Doesn't exist anymore, but when it was open, had best pizza around. The service was great and the food was always good. Tim the owner was very pleasant and always talked to the customers. read more

I have bought pizza from them before and thought it was pretty good but yesterday we ordered a sausage and mushroom pie for lunch and it was burnt. My daughter doesn't like mushrooms so she took them off. I took a bite and the mushrooms tasted like canned mushrooms so I took them off as well. My husband ate the pizza with the mushrooms and was sick for the rest of the day. Needless to say we will not be ordering from them anymore. read more

Cinema Pizza - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

My Husband and I were in the car on Tuesday June 2, 2020. I had such a headache because I didn't eat anything that usually happens to me a lot. My Husband went into CINEMA Pizza he ordered me a plain slice and a pomegranate tea. I loved eating the slice it was so good and crispy that I really enjoyed it so much that was my lunch. Then afterwards me and my Husband decided that we were also going to have food for CINEMA Pizza. We went to Big Lots got what we wanted and then It was back to CINEMA PIZZA to get dinner. My husband got a Large Half Mushroom and Sausage pie, Garlic Parmesan Chicken Wings, and Garlic Knots. Everything was delicious It was our first time getting food and taking it home It also won't be our last time there. We will definitely be going back to try a variety of different things on the menu and also posting more Reviews for CINEMA PIZZA! read more

We love all their food especially their pizza. It is always hot when it is delivered. I gave them 4 stars because we ordered fried dough for the first time and they were hard as rocks. I didn't expect small balls of dough but that's what we got. I know now to never get them again. I'll stick to their pizza and other food they serve.dinners and subs. read more

We've been going to see Tim and the guys here since they first opened. We have never had a bad meal from Tim. Every time we come in, he pretty much already knows what we're going to order. Always a smile and always chatting it up. We've been doing our part during the COVID-19 crisis by purchasing at least 2 sandwiches and one pizza every other week. That's how much we love them! They feed us for like a week. read more

The pizza is alright and it's in a great location, next to a movie theater. We made our friend Cat go to a scary movie and she can't stop crying Feeling: Guilty read more

Coming from NYC where the best food and of course pizza is made! But living in Orange County where no one really knows great pizza...Cinema Pizza gets it!!! Awesome pizza!!! A little more on the gravy would make it personally perfect! Their eggplant parm is scrumptious and cooked perfectly! Thanks Cinema Pizza read more

Delicious food and great prices! So far have had the penne vodka and chicken francaise and both have been delicious.... Can't wait to try their pizza with the awesome sauce that comes with the garlic knots. read more

You want some good NY Pizza for your out of state family members!? Hit 'em up, their Chicken bacon ranch pizza is a killa. Fastest delivery around. read more

If Jesus Christ himself came down from the clouds, ready to start performing miracles, he would stop at Cinema Pizza first for an Alla Vodka pizza. It's the best thing I've ever eaten. Good prices. Friendly staff that work super quickly. Bangin' pizza. 10/10 read more

Went out of our way to stop in for dinner. We would have been first time customers. Crappy hand written note on door , closed at 2 for catering event. So, are you a caterer or are you a restaurant ? We won't be back. read more

This places is great! We had our thirteen year old's birthday party there today before we took them to a movie, all the kids had a good time. The staff could not have been more friendly or helpful. They made us feel right at home. The food was excellent and reasonably priced. This is my new placed to go for wings. They were large, meaty and very flavorful. The pizza was just right. Good crust, lots of cheese and the sauce nice and sweet. The kids devoured the garlic knots. So they must have been good, I did not even get one. The bottom line, If you want great pizza and wings, served by a friendly and nice staff, this is the place to go. read more

My first time experience: Ordered a large cheese pizza for the first time ever, received the pizza within 30 min. I kid you not. After taking the first bite, I bit into a salty, pizza with old dough. The crust tasted as if they just threw a large pizza that they had been sitting in the restaurant since morning into the oven to warm it up and send out for delivery. My biggest pet peeve is ordering a fresh large cheese pizza and getting an old one instead. I HATE THAT! The cheese is good quality cheese and so is the sauce, therefore you guys get 1 Star for that and the delivery time was fast (since they just HAD TO CUT CORNERS) Just a little salty and that dough was just terrible. I didn't even bother calling the restaurant back because I wouldn't get anything out of it. Won't be ordering from here anymore. That was the first and last time. read more

