The only reason I will give 2 stars instead of 1 is because of the service. Our waiter was wonderful and it's not his fault the food is bad and the atmosphere is extremely noisy, like a cafeteria. The ambience: 0/10 due to it being extremely loud and not peaceful at all. It sounds like a noisy high school cafeteria. The food: 0/10 due to the taste being bad AND the price extremely high for what you get. We paid $80 for 1 filet mignon. Definitely not worth it. The baked potato was so overcooked. I feel like it had been cooking for days. It was dark and mushy inside. The Caesar salad was flavorless. The lettuce was wet and the dressing not tasty at all. There were 3 of us and our bill was over $500 for a noisy dinner with bad food. Take a pass on this steakhouse. You will regret going here. read more

We had a great experience. Our servers were on point and very attentive. While the butter for the bread was hard as a rock and wouldn't even spread, that was the only disappointment we had with our dinner. The drink I got was the best I've had on the island. I will say it was very loud as there were lots of groups, so don't make it too romantic which I was looking for. read more

See all

Topic: Seafire Steakhouse Date: 5/16/25 Quality: 8/10 Value: 2/10 Service: 7/10 Timeliness: 6/10 Atmosphere: 1/10 Total: 24/50 Regarding the atmosphere alone, I would not recommend anyone go here. We went at 8pm for a reservation, and it is INSANELY LOUD inside. (Easily the loudest restaurant I've ever been in - you have to yell for your table to hear anything you say, they also cheer very loudly for birthdays FYI which occur no less than once a minute) Part of the downgraded review is that the value is almost nonexistent here, the tab was about double what we expected to pay and we split 2 steaks for 4 people. We split the New York and they did kindly split it in the kitchen which was very thoughtful. If you drink water ensure you say tap and not flat or sparking as they charge $10 per bottle of water used. $37 for two prawns and an additional $5 for one side of sauce were other standouts for being very, very pricey. House bread and butter for table 2/5 (flavorless, butter needed salt) Moscow Mule 5/5 (Perfect amount of lime) Merlot Wine 4/5 New York 4.5/5 (Large cut - almost perfect! Just needed some plating work) Filet Mignon 4/5 (ordered medium, came closer to medium rare, still fairly good, needs a bit of seasoning) Hand Cut Steak Frites 1.5/5 (completely flavorless, needs salt and some more seasoning) Potato Puree 4/5 Brussel Sprouts 4/5 (a bit too sweet) Prawns 4/5 (a bit overcooked) read more

See all

Main waiter was nice, friendly and accommodating.. but I did notice that there were lots of servers just standing around conversing when our waters needed to be refilled, and empty plates needed to be removed. We ordered Wagyu Beef Tartare - just mediocre, nothing special, beef was a big mushy. Porterhouse steak - cooked medium rare , found this to be very good. Thick cut, well seasoned and flavourful Brussels Sprouts -- we opted to get the honey drizzle on the side.. while it was well cooked, it was too salty Mac & Cheese - very decadent and creamy, ironically needed more salt/ seasoning. Total before additional tip was $232. Best part of the meal was the Porterhouse & complimentary bread. read more

Seafire Steakhouse - Parmesan honey brussel sprouts. Porterhouse steak Mac & Cheese - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

See all

We always make a point to dine here on vacation! The staff is super fun and sing the loudest, most upbeat happy birthday song to guests. Can't beat a surf and turf dinner to end a day in paradise. They have wagyu steaks and Bahamian lobsters. The sea food tower is top notch. Delicious cocktails, wine and desserts. read more

I emailed them months beforehand and they had me fill out a form with food preferences and restrictions. We ate here twice. Both times, the chef came out and spoke with us. The bread was vegan. The chef also made an appetizer of heirloom tomato "salad" with vinegarette cucumber&olives, as well as brussel spouts. On the menu, the brussel sprouts had honey and cheese. The ones we received were sweet, but it seemed to be a slightly watery brown sugar mix vs agave vs maple syrup. I didn't think it tasted like honey but I haven't had honey for 10y. ‍ Also the waiter assured us it was not honey. However, we ordered this again the 2nd time and in conversation with the chef, I found out he was not aware honey is not vegan. I kindly educated him and recommended he assume vegans don't eat honey unless they state they do. He made our brussel sprouts the 2nd time with salt/pepper. We again ordered the tomato salad. Both times, the main was a special Beyond meat meal with baked potato and broccoli. The first one was more steak-like, the 2nd was more like a skillfully cooked Beyond burger patty. I never liked red meat and haven't had it since 2008, but both meals were still pretty good. Also had some bites of veganized steak frites (has gluten), but they were a littl dry. For dessert, we had sorbet both times. Overall, the chef was Michael and was EXTREMELY kind and caring. He did not get defensive about the honey issue and truly wanted to learn/improve. He made sure we were happy both times and even said goodbye after our meal. read more

