A good neighborhood pizzeria on Staten Island. The crust was crispy, not too thick, and the sauce was well balanced. The calamari appetizer was very chewy but otherwise it's a decent option of you're in the area read more

Jimmy Max - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Crabby Jimmy's bread was amazing $14 for garlic bread topped with crabmeat and Parmesan cheese was average price but omg soooo delicious, the bread perfectly crispy and flavored with decent amount of toppings of seafood and cheese. The pizza was also huge size unlike other pizzas that are smaller for same size around $20ish. My favorite isn't Sicilian though (it was my friends) hence the lower rating but I'm sure their other thinner crust pizzas were amazing as my friend loved this pizza. The appetizer of crabby Jimmy's bread definitely was the highlight and would come here again solely for that amazing app. Tables weren't the cleanest but decent sports bar/restaurant seating area and chill nighttime vibe read more

Jimmy Max - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Great local place with great food. I won a gift card with a pizza of the month for every month. Each month has a different theme and you can get half plain or full plain if not your type. Always comes out hot and fresh. Also recently ordered the chicken tenders. Def not the fast food garage you get at some places. Nice thick pieces of chicken with a great batter and some tasty Fries on the side read more

Jimmy Max - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Let's begin with the facts. I am a Chef with 27 years experience. I am a NYC Pizza "Snob". I don't care "Who" rated this pizza, it's on that "Higher plane" it's truly a fantastic pizza. Consistency has been present for decades. Most people do not realize just how difficult, and what an art form creating a pizza of this caliber. There are literally a small handful of pizza joints that fall into this category of greatness. This is hands down one of the "Crown Jewels" of Staten Island! And on top of that, it's one heck of a great place to hang out and kick back! If you've never had the pleasure of trying this pizza haven? I strongly suggest going mid-afternoon on a Sunday during Football season. That's just a suggestion, anytime is just as great! Highly recommend! read more

This restaurant is always a pleasure. The food is excellent, the service is attentive and the atmosphere is friendly and welcoming. It's a pleasure to support Jimmy Max because he supports the community. read more

The best! Was there for a 65 birthday party. Staff was great and helpful. Food as always was delicious and Jimmy is a great host.

This place has been on my must try list for a while. Finally made it with my daughter and granddaughter. Seems like a good place yo have a few cocktails at a reasonable price. But we went for the pizza. Got the Jimmy max special pizza. Which was like a Margarita pie. It was quite good. Not quite a 5. Close. So my 4 star was strictly based on the pizza. Service was good. Prices very fair. If you are in the area and want a good pie. Worth it read more

Jimmy Max - Someone enjoyed the pizza - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Jimmy Max has always been awesome great chicken rolls and pizza I've gotten for take out and then sit in has always been great too with great sangria and Chicken parm. This was one of the only places giving back to the sanitation workers cleaning our streets and keeping our city afloat during the storm. So not just good food but good people too. Definitely the place to spend your money read more

We discovered this place about 3 months ago and have been there about 6 times. My son asked where I wanted to go for lunch on Mother's Day and I chose Jimmy Max because of their gluten free choices. Anyway, we were there again last night but unfortunately, left in disappointment. We found a bar table empty and sat down to wait for service. Mind you, we had sat at that exact table twice before and had a waitress take our order without any issues. Last night was a totally different story, however. We sat for about 20 minutes without anyone coming over for our order. Granted, there was no menu on the table as in the past. I mentioned to my husband that we would most likely have to order at the bar. While we were discussing this, the bartender, who had been ignoring us the whole time, looked over and shouted, "that table is taken, they went outside to smoke". Seriously? We saw them occupying an outside table and there had been no indication that we had taken someone's table- no empty glasses or bottles. A guy who was at the bar told us that we could have the table - apparently, he was with the group outside. Anyway, this really irked us, because the bartender never acknowledged us except to say what she said about the table. Which btw, since when are folks allowed to occupy 2 tables? She couldn't have informed us that we needed to order at the bar? Well, we left the place- it may be a long time, if ever, that we return. read more

A Staten Island staple. The Food the beer the drinks all the pizzas all awesome classic old school bar & feel just a great place read more

Jimmy Max - At the bar w/ the boyzzzz - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

My husband and I have started coming here more regularly. The food is always good and so well priced compared to other places on the island. Even when it's really, the wait is never too long and you can tell the staff is working hard. It has a nice laid back vibe and I'm happy to keep supporting them. read more

Jimmy Max - Half Arugula Pie and half spinach and artichoke pie - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Had a retirement party for my husband about 60 people. We had plenty appetizers and pizza with a open bar. I was so impressed with the service. They wasn't a time I needed another drink. Not even a minute went by and the waitress was there with my drink. It was a memorable night. And guess what I didn't have to break the bank!!!! I give this place 100% rating There is a party room in the back that's private and my grandchildren was able walk around and play. read more

