fine but it is a standard menu option I didn't make it up. I tried to laugh. They made me feel dumb. I do not think I will return. I should add that the food quality was fine. It likely would not have warranted a review either way were it not for the circumstances. read more

Ordered carry out, asked for a receipt, cashier gave me a receipt, I immediately noticed it was NOT my receipt, when I explained that I was given the wrong receipt, the receipt she gave me was for a dine in order, a "duplicate", I requested she give me my receipt, the correct receipt, rather than accepting her error and printing my receipt, she advised me that there was a receipt stapled to me bag... after driving away, in heavy traffic, I realized that the receipt stapled to my order was marked "UNPAID", hence being worthless to me with regard to record keeping. (Taxes) I phoned and asked to speak with a manager, and was told there was no manager on duty and there wouldn't be a manager on duty at any time today. read more

I try not to eat fast food during the week buuuut life happens and I forgot to meal prep so, here I am for my first experience at Jersey Mike's! I was blankly staring at the extensive menu when the manager asked me what I was thinking about ordering. I told him I wasn't sure and that I'd never been before. He made several recommendations and gave me pretty good descriptions on each. Once I chose my sub, Chipotle Chicken Cheese Steak, it took about 4 minutes to get my food. My sub was great, had really good flavor and the bread was perfect. I wish they had a smaller option but hey, can't be too picky. Overall, I was really happy with this experience and would definitely give it another shot! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Zionsville, Indiana

I've been into Philly cheesesteak sandwiches recently so I thought I would give Jersey Mike's a try. I ordered a regular sized Mike's Famous Philly. It was absolutely delicious! But I didn't really understand if I could customize my sandwich at all. I didn't see if there were any other bread options or if I would get charged for adding another vegetable or topping. I liked that the sandwich was pretty large and I left feeling full, but I still thought it was pricey. The best decision that I made was to purchase a David's chocolate chip cookie that was by the register. Probably the best cookie I've ever had! Pretty sure I now won't be able to leave this place without one. Overall Jersey Mike's is a little expensive for me to go here often but everything is delicious! read more

Giving 3 stars because I love jersey mikes! But I'm very upset coming here and watching the guy cashing people out with gloves on touching the money then touching the sandwich's. Makes me feel sick. I never leave reviews but I hope this gets seen so they don't let it happen again because I didn't want to embarrass the boy by telling him in front of other guests read more

The servers made my sandwich. But it sat in a corner getting cold while they chose to make a bunch of white peoples food who came in after me and a black guy. The white people who came in after us had their food and was eating while me and the black guy were still waiting on our food. Racist much??? Blacks aren't welcomed at this location. I wish georgetown rd hadn't closed. read more

Came in here in a Saturday evening - June 26 around 6:30 and the guys working were working their tail off and was super nice even though they were slammed. Taking online orders and walk-ins can't be easy!!! Good job to the crew working that evening. read more

Middle of the road here. I've had subs from jersey mikes in jersey. It's still ok, but there is no comparison to the subs I've had there! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #17 Mike's Famous Philly - Fast Food Near Me - Zionsville, Indiana

See all

Decided to finally try Jersey Mike's after a co-worker suggested it was the best place to go for a sub. This place changed my life! I can no longer frequent other sub restaurants without feeling dissatisfaction. Jersey Mike's just does things different, from the actual grill where they cook their meats (not run them through a faux heater or sitting in plastic containers ready to pick up and separate slices), to the amount of meat/condiments that go on the sandwich. The bread is always fresh, the staff is super friendly and the restaurant always clean. read more

Bad experience. Young men making sandwiches seemed a bit inexperienced but pleasant the guy who took my order on the other hand was a real jerk. No pleasant greeting. Impatient & had the nerve ti tell me to "calm down" when after standing patiently waiting to regain his attention he proceeded to go on to the next customer. I had merely calmly told him I hadn't finished. He was rude & condescending & as a senior woman I felt disrespected. I should have left but since my son whom I was visiting is a regular & had asked me to pick up lunch I did not. So many choices out there. No reason to give hard earned money to businesses who don't appreciate their customers. read more

When I walked into this place I felt more welcome to come In than any other place I have ate before. Everyone was suuuuper nice and we got our sandwiches fast and it also went very smooth! When we went outside to eat a guy named Brandon asked us how our meal was and we told him how much we were enjoying our sandwiches! This guy is the nicest man I have ever met in a fast food restaurant. Thank you Jersey Mike's and the people working there! read more

