Domenico&#x27;s Pizza

Nice place, seems to have everything you need. A fast no nonsense counter for take out; delicious…read moreslices to choose from; and a back room to rent. The slices hit the spot, just point and get out of the way. I'll be back next time I'm running errands nearby.

This was good! Standard good quality pizza in NYC…read more I came to Mimmo's and ordered basic pizza slices to share with my niece and nephew. We had pepperoni and cheese slices. I also decided to try thier hot honey cheesesteak roll and I'm glad I tried it cause we loved it! We all shared the one roll and I was mad that I didn't get two. The cheesesteak roll tasted like a savory cinnamon roll. It was sweet and spicy. Yum. Service was friendly. Parking is tough, they have a small parking lot that feels up fast. They also offer indoor dining. I paid 16.00 for everything.

As the weather gets colder Mimmos gets hotter try one of our many delicious homemade soups.

Enjoy our great Italian coffee, espresso, cappuccino, with Italian biscotti.

See all

Complementary bruschetta and mixed olives when dining in. Re-opening February 14, 2021

Denino's Pizzeria & Tavern

4.2(1.1k reviews)

4.8 mi•Elm Park

101 years in business

Family-owned & operated

The Pizza was perfect, Service was perfect Jersey waitress, the restaurant was amazing and more…read moreover go to the ice cream place across the street after Ralph's "it's cash only" but the perfect compliment to Dinner and dessert

When in Staten Island, Denino's is a staple for all the locals here. Our friends brought us out for…read morelunch. While the pizza is good, it wouldn't be something I'd specially make the trek out for. I do like their Cheese Pie ($19.50), which had a crispy and thin crust. This was simple, but good. We also ordered the Garbage Pie ($28.50), which had various toppings as in the name. This one didn't quite have any flavor that stood out, but gave more sustenance. We also got an order of the Fried Calamari ($16), which were lightly coated and fried nicely. I did enjoy these as an appetizer, which is great for sharing. Overall, it's a solid place that lives more on nostalgia. The place does get busy though. They also have a small parking lot, but we were also able to find street parking on a Sunday afternoon.

Calamari

Penne vodka

See all

Broccoli Rabe ravioli w/ sausage sun dried tomato and broccoli rabe in a white wine sauce

Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe

4.6(122 reviews)

4.5 mi•Westerleigh

I'm still not over Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe. This place has completely won me over. The food is…read moreexcellent across the board, and the service matches it. It has a casual vibe, but still feels like a proper restaurant, which makes it perfect for anything from a quick bite to a relaxed sit down meal. It's a small spot, so I'd definitely recommend making a reservation if you plan to dine in. I've tried their signature coal oven pizza, chicken parmigiana, penne vodka, and the flatbread. Everything was absolutely delicious. You can also order drinks, not just soda or juice, which adds to the overall experience. Street parking can be a challenge, but it's worth it. I was so caught up with enjoying the food that I barely took any photos, and that just says it all. I'll definitely be back and add more pictures next time.

Many cultures around the Mediterranean have different forms of chickpea fritters and/or…read morechickpea-filled sandwiches. There's of course falafel to the east, garantita in Algeria, and panisse in France (or socca in a similar vein). Sicilian panelle is Italy's counterpart, and the version at Ungaro is an excellent example of it. The panelle comes served with a healthy serving of ricotta on a seeded bun. It has a relatively mild, filling flavor that lets you fully enjoy the chickpea fritters themselves. They also have a potato croquette sandwich on the menu - a distant cousin of the Vada pav I plan to try next time. The half vodka pizza we tried was good, with high-quality mozzarella and a decadent sauce. The pie itself had a nice chewiness to it - if I had any suggestions, perhaps next time they could go a bit easier on the quantity of the sauce.

See all

Calzone bottom

Pizzeria Giove

4.2(458 reviews)

1.4 mi•New Dorp, Oakwood

Definitely worth the hype. If you are looking for a high…read morespot, that seems to be a neighborhood institution, go here. The pizza is excellent and the vibe has that old school family feeling. Like a place where you take your family on a kid's milestone birthday. Actually got the pizza to go, and the customer service was excellent. The pie arrived even faster than I thought it would.

Good pizza and good assortment of things.They treat you well and have a good delivery service…read more It's one off the best pizza places in Staten Island.

Inside

See all

Inside

Joe & Pat's Pizzeria

3.5(558 reviews)

3.7 mi

I'm going to keep this quick and simple…read more Want the best Vodka pie in the entire Northeast? This is where you need to be. Do not hesitate. Just do it. Even if you never had or tasted vodka sauce, try it anyway. There will be no regrets. At all. The rest of their stuff is pretty good too... But Vodka. Buy it. Now.