Order a shrimp parmigiana sandwich. When it came it looked funky, parmigiana cheese, pesto, red pepper. I bite into it and knew there was no shrimp on this sandwich. I asked the guy what this was, gave me some name, but was a flatten fried chicken. I said I asked for a shrimp parm. He says, "Oh well I didn't hear you". Really, that's what you say? You charged me for shrimp parm. Waste of money, will not return with his attitude. It was the little guy with dark greasy hair. read more

Stopped in for a bite to eat after seeing the new Captain Marvel movie with my wife Donna and our young son. The wife and son split the special- two cheese slices and a fountain beverage, which they both enjoyed. I opted out for a slice of buffalo chicken and a slice of chicken bacon ranch. I eat a lot of pizza but I'll just say this- cinema pizza puts the lead in my pencil- 10/10 would repeat any day ! read more

Great Pizza. Great Crew! Pizza planet wasent that good but I find this place to be better. Different pizza slices everyday trying new things! Give them a shot and you wont be disappointed. read more

Cinema Pizza - the dining area of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

any other day I would say I love this place but tonight I called to order 2 pies and a sandwich, like I do once a week. Well I was told "the kitchen is closed, but I will make the pizza" then I said ok and was hung up on. (it was only 8:30) the person who answered wasn't the normal guy. Terrible way to keep business especially since we are regulars . read more

I definitely have a new favorite pizza place! These guys have great pizza! It's refreshing to eat a slice without having a plate full of grease after! Also they have random specials on different kinds of pizza pies. Once they had a penne Alfredo pizza that I fell in love with! They are always in a great mood, have great sandwiches as well and the selection always makes it hard to chose! And if you have it delivered it's never more then 45 minutes which is hard to find around New Windsor and Newburgh area! So definitely chose Cinema Pizza for your next "pizza night" or "sandwich night " even "pasta night" you'll absolutely agree they are worth it every time!! read more

I ordered a delivery a couple days ago, a large plain pie, garlic knots and an order of wings with their "homemade" buffalo sauce. When I got the food the pizza tasted salty and the sauce was not appetizing. The garlic knots were burned black and the sauce on the wings tasted like buffalo sauce mixed with ketchup. I called the restaurant back and the owner picked up which by the way is EXTREMELY rude. Instead of apologizing and giving great customer service like any owner would he told us "well you aren't regular customers" as if our opinion didn't matter because we aren't regulars. Any owner would've apologized and at least tried to gain a new customer but this experience was horrible. I do not recommend this place at all. read more

Oh boy oh boy, this is my favorite pizza place in new windsor! I frequently do the two cheese slices with a fountain dew special for 6 dollars and its a bargain for sure! They also have some awesome valpak deals! read more

The pizza & prices are good, some of the guys that work there aren't the friendliest making me feel as if I'm imposing when I walk in, but overall it's a good place and I'm not going there to make friends lol so... yeah. I like it and I have definitely visited there multiple times. I tried their Broccoli & Chicken Alfredo pasta and found it delicious. read more

I used the Order/delivery feature via Yelp for the first time with this order - great feature!!! My order was placed at 7 pm with a 7:30 PM pickup time. I got there and the order was ready and waiting for me. Very friendly atmosphere. I must admit the pizza here have improved...A LOT!!!! (you wouldn't believe how awful it used to be). I ordered wings as well and they were spicy and oh so good. Anyways! Kudos Cinema Pizza...I'll be placing more orders. read more

We have had nothing but great experiences with Cinema Pizza. Their service is great, plenty of room, very very clean, prompt and speedy.

