Not a good representation of Jimmy's legacy. Went here for lunch, it was not busy at all. Had the Mahi sandwich. Took forever for the food to come out and the sandwich would've been good, but the bun was stale and the fries had been sitting out a while as they were less than warm. Service was not very attentive or pleasant. Sodas are $4.50 and refills are $1.50. Total for the meal, all in, was $44. Restaurant was a bit grungy. Bathrooms are located through the gift shop and are poorly maintained. read more

Jimmy Buffett's - Menu - Burgers Near Me - Nassau, New York

See all

Topic: Jimmy Buffett's Margaritaville Bahamas Date: 5/14/25 Quality: 6/10 Value: 5/10 Service: 2/10 Timeliness: 6/10 Atmosphere: 3/10 Total: 22/50 Note: This is a longer review as there were a few issues we experienced with this location. As a major point within our meal - a guy with a broom and dustpan smashed and killed a giant centipede by the entrance while we were eating, not exactly appetizing. This took him over a full minute of hitting it on the ground while the entire restaurant was watching him do so. He actually broke the dustpan, he was hitting for so long. One of the most absurd restaurant experiences of our life. Watermelon Margarita 5/5 (Great drink) Piña Coloda 4/5 (Needs more pineapple) Chocolate Banana Colada 4.5/5 (Came back for this one) Steak Sandwich 4/5 Fresh Fish Tacos 4.25/5 Side Caesar Salad 0/5 (The salad smelled and tasted like feet, salad came warm, couldn't keep eating) We told the server about the Caesar salad who recommended we order it next time with cheese on the side. I NEVER send food back. In my entire life, maybe 2 or 3 times. For transparency, Caesar salads are my favorite type of salad and I've eaten no less than 100 of them in my life, many from different establishments. This was the first one I've experienced like this. We were still charged for the side salads that we hardly could touch. This was not a very pleasant experience service-wise, the drinks were good however. If you order the drinks as to-go you get more in them, just a little tip. read more

See all

People were nice but the food was not good. I ordered the fish tacos grilled and blackened. The fish was poor quility and dry. Won't be back here and left a bit hungry. read more

Food generally in Bahamas and living cost are expensive. Seated quickly on Tuesday lunch and we loved the mahi burger with sweet potato fries. Everything perfect including the coleslaw within the burger. Service was quick , ambience is ok - Margaritaville style. Vat and 15% gratuity are includeAll services in the resto in Bahamas read more

Jimmy Buffett's - Mahi burger with sweet potato fries. - Burgers Near Me - Nassau, New York

Young lady at hostess stand was so nice. Fast friendly service at outside bar L'Tahj took every need. Great boat drinks and food. Let the #Tikitriathlon continue. Dine,Drink & Shop. Fun beach atmosphere. read more

See all

Think twice about going to this restaurant. I'm surprised I went, but I did not have my phone and I did not look at Yelp ahead of time! A soda is $4.50 and a refill is $1.50. And good luck getting a refill. I had to walk my cup up to the bar to get the refill myself. I had the not so fresh fish tacos. Luckily there were three of them. One of them was inedible. Instead of lettuce, they should've used cabbage, but luckily, I got coleslaw having a feeling that I would need to add it. The chipotle sauce that came with my lobster bites was an extra dollar but that helped make the tacos better. The lobster bites were actually okay. My husband had the Alfredo with seafood for $42 and it tasted like a stick of butter. read more

We were down by the docks fishing and watching all those tourist covered in oil.That's when I saw the sign...Margaritaville!! My family and I decided to go and give it a try.We were hungry.We were greeted right away with those big wide Bahamian smiles.The people of the Bahamas are so nice! It wasn't long before we were seated and our drink and appetizer order was taken and brought out very quickly.The wings were just that...wings.However the South West eggs rolls and the Ahi Tuna Nachos were well done! The tortillas were made from scratch.The tuna was fresh caught and the sauces were so good! I ordered the Mahi Mahi Fingers with peas and rice.Peas and rice is a main side dish down here in the Bahamas.I could eat this everyday and my wife and kids loved it.They do have kids stuff on the menu! Chicken tenders and fries were my kids go to thing! My wife had the blackened Mahi Mahi with peas and rice and baked macaroni.Another Popular Bahamian side.We were down here for 10 days and we ate these two items almost everyday!The flavors were all so good! The location down by the docks is such an awesome experience.Its a typical island thing but it makes a big deal in terms of Ambiance.One can sit outside right next to the ocean or inside the restaurant.Its an open concept and so the nice tranquil breezes and the calm crash of ocean waves fills the restaurant. We only gave four stars because parking is tight and some of the peas and rice was cold.No drinking here for us but there is a full bar and they are known for that frozen concoction that would help one hold on...hence the name Margaritaville You gotta check out Jimmy Buffets Margaritaville if you are down in the Bahamas. read more

See all

Located at the end of crossing bridge in Paradise Island Bahamas. I tried changing the address but there is no Bahamas on the list of countries to change it to. Food was great. Service was a bit slow. The place is nice and it's good for big groups. read more

Jimmy Buffett's - Burgers Near Me - Nassau, New York

The food was awful. The service was even worse, and the management could care less about making customers happy.

