It's not the Jimmy's that we had before the building he was in for many years was taken away. However, despite the limited menu, and limited hours, what they are serving is very good. We had a gyro an order of stuffed green peppers. I continue to hope Jimmy will eventually open another brick and mortar restaurant. read more

Ordered a gyro platter got a sandwich and ton of french fries and a salad with rotten tomatoes Called the restaurant spoke to one of the employees who pit me on hold first and then asked me the same question as if he didn't speak English He really couldn't be bothered and hang up I called back and asked for Jimmy obviously he was not there Will not order again read more

At the Mall and end of day hungry. A Greek salad always sounds good. And this one didn't disappoint. A little less feta would be ok too. But a great salad. Thoroughly enjoyed. Excellent fries too. Remind me of shore boardwalk fries. Friendly service. Genuine. The falafel appetizer, not so much. And it's a food court. You're not here for fine dining. But yeah! Good food. read more

See all

First time today. Got the gyro platter which came with a great gyro, fries and a good Greek salad. Will definitely be back.

Everything was amazing and I would've gave it four stars but the tzatziki sauce was a bit bland . The gyro itself is the best in town for sure . Located in the mall though so it's kind of inconvenient. Other then that food seems fresh. read more

Jimmy's Greek American Grill - Greek Near Me - Sebring, Florida

See all

I ordered a Greek salad and it was so tasty. The service was very friendly and timely. read more

Jimmy's Greek American Grill - Greek salad with chicken - Greek Near Me - Sebring, Florida

Great Greek salad and chicken pita. Good homemade French fries. All around great experience.

Great gyros, good Greek salad and excellent fries Fast service Plenty of parking Worth the trip to an almost empty mall read more

They had to relocate to the Lake Shore Mall food court. Not the best place to have a meal but take out is still to die for. The Gyros are full and so tasty. Do not let the location turn you off of the great food they still provide. They have a full menu and it all is excellent. Great Greek food!! Fast and very professional service!! read more

I was running errands in Sebring and needed a quick, solid sit-down meal and as always Jimmy's delivered! Open twelves years with a consistent four stars they have never failed to deliver for me. Nothing fancy, just good solid home cooked food. Adult Libations- Basic beer and wine. A had a couple of classes of Merlot that were a heavy poor and went great with my food. Customer Service- Nice ladies scurrying around efficiently with big smiles. No complaints. Food- Yes, it's Greek with plenty of classic choices but there is also lots of Italian and American selections. I went Italian with a Sausage & Peppers Parmesan Grinder and a side of fresh-cut fries. It was out quickly, and the aroma was off-the charts! Damn was it good! Lots of sausage and melty cheese and a fresh sauce. I love fresh-cut fries. They were not super crispy as most little places like this can't double cook them, but they were still great! Including two glasses of wine my bill was about $18 and I was out the door in forty minutes with a smile on my face! read more

Jimmy's Greek American Grill - I love fresh-cut fries! - Greek Near Me - Sebring, Florida

A "whole in the wall" [quite literally] hidden gem inside of Sebring, Floridas style dystopian mall. Very few businesses are left, but this amazing food is located across from the AMC theater. Management is super nice and professional and very knowledgeable about what they are making. Greek salad is delicious!!! Tried a few other appetizers, and my daughter got the classic gyro. All delicious. read more

Jimmy's Greek American Grill - Greek Near Me - Sebring, Florida

See all

Visited In mall in Sebring at the food court Gyros were $8.99. Platter of salad and fries $11.99. Very juicy gyro and was delicious. All I ordered. The staff answered questions about ingredients and were sure to let us know "no lemon" in gyro. Atmosphere in food court was quiet. Opposite AMC theater 3:30 pm. Large Greek menu. Recommend it as fast stop. read more

Nice place. Good food. Fair price. You won't be sorry. Enjoy your food! I like to go here and then see a movie. AMC is right there.