The gravy was way too acidic. The veal was too tough. Very disappointing. The front of the house…read morewas nicely decorated wa a little messy attention to the kitchen

Inside

Margherita Pizza with clams, shrimp, and pancetta.

See all

Outside

Lee's Tavern

4.4(737 reviews)

2.9 mi•Dongan Hills

amazing!! clam pie and a blue moon beer priceless! love this place, have been going there for years!read more

True Score: 4.25 Stars…read more Probably the best bar old school place in Staten Island. Lees Tavern is a bar pizza joint in Staten Island. It's off the beaten path but worth a visit. The pizza was fresh and delicious with a crisp crust. The food is served by the nicest, friendliest people. We visited here on a recommendation from a friend and were very pleased we did. The pizza was delicious (the best we've had on our trip) the atmosphere is warm, and the team are really friendly. It feels like a proper bar with personality unlike much of New York. If you're a tourist getting the Staten Island Ferry to see the Statue of Liberty, rather than getting straight back on, take a break to come here instead, you won't be disappointed. Wait, I need to enhance my earlier comment. This is the best family dive bar on the island. I true classic. A must stop. Thanks

Buffalo "galamad!" (Calamari)

See all

Beautiful Bar Room

Mamma Mia Pizzeria & Cucina

4.3(15 reviews)

4.0 mi•Rossville

This place is the definition of a hidden gem, and I mean hidden. It is tucked away in a big lot…read morenext door to a laundromat, making it incredibly easy to drive right past unless you're specifically looking for it or happen to be there to do laundry. I wouldn't have known it existed if I hadn't gone searching for new spots, and I'm so glad I did. The pizza here is excellent. I tried a couple of their speciality slices, and it made me want to come back to try more. It's one of those places where you take one bite and immediately start planning your next visit. The service was another pleasant surprise. Everyone was welcoming, the food came out quickly, and the overall experience was just as enjoyable as the pizza itself. Some places deserve more attention, and this is definitely one of them. I'll absolutely be back... again, again and again.

They don't put any sauce on their vodka pies. I could not taste any of it on this pizza. You would…read morenever even guess that it's a vodka pie from this photo.

Vodka Pie wit mushrooms

Vodka grandma with half pepperoni

See all

Nonna’s

4.6(13 reviews)

6.0 mi

Driving the New Jersey Turnpike towards Long Island when the pizza urge hit. A short Staten Island…read moredetour brought us to this excellent and genuine NY pizza stand with outside seating. A dozen different pizza varieties - we picked Sicilian pepperoni, eggplant, and white meatball. All were thin, oily and with crispy crust. A bottle of Mexican coke to accompany. Perfect.

I took a lengthy bicycle ride through Staten Island and I rode up to Nonna's for a bite. I ordered…read moretwo Margherita slices and then planted myself outside. The slices were thin and crispy. Twelve dollars for two slices and a bottle of water is fair. I'll be back!

They make a delicious thin and crispy pizza! The margarita was my our favorite!

See all

Vodka and spinach artichoke DELICIOUSNESS!

Brother's Pizzeria

3.9(312 reviews)

4.5 mi•Elm Park

I was heading back to my hotel from target when I passed this place. I Decided to stop in for some…read morefood. When I got back to my hotel, the clerk saw my bag and asked me where I went. I told him, "brother's." he smiled, nodded, and said "they're good." He was right. It's a nice place, nothing fancy, they do have a nice dining area. The people are friendly. I decided to get a margherita slice, and I saw these little balls. I asked what they were, and he said "potato croquettes." they came in an order of three. I got my food and I took it back to my hotel. It was amazing. The slice, the dough was perfectly thin, not tough at all, it was a very good quality cheese, I could definitely taste the basil, and the sauce underneath was amazing. The croquettes, they were not over breaded or over fried, they were very tender. The potato inside was creamy and delicious, and they came with an amazing marinara for dipping. This wasn't just your normal tomato sauce. This marinara had a deep rich flavor that went perfect with the croquettes. The price was extremely reasonable for what I got. They are cash only, but they do have ATM at the entrance to the store. I'm a fan. Next time I'm in the neighborhood, I will be back. Thank you.

Ordered two pizzas for delivery: Buffalo chicken and pan pizza. Total (not including tip) was about…read more$65. Both pizzas had cardboard crusts. The pan pizza was soggy in the center, tough throughout most of the slices, and not crispy except, mercifully, at the edges. It was loaded with mozzarella but didn't have nearly enough tomato sauce to cut through the fat. The buffalo chicken pizza had a tough, mealy undercarriage, with dry chicken and not enough sauce. My order was delayed by about 10 minutes, taking over an hour to arrive even though I live nearby. It definitely wasn't worth the $74 I paid post-tip. Can't speak to the ambiance since it was a delivery.