Food and service excellent as always. Seated quickly and friendly waitstaff. Excellent music from the DJ (meaning popular enough that I could sing/dance in my seat to embarrass my kids). Only downfall being too loud of music to hear the staff well or have a dinner conversation read more

No air conditioning. Sweltering hot for baby. Flies swarming even freshly served food. No fly traps. Mens bathroom poorly accessible inside gift shop, floor and sink dirty, empty soap dispenser and no paper for hand drying. Food was soggy sweet potato fries, very fatty bbq ribs, and overdone fish. read more

On Saturday May 24th 2025 my family and I had dinner at Jimmy buffett's Margaritaville we were here 2 years ago 4 days out of the Seventh-Day vacation and lthe food was delicious. Today at 8:00 p.m. I ordered the cheeseburger my wife ordered the catch of the day. "mahi mahi" it was very dry and tasted extremely fishy. The manager sent it back and we did not order anything else. The manager was friendly and nice enough but I was shocked the whole meal was not removed just $28.00 off a $38.00 dollar meal.we went back to the room across the street and my wife had to take a Anacid pill because her stomach was upset. The same day at 10:15 p.m. we returned with six other family members that just arrived to the Bahamas from the airport. they ordered 3 orders of shrimp all three orders were overcooked and rubbery It tasted horrible the waitress immediately took all 3 orders back and we can tell there was a problem with the shrimp. The red snapper was dry the tacos & club sandwich was ok. We won't be back to eat any fish at this location. read more

Frozen trash burgers. It was so bad that I felt ill the rest of the day. Do they even care? Nah. Probably not. Don't go here. The positive reviews must be drunk people read more

Terrible food. Don't waste your time and money. Go eat local. Seriously. The only thing decent about this place was the drinks were strong to counter balance the terrible food. read more

This night service was great. Our server was managing the bar and waiting on tables. Multitasked well. Most expensive dinner. Too Pricey. Overall, Okay. read more

Jimmy Buffett's - Burgers Near Me - Nassau, New York

See all

The strawberry daiquiri was good. The second best thing was the Dasani water bottle. There was no Cajun seasoning on the chicken. The Tres Amigos appetizer was not great. The chips were good but very salty. The cheese tastes like it was out of a can. The shrimp were not jumbo. They were overcooked with little seasoning. Don't recommend. Save your money. read more

Jimmy Buffett's - Cajun Chicken Cobb Salad and Fried Jumbo Shrimp with fries and mixed green salad - Burgers Near Me - Nassau, New York

Now named Margaritaville. Margaritas are $15 and so small you get 3 sips. Ordered the fajitas and they were ok. Very average. Got the key lime pie and it was good but they put a slice of lemon on it! Demonstrating a severe lack of knowledge of what a key lime is! read more

Terrible service. We sat for 15 minutes & no one came to take a drink or food order. We decided to leave. Stopped by the hostess & she apologized & asked another waitress to take our order. Both hostess & waitress were very nice & polite. They saved our evening plus the margaritas were delicious. read more

Ok, so here's the issue, calling Jimmy Buffett a sell out or something like that is too contrived to even hang my hat on that. We know he is and it's just an immutable fact. But the problem with this restaurant is that it's not a place Jimmy would want to hang out. And, by extension, his fans don't want to hang out there. We were there for approximately 90 minutes, and guess what, we heard ZERO Jimmy songs. We heard Rihanna and a Kelly Clarkson song for gods sake. We did hear one George Strait song which is good but everything else was hip hop. Problem two: the drinks were weak as hell. I ordered a glass of white wine and a shot of their house tequila. The wine is a 5 ounce pour (I'm being generous) and the shot was definitely not one ounce (and it should be 1.5 ounces). The wife got a margarita that was as pretty weak. And I know this is Bahamas but everything was crazy expensive. You know what you want? You know what Jimmy wants? Good food, fairly priced, and to listen to some dang island music while drinking full size drinks. The problem here is that Jimmy slapped his name to this place and it totally fails to represent what HE represents, needless to say what Parrotheads would want when they want to go to dinner and relax and listen to some Jimmy Buffett. Like seriously, whoever is managing this place and (hopefully) reading this review, put Jimmy on repeat because no one...and let's be one hundred percent clear here...NO ONE is going to Jimmy Buffett's Margartaville to listen to Rihanna. read more

Jimmy Buffett's - Menu - Burgers Near Me - Nassau, New York

been here for over an hour.. no food yet. drinks took 30 minutes. will never come back. i repete., do not waste your time, energy, or money!! read more

The food and the service were horrible. Our waiter was slow and forgot what we ordered. The food was subpar at best.

Disgusting. Horrific. Terrible. Save your money and time this place is gross. Way overpriced and the food was terrible. $16 kids meal with a tiny bowl of pasta. Supposed to come with a free frisbee too - nope we don't have those (Even though it's advertised on the menu). No soap in the bathroom - you think the cooks are washing their hands? Waitress was miserable too. So so gross. read more

Good food and drinks much more affordable than Atlantis. Also great setting and service

Worst burger in not paradise! Had to ask for the special sauce because they left it off and was told it may take awhile to get it!

Horrible service!!! I mean HORRIBLE!!! The people next to us waited 90 mins for food. And it wasn't even busy!!! Terrible, terrible, terrible!!!! read more

$100 for a fish sandwich, shrimp, 1 beer, and a po'boy. What's even worse is the required $15 tip after waiting over 2 whole hours and not getting our food. I missed my appointment because of the atrocious service and I feel as though I have been swindled. The fact I am required to tip after waiting over 2 hours is criminal. I will not ever return here. My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined. None of this is satire or exaggerated. This review is an accurate reflection of my experience at this establishment. read more