I was heading back to my hotel from target when I passed this place. I Decided to stop in for some food. When I got back to my hotel, the clerk saw my bag and asked me where I went. I told him, "brother's." he smiled, nodded, and said "they're good." He was right. It's a nice place, nothing fancy, they do have a nice dining area. The people are friendly. I decided to get a margherita slice, and I saw these little balls. I asked what they were, and he said "potato croquettes." they came in an order of three. I got my food and I took it back to my hotel. It was amazing. The slice, the dough was perfectly thin, not tough at all, it was a very good quality cheese, I could definitely taste the basil, and the sauce underneath was amazing. The croquettes, they were not over breaded or over fried, they were very tender. The potato inside was creamy and delicious, and they came with an amazing marinara for dipping. This wasn't just your normal tomato sauce. This marinara had a deep rich flavor that went perfect with the croquettes. The price was extremely reasonable for what I got. They are cash only, but they do have ATM at the entrance to the store. I'm a fan. Next time I'm in the neighborhood, I will be back. Thank you. read more

See all

Ordered two pizzas for delivery: Buffalo chicken and pan pizza. Total (not including tip) was about $65. Both pizzas had cardboard crusts. The pan pizza was soggy in the center, tough throughout most of the slices, and not crispy except, mercifully, at the edges. It was loaded with mozzarella but didn't have nearly enough tomato sauce to cut through the fat. The buffalo chicken pizza had a tough, mealy undercarriage, with dry chicken and not enough sauce. My order was delayed by about 10 minutes, taking over an hour to arrive even though I live nearby. It definitely wasn't worth the $74 I paid post-tip. Can't speak to the ambiance since it was a delivery. read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Large buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

I wanted to go to Brothers yesterday as I haven't had them in a while. I was very disappointed. My first complaint is how they cut the pizza. If you look at my picture, you will notice that this isn't a pizza cut, but rather a property line dispute. Then they charged $34 for the pie. Finally. The quality is definitely not how I remember it. It used to be soft and fluffy and was anything but that. On a positive note, the sauce was sweet, but they definitely need to revamp their recipe. read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Square pie - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

This place has become a staple when I visit my family in Staten Island. They have a plethora of food to choose from, but you can never go wrong with getting a slice, especially one that's hot and ready to go. My cousin got a plain pie and I got two "rice balls" aka arancini and a margherita slice (at least that's what I think it was). The rice balls were incredible and comparable to those that I had in Sicily. The slice was like heaven. The ingredients were so fresh and it was hard not to devour it in one bite. I def. savored that slice as best I could. Not sure if I'll make it back there before I leave and if not, I know I'll be back next time. read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Rice balls and a slice - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Update: Chicken roll was pretty good on my last visit. It was stuffed with big pieces of chicken and loaded with cheese. The sauce was pretty good too. Their squares are classic Sicilians and something you expect to find in a classic pizzeria. read more

Brother's Pizzeria - two pieces of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

New ppl working in here and burnt my pizza and the wait for two slices was so long and the pizza order came out wrong but the wait was so long im hungry to complain and wait again i just ate it. And why is two slices of pizza and an order of Caesar salad with chicken $30???????!!!? Such an unhappy ang unpleasant experience. Except the kitchen lady and bathroom they were nice read more

Brother's Pizzeria - caesar salad chicken cutlet - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Miss this place! Such a Wonderful Family owned business. The Pizza Margherita & Calzones were so delicious & Reasonably priced. Hubby & I got to meet Filippo Giove Jr & He was very polite & super chill, even made our pizza! We'll definitely visit again! read more

See all

This is my favorite Pizza spot on the island. The pizza is always nice and fresh, the service is fast and friendly and the ambiance is cool and laid back. read more

See all

One of my favorite pizzerias in Staten Island. The food is always fresh and delicious, the pizza is consistently great, and the service is friendly. Whether it's a quick pickup or delivery, it never disappoints. Highly recommend! read more

Brothers pizza has the best food also the service is good.. they all have good service to the customers read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Steffybotz... I like brothers chili demons - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

