I ordered delivery. The roasted beast Sammy, toasted with horseradish and stuff, was immense. Filling. And delicious. The person taking the order was very friendly and polite. It was an excellent choice. read more

Let me start by saying: I love Jimmy John's sandwiches. I used to work at a franchise in Columbus for nearly two years, both as an inshop and a manager, so I know this business inside and out. But this particular location on Court Street? It's a joke--and not the funny kind. I get cravings for these subs maybe two or three times a year, and without fail, there's a 50/50 chance they're out of bread. Bread. The foundation of the entire menu. How does a sandwich shop not have bread? That's like a gas station with no gas. And don't get it twisted--I'm not blaming the workers. I know what it's like behind the counter. I've put in thousands of hours at Jimmy John's and can count on one hand the number of times we ran out of bread. You know why? Because we had competent management. Managers who understood basic prep, who knew how to run a store, who didn't let the place fall apart daily. The fact that this keeps happening means one thing: the management at this location is either completely checked out or totally incompetent. You don't get to say you're "freaky fast" when customers are standing around for 30 minutes waiting on basic prep that should've been done hours earlier. At this point, walking by and not seeing a "We're out of bread" sign feels like a miracle. If I'm this frustrated only showing up a couple times a year, I can't imagine how fed up regular customers must be. The food is great--but none of that matters if the manager can't do the absolute bare minimum to keep the store functioning. Fix it. read more

The pickle was delicious! Staff was nice. Dining room clean. Ice on floor overall great experience.

If you can't accept orders on Uber eats then don't have your system on. I'm from out of town and it was depending on this for dinner at my hotel stay. If you can't fulfill the orders don't accept them on the app read more

What a joke. Ordered at 12:13 for delivery by 1. 1:30 rolls around, no food. I call and am told it's on it's way. 2:45 and still no food. Call back and am told they voided my order. No notification. Not that I would eat a lunch meat sandwich that was made 2 hours prior but come on. If I could give 0 star review, I would. read more

They didn't have a toaster for the sandwich's which I thought was weird. But the costumer service we had was more then worth it this is because they offered us free drinks when we ordered and also free brownies on our way out which was really kind of them even though that's probably not allowed. I highly recommend this place over the other sandwich shops even though I'm not the biggest fan of jimmy John's but if you're looking for kind service and maybe free stuff if you're lucky this is the place for you read more

They always mess up my order when I come here. Nice people but my sandwich isn't that hard to not mess up.

Order finally came after 50 minutes but they made the wrong sandwich. I thought jimmy johns was freaky fast

I love Jimmy John's sandwiches. I have eaten here for years. But my last three visits have been terrible. The place is dark, they don't have lights on behind the counter, it is dirty, no filthy. A lot of the kitchen equipment and boxes are piled into the booths in the dinning area. And what used to be fast and friendly service is no longer. I tried to provide feedback on the company sight, but they require lots of personal Information from you just so you can tell them that they have a problem. So it is strike three for the Jimmy John's in Athens. read more

Not freaky fast...just freaky... and disappointing. Ordered three subs via the app and drove to pick them up. There is ONE guy working. Order is not ready. I wait. One of my subs has turkey, provolone, and avocado. I added bacon. He informs me he doesn't have any turkey so he made my turkey sub with ham. To add insult to injury when I finally do get home with my subs he forgot the bacon! I know they are struggling to find employees and it's not the fault of this poor guy who was stuck working, but if you can't make a turkey sub with bacon at a Jimmy Johns you need to just close for the night. read more

Horrible service, NOT fast! If they don't run out of bread, it takes over an hour for delivery. No remorse, no concern.

Aight so this be my second time ordering from the Johns of Jimmy, and it's aight. I gotta say it literally tastes like a $10 version of what your mom would make you for lunch sophomore year of high school. Applying my own mustard is interesting, I guess it's confusing for the workers to use a mustard bottle to apply that shit themselves. Other than that the staff was dope as fuck and I would souly come back just to talk it up with them, but other than that Imma stick with Penn Station and Subway. read more

My friend came from OSU to visit for fest. We went to jimmy johns and they were out of bread and said they would be up and running in a few hours. We called and asked if we were good to order from the app and they said yes (they had bread finally). We ordered at 10:20pm and had to call 4 times to check the status. Each time we got a different answer (employees were so rude) it is now 12:20am and still no food. We called to void our order because we are tired and can't stay up any longer for the food to come. Freaky Fast my ass read more

I made my name on the order AND the instructions to cut my sandwich in half. They still didn't. Absolutely absurd. The pickles will forever be gas but still upset. 5/5 for the pickles. 1/5 for the worker who can't read to cut the sandwich. Still good tho read more