I went in for a veggie sandwich and usually when I order the sandwich the staff changes their gloves however this location didn't change the gloves nor did they prep the cheese that was going to go on my veggie sandwich on a different slicer. It was going to be cut on the same slicer that the pork and other meats had already been processed on and it was not cleaned before hand. It was a clear case of cross contamination and the first time I've experienced it at a Jersey mikes. read more

Took my order and never made my food. I had to ask them about my order just for them to start

The service is absolutely amazing they move with a sense of urgency and the food is great they're right up there along the lines of Chick-fil-A as far as customer service goes thank you guys for such a great job read more

We tried Jersey Mikes for the first time as the local sandwich shops were closed. Waited an hour for our meal as the staff fooled around in the back doing who knows what. Store was dirty and we ended up not eating after all that time because we were concerned about food poisoning. Highly recommend avoiding. read more

Will never return management was rude to my party of 3 aging from 67 -89 years didn't want to wait on use we were three Black woman. I had to address it and ask for my money back will never return and posted picture and rudeness on Facebook made me very angry never had been treat way was not my 1st time there. read more

Hands down THE BEST SUB SHOP north of 465. Although their subs are a few dollars more than subway or jimmy johns they are well worth it! First you choose fresh baked white or wheat bread, then they hand slice cheese for you based on what sandwich you get, so fresh and delicious. I always get the veggie so no meat for me, but still so perfect in every way. Next they ask it you want it "Mikes way" I don't bc I'm particular about my topping but I get lettuce , onion, & xtra tomatoes. Then I get a few jalapeños and lots of mayo. Lastly they have oregano and a little vinegar&oil, help pull it all together. Try them out, everyone's always like it's just a sandwich but once you try theirs you will be hooked! Or at least all my friends I've shown have been :) read more

Absolutely my favorite place to go for a sandwich. The bread is homemade and since they have come out with their rosemary Parm bread I just can't say no. The hot sandwich can be kind of hit or miss but are still good. Where they really get my vote is the roast beef, turkey, and bacon. To start, the back is always crispy and not flabby undercooked like some fast food places can be. The roast beef is made a perfect medium rare and is tender and so flavorful. If that's not quite your style I second recommend the Italian. 5 kinds of Italian meats make this one big sandwich. The sandwiches always come out tasting like they were made at an actual deli. Don't forget Mike's way either. That is lettuce onion tomato a special blend of spices, salt and pepper along with oil and vinegar. The service here is always consistent, evidenced by the same question every time. Would you like that Mike's way? Well I guess I know what I'm having for lunch tomorrow! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - The original Italian! - Fast Food Near Me - Zionsville, Indiana

Great sub shop! You get a lot for your buck. I got the #7 regular turkey and provolone sandwich. It is HUGE! I love how much you get, especially since it can be a little pricey, but they definitely make it worth it! The staff was very friendly and immediately greeted me as I walked in. They were quick and efficient making the food. I was impressed and will probably be visiting here more, and subway less! read more

Went to this your shop in Carmel, undoubtedly the worst sandwich I've ever had. I got the original Italian and the guy there drowned it in vinegar and oil so badly it had completely soaked the bottom of my foot long where the bread was soggy and inedible by the time I got home in Whitestown. It was two younger black men working the counter that evening who were busier talking to each other than they were with making the sandwich correctly. I have been to other Jersey Mike's and not only had good service but an excellent sandwich, but not at your Carmel store. This was my first time to your shop and it will be my last unfortunately. Big waste of almost $16. read more

I always forget this location is here because it's sort of tucked away. I am pregnant so I can't eat cold lunch meat sandwiches. This place is perfect because they cut all of the meat right away and then cook anything you ordered fresh. I recommend the buffalo chicken sandwich. I get ranch instead of blue cheese dressing read more

I used to love Jersey Mikes. So much get a sandwich every week. Then ordered online and DoorDash mixed up the order. No problem. Called DoorDash they told me to contact JS. OK. Contacted them. They told me they forwarded my issue to the store owner, and he/she would be in contact with me. OK. Surprise surprise no contact. I give up. You can have my $30. Would have had more if you would have simply taken care of this. Not down voting the sandwiches, down voting the management. Long term customer is worth more than than $30. Also all the employees are great! Very friendly each time. This is not a knock against them. Unfortunately they have to work for a corporation like this. read more