Recently moved to the area so needed a regular pizza place. Good pizza and appetizers, good prices and quick delivery. Highly recommend

Very quick delivery, the people who work here are so friendly and accommodating. The delivery guy actually asked me to check my pizza to make sure that the cheese didn't slide, instead of just delivering it and making it my problem after him leaving. The pizza was perfect. The second time we ordered the Sicilian pizza and it honestly was the best Sicilian pie my family and I have EVER had!! And that is saying a lot, we have had a lot of pizza Absolutely great place to grab a slice in a neighborhood filled with pizza places, definitely try Cinema! read more

Ever since I moved to Cornwall 2 years ago I was told to go to Cinema Pizza was the place to go. Tim the owner and his workers are amazing, Always friendly and serve great food. During the Covid outbreak I lost my grandmother and I called him last minute and asked if he could do some kind of trays of food for the staff at the hospital to thank them for all they did to help her. What I was thinking and what he prepared went way above and beyond. He was willing to do whatever he could to help my situation in such a short time.He is an amazing asset to the community. This is my family's go to pizza place read more

Food is great. It's so easy to order online. The restaurant is super clean and every one is really nice. Everything I have tried so far is delicious. read more

Had pizza there for first time. Great value, good taste, perfect crust. Will go back.

Not the best in town. Sauce is bland and thin. The crust is too chewy and could use less flour. Orders from here a few time. Will not be back. read more

Amazing pizza. Crust and favor. Variety was amazing. Just had pizza better than I had in Italy

best pizza in 845.. scratch that all of New York. I order there at least three times a week! Their buffalo garlic knots are to die for The blonde counter girl always remembers my order when I call.. s/o Tim read more

Great pizza!! I feel like they're pizza is so good! They're friendly and have great deals. If you're looking to grab a bite before a movie next door or just in general come here. Their pizza isn't the only thing that was good, all their food is! read more

Horrible, horrible food. I have been there 3 times ever since it was opened ( it's right next to my local theatre ) and have been disgusted all three times. The pizza is mostly greasy and has too much tomato sauce to cheese. I once ordered their buffalo wing pizza and when it came I found myself looking at a tortilla with cheese and cut up buffalo wings on top of it. Would not recommend unless you want to try their buffalo wings ( which they only make one flavor, its not spicy at all and is actually sweet ). read more

This review is for the owner f Timothy I saw you're response you know exactly what happened that day so do not lie ! Yes you are right you dont need to give any explanation but you could of gave a better customer service by other than saying no. I sat down with no complaints my wife ask you what is the reason for not putting different sauces without even saying anything you just roll you're eyes gave a lame excuse. The part that got me mad was the smart remarks you responded by saying I'll give you half plain and half bbq which to be honest I did not mention bbq for the sauce and you gave a smirk! This when I told you in w exact words you are being cheap than you kick us out ! Yes like i mentioned before i said something nasty to you im not denying it ! Yes you ask me do you want any problems which I look at you no I do not want any problems . You still looking at me with intentions to fight me I just said give me money back I'll be at of you're way still hesitant to give me my money back, I had to ask you ask you again just give me my money back. So idk if you had bad day but the fact remains you were absolutely rude! There are few reviews I found the staff was rude. Maybe I shouldn't said those words but just remember the face expression you gave and the smart remarks and top of all that kicking us out lead me to say something to nasty to you ! So do not act like you were acting all professional that day and nice like I've mentioned I went to another pizzeria with no problem giving me two different sauces! Just to be fair I explain to the other pizzeria owner or employee about the situation I've just experienced he said oh really he was suprised you acted like that. So off that note im not making up any story about that day I've encountered with you Timothy, I'm here saying another pizzeria owner mentioned he is suprised you act in that matter so there is no reason for me as a person to lie and no reason if I wanted to let them no you are just rude inconsiderate person I will not mention another owner is suprised you acted in that manner. But yes you were rude ! read more

Pizza and wings all the way. Great product and great value, but the greatest thing is there service. I use yelp app to order for pick up and there timing is spot on. Always hot and ready at the specified time. I love that. Super friendly and professional. He calls me by name every time I come in and even on the phone. I don't even remember telling him my name. Go to spot for sure. read more

I stop in at Cinema all the time, always a good selection of slices to pick from! It appears they just got a new pizza guy and the pizza is even better than ever! Try cinema out, you wont regret it! read more