See all

The food and service were good, and the steakhouse had a nice ambiance, though it was very loud due to poor acoustics. The steak was slightly overcooked in places, but the dishes, including the Potter house, penne pasta, and apple pie, were enjoyable. However, the pricing for kids' fountain drinks was excessive at $4-$6 per small glass with NO refills, which was disappointing and added up quickly with teens who had multiple drinks. We wish the server would have informed us of this. Dinner was roughly a 2 hour experience. $$$$ Over all - good but expected better. read more

Seafire Steakhouse - Porter house and penne bolognese. - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

Reservations strongly encouraged. Very loud environment. Lots of anniversary and birthday songs are sung. Good selection for a steakhouse. The baked potato side is interesting. A mix of cheese, chives, and bacon. Pretty tasty. $170 for two entrées, one side and one cocktail. Remember, 25% get automatically added to every bill. It's worth a try. Enjoy! read more

See all

Typical hotel restaurant. Food was OK. Bahamian staff was mediocre at best. Will not return

It was ok. Family and I went around prime dinner time (6-7pm) which could have impacted our experience but we were overwhelmed from the start. The entrance is very small and packed and it was hard to reach the front desk because you can't tell who's in line and who isn't. Once we got back to our table we could barely move our seats. Our table was right against a pole and in between two large parties. My family and I could barely speak to each other because it was so loud. The food was ok. Nothing special. read more

Seafire Steakhouse - Filet - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

Expensive but not bad considering some of the other spots in Atlantis . We enjoyed dinner if you can sit outside read more

Seafire Steakhouse - Lobster was amazing - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

Staying at the Margaritaville Hotel here in the Bahamas people here are wonderful, but I wouldn't stay at this hotel ever again. Our shower broke in the evening and they couldn't get it fixed so we couldn't shower that night after being out at the beach all day they set up an appointment for 8 AM to come fix the shower. No one ever showed up. I had to get dressed without showering and go downstairs and tell them and then they had to move us to another room so we had to repack everything up, which was a great inconvenience as I am a little older Family was waiting for us at the beach wasn't even able to get out of the room Till about 11:30 AM by the time I took my luggage it was already noon. Half the day was gone don't want to do anything to compensate for it. I will never stay here again, but the island itself is gorgeous and for the most part people here are amazing read more

The atmosphere was lively and upbeat. I was really to excited to come here for dinner because I had come years ago and it was very good. This time I will call it good but not excellent. We started with the oyster Rockefellers and we enjoyed those. We also had the crabcakes which I thought were OK but my son thought that they were great. we also had an order of grilled shrimp which were actually pretty well seasoned and tasty. For my entrée, I had the braised short ribs. The sauce they were served in was really good, but some of the meat was not as tender as I thought it would be. The mashed potatoes served with them were good. My son ordered the lobster mac & cheese, and it was terrible. We actually sent it back and had them remove it from the check because not only was the macaroni not flavorful, but it was also soft with a terrible texture. In addition , the lobster tail was also pretty yucky and it is very hard to mess up lobster tail so we didn't understand that one. The dirty martinis were absolutely excellent. The lemon drop martini was good as well. It was packed when we arrived at 7:45, but we were seated within 10 minutes of our reservation time. Our server was just OK. She never really asked us anything about ourselves or interact with us. She simply took our orders and brought everything to us that we asked for. She wasn't rude. She just really wasn't that friendly, but I know that it was busy when we were there. They have a very large menu selection and maybe next time I'll try the steak or salmon. Lastly, br prepared that this is one of the more expensive restaurants at Atlantis Me and my son split everything - two cocktails, one entree and two appetizers and two glasses of lemonade and it was $200. $40 of that was taxes, fees and tip. read more

See all

First night in Bahamas, wasn't sure what to expect based off the reviews but glad we decided to try. Steak was cooked as requested and had perfect amount of seasoning and tenderness. Most importantly, not fatty! Mac and cheese was delicious as well as Mashed potatoes. Raw Oysters (not pictured) were also good. We ate around 830 & sat outside, around 9p there was a show/parade thru the town and was perfect - Dinner and a show! read more

See all

From the moment I walked in the service and atmosphere was wonderful. I was sat immediately and my waitress was awesome. The staff were very attentive. The food came out hot and fresh. Everything was wonderful and that had been my best meal being on the island. read more

See all

The steaks are amazing and the service is nice the interior reminds me of an old fashioned steak house which is exactly what it is. read more

Seafire Steakhouse - Food - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

Great service by Damon. Food was tasty (Porterhouse) and drinks were good. It is a little loud but we were there during high season. We met college golfer Antoine Jasmin read more

Great food and one of the best ambience you have ever seen. The service was first class and a great experience.