Had a hard time finding the place. Nobody mentioned that it's in the food court of an almost dead mall. Once I was in the food court I still managed to walk right past it. But the people were friendly and the food was good. On par with most free standing restaurants. If I was in the neighborhood I would eat there again. read more

Did not eat there. Online pics indicated inside dining with beer and wine available. The restaurant is in the mall now, not a stand alone or enclosed building. Seating is in the food court. Jimmys was located next to a strip mall in a free standing building. The pics online are mostly of the old location. Food is now served on disposable plates, not the China shown in the pics. As long as you dont expect China, beer or wine and know it's dining in the food court, give it a shot. I have been told the food was quite good at their previous location. read more

Jimmy's boasts of having the best gyro in town, but tonight it was all about being the closest thing to the office after a stressful day. And yes, they have cheap beer. Two Coors Light made for a bit of "relaxation therapy" before and during my meal. Service was excellent, but that's likely because there were two waitresses working and I was the only person in there. Which is fine. I did get the gyro and it was quite good. Very well stuffed with (I assume) lamb and an extra pot of tzatziki on the side was a nice help. Fries were okay, the salad was excellent. Despite it being 9:00 at night, the lettuce was clean and crisp and fresh. A good amount of dressing and plenty of crumbled feta cheese was excellent. And that gyro just kept pouring out meat like some sort of bottomless pita bread. I also got a piece of baklava and it was pretty good. I'm glad I didn't go for the extra drizzle of honey as it absolutely did not need it. Flaky and tasty. Yum. Good stuff here at Jimmy's! read more

See all

Excellent burgers and service!!! Close to the AMC movie theater in the mall! Good menu as well!!!

The Gyro at Jimmy's was solid. The meat was tender, the onions were crisp, the pita bread was soft, and the tzatziki sauce was creamy. Overall, an enjoyable meal and a place I would visit again if I happen to be in the area. read more

Jimmy's Greek American Grill - Gyro - Greek Near Me - Sebring, Florida

Good food fair prices... old style type restaurant with hand checks no computer...gyro was good.. mausaka good too . read more

See all

Jimmy's is open again at 901 US Hwy 27 N, Sebring Lakeshore Mall. The food is SOOOOO GOOD. Great food and Great staff. We will be back!

On Jan 24, I was passing through Sebring and spotted Jimmy's Greek and American Grill. I stopped in and knew it was going to be good from the aroma on entering. The waitress was friendly and prompt to get drink and appetizer order. I had a draft beer which was nice and cold and tasted great. I ordered the Greek appetizer - with feta cheese, Mediterranean olives, cucumber, tomato, onion, peperoncini and grilled Pita bread. It was delicious! I ordered the Gyro platter and it was fantastic. The Greek salad was fresh and great and the Gyro meat had a lot of great flavor. Monica ordered the stuffed shrimp (stuffed with crab meat) (which I got to try) and they were delicious! The prices were reasonable. The service was great. The place is clean. It is not fancy but not a dive either. I wish I could visit this place on a regular basis. I will visit as soon as I can get back in the area again. I've posted photos of the place and food. read more

See all

Jimmy's USED to be good. Not so anymore. We kept going back thinking things would get better but sadly, things have gotten only worse. Had the gyro platter yesterday. The salad was old, the fries mushy and cold and the gyro itself was on old bread and the meat was overcooked. Unfortunately all this year the majority of meals have been subpar. We are going to have to cross this restaurant off our list of good places to eat. read more

Great place, good food. I went to my Yelp app today to make sure they are open. Yelp says they are open until 9:00 p.m. I drove out of my way to get food to enjoy later in my hotel room. I pulled in at 6:45 to find a sign on the door that stated "NEW SUMMER HOURS 7:00 - 4:00 " read more

Let's not just go throwing around five stars, OK? Competent kitchen. We had some well prepared fries and tasty souvlaki. Pita was better than the run of the mill. Also, reasonable French toast. Coffee was Ok. Folks were nice and accommodating. The building? It should be condemned. And the cleanliness of the place left much to be desired. Three stars and not a glimmer more. read more

First timers and not disappointed. Early Sunday morning for breakfast , seated right away, nice comfortable atmosphere and clean. Food was good, eggs Benedict ..yum Service was good also we will return!! read more

Great Greek/Italian food and service, everything from gryos to spaghetti. Sandwichs are a meal and the quality is first class.

