Was in the area doing some shopping & wanted a quick bite to eat. First time at this pizza shop, which serves more than just pizza. Greeted at the counter. There is plenty of seating inside. I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni pizza & a drink. I also was given an extra slice of what I believed to be a chicken cutlet slice to try out. It was pretty tasty. Now I know of a great pizza shop when I'm back in the area read more

See all

So I usually go to Pellegrino's, but because this place is closer, I decided to go here really bad mistake. I ordered a plain personal pizza with just chicken and avocado. Came in this was my mistake. Apparently they already have a chicken and avocado pizza talked to them told them that I couldn't have the ranch on the pizza because I'm allergic and I just wanted a plain pizza with avocado and chicken, they say yes I go out and about come back and I receive a pizza plain with just avocado. I know I'm not an idiot. I know I said chicken and avocado stated it multiple times. I don't know if I pissed somebody off I will not be coming back read more

Joey's Pizza Italian Restuarant - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

We decided to order takeout on a really busy day. We ordered the Cranberry Walnut Salad. Salads are my go to since I can't eat dairy or eggs. I had my salad without cheese--they were happy to leave it out. Yelp says vegan options but I didn't see any on the menu--that's why I gave 4 stars. Some people seek vegan due to food allergies. Service was fast. The food was fresh. The salad was amazing and filling and great for the price. I can't comment on Ambiance since it was a quick online order and pickup. Serving size was great for a salad. Will come back! read more

Joey's Pizza Italian Restuarant - Cranberry Walnut Salad - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

Breaking up a long trip in Middletown and Joeys was near the hotel. Best pizza we've had in quite a while. Excellent sauce and plenty of pepperoni. Wish we had a place this good back home. read more

Joey's has always been one of my favorite places for pizza! I know they had new owners so I figured I'd give it a shot. We were out Xmas shopping and stopped in today. Customer service was great, place was spotless however... The girl pulled my slice out from underneath the counter and it looked old and dry. My mom got a slice with sausage, hers was off the counter. Looked dry also. The girl put the slices in the oven, told us she'd bring them to us. We sit down, she brings us the slices and both were burnt to a crisp and super dry. It reminded me of cardboard but super crunchy. It didn't even taste good. I hope this was just a fluke. I really was craving good doughy Joey's pizza!! Super disappointed! read more

I absolutely love this place !! My family goes here almost every Sunday after dollar Sundays in goodwill and the pizza and quiet literally everything is perfect ! Not to mention the staff are tremendously nice ! Really gives like a homey pizzeria feel ! I tell my coworkers and friends about this place all the time we ordered cupped pepperoni pizza from here for my coworkers baby shower because she's been asking for it for so long and i knew they had it ! She loved every bit of it ! read more

Joey's Pizza Italian Restuarant - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

Love this spot. Great variety (try the chicken BLT and penne vodka slices) as well as all the regular stuff. Powerful AC, it's always a little chilly but that's great for summer. Service is super quick. read more

Tried Joey's again. Once again the food was disappointing. Let's start with the Fried Ravioli, we never got them, how do you forget an item but yet charget us an extra $4.84 for extra Cheese on your Chicken Parm.‍ Next up Cheese Mozzarella & Ricotta calzone, I ordered it with mushrooms. There were exactly 6 mushrooms in the whole calzone for which i paid extra. The calzone arrived very soggy and not crispy. So, in summary if you want food that is overpriced or better yet missing ingredients and items. This is your place to go. Joey's is now on the save your money list!! Rate: 2/10 read more

Pretty Decent Place for Mall Pizza! Restaurant seemed very clean even the Bathrooms were clean. Issue we had was why we're all the soda bottles stacked in the hallway to the bathroom? Service was pretty lacking as we walked up to the counter to pick the food for who knows how long it had been sitting out (hours or days)! The Garlic Knots and Calzone were delicious once we carried back to the table ourselves and cleaned the plates off our own table. Had a pretty steady crowd coming thru for dinner! We would come back here again if we were in Middletown read more