If you're looking for a steakhouse, look no further. They have some super strong alcoholic drinks here as well. One will give you a great buzz. The service was great. We got the porterhouse and it was decent. The filet mignon half was juicy, but the other half was a little dry. Overall, it's decent but not the best. read more

See all

I tried to make reservation but no avail. All dates for the week ( and the next) were sold out

We were excited by the menu walking by, but so incredibly disappointed when we ate here. The lobster bisque was some of the worst I've had. Also, the prices were a bit steep for what you get. read more

Seafire Steakhouse - Lobster bisque... more like lobster gravy. - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

Food was good as well as service. Make sure to book ASAP because we didn't and we had to eat later which was not the best. The food was great and the service was good considering how big the restaurant is. read more

Upon checking in for our reservations we were greeted by two waiters and one of them informed us immediately that the kitchen was backed up. And we told him that we wanted to place our appetizers first and then our entree. He did not like our response I informed the other kind waiter that we only wanted him up serve us. We ordered the Caesar salad and Cobb salad for an appetizer. Then we had the 10 oz Bahamian lobster tail and cheeseburger with onion rings. In addition, we ordered sparkling water and a gin speciality cocktail. The food was okay, but not reflective of the price. The gratuity is already added to the bill. We left additional cash for the nice waiter. If your seeking anything spectacular this is not the place. read more

See all

My fiancé and I were extremely excited to try this steakhouse. The service was great and start it out with drinks I had an old fashion; and we had to get appetizers of course! He had the shrimp cocktail I had the Caesar salad. For a entrée we had the porterhouse for two, my only complaint was that it was a little bit dry I had to ask for the house steak sauce which was an extra charge but no big deal. We picked the Parmesan fries as a side and they were delicious thick cut! read more

See all

Perfect service. It does however irritate me to no end that they just arbitrarily close every Thursday!! I'm always on business in Nassau on Thursdays!! WTH! read more

Very good experience here on may 4th. Very nice room. Service was outstanding. Started with a chopped salad split for 2. Ample, great mix of veggies, delicious light dressing. I had a 14 oz prime strip. Done perfect at MR. Wife had 8 oz filet, also perfect MR. Both were great. Sides of crispy brussel sprouts and mac n cheese were excellent. Pricing was slightly below NY steakhouse pricing and well worth it. read more

This was my favorite restaurant during my stay in Atlantis. I came here on Christmas Day for dinner. Loved everything about it from the contemporary decor to the amazing service and not to mention, the food was exceptionally delicious! I got the prime boneless ribeye and crispy brussel sprouts. Been craving it ever since. The steak was cooked to perfection and so flavorful-no steak sauce needed and the brussel sprouts (with honey & parmesan cheese) was the best I've ever had, it's to die for. Their grilled grouper was also very good. Not your typical steakhouse. If you're looking for quality steak and fresh seafood, this place is a must try! read more

See all

Nice spot, we were here on a Friday night and they where super busy! Service was a little slow but very nice and the food was worth waiting for. You get a bread basket so we dug into that one while waiting for food and drinks. The shrimp cocktail had the largest shrimp I ever seen! Today's Fisk was grouper and that was delicious, I chose Brussel sprout as a side and they where amazing...! read more

See all

Mouth watering steak, mashed and potatoes and Brussel sprouts. Cold, fresh wedge salad. Lemmon meringue tart for dinner. Super delicious!!! If you're craving flavorful steak cooked according to your order, this is the place for you!! so yummy and delicious!! This place is a win all the way around!! read more

Incredibly slow service on a Friday night despite the well staffed restaurant not being overly busy. Do not order the twin lobster. You get one, not two, and it's Bahamian lobster, so you're paying $60ish for one chewy and dry lobster tail. They messed up the orders on the burgers. Go elsewhere, like Chopsticks or Bimini. Ambiance was fine. read more

Eight of us went to dinner at the Seafire last night & I have to say ... it was a great dining experience. After reading some of the Elite Reviewers comments before hand, I was pleasantly surprised. The ambiance was warm but classy, we had three servers (one for each couple), that gave us impeccable service. The wifey and I both started by splitting a wedge salad which she describes as yummy. We both had the small filet (mild rare), it absolutely melted in my mouth. We split a large bakers potato with their special bacon butter (yum). The group topped it all off with the pass-a-round of "sticky-icky" & chocolate sundae. If you haven't heard of the "sticky-icky" ... and you're a desert lover ... you have to check it out. All-in-all an amazing dining experience and management must have listened to previous reviews. Highly recommend it. read more

Seafire Steakhouse - Chocolate Sundae - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

See all

The food was just so-so, we were completely rushed through our meal and the waitress was rude. A steakhouse meal, especially one this expensive, is meant to be enjoyed. Don't bother with this place; it isn't worth it. read more