Horrible!! I ordered fruit platter and fruit was ROTTON!! My wife ordered roast beef and it was not bad but ROTTEN as well as in turned, spoiled, would've caused food poisoning for sure had she ate it, my sons fries look like they don't change grease in fryer and his chicken fingers looked way overcooked, my two daughters had spaghetti and meatballs and they seemed to like it but it looked chef boyardee, not even deserving of one star, this place should be shutdown, be careful read more

Jimmy's Greek American Grill - Greek Near Me - Sebring, Florida

OMG. best gyro in the state. Extremely friendly service and staff. $24.00 with tip for 2. read more

Waitress cocky over charged for breakfast. Owner sat and watched did nothing. 33.00 for two. Wont go back. Plenty of better restaurants in Sebring. read more

Wonderful gyro sandwich with the best sauce I've ever had. Worth your time, great fast cook but go early to avoid the rush

The grouper was excellent, Greek salad crisp and real carrots. Just loved the dinner .

I'm from the New York metropolitan area and I was raised on Greek diners. They're in my blood. Living here in Sebring I've been missing my Greek diners something awful. Imagine my delight upon discovering Jimmy's. I had the Gyro Platter and ordered 6 stuffed grape leaves on the side. The grape leaves, brought to us by the lovely and delightful Holly, were so delicious my eyes rolled back in my head. The gyro was flavorful authentic and the tzatziki sauce.... Yum!!!! Service was prompt friendly and delivered with a smile. We will be coming back here frequently!!!!! Made my week!! read more

First, the food is good. Not great, just good. However, the owner walks the floor during the peak service hours, only greeting and talking to his regular patrons. He has absolutely no interest in greeting new customers. This is pretty obnoxious considering that our order was wrong. Our waitress dropped it off at our table, immediately promised to fix the problem, but then never returned to do so much as refill our beverages. Meanwhile, the owner was literally one table over, schmoozing with someone while we could hear cooks yelling at each other on the line. This is basic management stuff: smoothing out the edges. When we finally got his attention, all he did was call our server over to the table and continue his conversation. This place appears to suffer from laziness and indifference. read more

Probably the best restaurant we've been to in Sebring the grouper was the best An I'm picky.. the stuffed peppers rice pasta corn made Billy almost cried the rice pudding was so so good so good!!.. we won't go anywhere else!! What a great Find!! read more

Great place to eat no frills great food good prices. Good atmosphere. What else can you ask?

Owner Jimmy and his daughter Penny gives personal service. Our go to breakfast place and their drive thru service is great!!

Very good place to go for Greek food. We went here for lunch twice this week. Had the gyro and fries one day and the gyro platter the second say. Would recommend this to anyone who wants a great lunch read more

I love this restaurant! Their Greek salad is phenomenal and always fresh. You can't go wrong if you go in or dine inside. The service is excellent. Don't leave without trying the spinach pie. You feel like part of the family when dining here. read more

The best Souvlaki with Taziki sauce I've eaten since being in Greece many years ago. The restaurant is actually owned by a Greek and his food is rich in traditional dishes as well as a number of American favorites like meat loaf, fried fish and other daily specials. I often order take out and can just drive up to the window and pick up my meal. Not much on atmosphere but the food makes up for that. read more

Overall fair price for the money Had chicken Slovakia platter which had decent amount of chicken. Lots of fries and Greek salad Nice People. Good choice read more