I've been frequenting this Jersey Mike's location since it opened. I ordered online for pickup today. The sandwiches are always consistently good - very typical of Jersey Mike's. Giving it only two stars today because of the customer service. The lady at the cashier (older lady with rough voice) needs basic good customer service training and needs to learn the business she is in. I arrived and stood in front of the register while she finished talking to another employee. I said hello but no response. I waiting a few awkward minutes before she looked up and asked how she could help. I told her I was there for a pickup. She said "for who?" in an unfriendly tone. I then told her tried to create a shore rewards account but kept getting kicked-out the Jersey Mike's website to get credit on this order, but that I'd since got it setup and wanted to add it now. She said she couldn't do it. And spent a considerable amount of time showing me on her register why she could not do that on online orders and that it was too bad because today is double points day. I took my purchase and figured I'd work on it later. Came to find out later that you CAN INDEED add a previous purchase with receipt to your online account. If she had only spent a few minutes on what could have been a relatively easy fix, I would probably not be writing this review. But the whole experience with this one employee was disappointing. I hope she wasn't a supervisor or manager! read more

These guys actually know how to make a decent cheesesteak the way it is done in Philly or down the Shore. Closest thing you'll find way up here in this chain laden wasteland. The bread actually tastes like bread baked back east, not some generic tasteless glop that passes for bread elsewhere. read more

Just a good, solid east coast sandwich shop. Fresh meat, consistent, tasty every time. Cheese steaks are the closet to Philly I've had (even though you can't get authentic cheese steaks outside of Philly). Now if they could be a Hoagie AND Grinder place I'd say they are completely authentic. No Grinders here, not even sure anyone outside the East Coast knows what that means. Other than running out of bread periodically (happened more than once to me) this place is a sure thing. read more

What used to be a premiere sub shop is now just an also-ran in my book. So the reason this franchise receives four stars is simply the people are consistently friendly and helpful. They can't make much more than those who work at nearby fast food places, but somehow they've found excellent employees out of the same pool of candidates a nearby McDonalds does. Yet somehow their employees seem completely clueless. If you like brown mustard more than Dijon choose this spot over JJs. read more

Poorly managed and it shows because the manager himself gave me attitude. My wife and I were on a little 2 hour outing with our newborn and wanted to order something quick and online. We placed an order at 12:45 online with Jersey Mikes. At 1:00pm I went it to grab our order. There was about 5-6 people in line and 4 people working behind the line. They all seemed flustered and not happy at all. After 5 minutes or so one of the employees asked if I had an online order of which I replied that I did. He said "sorry, we have a line so it's going to be a while." If I knew that when I ordered online I would have just waited in the 5 person line. Around 1:20 I inquired about my online order. One of the employees said "we will make it in a bit, less than 5 min, less than 5 min". At 1:28 my order was complete. Almost 45 minutes! I let them know that I was disappointed for waiting so long but none of the employees seemed to care or offered an explanation or apology. In fact, Manager Matt looked up and said "we tried our best, man." If 4 employees get flustered by 5 people in line then some retraining is desperately needed. I did not appreciate the way I was treated and that my online order was such an inconvenience that they took 45 minutes to make it. I also wrote my frustration to corporate and have not heard anything either so I will not go back and don't advise that you do either. read more

Food was good, but service is questionable. On the 2nd visit an employee had such a bad attitude and soaked my sandwich in dressing/vinegar that it was not edible. When asking about the sandwich I wanted, one of the employees argued with me and said I should try something else instead of just adding regular yellow mustard. THEN when you go to pay, the employee is staring at you and you FEEL you have to give a tip even though in this case they certainly did not deserve it. Go back to Jersey Mike, cuz this was not Hoosier hospitality read more

Food is ok but do not bother to order online. Have ordered online twice and both times the store "could not find the order". They insisted I had ordered through a different store. Twice, after showing the staff the confirmation emails that I had ordered from their store, there was an extended wait while they made the sandwiches. read more

Come here for a lunch break and they have 4 ppl behind the counter with a line of at least 15 ppl. They were so slow and incompetent that they messed up my order as well as my co workers. Very rude when asking them to fix it. Lazy workers. read more