The food was not good enough for the prices they charge, but good overall. The service I experienced was outstanding, making up some of the food's shortfall. 4 stars is a sufficient rating.. worth a try! read more

See all

Food is bad! None of our dishes were good. Overcooked, not fine dining. Service is just ok. read more

Amazing!!! The food is amazing and the service is top notch... make reservations because the the place get full very quickly. You will not regret it. read more

See all

I cannot recommend this place enough! My husband and I were very excited for a steak, and we were blown away. We split a Caesar salad and some raw oysters for starters, then ordered a tomahawk steak, mac n cheese, brussels, and a baked potato. Each thing we received was even better than the last!! This was truly one of the best meals I've had in a long time, from start to finish. The entire staff was friendly and helpful, but our waitress, Rochelle, was exceptional! She went above and beyond to make our dining experience great. We will certainly be back during future visits! read more

The food was delicious and the service was above amazing!! The restaurant itself was comfortable and relaxing!! Would recommend to all!! read more

Seafire Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

Food and service were terrible. We went here for our anniversary dinner and my husband wrote in the reservation it was our anniversary for the celebration and cake. Our waiter visited our table maybe 4 times throughout the whole night, while also rushing us to order. Gave us the wrong order, when we sent it back we asked for lemons to go with our LOBSTER, never received them nor did he ever come back. We asked 3 times. We finished our food before getting our correct sides so I told them to send it back and they walked out with it shortly after and the steak frites were quite literally hard potatoes. They Basically purposely cooked them terribly so they could close the kitchen down. (Our reservation was at 9:15 and they took 20 minutes to even come take our drinks so this was not our fault we were late.) They also never gave us our cake to celebrate. Terrible food, TERRIBLE service. Don't waste your money or time, go to carmines instead read more

Seafire Steakhouse - Shrimp. Undercooked and sauce was not good at all - Steakhouses Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

See all

Last night/dinner while at Atlantis (when is Yelp going to properly add the Bahamas instead of using Florida when it comes to the Atlantis Resort?!) and the family thought we'd go out 'classy' with a steakhouse. Our first/only time in the Marina 'village' of Atlantis and it was this awesome little 'town' (complete with yachts costing a cool $10M and their staff/owners looking like they're living the very best life the rest of us could never even imagine). We were greeted by the hostesses and I'm pretty sure they gave us a cool reception because my kids were definitely not dressed properly (we only saw the dress code sign as we were walking in and hoped our kids were young/cute enough to slide by) but the rest of the staff were beyond professional and extremely cool. Resort.  Steakhouse.  We knew this dinner was going to really dent our wallet but you gotta go big (and then go home), right? Steaks - family said they were really good but not the best they've ever had. Salmon - yes, I'm that guy at a steakhouse - was just perfectly cooked and seasoned and not a skimpy size. Sides - Brussels sprouts were incredible, the steak fries were massive slabs of potato with a great odd/unique coating of seasoning, baked potato was tender (I didn't bother with the jerk mayo or any of that other stuff they gave with the sides). The Mrs. really dug her Cesar salad.  (And she swore that the bread was great as well.) Wine (another place not shy about hyping their collection of thousand-dollar-bottles, huh?!) - a glass of their (house) pinot noir was solid. Over $400 spent, no desserts/coffee either. read more

If you are visiting Atlantis, Seafire is a must!!! First, make a reservation if you can ahead of time because they get super busy around dinner time!!! The bar is first come first serve seating but if you want to sit in the main dining room a reservation is not required but recommended to minimize your wait time. Our server was a doll!! She was so attentive and present during our entire meal!! She was always wiling to answer and questions as well as make recommendations on menu items. She quickly took our drink orders and gave us some time to check out the menu. A bread basket is provided while you wait for your food. My Steakhouse Burger was great!!! A thick juicy burger cooked to my liking garnished with a huge onion ring and steak fries that were huge and all potato!!! Crisp on the outside and fluffy potato on the inside. The Oyster Rockefeller was decent, not he best one Ive had but it was still a contender in the taste department, plus the bacon was cooked extra crispy!!! The Crab Mac and Cheese is interesting!! The cavatappi pasta served as a catch all for the mixture of cheeses and chunks of crab meat. Super cheesy mac and the crab meet was not overpowering. When in the Bahamas you do as the Bahamians do and have a Kalik to bring your experience full circle. I did recognize that our server bought a chilled glass for the beer, however I like my beer right from the bottle. The service was good and everyone was friendly when interacting with your table. Do not expect rapid service as island time is a thing and in all fairness I asked for them to bring the food out as it was ready instead of waiting for everyone's food to be ready which they obliged. PS. Ignore the address as the Bahamian address do not register on yelp. The actual address is: 3, One Casino Drive, Paradise Island, The Bahamas. read more

See all