See all

Awesome service & amazing food. Best chicken Parm I've had in a long time! Clean restaurant, nice music. Our entire group was very pleased with our meals. read more

Joey's Pizza Italian Restuarant - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

Passing through town & my kid wants pizza. We get pizza at home, on the regular, but it's a treat to see if "out of town pizza" holds up to our weekly fare. We arrived at Joey's around 7 pm on a Tuesday & I was afraid they were closed with only the staff inside. Once we sat down, business picked right up! Several to-go orders, meal delivery orders, and a few others choosing to grab a seat indoors with the refreshing air conditioning. For a place that closes at 830 on a Tuesday, they were steadily busy for the duration of our meal. The oldest got a slice of deep dish cheese pizza. The youngest got a slice of large & thin Sicilian cheese pizza. I ordered the small Antipasto salad with house Italian dressing, and the Grilled Chicken Tuscan Sun hero, no bread. The kids LOVED their slices; especially being able to get 2 different kinds of crust but essentially the same thing. I was too excited to eat before snapping a photo of my Antipasto salad. Crisp Iceberg lettuce, green olives, green peppers, tomato, red onion, paper thin slices of salami folded into cups, surrounding strips of roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella. Then came the anti-hero. The chicken - very tender - covered the ENTIRE plate! More roasted red peppers, more fresh mozzarella, and a very tasty balsamic vinaigrette. It was delicious! And the price for it all was a steal! I wasn't expecting a pizza joint in a strip mall, but I'm so glad we gave it a try! read more

See all

The staff was nice and the food tasted great! The prices and menu variety was nice and there was plenty of tables to sit at. Loads of parking and they also participate with the app "Slice." read more

Joey's Pizza Italian Restuarant - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

See all

(4 stars since we only tried very few items) Stopped in here after a hobby lobby trip with my 17 month old. I ordered a regular slice, pasta slice and kids order of meatballs. Regular slice was very good and the baby loved the meatballs! It came with 3 good size meatballs and he ate 2 which is a lot! It also came with a hero size side of toasted Italian bread. The sauce was also very good. I'm not a fan of outside marinara sauces but I would absolutely order a dish with theirs again. Staff was very nice. The girl brought our food to us and they found time to check on us even with a busy counter. And for parents, the high chairs were clean! That's a big plus. I feel like 90% of places never wipe down their high chairs. I'll definitely be stopping in again and will order some different items. read more

I've gotten both take out and dined in. It's always a good experience. Incredibly fast service, even when you order on a Friday night. The food is delicious and they are incredibly generous with the portions, so much so that one entree usually becomes an eating challenge. Highly recommend. read more

I love these NY style pizza places. This one was recommended by a local. The pizza had that crispy NY style crust and had a good flavor. Salad was huge but dressing wasn't as good as I was hoping. Fresh lettuce and toppings it just would taste better with a different type of salad dressing. Service was fast and friendly. My coworker I was traveling with had wanted wine but they don't offer wine. read more

Joey's Pizza Italian Restuarant - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

See all

no good service i waited 15 minutes for my pizza guy put it in the oven i had to say something then i was given cold pizza i will never come here again read more

Best pizza around ! Everything on the menu is made fresh ! Very friendly staff and owner!

Under New Ownership Pizza is nothing like it was. They have some good looking pizza but not what it was. I had a slice of something with vodka sauce it was ok. I also ordered 6 wings with a Garlic Parmesan sauce Nice big wings however the Chicken tasted off I believe the wings were spoiled. I ate two and that was enough. The restaurant offered to make new ones but I declined. Also offered a slice of pizza But also declined my stomach was a little twisted from the wings. Service was good workers friendly. Just not for me I wish them luck read more

The music was enjoyable while eating and the people there was stunning and nice, the food at the other hand was pretty bad the toppings and cheese fell off as soon as we grabbed it, it was very soggy. It was New York Pizza but not at the same time. Everything else was good and amazing but its just the food. read more