OK Tough Guy - Stop claiming to be from New York City. Everyone knows you're from Milford, Pennsylvania or Fishkill, New York - Please spare us the lies and stolen valor. Bronx born, Long Island raised, Toured the Means Streets of Every Borough in this City - Battling the Demons in countless Emergency Rooms across the great city of New York - And, yes - I lived in Queens throughout my tenure which traumatized me. No Psychiatrist could calm be down; The only thing I could find to relax me is a good slice and an ice cold Mexican Coca Cola; - I've had them all, across Queens, Manhattan, Brooklyn, the Bronx and in the current decade - G-d has brought me to Staten Island. If you are still reading this, I guess you have figured it out, sizzle chest, this Fat Hebrew boy knows what he's talking about. Brother's Pizza in Staten Island quite possible may be the best and finest Pizza on the planet. Take a Prozac New Haven - yeah, you guys are amazing - But, you haven't tried the Sicilian slices at Brother's Pizza in the enchanted and forgotten world of Staten Italy, I mean Staten Island. Confession, please don't have me wacked for saying this, the regular Napolitano slice is off the chart too. Why is Brother's Pizza so incredible? Does this Pizzeria sit upon ground containing magical water, pumped from the sacred ground making the most incredible and delicious pizza dough? Is it the "Love" and "Skill" of Filippo Giove and his Colorful and Friendly band of Loyal Meshugganahs Pizza Boys who pull each and every one of their culinary masterpieces out of the oven. Let's cut to the chase, Pizza is exceptional and made from the finest ingredients. Every visit to Brother's Pizza, you will get service with a smile and perfection. Don't be a putz, make the shlep to Staten Island - Yes, they have Parking. I suspect you may find some of the best pizza, particularly the Sicilian, on the planet earth. Don't forget to show Love and Respect to the G-dfather, Filippo - He's just a regular, run of the mill Mensch. L'Chayim / Salute! read more

See all

I have been going to Brothers pizza for decades it's my goto spot for QUALITY authentic old school slices . The Sicilian is their most popular for good reason but the vodka slice and margarita are pizza perfection , BEST chicken roll by far and entrees that really are very GOOD and nice portions . The owner is very cordial and and a excellent staff to deal with the crowds read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Heaven !! My go to at Brothers - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Pizza was amazing !!! I highly recommend this establishment. Friendly staff and lots of options read more

See all

Been coming here for years since I was a child the owner is a sweetheart there pizza is the best on Staten Island and nyc no one can beat this if u haven't tried u need to read more

First time here and I was blown away by their Sicilian slice, the crust, sauce, and cheese were perfection! The crunchy and chewy corner could be best described as pizza candy. The guys behind the counter were super friendly and service was flawless! One of their guys has also won 3rd place for best pizza in the Wisconsin Restaurant Expo! The establishment was clean with plenty of tables for seating and clean bathrooms. Highly recommended! read more

See all

I've been eating at Brothers Pizza since the brothers actually owned it. I don't know who owns it now, but it has definitely changed a lot. The once tasty pizza has been replaced with a tasteless sauce and really chewy dough. The sides I ordered left much to be desired, that being the rice balls, the mozzarella sticks and the potato croquettes. The mozzarella sticks were the only tasty thing I ate that afternoon. I had to cover the pizza squares with seasonings and it still didn't help. Sadly, I will never eat there again. read more

See all

I ordered the same thing every time I go and the employees are charging me different prices. This is not the first time this has happened.

I haven't had their pizza in awhile and decided to try it. It as simply awful, the pie was burnt Crust black and cheese brown Shows a complete neglect of basic cooking I threw it out It was disgusting Same your money read more

Still one of the best when it comes to taste but the finished product is sometimes inconsistent. When paying the high prices here, perfection is expected. Sicilian pie should have some crisp and be cooked fully on bottom. This wasn't read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Pizza has tons of oil. Amazing flavor. But it's just has too much oil. I've had better pizza, but for last minute run it's perfect.

The pizza is always very good! The crust, sauce and cheese and generous with the toppings makes the pizza perfect everytime! When my family and friends are in town that is their first stop and last stop before they fly back home! If you ordered from here then you know! If you haven't then you need to try their Sicilian! read more

Super friendly service. Owner showed us his pizza throwing skills even. The pizza was amazing and they even had gluten free pizza, which my friends said tasted even better than the regular pizza. Inside was a typical NYC pizzeria. read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza with basil and hot honey. - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I been going to Brothers pizzeria for years. Its quality pizza made fresh. And if you want to eat in the ambiance is like little Italy. But that's just one person's opinion. read more

Absolutely my favorite pizza. I can't come to Staten island without stopping by. I've never had anything I didn't like here. The squares are already sold by the time they come out of the oven. Amazing!! read more

Pizza was OK. I've had better service was wonderful though they get you as soon as you walk in the door ambience is just like any other pizza shop tacky looking. read more

Haven't been here in some time and unfortunately this will be my last. Firstly it's cash only so when you are having your pizza craving , you're not going to leave but you'll use the conventionally place atm machine in the shop that costs $2.75 added to the pizza bill I had a square and a slice and got nauseous. The cheese has been cut down to some really cheap mozzarella imitation. I'd rather spend a little more and get a good time time real mozz slice in any of the other hundreds of places around read more

Sicilian square cheese tastes like Crisco must be a processed cheese. Worst slice. After taste like vegetable oil.