Booked my son's first birthday here with Erin. I can't say enough good things, between the communication, the quality of food, and the fairness of the price it was a party we will never forget. We will deffinitley be back for future parties and can't thank the staff at jimmy max enough. (The wings and ice cold rolling rock are phenomenal). read more

Can't order a blackened chicken Caesar wrap for pickup is insane . Just tried ordering pizza an app and a wrap but wasn't able to order the wrap. Can't wrap my head around that one read more

I had my daughters baptism party in the private room for brunch on a Saturday. Service was great. Food was good with plenty of leftovers which we were able to take home. We were allowed our own speaker for music and our own restrooms for privacy. I abs love it and it's affordable. My mom knows Jim from OLGC which is awesome. I've also came for the bar some nights and it's great. Games are on TV. Bar is a bit tight, but it works ya know. Pizza here is spot on! read more

Food is delicious and the portions are plentiful. The baked clams are good and the mozzarella sticks are the best. The appetizer sampler is huge and the hot sauce the best I've had on the island. Pizza is crispy and delicious. Service was good in spite of it being very crowded as a fundraiser was happening there on Thursday 10/10/24. I look forward to going back soon! read more

First time here. Friday night was crowded and without a reservation only waited 10 min for a party of 4. This is a neighborhood pizza place/ restaurant/ sports bar. Many televisions. Many crying babies. Loved the pizza but the other food was just passable. Cold antipasto was stuff out of a marinated jar. No prosciutto or ham. No slices of provolone or mozzarella cheese. Fried calamari had no taste and was greasy. Shrimp Parm hero wasn't good either. Shrimp was not great quality and was overly fried. Pasta with vodka sauce was ok. I'd come back for the pizza only. Crust was delicious read more

Right now I can't say enough good things about this place. my husband's daughter had a fundraiser there and the place was absolutely packed wall-to-wall. The food was great. The service was amazing, especially considering how chaotic it was in the restaurant with all those people. The menu has plenty of choices and many are gluten-free if that's your thing. the prices were on point and I am looking forward to going back read more

Great family owned place in the neighborhood. It's familiar and warm. We usually only order pizzas here for delivery or take out. Tasty, never disappoints. read more

I went here for a friend's birthday party and the food was just exquisite. The service is great, and there were no errors whatsoever and this is because the waiters listen and care. The restaurant itself is beautiful and I am planning on returning soon. read more

Staple neighbor the turn around time is fast!! Love the pizza. You will as well. The cheese is amazing.

We come here to grab a quick bit to eat . This local eatery never disappoints. Fried Calamari was out quickly and was Freshly fried. Ordered 2 pizza's nice thin crust . Which was very good . read more

Jimmy Max - Fried Calamari - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

The food and drinks were great as was the service. When you combine this with their contributions to the community, it is a hard place to beat. Thank you for a great evening. read more

First Post... Jimmy Max - Max Brunch Burger $10.95 Bacon, Egg, and Cheese on a Brioche Roll... with a hamburger! Ordered medium, came out medium. Very juicy, flavor to the meat, bun exactly as it should be, very brioche-ey. Egg was fried well, so no goo running down the burger, but the cheese was melted nicely and did run down the burger. Bacon was good. Served with home fries...cubed potatoes and onions, decently seasoned... Bonus Points... staff at the bar are great on a Sunday. Friendly, attentive, quick to tend to your needs... read more

Jimmy Max - Max Brunch Burger - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Hospitality is definitely what makes this place a hotspot. Food on the other hand is mediocre at best. Pizza is just not that good and chicken is rubbery. Good spot if you are looking for something quick or you're blitzed. read more

I went to Jimmy Max this past week for a lunch - my sister's track team was doing a fundraiser with the establishment and 50% of the check went to them. Immediately I thought this was very generous and love that this local business is supporting the Staten Island community. We ordered fried zucchini as an appetizer and each of us got our own hero. The fried zucchini came out piping hot and was extremely fresh. We could not stop eating them throughout the course of our meal. I ordered the Mary Max hero. It was similar to a chicken francese. There was definitely a lot of chicken in it but I wish there was either more sauce or cheese it seemed to be lacking a little bit of flavor. The price was definitely worth it though for the amount in the hero - plus I had the other half as my lunch the next day! I will definitely be coming back to Jimmy Max again. There is so much on the menu that I am looking forward to trying. I couldn't get over the variety of appetizers, dishes, and pizzas. read more

Jimmy Max - Mary Max hero. - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

will recommend it! Great food! Nice ambience and convenient with prices. Good customer service.