Outstanding! Our dinner tonight is as great! I had the Cheesesteak with onions and American cheese that was on their homemade bread. Out of this world! My husband had the spaghetti and meatballs unbelievably delish. The garlic cheese bread was a little over powering with garlic. Been coming here over ver 10 years. We've have been disappointed. Keep up the great work. read more

Vegan was a bit salty today and the other pie was garbage. The dough was uncooked on the non vegan pie and I couldn't get it to finish cooking in my oven at home. Waste of money tonight. read more

Joey's Pizza Italian Restuarant - Uncooked top of crust was very doughy. Couldn't eat the pie. - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

Mediocre pizza, would not write home about it. Easy online ordering but bland flavor. Ordered the Margarita pizza. Put pesto on the leftovers and it was tastier. read more

It's a hit or miss every time you go. Sometimes it's good, sometimes the crust is so thin you poke holes in the crust lifting it up to fold it. Always check your bill as well. read more

Tasty vegan pizza. I'm not a vegan but the person for whom I bought it for really liked it as well.

I would absolutely love to give this place 5stars! however I haven't tried their pizza!! I did however enjoy their pasta entrees, and from all the entrees I was able to try .. WOW! So delicious. The portions are big and I was able to enjoy the food for two days! The pasta dishes specifically are superior and 100% better than ANY New York pizzeria I have encountered. The chicken dishes included the pasta within the plate. Usually pasta and chicken is separated. Wow. What a place! I truly enjoyed this big difference. I have a friend who lives around the area and I was lucky enough to go here and I was very impressed. The place was pretty busy for dinner on a Thursday night and I know why. There was no wait, someone helped me right away. Since we ordered take out we just picked up the food but from the looks of this pizzeria- it looks clean, and the slices on the counter all looked delicious and fresh. I will be coming back for more ! And of course to try the pizza. read more

Best place hours on Sunday are wrong they close at 9:30pm just so everyone knows very clean and tasty food they care to make the best for everyone read more

Joey's Pizza Italian Restuarant - Beautiful - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

Great pizza! Since I moved to the area this has become my favorite pizza spot. Really love the chicken Parmesan pizza! The staff is always great and courteous. read more

Kitchen food is outstanding, and great lunch specials! They will also customize anything you want, including the pizzas. read more

Joey's Pizza Italian Restuarant - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

Delicious pizza every time I've been. Amazing staff service, never keep you waiting to order! Kept clean & very welcoming

Ordered delivery on DoorDash and got the Miami, the garlic and the volcanic wings. The garlic wings were super unseasoned and tasted only of fried garlic. There was no salt whatsoever. The volcanic wing in simpler terms was just buffalo with chilly flakes sprinkled on. Not really what I was expecting and both wings were meh. The Miami pizza is a square pizza loaded with pepperoni. The only problem that I had with this was that it was on the sweet side. I'm guessing that the pepperoni is sweet? I'm ok with it personally but I'm sure most people will prefer the standard savory pizza instead. read more

Gotta try the Sicilian! It's surprisingly light - almost pan pizza like. Super service!