Seating area

Square pie

See all

Round Pie Pizza Company

4.1(139 reviews)

3.6 mi

My husband and I order here often especially during my pregnancy. I love their California and…read moreCaesar wraps. My kids love their pizza. When I am not filing well their Cheddar Broccoli soup hits the spot. You do wait a while for your food but that's because it's always packed. No matter what time of the day they have a long list of people that are ordering. So call ahead or order online then wait about 15-20 minutes but I think it's worth the wait.

We ordered from here a lot. The hot honeyroni pie is my husband's favorite and the California…read morechicken is my son's favorite. I was never really a fan until I tried their spinach and artichoke slice. It's excellent. It taste like a spinach and artichoke dip. Absolutely loved it. Can't wait to order the whole pie. I ordered their rice balls. I wasn't really a fan, but the spinach and artichoke is excellent.

Things to do in Staten Island

Yummm

See all

Rice Ball Parmigiana

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

10 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Val Z.

8 years ago

Domenico's Pizzeria in Bay Terrace has been successfully doing business for over 10 years! We could not have achieved this without the patronage from our loyal customers throughout the years. On behalf of our staff I express our sincere thanks and appreciation to all who have chosen to order from us on so many occassions. With that being said we hope you are not influenced by any negative comments on social media and online reviews as we had many false review published. Our commitment to work hard and provide the best service and dining experience with always remain as long as I am the owner of Domenico's Pizzeria. Once again on behalf of myself and the staff here at Domenico's Pizzeria, we would like to thank you for choosing us and being apart of the Domenico's family! read more

Mr. M.

2 years ago

Although I generally refrain from designating favorites, I must assert that their Margherita pizza ranks among the finest I have ever encountered. The sauce is not only authentically traditional but also exquisitely crafted, while the dough is remarkably fresh and airy--a quality that is rather elusive in this locality. While my experience with their menu has been somewhat limited, I am eager to return and explore a broader selection for further assessment. read more

Leo G.

11 years ago

The food is always excellent! The pizza is always hot upon delivery & you can definitely tell that fresh ingredients are being used. Domenico's is not just an excellent pizzeria, but an excellent restaurant as well. The salads and whole-wheat wraps are amazing, and the entrees that I've tried have never disappointed! The waitresses are very accommodating and friendly and my experience eating in the restaurant has always been pleasant. read more

Max L.

7 years ago

Unprofessional staff. Manager is scum. You reap what you sow. 9 dollar mozzarella carrozza. You've got to be kidding me. And the marinara is like water. Scumbag manager challenges me to a fight over the phone. This place is an embarrassment to the neighborhood. Typical staten Island wannabe tough guy bullshit. He can make more pizza and less Mooney. read more

Petey M.

6 years ago

This is how they Send a pizza with Extra Meatball ...when I explained to them what happened...they Said they would Make a Fresh pie ...but the Catch was ...I had to come Pick it up ...this is how they treat a good Customer...I used to Order a few times a week ...I will be giving All our Business to Nonna's pizza Great kills read more

Sam S.

12 years ago

I've recently tried this pizzeria and was taken by surprise. The pizza as well as the food was unbelievable and the atmosphere was awesome. I was immediately greeted by the staff and was quickly seated to eat. I am definitely going to come by again!! read more

Mark A.

4 years ago

Great pizzeria, has great pizza and paninis. Their grandpa pie vodka is the best around. They're very busy there but that speaks to the great food they pump out. read more

Juliia K.

4 years ago

Always delicious, always on time. Meeting our expectations! Thank you! read more

Alina V.

11 years ago

Amazing thin tasty pizza and the best mussels I have ever tried!

Gregory K.

15 years ago

Hero's are outstanding and the grandpa pie is a must have

Domenico's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

Best of Staten Island

People found Domenico's Pizza by searching for…

People who viewed Domenico's Pizza also viewed

The Original Giuseppe's Pizza

4.0

(38 reviews)

We ordered a variety of pies for delivery on a Saturday around lunch time. The pepperoni pie and…read moregrandma pie were great. The ricotta on the white pie was piped onto the pie instead of just dolloped like I usually see it. The white pie was lacking in flavor despite the pretty presentation. The veggie slice was PACKED with veggies. We ordered anchovy pizza and it was honestly brutal. I've had anchovy pizza before but this was next level fishy. Definitely would recommend if in the area!

After 5 months of searching for a pizzeria that delivers to our new home, we have just found it!…read more My husband's family had been going here since he was a little kid but he hasn't had their pizza in years -- needless to say it was an incredibly nostalgic experience for him & the pizza was as phenomenal as he remembered! Best pizza I've had on Staten Island I've ever had!