I gave Jimmy Max another try since it was my dads birthday and he wanted Italian for his birthday dinner. We ordered beforehand and said that we would pick up the order at 6:00. This time I waited about five minutes and two workers helped bring all the food to the car. We also got wine on the house and the lady in the front that helped us was super friendly. Overall the food was great and I would come here again. read more

See all

Love love love they're rigatoni bolognese amazing so fresh and homemade always happy on The Weeknd they get so busy I felt only once it was rushed read more

Jimmy Max is probably the only reason I'll return to Staten Island again now that my friend has moved away. Great food, service, atmosphere, prices, people, beer and drink choices!!! On top of all of that they are constantly giving back to the community!!! This place deserves 1,000,000 stars!!! read more

Visiting one of my old haunts... Recently renovated back in 2017 Jimmy Max has a whole different look to it. Where a private party room used to be is now a very modern looking bar. And where the old bar was is now a dining area with plenty of space compared to the old days. Came in earlier for lunch with my brother. Actually passed on pizza for a change. But they do have quite the gluten free menu on that end. He ordered a pasta dish called A La Maria. Sautéed chicken breast , sun dried tomatoes & broccoli in a white wine sauce. Substituting the rigatoni with a whole wheat pasta. I went with a local favorite, the Mary Max sandwich. Sliced chicken cutlet with lemon, white wine , a hint of butter & topped with mozzarella. As good as it used to be. This is a very family/ kid friendly casual restaurant. Believe they still have the after school activities for the little ones. Which is in the very large party room off to the right as you walk in. Like what they're done to this place. Adding many large screen TV's in the bar and dining area to watch a game. They do have a rather extensive beer list. Plus specials galore on game day. Enjoy. read more

Jimmy Max - Mary Max sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

I gotta tell youse folks that my wife and I were very, very disappointed tonight at one of our favorite pizza places. Tonight, we ordered a pizza and checked with our server three times within an hour to find out when it would be served, each time he told us the pizza was in, however, it was taking extra time cause they were backed up. After seeing some folks who walked in after us get their pizza, we asked a different server to check on our pizza, we were ensured that the pizza was on it's way. Ten minutes later we checked again and our server told us the pizza was not ordered. At this point we decided to call it a night despite assurances that our pizza was in the oven and would be out shortly. While we appreciate the apology from management (who we had to call over) for not charging us for our drinks and eggplant parm hero, the bad taste in our mouths from the dishonesty from the staff could not be quelled. We certainly are upset about tonight cause Jimmy Maxx is a go to place for us and sadly that is no longer the case. read more

Pizza came out great and the staff was very friendly. The appetizers were excellent. Will be back again to get more food. read more

Jimmy Max - Half Jimmy Max Special Pizza and half Who Cares Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Let me start out by saying I used to love this pizza. However, tonight I went in with my family to eat and we were seated in the back dining room which we shared with only had one table: three adults and three small children. When I tell You that these people were boisterous and carrying on so loud, it was insane. Literally yelling and laughing as if no one else was in the room. They didn't have any consideration for us. The guy yelled "NO FARTING OK?" This is the crap we have to listen to while dining there? How about No. No one expects silence when you're dining but you don't want to feel like you're at a damn tailgate party either. The kids were running circles in the dining room and this ruined our dinner. The servers did absolutely NOTHING about it. This is what is allowed. "Do what you want like you own the damn place." Last time we will ever go there. Literally the worst experience. If you know the owner, and chat it up, you're good. Otherwise, find another pizzeria. I'm So disgusted. You can keep your pizza Jimmy Max. read more

Jimmy is a very generous person, as evidenced by the amount of fundraisers he sponsors. He gives back 50%. The food isn't so bad neither. The rice balls are fresh. The Mary Max pizza is so much better than the hero. Big menu and many choices The newer look in the bar area is great. Sometimes it's too loud from bar guests; other times it's quiet and no music is playing. Dine in or delivery, it's a hit read more

Nice place with a tavern vibe. Went with family for my hubby's birthday and we had a great night. Nice assortment of appetizers and pizzas were really good . Sangria did not disappoint either. Very good service also . read more

Awesome pizza - nothing has changed!! We love the service and the clientele...and they have a great bar scene. Highly recommend!

We had a family gathering here. It was wonderful. The service was on point. We had a party of eight and didn't want for anything. The food was over the moon. I had the eggplant. It was perfect. Since I have been living in Georgia for the last 27 years, I haven't been able to get a decent eggplant dish. I wish I could have it shipped to me. read more

We celebrated my husband's birthday yesterday at Jimmy Max for dinner. We made reservations for 6 people the same day. Everyone had something different and all were satisfied with their choices. The entire staff could not have been more friendly and very accommodating. Would definitely recommend! read more

Brought my Mother, wife and In Laws in to my old favorite place from 15 years ago. What a horrible meal, service and place it turned into. Calamari was rubber and bland. No seasoning in the batter. Fried fish breading was gummy and undercooked. Service was never to.be found. I got up 3 times to get condiments, forks, napkins. Unacceptable. Stuffed mushrooms tasted old and filling looked like scraps of garbage. Smelled worse. Pizza, the Max Special, was the only saving grace. My memories of the 90s held true. It was good, but still nothing like the pizza with strips of tomato and fresh grated Romano cheese like the past. You guys should be emabarrased. I was with my family for recommending you. read more