I decided to come here because of some of the good reviews this place has, especially for the eggplant pizza. My main gripe about this restaurant is the cleanliness. The service was overall very good, as two of the workers in particular, were very friendly and attentive, but I am concerned about cleanliness. I don't know what the health code is here, but I noticed that the young man who is a cashier was also preparing food to order. I was sitting at a table nearby waiting for my to-go order, and with the customers coming in after me, I noticed the young man was handling payments with his bare hands, and also picking up pizza slices with his bare hands to heat up. He would briefly wash his hands...like enough to get his hands just wet and then wipe them. I did not see him using soap, so that was a bit gross to know. He did this multiple times in plain view. Their sink is right behind their food display, so it's not that hard to miss if you're paying attention. Don't get me wrong, he was very nice, but I'm not so sure about being sanitary...I also saw a few workers that were behind the register within my view playing on their phones while they're working in the kitchen. That's also concerning given that there are many news articles now that people take their phones into the bathroom, and that phones are even dirtier than toilet seats Aside from the health concerns, I ordered the eggplant pizza slice as many people recommended. I don't think the slices are made to order, but are rather warmed to order, and I understand why they would do that. If you want your pizza fresh, you'd probably want to order a whole pizza, but other reviewers have mentioned the concern of paying more for the whole pizza, so keep that in consideration. My mom ordered one of the philly cheesesteak sandwiches, and I would not recommend it. The bread was toasted, which was nice. The beef didn't have the depth of seasoning I expected, and tasted like it was just boiled and salted. There were some pickled peppers in there, which made the sandwich taste better. However, after enjoying the pizza, the sandwich was pretty disappointing and I couldn't help my mom finish her sandwich, so we ended up tossing at least half away. They do give a bag of chips, so that's pretty cool. We ordered an extra can of pineapple Fanta. I'm not factoring this into the rating because they didn't produce that, but I wouldn't recommend it because the taste of pineapple is very mild, and it tastes a bit too sweet. I'd stick to regular orange Fanta. Overall, the pizza is decent, but all other things considered, it is just a fair pizza place. read more

See all

Pizza was OK at best. Got two different pies, one chicken parm and another was their specialty pie. Both were drowned in cheese and not too crispy of a crust. Went numerous times before and the previous time to this review was a very similar experience, but I figured I would give them another shot. I'm not all for a massive pool of melted mozzarella on my slices, but that might just be me. read more

Just for the record this may not be the best atmosphere, but as for food and I mean food not pizza this is one of the best restaurants around. The food is prepared to order and comes out hot The salad is fresh and as for the garlic bread It is to die for because they use real garlic not a spread. The waitress Kayla on Saturday is one of the most pleasant people I have met Her attitude is down to earth and makes the visit pleasant But as for the food it is to die for. There is no other other place in Middletown for Italian and the prices are great and the portions are huge. I strongly recommend that you try it for the food and even the pizza you will not be sorry read more

This place is a great one to visit when we are on this side of town and we've never been unhappy. It's always very busy but they handle it well. We've never been there and felt ignored or walked out due to a wait. We order specialty slices from the counter and then wait for them to be heated up. The pizza has always been good. Service is always good, staff is polite. We enjoy the food when we go there. read more

I love the pizza here, and the friendly staff. It is always a treat for me when I'm shopping in the plaza. I am a bit confused about some of the bad reviews, but it doesn't seem to hurt their business any, as it is consistently busy. read more

One word: FIRE This the best pizza we've ever had (and we're from NYC- home of NY style pizza) On top of the amazing food, the staff members (Eric and Nick) were so welcoming and offered great service. Will definitely come back again! read more

My brother and I were visiting from Florida. We wanted an authentic NY food experience so we sought out some pizza! While looking for a good pizza place, my wife said that a co-worker back in FL. Loved this place. She said " go to Joey's". Glad we listened to her. Some of the best pizza I've had in my life. Lots of slice options and FRESH. read more

Joey's Pizza Italian Restuarant - Can't decide? Get them ALL! - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

Stopped in here a couple of weeks ago after I had my hair done because I was starving. I got a regular slice and a margarita slice. Both were excellent. Couldn't get them in my mouth fast enough because I was so hungry. The margarita slice could have been heated a little longer but it had great flavor. The crust which was probably about an inch and a half from the edge was just the perfect bite of soft and slightly chewy and slightly crunchy in some spots. The regular slice needed a little salt. But otherwise it was really good pie. read more

Man this place was a find! We were on the highway and started to get hungry! Pizza is a great quick bite! We got a slice of Buffalo Chicken And a slice of Eggplant/Tomato/Pesto! Super delicious!! Crispy crust, amazing sauce, fresh toppings! Just perfect! Oh and you have to get the garlic knots! Their marinara is fantastic!! Simple & sweet! read more