I Love Brother's I haven't been there in a while but It was great the food,the drinks,and the service !

A very decent spot for pizza on the island! Ordered from here for Super Bowl. We ordered a whole pie - half was plain and the other half had mushroom. We also ordered two separate pizza slices with sausage. The pizza was tasty and had a good amount of cheese and sauce. The crust was crispy too. We also ordered calamari and they were soft yet crunchy at the same time. My family and I were satisfied with our meal! Important to note that it is pick up only and the service was pretty fast. read more

This place scams their customer and it is absolutely ridiculous. I literally ordered food and they charged me more so i leave and call the store on my phone and ask how much was it for what i got and they tell me a cheaper price and i asked why are your workers charging me more and i said it happens a lot and they just dont care so i feel like they are teaming up stealing money from the owner by up charging customers. I let it go a couple of times but it has been happening a lot and it has gotten out of control they change the price on their customers whenever they want and it is usually the older hispanic workers. I see the owner talking and welcoming their customer and that is great but the fact that your workers are doing this to the customer is a big slap in the face and if the owner know about this and isnt doing anything that is sad. read more

With this pizzeria, and this review, my pizza project for finding the best slice of pizza in New York City is over. I ordered 3 slices here, a regular plain, a Sicilian, and a white. All of it came out to under $10, but they do not take credit cards. With all that said, let me get to the slices. Regular slice: Solid slice, well balanced, the crust is more chewy than crispy. The cheese pulls away from the slice and it can get messy. The bottom of the crust is big and could be used as a breadstick. I liked this slice the most. It is like Rick Astley, it will never give you up, and never let you down. Sicilian slice: A very cheesy Sicilian slice. It has a fluffy crust, plenty of sauce, but does not make you feel stupid afterwards. It is like that kid who everybody picked on, but later learned not to. It might not be pretty, it might make for an easy target for ridicule, but once you give it a chance and see it for what it really is, you will be happy you took a chance on this slice. White slice: My least favorite of the slices I tried. The crust is undercooked; the cheese is uneven and messy. This is one slice I regret buying. I have had better white slices elsewhere; this is one I strongly recommend you look the other way. -- As the last pizza joint, I am happy I finished on a relatively high note. The regular slice is a good slice for the value, it has the qualities that I seek in a New York slice. It blocks out the evil and brings out the good in us. It is not the best slice I had, (forgive me, for I went to 30 pizzerias across five boroughs in a city with a population of approximately eight million people) but I think I can expect good things out of this slice in the future. read more

Brother's Pizzeria - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

The wait time was short. The Sicilian pizza was great. The round pie was delicious!! I have eaten here numerous times and will continue to do so. I wish you would deliver!!! read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Me I wrote the review!!! - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I stopped in for a few Sicilian slice. It's a real pizzeria look with a great selection and ambiance. The counter service was fine. The pizza was absolutely delicious. I'm glad a came. read more

Best pizza on Staten Island. Never disappoints Chicken rolls. Vodka chicken rolls. Buffalo chicken rolls. Vodka squares. Everything is phenomenal read more

Ordered a Sicilian and pepperoni pies. Came out to $55. Insane. The Sicilian was good. The pepperoni was soggy and coated your finger tips in flour. Was not impressed. Never saw the hype with Brothers. Especially being a cash only establishment. I personally prefer Deninos-they never miss. Brothers is decent for a slice or two in a pinch. Now that's I'm on the island occasionally-realized i wasn't missing anything. read more

I came here on a Monday when Denino's was closed, but I thought it was a hearty if not a gigantic delightful pizza. We split a pepperoni pizza, and even for 3 people we couldn't finish it. It's really not something that's easy to eat with one's hands. The slices are huge and it's heavy from the cheese, but if you use a knife and fork, that's easy to overcome. It was overloaded with pepperoni and had a great flavor to it. Definitely don't need to ask for extra cheese. Service was good. We did start with calamari which was good but nothing amazing. If you enjoy pizza leftovers, this is good one or if you go with 4 people it would be enough. There's a small parking lot in back, but if that's full, there should be street parking nearby. read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

This is one of our familie's favorite pizzerias. Good tasting sauce. Very good chicken rolls. In fact they are the biggest chicken rolls of any in the area. The squares are awesome so are the small rice balls. The place is busy so you have a quick turnover in food, keeping what you buy fresh. 25 year customer. read more

Best Sicilian pizza on the planet hands down, I've been a customer for 30 years and still amazing read more

Brother's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Bought 2 pies for the family.. 1 extra cheese, the other sausage. Ordered ahead of time and my order was hot and ready when I arrived. Both pies were delicious. Brothers never disappoints. Definitely recommend. read more

Best on the island. You can never go wrong here. Anything you order is good. There's a reason they are always crowded.