La Piazza Pizzeria and Restaurant

3.3

(116 reviews)

I can't rave enough bout the calamari pizza! The fried calamari pieces had a good crunch, not flat…read moreat all. Good flavor. Friendly staff. They had other pizza slices that I'm definitely eyeing for next time. Pay in cash, there's a discount.

They added a gelato machine. You have to check it out. The coffee gelato is delicious.read more

Villa Monte Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.4

(225 reviews)

I recently catered through Villamonte on Richmond Ave for a birthday. Food was excellent, fresh…read moreand hot. Delivered on time! Guests were very happy with the delicious food as well. Would definitely recommend and use their catering services again in the near future.

Just had dinner there was delicious. I ordered a fresh cold calamari salad with lettuce and celery…read more It was so delicious. Not salty. It was a big portion too!

Ti Amo Pizza

3.9

(57 reviews)

After all that running around and playing at "We Rock the Spectrum" just across the parking lot, my…read morepizza-loving son needed lunch, so we decided to give Ti Amo a try. The place was packed with kids and family for a late Saturday afternoon, which is always nice to see. The place was bright and clean, with the staff waiting to take our order with smiles. My son quickly picked his regular slice, and I opted for their chicken and broccoli alfredo slice - YUM! It was warmed to perfection, and my son ate his slice with gusto - crust included! My alfredo was delicious and crispy! The slice was more firm than what I was expecting, and was even debating about bringing a slice home for hubby, but decided fresh is best; better luck next time for him! For our slices, a bottle of water and a Brisk iced tea, it came to $10 cash! That's something that can't be beat!

Want authentic "Brooklyn style" pizza This is your place! We had the pepperoni roll, margherita &…read moreWhite pizza so friggin' delicious OMG the crust Food is not greasy, not dry or salty Made just right! We carried out -vodka & pepperoni pie. 5 stars for service, Ambiance and the staff! So glad my son & I stopped here before heading back to Jersey. Will definitely be back! Thank you Ti amo pizza

Kingdom Cafe

3.2

(47 reviews)

We had half pepperoni/half plain with garlic knot crust which could have used a little more garlic…read morebut was definitely tasty. The mozzarella sticks were a bit greasy but the chicken fingers & fries hit the spot! Delivery was quicker than expected. Will be ordering again!

Great neighborhood pizza place. Plain slice was delicious. Thin, crunchy, great cheese to sauce…read moreratio, sauce and cheese were spot on. Good bet for a quick lunch

Sal & Lloyd's Pizza Place

4.3

(43 reviews)

This is exactly what a classic pizza place should be. Family-run, welcoming, and built on genuine…read morerelationships, they take the time to know their customers--especially the regulars, who are greeted by name the moment they walk in. There is a level of care here that is becoming harder to find. They are always willing to accommodate a special request, even if it is not on the menu, and they do so with a smile rather than hesitation. The pizza is consistently excellent, but what truly sets this place apart is the full menu. The hot meals are just as impressive--fresh, satisfying, and clearly made with the same attention to detail. A dependable spot that delivers both quality food and a sense of community.

Best pizza I've had since growing up in Brooklyn. Delicious! Huge slice, crispy from oven with the…read moreperfect amount of cheese -- it was how pizza SHOULD taste. Everyone else falls short. Also, AFFORDABLE. This is old-school pizza that everyone should experience. I'll be back soon!

Primo Pizzeria

3.3

(63 reviews)

We had spent the day celebrating my parents birthdays in the city (we took the Staten Island…read moreFerry). On our way home, we wanted to find some quality Italian food on the island for dinner. My mom had found Osteria by Primo on google. Unfortunately, they were unable to accommodate our party of 7. They suggested we go next door to their self serve less formal sister restaurant. Luckily, there was a large table outside. Overall, we had such a great experience here! Frank's customer service really stood out and honestly went above and beyond. He made it seem like we sat at the actual restaurant. Everyone was so friendly, welcoming, and attentive, and you could tell they genuinely cared about making sure we had a good experience. It's not often you come across that level of service, and it really made a difference. The restaurant was intimate and small. It was located on a corner of a residence street and a busy road. We never felt rushed, and the staff made us feel right at home. Both of my two boys (10 and 8year old) absolutely enjoyed the food. We absolutely enjoyed it as well. You can tell their food is fresh and not frozen. Frank had told us they put in their order every couple of days to really provide the quality. We'll definitely be coming back! It's always nice to find a restaurant with great food, but even better when the people working there make you want to return. Highly recommend!

Gluten free pizza ,not up to par ,need new recipe…read more Unfortunately I not able to eat regular pizza

Prime Pizza Kitchen

4.1

(90 reviews)