This used to be one of my favorite late night choices in Athens. Until one fateful night.... I was grabbing some 2:30 AM subs with friends when I notice something weird about the glove on the guy prepping subs across the counter. His glove appeared red. I didn't understand what I was seeing, obviously quite a few drinks in being past 2 AM. I kept looking and it was a dark red, and looked a lot like blood...filling his glove?! I thought it was impossible and I was most likely seeing things. I kindly asked the cashier as she handed back my card about the worker's glove. She said "Oh, yeah, he cut himself pretty bad on our meat slicer earlier. He had it bandaged but it kept leaking. He has a glove on though." My mouth dropped. An employee, with BLOOD gushing from his hand so fast that it literally filled his entire right glove, was making our subs. Most people were too drunk or distracted by friends to even notice. I demanded a refund from the manager and stated that I would never, ever return. I got my refund and will not return as an alumni to this day. Disgusting. read more

Tried to get a piece of bread. Refused to serve me and told me I had to order a full sandwich. I tried to pay full price for said bread but I was denied. Mean man, 1 star. read more

I like Jimmy Johns. Really like em. In fact, they're one of my favorite chain lunch locations. My fave sando is the beach club with extra turkey and tomatos on their whole grain bread. It's delsih and healthy. All that said, how in the world could JJ's have a 4.5 star rating? This speaks to the dearth of great eats in Athens. read more

Good lord, they are not joking when they say freaky fast. I was staying in a hotel on east state where I placed my delivery order. I timed it. 7 minutes and 14 seconds from the second I hung up the phone to when they knocked on my hotel door. I was throughly impressed, from that as well as the quality of the food. I highly recommend!! read more

Not amazing but reliable, good for late nights. The roast beef with tuna is a surprisingly good combination. read more

Talk about Freaky SLOW delivery. Took an hour for my sandwich to get to me. Disappointing. Food was fine, but the delivery speed? Terrible.

I love Jimmie John's. But this Athens store does not stand up to the quality of the others. I feel as if they didn't care about the product they were putting out. I'm hoping it is better next time. read more

I love their food they deliver but I want to be honest they are pricey not food is good staff are nice there. It's not a bad place just there prices are little high. But they do have good subs they are sweet. read more

If I could give it zero stars I would. I ordered a BLT and got stale crusty bread, overwhelmingly salty bacon. Three thin slices of roma tomatoes - oops! one of those slices was a pointy end of the tomato about the diameter of a quarter. My grandson ordered the turkey which I then paid $1 extra for cheese which we discovered after we got home was skipped. My daughter ordered a specialty turkey sub that was supposed to have avocado. This was her choice of where to eat and she had to open the sub and dig around to find it. I will never eat there again. The bill was almost $18 (subs only, no drink or extras as it was eaten at home). I was gouged. read more

After eating here a few more times, I'd definitely say it's the best sub place in Athens

So fast you'll freak!? I ordered a sandwich for delivery. Three blocks away! 2hours later the delivery person says he can't find the post office. You gotta be kidding me! read more

I don't know what the staff are like during the day shift, but last night the men working here were extremely rude and unprofessional. Apparently they ignore their customers (in the same room) for 15+ minutes and then ask "WHAT DO YOU WANT?!" when they finally acknowledge your presence. Quiznos was closed and Avalanche pre-makes their sandwiches so Jimmy Johns was the only other option I could think of. I recommend going to Kroger and buying your own bread, meat, veggies, etc instead of giving Jimmy John's in Athens your money until they hire better staff. read more

Super fresh and super fast! Best sandwich place in town. My favorite is a veggie - cheese and mayo for vegan style, extra avocado, dijon mustard, extra lettuce, extra tomatoes and their signature fresh bread too. We've had Jimmy Johns pick up, dine in and their super fast delivery - consistent quality and service every time. 5 stars read more

Sandwiches are Excellent. Service is alright. Recently "corporate" decided to cut out about 1/2 of their delivery area because it wasn't within "2 miles of the store." I clocked it on my way home, they stopped at 1.5 miles and i live less than a 1/4 of a mile from the cut off point. Their "line" also removed about 1/2 of the faculty/staff at Ohio University that live in Athens. These are people who live there year round and HAVE money to buy Jimmy John's regularly. I am not sure what brainiac came up with this new delivery area but it couldn't have helped their bottom line any. read more

Honestly the best jimmy johns I've been to so far. Super friendly workers and fast! The eating area is also very clean.

Best staff ever. Please give max and andy a raise. they're so great and they're so nice. if they dont get a raise you will lose my business.

This is such a terrible jimmy johns. I am currently waiting for my food and it's been well over an hour. This seems to happen every time. Awful service. Awful delivery. read more

Jimmy John's on Court Street in Athens Ohio has bounced their payroll checks three times in a row causing havoc in their employees lives. Do not patronize a business that does not pay their employees. read more

I don't know what it is about their subs, but I am not a big fan. They are alright but I have yet to have a sub that I thought was really good. Between the other sub places in town they would be better than Grinders, but take me to Subway or Quiznos instead. read more

I eat jimmy johns when I have to because there is so few food options in this shit hole town. Jimmy johns is know for their "speedy service" but I'd rather wait a few minutes longer not to have these cracked out locals make my sub. The one thing I find inexcusable and to be honest below me is that jimmy johns doesn't provide napkins! Am I to wipe my mouth and hands with my shirt? I dare not take a shit in the bathroom, I'd worry they didn't provide toilet paper. read more